Join Josh Clark and Chuck Bryant in a riveting episode of "Stuff You Should Know," as they delve into the extraordinary tale of the Biosphere 2 project—a vision of environmental utopia that evolved into a notorious scientific saga. Financed by billionaire Ed Bass and spurred by the eco-conscious 1980s, this ambitious experiment aimed to forge self-sustaining enclosed ecosystems. Josh and Chuck unravel the fascinating journey from the crew’s origins at Synergia Ranch to constructing what became the largest private science project of its era, and the ensuing struggles that tested the very foundations of their closed-world.
The story that unfolds is one of human perseverance amidst ecological miscalculations, atmospheric anomalies, and psychological hardships that shook the futuristic habitat and its inhabitants. As problems arose, secrecy led to a backlash from the press, casting a shadow over the project's scientific contributions. Yet, through the storms of criticism, the crew endured, and the resulting insights on closed ecosystems and environmental issues offered a silver lining. Clark and Bryant walk us through how these trials and revelations sparked a renewed emphasis on environmental stewardship, demonstrating how even flawed experiments can illuminate the path toward sustainability.
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
Billionaire Ed Bass finances John Allen's ambitions and establishes the Biosphere 2 project in Oracle, Arizona, aimed at creating self-sustaining closed ecosystems. They draw upon their experience from Synergia Ranch in New Mexico, where they lived self-sufficiently and engaged in creative ventures such as the construction of the Heraclitus ship. Specifically, the Biosphere 2 is built as the largest private science project of its time, spurred by the environmental worries of the 1980s.
The project faces a suite of issues, from structural glitches affecting the biospheres to atmospheric imbalances due to excessive CO2 absorption by concrete, leading to oxygen scarcity. Resultingly, the ecosystem experiences unwanted species growth, leading to nutritional deficits and psychological strain amongst the crew. Critical incidents, such as Jane Poynter’s exit for medical reasons, undermine the experiment’s integrity, while the lack of wind weakens tree growth, mirroring high-altitude living conditions.
Publicity turns sour as the media catches wind of the hidden struggles within Biosphere 2, with Time Magazine going so far as to decry it as one of the "100 worst ideas of the 20th century." The lack of transparency and protocol breaches, such as Poynter’s exit, exacerbate the experiment's scientific credibility issues.
Despite widespread criticism, the crew completes the two-year stint, and the project yields significant scientific data, with breakthroughs in understanding closed ecosystems, wastewater management, and coral behaviors. Importantly, Biosphere 2 reignites the environmental movement, drawing increased attention to global ecological issues.
1-Page Summary
Chuck Bryant and Josh Clark discuss the ambitious Biosphere 2 project, an experimental closed ecosystem in Oracle, Arizona, designed to study what would happen in a sealed-off Earth environment. Despite being laden with issues, the endeavor led to valuable studies and a resurgence in the environmental movement.
The project, led by John Allen and his ambitious albeit eccentric group, received a massive funding boost from billionaire Ed Bass, whose intention was to make money from potential scientific developments. The Synergia Ranch in New Mexico became a hub of creativity, with roots in performance art and ambitious building projects like the research vessel Heraclitus.
The Biosphere was constructed to be fully enclosed and maintain human life in order to monitor Earth's ecosystems. It became the largest privately funded science project in history, financed by Bass's $150 to $200 million investment and conceived as a response to growing concerns about Earth's environmental imbalances in the early '80s.
Despite the project's goals, the crew encountered significant challenges, including design flaws such as the proximity of different biomes, which altered natural conditions, and concrete that acted as a carbon sink absorbing CO2, creating an imbalance in the atmosphere. The nutrient-rich soil led to an overgrowth of microbes that consumed oxygen faster than plants could produce it.
Species extinctions and the outgrowth of unintended species like morning glory vines and ants disrupted the planned biosphere interactions. The ambitious but flawed nature of the project resulted in crop failures, and hunger among the crew who struggled to reach the 2,500-calorie daily goal initially set, often consuming as little as 1,800 calories a day. Limited supplies of luxuries like coffee fueled discontent, leading to strained group dynamics.
Jane Poynter, responsible for farming, had to break the sealed condition for medical treatment, raising controversy and undermining the project's rules. Wind's absence resulted in trees growing tall but weak, and low oxygen and high carbon dioxide levels mirrored conditions at high altitudes, causing crew members to struggle with simple tasks.
Failed experiment, renewed environmentalism
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser