Podcasts > Stuff You Should Know > Short Stuff: Scheele's Green | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Short Stuff: Scheele's Green | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

By iHeartPodcasts

Dive into the fascinating and little-known history of a deadly dye with Josh Clark and Dana Carvey in the "Stuff You Should Know" podcast, as they unravel the story of Scheele's Green—a vibrant pigment that once took society by storm. Discovered by Carl Wilhelm Scheele during the drab Industrial Revolution, this 'gardeny, vegetal' green captured the longing for nature in an urban world. But as Josh and Dana explore, this alluring hue had a dark side—an arsenic base that caused unknown suffering and disease among those who delighted in its color.

As the tragic consequences of Scheele's Green unfold, "Stuff You Should Know" illustrates the paramount importance of safety regulations in consumer products. The widespread 19th-century use of the pigment in items like wallpapers and textiles not only impacted high-profile individuals like Claire Booth Luce but also led to the enthralling speculation about Napoleon Bonaparte's demise. Join the hosts as they weave together historical accounts that ultimately sparked the protective consumer safety standards we rely on today, and discover how a mere color could change the world.

Listen to the original

Short Stuff: Scheele's Green | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Dec 28, 2023 episode of the Stuff You Should Know

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Short Stuff: Scheele's Green | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

1-Page Summary

Color Discoveries

Carl Wilhelm Scheele, a German Swedish chemist, has a notable history with color through his serendipitous development of Scheele's Green, a pigment that initially amazed society with its vibrancy. In the midst of the monochromatic Industrial Revolution landscape, the pigment, also known as Schloss Green, provided a fresh, nature-evoking hue that stood apart for its intense saturation and rich "gardeny, vegetal" character, satisfying the people's desire for natural elements within the urban scene. Unfortunately, this pigment harbored a lethal secret.

Unknown to many at the time, the pigment's arsenic base meant it could cause acute poisoning, with symptoms commonly mistaken for other diseases, such as vomiting and abdominal pain. Prolonged interaction with the pigment was even more hazardous, potentially resulting in serious conditions like skin lesions, discolorations, and various cancers. Notable individuals, including Claire Booth Luce, experienced significant health issues due to the arsenic in Scheele's Green, although it did not directly claim her life. These adverse health effects alerted society to the hidden dangers within this popular color.

Color Regulations

Public safety concerns stemming from the use of harmful color pigments led to the establishment of regulations designed to safeguard consumers. Scheele's Green, due to its arsenic content, brought attention to the need for such regulations. This pigment was widely used in the 19th century for dyeing an array of materials, including wallpapers, paints, and textiles. Its popularity declined as its toxicity became clear and regulations emerged to prevent similar public health risks.

Historical anecdotes suggest that Scheele's Green's toxic nature may have had lethal consequences for significant historical figures, including the speculation surrounding Napoleon Bonaparte's death. The potential for poisoning from the arsenic-laden wallpaper in his final residence has intrigued historians and underscored the importance of regulating toxic substances in everyday products. As a result, modern-day consumer safety standards now restrict the use of dangerous materials in manufacturing, ensuring that such tragedies are not repeated.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Scheele's Green, a pigment developed in the 18th century, contained arsenic, a toxic element. Prolonged exposure to arsenic can lead to acute poisoning, causing symptoms like vomiting and abdominal pain. The arsenic in the pigment could also result in severe health conditions such as skin lesions and various cancers. This toxicity led to the decline in the use of Scheele's Green and prompted the establishment of regulations to protect public health.
  • Claire Booth Luce, a prominent figure, suffered health problems attributed to the arsenic content in Scheele's Green pigment. The toxic nature of this pigment, commonly used in various products, led to adverse health effects in individuals exposed to it. Luce's experience underscores the hidden dangers of arsenic-based pigments like Scheele's Green. This historical incident highlights the importance of regulating toxic substances in consumer products to prevent health risks.
  • Napoleon Bonaparte's death has been the subject of historical speculation, with some theories suggesting that his health issues may have been exacerbated by exposure to toxic substances like arsenic. There are hypotheses that the green wallpaper in his residence, possibly colored with arsenic-based pigments like Scheele's Green, could have contributed to his deteriorating health. This speculation highlights the potential dangers of toxic pigments in everyday items and the importance of regulating such substances to protect public health. Napoleon's case serves as a cautionary tale about the unintended consequences of using hazardous materials in common products.
  • Modern-day consumer safety standards encompass regulations and guidelines that aim to protect consumers from potential harm caused by products. These standards set requirements for the materials used in manufacturing to ensure they are safe for consumers' health and well-being. By restricting the use of dangerous materials, such as toxic pigments like Scheele's Green with arsenic, these standards help prevent health risks and ensure product safety. Compliance with these standards is essential for manufacturers to meet legal requirements and maintain consumer trust.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Short Stuff: Scheele's Green | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Color Discoveries

Carl Wilhelm Scheele, a German Swedish chemist, made a significant contribution to the world of color through his accidental creation of a unique green pigment that both captivated and eventually concerned society.

Scheele's Green Properties and Popularity

Discovery of Scheele's Green pigment

In a fortuitous experiment, Scheele, while heating sodium carbonate, combined it with arsenious oxide and stirred the mixture. When he added copper sulfate, the resulting chemical reaction produced a brilliant green pigment, which came to be known as Scheele's Green or Schloss Green.

Scheele's Green was truly a revelation in its time—a natural green pigment with a vibrant "gardeny, vegetal" quality that had not been seen before. Amidst the drabness and smog of the Industrial Revolution, Scheele's Green represented the lushness of rural landscapes, offering an injection of color into the increasingly industrialized backdrop of everyday life. This full-saturation, middle green stood out for its vibrance compared to previous copper-based greens, fulfilling the contemporary yearning for the hue of nature within the confines of the urban environment.

Scheele's Green Toxicity

Scheele's Green arsenic and poisoning

The dazzling pigment, however, had a dark side owing to its arsenic content. Acute arsenic poisoning from Scheele's Green could manifest in symptoms such as vomiting, abdominal pain, and diarrhea—ailments that could easily be misinterpreted as other c ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Color Discoveries

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Scheele's Green was created by combining sodium carbonate and arsenious oxide, then adding copper sulfate. This mixture resulted in the formation of the vibrant green pigment known as Scheele's Green or Schloss Green. The chemical reaction between these components led to the unique color that captivated society.
  • The Industrial Revolution, which began in the late 18th century, marked a significant shift from agrarian societies to industrialized ones, leading to rapid urbanization and technological advancements. This period saw the rise of factories, mass production, and urban centers, resulting in pollution, overcrowding, and a stark contrast between rural and urban environments. The shift towards industrialization influenced color perception as peop ...

Counterarguments

...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Short Stuff: Scheele's Green | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Color Regulations

In response to concerns over the safety of pigments used in various products, regulations have been established to limit the use of toxic substances.

Regulations Passed on Toxic Pigments

Historically, the use of certain color pigments has led to serious health concerns, prompting the creation of regulations to protect public safety.

Regulation passed due to Sheele's Green toxicity

One notable example of this is the regulation passed in response to the toxicity of Sheele's Green. This pigment contained arsenic and was commonly used in the 19th century for coloring wallpapers, paints, and even clothing, despite its dangerous effects on those who came into contact with it.

Possible Napoleon death from Sheele's Green

The po ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Color Regulations

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Scheele's Green, also known as Schloss Green, is a yellowish-green pigment containing arsenic that was widely used in the 19th century. It was commonly used in paints and various products but fell out of favor due to its toxicity and color instability. The pigment's toxic nature led to health concerns and its decline in popularity by the late 19th century. Napoleon Bonaparte's potential exposure to Scheele's Green is linked to speculation about his death due to arsenic poisoning.
  • Green pigments historically contained arsenic, a toxic substance. Arsenic was used in pigments like Sheele's Green, which posed health risks due to its poisonous nature. The toxicity of arsenic in pigments led to regulations being established to protect public safety. Arsenic in pigments like Sheele's Green was a significant concern due to its harmful effects on those exposed to it.
  • Napoleon Bonaparte's potential poisoning from Sheele's Green is a historical theory suggesting that the arsenic in the green pigment used in his wallpaper may have contributed to his health issues or death. This speculation is based on the toxic nature of Sheele's Green, which was commonly used in the 19th century despite its known dangers. While there is no definitive proof of poisoning, some historians believe that prolonged exposure to arsenic from the wallpaper could have impacted Napoleon's health during his exile on the island of Saint Helena. ...

Counterarguments

  • Regulations may sometimes be too restrictive and stifle innovation in the development of new pigments and products.
  • Historical accounts of health concerns may be exaggerated or not entirely based on scientific evidence, and modern regulations might be influenced by such misconceptions.
  • The case of Sheele's Green toxicity might not be representative of all color pigments, and regulations should be specific and evidence-based rather than broad and potentially overreaching.
  • The speculation regarding Napoleon Bonaparte's death due to Sheele's Green may not be substa ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA