Podcasts > Stuff You Should Know > Short Stuff: Pickles | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Short Stuff: Pickles | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

By iHeartPodcasts

Dive into a tangy discussion with Josh Clark and Chuck Bryant on the "Stuff You Should Know" podcast. Exploring the world of pickles, Josh and Chuck offer a delightful contrast of perspectives, as Chuck voices his dislike for pickles against Josh's clear fascination. Their engaging banter is peppered with personal anecdotes, such as Chuck's family tale of shared pickle aversion and discussions about their surprising and sometimes unwelcome appearance in meals. The episode addresses the polarizing nature of pickles, a theme relatable to many with strong culinary preferences.

Unwrapping the salty history and clever techniques behind pickling, the hosts travel back to ancient Mesopotamia, uncovering the earliest practices and the evolution of pickles as status symbols in Victorian England. Listeners learn about lacto-fermentation alongside recipes for classic dill and bread & butter pickles. Josh and Chuck also examine the health benefits of pickles, their role in New York deli culture, and how brands like H.J. Heinz revolutionized the pickle industry. By the end, even the most selective eaters might be inspired to give pickles another chance, with a nudge towards the intriguing half-sour dill from the enthusiastic Josh.

Listen to the original

Short Stuff: Pickles | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Dec 14, 2023 episode of the Stuff You Should Know

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Short Stuff: Pickles | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

1-Page Summary

Hosts' Pickle Perspectives

Playful Banter and Differing Opinions

Josh Clark and Chuck Bryant, the voices behind the "Short Stuff: Pickles" podcast, share a humorous and dynamic chemistry that quickly draws listeners into their pickle discourse. Chuck makes no secret of his distaste for pickles, a sentiment not shared by his co-host Josh, who approaches the topic with zest.

Personal Anecdotes and Taste Aversions

In a personal twist, Chuck recounts a story about his nephew's wife, who shares his pickle aversion. This anecdote underscores the pair's discussion about the divisive nature of pickles and their sometimes unexpected appearances in meals, much to the chagrin of some diners.

The Rich History of Pickles

Ancient Origins and Global Traditions

The podcast takes us on a journey through time, beginning with the inception of pickling in ancient Mesopotamia around 2030 BCE for the preservation and transportation of cucumbers. An even older pickling tradition hailing from China is mentioned, though cucumbers were not the pickled fruit of choice in this culture. The etymology of the word 'pickle' is also explored, with potential roots in Dutch or German terms.

Status Symbols and Victorian Indulgence

During the Victorian era in England, pickles were more than just food; they were a statement of wealth. Ornate pickle castors were used at the table, signifying a person's social standing. While pickling was initially a practice common among rural folks, it evolved into a marker of sophistication among city dwellers.

Delving into Pickling Techniques

The Art of Lacto-fermentation

Josh takes a moment to describe the traditional method of creating lacto-fermented pickles at home. This process, which entails using a salt brine to encourage the growth of beneficial bacteria, gives homemade pickles a unique and often more robust flavor profile compared to their commercial counterparts.

Classic Dill and Bread & Butter Preparations

Chuck contributes to the discussion by detailing the recipe for making classic dill pickles, using white vinegar, mustard seed, and dill, which contrast with his preferred bread and butter pickles that are sweetened and spiced with celery seed and turmeric.

The Impact of Pasteurization on Texture and Probiotics

As the conversation delves deeper, Josh debunks the myth that soft pickles are a natural state, explaining that pasteurization often leads to this softer texture while unfortunately eliminating the beneficial probiotics.

Health and Culinary Delights of Pickles

Fermentation and Blood Sugar Regulation

While navigating through the various pickling methods, Josh highlights the health benefits of both vinegar-based and salt brine pickles, noting how vinegar can help maintain stable blood sugar levels.

The Palate-Cleansing Tradition in Jewish Delis

The pair also reflects on the customary pairing of dill pickles with sandwiches in 1930s New York delis, noting the role of pickles in refreshing the palate between bites of rich meats and bread.

From Glass Jars to Global Fairs: The Business of Pickles

The Rise of H.J. Heinz and Competitors

Transitioning from the consumption to the commercialization of pickles, H.J. Heinz's breakthrough into the jarred pickle market in 1860 is discussed, along with mentions of competing brands like Claussen, Mount Olive, and Vlasic.

Ingenious Marketing Tactics

The hosts touch upon a creative marketing campaign from the 1893 World's Fair, where pickle pendants became an inventive lure for potential customers.

Cultural Reflections and Personal Tastes

In the final sections of the podcast, Chuck reveals his nuanced palate, expressing a particular fondness for the silky richness of balsamic vinegar over others.

Adopting New Pickle Varieties for the Selective Palate

The episode comes to a close with Josh playfully acknowledging Chuck's unique taste preferences and inviting him to explore the world of pickles with an open mind, possibly starting with the half sour dill variety that might just satisfy his selective taste buds.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The word 'pickle' has potential roots in Dutch "pekel" or German "pökel," both referring to a solution used for preserving food. These terms evolved to describe the process of preserving food in a brine solution, leading to the modern usage of 'pickle' for preserved foods like cucumbers. The etymology highlights the historical practice of pickling across different cultures and languages, showcasing a shared tradition of food preservation.
  • During the Victorian era, ornate pickle castors were decorative containers used to hold pickles at the dining table. These castors were often made of silver or other luxurious materials and featured intricate designs, showcasing the host's wealth and social status. Displaying these elaborate pickle castors during meals was a way for affluent individuals to demonstrate their refined taste and sophistication. The use of such ornate tableware reflected the Victorian emphasis on etiquette, presentation, and the symbolism of material possessions.
  • Lacto-fermentation is a traditional method of pickling that involves creating an anaerobic environment using a salt brine to encourage the growth of beneficial bacteria, specifically Lactobacillus. These bacteria convert sugars in the vegetables into lactic acid, which acts as a natural preservative and gives the pickles their tangy flavor. This process not only enhances the taste and texture of the pickles but also promotes the growth of probiotics, which are beneficial for gut health. Lacto-fermented pickles are known for their complex flavors and are often more crisp and flavorful compared to commercially processed pickles.
  • Pasteurization, a heat treatment process used in commercial pickling, can lead to softer pickle textures by breaking down the cell structure of cucumbers. Unfortunately, this process also eliminates beneficial probiotics naturally present in unpasteurized pickles. The loss of probiotics due to pasteurization can impact the potential health benefits associated with consuming fermented foods like pickles. Soft pickles are not a natural state but can result from the pasteurization process commonly used in commercial pickle production.
  • Vinegar-based pickles offer health benefits due to the acetic acid in vinegar, which may help regulate blood sugar levels. Salt brine pickles can be beneficial as they undergo fermentation, promoting the growth of probiotic bacteria that can support gut health. These pickles can be a source of probiotics, which are beneficial microorganisms that can contribute to a healthy gut microbiome.
  • In the 1930s, New York delis had a tradition of serving dill pickles alongside sandwiches. Dill pickles were commonly offered as a side dish to complement the flavors of the sandwiches. This pairing was popular as the tangy and crunchy nature of dill pickles helped cleanse the palate between bites of rich meats and bread. The contrast in flavors and textures enhanced the overall dining experience for patrons.
  • H.J. Heinz, a prominent figure in the food industry, made a significant impact by introducing jarred pickles to the market in 1860. This move revolutionized the way pickles were preserved and sold, contributing to the widespread availability and popularity of pickles in households. Heinz's innovation in packaging pickles in jars helped establish his brand as a leader in the pickle industry during that time.
  • Pickle pendants were a creative marketing tactic used at the 1893 World's Fair to attract customers to pickle vendors' stalls. These pendants were small, decorative items shaped like pickles that were worn as jewelry or accessories. They served as eye-catching and memorable souvenirs for fair attendees, helping to promote the pickle vendors' products. The novelty and uniqueness of these pickle pendants helped draw attention to the pickle booths and generate interest in their offerings.

Counterarguments

  • While Chuck Bryant's dislike for pickles is clear, it's possible that his aversion is not as strong as portrayed and could be exaggerated for entertainment value.
  • The story shared by Chuck about his pickle aversion may not fully capture the complexity of why some people dislike pickles, as taste aversions can be due to a variety of factors beyond unexpected appearances in meals.
  • The history of pickling may be more diverse than presented, with other cultures possibly practicing it around the same time or earlier than ancient Mesopotamia.
  • Victorian England's use of pickles as status symbols might not have been as widespread as suggested, and other factors could have contributed to the perception of pickles as a marker of sophistication.
  • Lacto-fermentation is one of many methods to create pickles, and some might argue that other methods can produce flavors just as unique and robust.
  • The preference for classic dill versus bread & butter pickles is subjective, and some might argue that neither recipe is superior in taste.
  • Pasteurization's impact on texture and probiotics might be seen as a necessary trade-off for ensuring the safety and shelf-stability of commercial pickles.
  • The health benefits of vinegar-based pickles, such as blood sugar regulation, might be overstated or require more scientific evidence to be considered conclusive.
  • The tradition of palate-cleansing with dill pickles in Jewish delis is one of many cultural practices involving pickles, and other traditions might also be significant.
  • H.J. Heinz's role in the pickle market is notable, but other innovators and brands may have also played a critical role in the development and popularization of pickles.
  • The effectiveness of marketing tactics like pickle pendants at the 1893 World's Fair could be debated, as the success of such campaigns can be influenced by many factors.
  • Chuck's preference for balsamic vinegar might not be shared by all, and some might argue for the merits of other types of vinegar in pickling.
  • The suggestion for Chuck to try half sour dill pickles assumes that this variety will be more palatable to him, which may not be the case as taste preferences are highly individual.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Short Stuff: Pickles | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Hosts' Pickle Perspectives

Playful Banter and Differing Opinions

Josh Clark and Chuck Bryant, the voices behind the 'Short Stuff: Pickles' podcast, share a humorous and dynamic chemistry that quickly draws listeners into their pickle discourse.

During the lively exchange, Chuck expresses his personal preference for bread and butter pickles despite a general aversion to pickles, a sentiment not shared by his co-host Josh, who has a strong dislike for cucumbers unless they are pickled.

Personal Anecdotes and Taste Aversions

In a personal twist, Chuck recounts a story about his nephew's ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Hosts' Pickle Perspectives

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Chuck's preference for bread and butter pickles despite not liking pickles in general can be seen as a unique taste preference. Bread and butter pickles have a sweeter flavor profile compared to traditional dill pickles, which might appeal to Chuck despite his general aversion to pickles. This preference showcases how individual taste preferences can vary even within a broader category like pickles.
  • Josh's dislike for cucumbers unless they are pickled could stem from a preference for the tangy and flavorful taste that pickling imparts to cucumbers. Pickling cucumbers involves preserving them in a brine solution, which alters their texture and flavor profile significantly. This transformation might make pickled cucumbers more appealing to Josh compared to the fresh, crunchy nature of raw cucumbers. Josh's specific aversion to raw cucumbers but enjoyment of pickled cucumbers showcases a unique palate preference for transformed flavors.
  • When people who dislike pickles find them automatically included with meals ...

Counterarguments

  • While Josh and Chuck's chemistry is described as humorous and dynamic, some listeners might not find their banter as engaging or might prefer a more structured and informative approach to podcasting.
  • The preference for bread and butter pickles over other types might not be universal; some people might argue that other varieties, such as dill or gherkin, offer a superior taste or texture.
  • Josh's dislike for cucumbers unless pickled is a personal taste, but others might argue that cucumbers are versatile and can be enjoyed in many forms, such as in salads, sandwiches, or as a refreshing snack.
  • The anecdote about Chuck's nephew's wife disliking pickles is a singular personal experience and might not reflect a widespread sentiment; there are many indiv ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Short Stuff: Pickles | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

The Rich History of Pickles

Ancient Origins and Global Traditions

The podcast takes us on a journey through time, uncovering the ancient origins of pickling, which dates back to 2030 BCE in Mesopotamia for cucumbers and even further in China where the practice began 9,000 years ago, albeit not with cucumbers.

The exploration of the word 'pickle' extends to possible roots in Dutch or German language, connected to terms for saltwater or brine.

Status Symbols and Victorian Indulgence

During the Victorian era in England, the esteem for pickles transcended consumption, as they were dis ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The Rich History of Pickles

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The year 2030 BCE is mentioned as the origin of pickling in Mesopotamia based on historical evidence and archaeological findings that suggest early civilizations in the region practiced pickling around this time. Pickling was a method used to preserve food by immersing it in a brine solution, allowing it to be stored for extended periods. Mesopotamia, known for its advanced agricultural practices, is believed to have played a significant role in the early development of pickling techniques. The specific date helps establish a timeline for the historical roots of pickling and its importance in ancient civilizations.
  • Pickle castors were ornate containers used to display pickles during the Victorian era in England. They served as decorative table centerpieces, showcasing the pickles in an elegant and sophisticated manner. These castors were a symbol of social status and were often found in affluent households as a luxurious way to present and serve pickled foods. The tradition of using pickle castors highlighted the transformation of pickling from a simple rural craft to a symbol of opulence and refinement among the urban elite.
  • Pickling, historically a common practice in rural communities for food preservation, evolved into a symbol of luxury and socia ...

Counterarguments

  • The assertion that pickling dates back to 2030 BCE in Mesopotamia specifically for cucumbers may be too specific without archaeological evidence directly linking cucumbers to that exact date and location.
  • While the text suggests that the practice of pickling in China did not start with cucumbers 9,000 years ago, it does not specify what was pickled, which could lead to a misunderstanding of the historical context and practices.
  • The etymology of the word 'pickle' might be more complex and could have influences from other languages as well, not just Dutch or German.
  • The text implies that pickle castors were universally indicative of social standing during the Victorian era, but this might not have been the case for all social classes or in all regions.
  • The transformation of pickling from a rural craft to a luxury emblem might n ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Short Stuff: Pickles | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Delving into Pickling Techniques

The Art of Lacto-fermentation

Josh explains the nuanced process of lacto-fermentation at home, which includes an essential tip to keep the pickles fully submerged in the brine, thus fostering the right conditions for beneficial bacteria to flourish and safe preservation.

Classic Dill and Bread & Butter Preparations

Chuck begins by explaining the traditional salt brine pickling technique before delving into the specifics of creating classic dill pickles using white vinegar, mustard seed, and dill.

He contrasts this with his preferred bread and butter pickles, detailing the recipe that includes an extra serving of sugar, along with spices like celery seed and turmeric, contributing to their unique sweet-savory flavor profile.

The Impact of Pasteurization on Texture and Probiotics

Josh Clark provides insight into the texture of p ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Delving into Pickling Techniques

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Lacto-fermentation is a natural process where beneficial bacteria convert sugars into lactic acid, preserving the food. This process not only extends the shelf life of the food but also enhances its flavor and nutritional value. In pickling, lacto-fermentation creates a tangy taste and helps develop complex flavors in the vegetables. It is a traditional method of food preservation that has been used for centuries across various cultures.
  • The traditional salt brine pickling technique involves submerging vegetables in a solution of water and salt to create an environment that inhibits harmful bacteria while encouraging the growth of beneficial bacteria for fermentation. This method helps preserve the vegetables and develop their flavors over time. The salt concentration in the brine is crucial for controlling the fermentation process and ensuring the safety and quality of the pickles. The fermentation process in the salt brine enhances the tanginess and complexity of the pickles' taste.
  • Pasteurization is a heat treatment process used to kill harmful bacteria in food. In the context of pickles, pasteurization can affect the texture by making them less crunchy. Additionally, pasteurization can eliminate probiotics, ...

Counterarguments

  • While Josh emphasizes the importance of keeping pickles submerged to foster beneficial bacteria, it's also important to note that the type of salt used and the temperature at which fermentation occurs are critical factors in the success of lacto-fermentation.
  • Chuck's preference for bread & butter pickles with extra sugar may not align with those seeking lower sugar content for dietary reasons, and some may argue that the high sugar content could overshadow the natural flavors of the cucumbers and spices.
  • The assertion that pasteurization always results in a lack of crunchiness in pickles could be challenged, as the crunchiness can also be affected by factors such as the freshness of the cucumbers, the pickling time, and the specific pasteurization process used.
  • While Josh points out that pasteurization eliminates probiotics, some might argue that the safety benefits of pasteurizat ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Short Stuff: Pickles | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Health and Culinary Delights of Pickles

Fermentation and Blood Sugar Regulation

Josh highlights the health benefits associated with the pickling process, particularly noting how vinegar-based brine can aid in maintaining stable blood sugar levels, a point that’s often overlooked but is essential for its dietary significance.

The Palate-Cleansing Tradition in Jewish Delis

Chuck and Josh discuss the historical palate-cleansing tradition of Jewish delis established in the 19 ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Health and Culinary Delights of Pickles

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The palate-cleansing tradition in Jewish delis involves serving dill pickles with sandwiches to refresh the taste buds between bites of rich meats and breads. This practice originated in the 1930s among Jewish immigrants in New York and became a customary part of the deli experience. Dill pickles are known for their tangy flavor and crisp texture, which can help cleanse the palate and enhance the overall dining experience. This tradition reflects the cultural influence of Jewish cuisine and the importance of balancing flavors in a meal.
  • Vinegar-based brine in pickles can help regulate blood sugar levels due to its acetic acid content, which may improve insulin sensitivity and reduce blood sugar spikes after meals. This effect is beneficial for individuals aiming to manage their blood sugar levels, especially those with diabetes or insulin r ...

Counterarguments

  • While vinegar-based brine may help with blood sugar regulation, it's important to note that pickles can be high in sodium, which may not be suitable for everyone, especially those with hypertension or a need to manage sodium intake.
  • The health benefits of pickles can vary greatly depending on the type and amount of added sugars and preservatives in the pickling process, which can sometimes negate the benefits.
  • The tradition of palate cleansing with pickles in Jewish delis, while established, may not be universally practiced or recognized in all Jewish ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Short Stuff: Pickles | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

From Glass Jars to Global Fairs: The Business of Pickles

The Rise of H.J. Heinz and Competitors

With a significant leap in pickle commerce, H.J. Heinz spearheaded the jarred pickle market beginning in 1860, setting a cornerstone for what would become an industry with numerous formidable brands like Claussen, Mount Olive, and Vlasic vying for market share.

Ingenious Marketing Tactics

A peculiar yet effective marketing ploy manifested at the 1893 Wo ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

From Glass Jars to Global Fairs: The Business of Pickles

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Pickle commerce was significant due to the pioneering efforts of H.J. Heinz in the 1860s, which transformed the industry. This led to the establishment of a competitive market with various well-known brands vying for consumer attention and market share. The innovative marketing strategies employed, such as pickle pendants at the 1893 World's Fair, helped boost sales and showcase the creativity within the pickle industry.
  • H.J. Heinz played a pivotal role in revolutionizing the pickle industry by popularizing jarred pickles and establishing a strong market presence. Heinz's innovative approach and quality products set a high standard for competitors, shaping the industry's development. His contributions led to increased consumer demand for pickles and paved the way for other well-known pickle brands to emerge.
  • The 1893 World's Fair, also known as the World's Columbian Exposition, was a major event held in Chicago to cele ...

Counterarguments

  • While H.J. Heinz was influential, it's important to recognize that the popularity of jarred pickles was likely the result of many contributors, including smaller, local producers who may not have been as well-documented in history.
  • The success of brands like Claussen, Mount Olive, and Vlasic suggests that the market dynamics were competitive and that consumer preferences played a significant role in shaping the industry, which could be explored further.
  • The use of pickle pendants at the 1893 World's Fair, while innovative, migh ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Short Stuff: Pickles | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Cultural Reflections and Personal Tastes

In the final sections of the podcast, Chuck reveals his nuanced palate, expressing a particular fondness for the silky richness of balsamic vinegar over others.

Adopting New Pickle Varieties for the Selective Palate

As the episode concludes, Josh acknowledges Chuck's intricate food preferences and their comedic rapport.

The light-hearted conclusion embodies the po ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Cultural Reflections and Personal Tastes

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Chuck's nuanced palate indicates that he has a refined and sophisticated taste for different flavors and textures, particularly in the context of food and beverages. This suggests that Chuck is discerning and appreciative of subtle nuances and complexities in the items he consumes. It implies that Chuck may have a heightened sensitivity to flavors and a deep understanding of various culinary elements. Chuck's nuanced palate could mean that he enjoys exploring and experiencing a wide range of tastes, often preferring high-quality or unique options.
  • Chuck's intricate food preferences suggest that he has very detailed and specific tastes when it comes to food, especially regarding vinegar and pickles. This implies that Chuck is discerning and particular about the flavors, textures, and qualities of the food he enjoys. His nuanced palate indicates that he appreciates subtle differences and complexities in the foods he consumes, such as the silky richness of balsamic vinegar and the unique qualities of various pickle varieties.
  • A variety of ...

Counterarguments

  • While Chuck prefers balsamic vinegar, some listeners might find its sweetness overpowering and may advocate for the versatility of apple cider vinegar or the sharpness of red wine vinegar in cooking.
  • Acknowledging Chuck's intricate food preferences might not resonate with all listeners, who could prefer a more inclusive approach that doesn't highlight individual tastes as much.
  • The recommendation to start with half sour di ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA