"John Williams"
In this SmartLess podcast episode, renowned film composer John Williams shares his meticulous approach to crafting impactful scores. He delves into his process of tirelessly refining motifs until they feel "inevitable," and his emphasis on tailoring his compositions to the emotional arc of a film's visuals.
Williams also reflects on his contrasting collaborations with directors like Steven Spielberg, who granted him significant creative freedom, and those whose naturalistic preferences led to more resistance towards music enhancing scenes. The episode touches on Williams' background as a classically trained yet jazz-influenced prodigy, and how the hosts connect with the universality and emotional power of his iconic work.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Jun 17, 2024 episode of the SmartLess
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
John Williams' Creative Process
Renowned composer John Williams shares his meticulous method for crafting iconic film scores. According to Williams, he composes themes meant to feel "inevitable" through extensive piano work and responding directly to a film's visuals.
Williams' "Inevitable" Themes
To find the iconic 5-note motif for "Close Encounters," Williams played hundreds of variations for Spielberg before they settled on one that felt like "a childhood memory."
Composing to the Visuals
Rather than creating music independently, Williams tailors his scores to the emotional narrative of the film, sometimes leading to the editing being adjusted to his compositions, as Spielberg did for the ending of "E.T."
Collaborating with Directors
Williams' scores are the product of close collaborations with visionary directors who had their own preferences and processes.
Open Collaborators Like Spielberg
Spielberg gave Williams substantial creative freedom, from greenlighting the simple "Jaws" theme to re-editing "E.T.'s" climax to Williams' sweeping score.
More Resistance From Some
Other directors like Martin Ritt preferred a more naturalistic approach and were resistant to letting music enhance scenes.
Williams' Background and Influences
From a young piano prodigy destined for concert halls, Williams was drawn to film scoring thanks to his father's work and diverse musical influences.
A Melting Pot of Styles
Williams drew from both his classical training and exposure to jazz, creating his sophisticated, genre-blending style.
Military Impact
Williams' marches and orchestrations were also shaped by his time in the Air Force, where he admired the excellence of military bands.
Universal Emotional Power
Hosts Bateman, Arnett, and Hayes celebrate how Williams' music transcends language to tap into shared human experiences and emotions.
A Universal "Language"
Williams likens the 5-note "Close Encounters" theme to a connective language that requires no translation.
Deeply Moving Impact
The hosts recount being profoundly moved by Williams' music from childhood, sparking their own musical awakenings and love for the art form.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While Williams' themes are designed to feel "inevitable," some critics argue that the process of finding such themes can be somewhat subjective and what feels "inevitable" to one person may not to another.
- The idea that Williams' scores are tailored to the emotional narrative of the film could be seen as limiting the potential for the music to stand on its own outside the context of the film.
- The collaboration between Williams and directors, while often successful, might overshadow the contributions of other important figures in the filmmaking process, such as sound designers and editors.
- The notion that Spielberg gave Williams complete creative freedom could be nuanced by acknowledging that even in collaborative relationships, there are always negotiations and compromises.
- The resistance from directors like Martin Ritt to enhance scenes with music could be defended as a legitimate artistic choice that aims for a different kind of authenticity or emotional impact.
- Williams' drawing from his classical training and jazz could be critiqued by purists of either genre as diluting the distinctiveness of those styles.
- The influence of Williams' time in the Air Force on his music might be overstated or might marginalize other influences that have shaped his compositional style.
- The claim that Williams' music transcends language and taps into shared human experiences could be challenged by cultural relativists who argue that musical interpretation is heavily influenced by cultural context.
- The idea that the 5-note "Close Encounters" theme is a universal language might be contested by pointing out that the emotional response to music is highly individual and can vary widely based on personal and cultural experiences.
- The hosts' personal emotional responses to Williams' music, while valid, may not be universal, and other listeners may not have the same connection or awakening to the art form.
Actionables
- Explore your own "inevitable" themes by improvising on a musical instrument, focusing on creating melodies that resonate with your personal experiences or visual cues from your surroundings. As you play, try to find a sequence of notes that feels familiar or comforting, much like a motif that could serve as your own signature.
- Develop a deeper connection with music by creating a playlist that aligns with the emotional narrative of your day or a specific event. Choose songs that match your feelings at different moments, and notice how music can influence or enhance your perception of these events, similar to a film score complementing a scene.
- Engage with music as a universal language by sharing a piece of music that has deeply moved you with someone from a different cultural background. Discuss the emotions and memories it evokes for both of you, and explore how despite language barriers, certain melodies or rhythms can convey shared human experiences.
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
John Williams' creative process and approach to film composition
The celebrated composer John Williams shares insights into his meticulous method when crafting unforgettable musical scores for film, a process that bridges deliberate experimentation with a response to cinema’s visual storytelling.
Williams crafts musical's themes that feel "inevitable" through extensive piano work and experimentation
Williams illustrates the labor behind composing themes that feel as though they have always existed. This involves returning to the piano after watching a film to manipulate themes which he then refines to feel “inevitable.”
Williams played hundreds of 5-note musical motifs for Spielberg before landing on the iconic theme for Close Encounters
For "Close Encounters of the Third Kind," Williams shared an anecdote about the exhaustive process of finding the right theme. He composed over a hundred five-note motifs, varying the intervallic relationships without concern for note length. Together with Spielberg, they individually identified a particular motif that grabbed their attention. Eventually, they both settled on the very motif they had unconsciously circulated.
Williams emphasized that the motif, as it is recognized today, feels like a childhood memory, part of an incomplete sentence, which holds a profound and unsettling power.
Williams' creative process often involves responding to the visuals, rather than composing music first
Williams often tailors his music to complement the narrative and emotional context of the visuals of a film. Although he does not explicitly state his preference to watch the rough cut of a film before scoring it, his approach to "Close ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
John Williams' creative process and approach to film composition
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While Williams' themes may feel "inevitable," some critics argue that the process of making music feel this way can sometimes lead to over-reliance on familiar musical tropes, which may limit innovation.
- The anecdote about playing hundreds of motifs for Spielberg could be seen as an inefficient process, and some might argue that a more systematic approach to composition could yield results more quickly.
- Responding to visuals is a common approach in film scoring, but some composers argue for the benefits of creating music independently of the film to bring a fresh perspective that can influence the film's editing and narrative, rather than always havin ...
Actionables
- You can explore the power of iteration by creating variations on a simple idea until it resonates with you. Start with a basic concept or project, like a drawing, a short story, or a simple melody if you're musically inclined. Make small changes with each iteration, and notice how your perception of the idea evolves. This mirrors the process of finding the "inevitable" theme through experimentation.
- Develop a habit of using visual prompts to inspire your creative projects. If you're writing, painting, or composing, choose a picture or scene from a movie and create something that you feel represents the essence of that image. This practice can help you experience the interplay between visuals and your own creative output, similar to how a composer might respond to film scenes.
- Engage in collaborative feedbac ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Williams' collaborations with directors and the dynamic between composer and filmmaker
John Williams' career as a composer showcases a long history of deep collaborations and dynamic interactions with prominent directors, each with their own stylistic preferences and creative processes.
Williams had a highly collaborative relationship with directors like Steven Spielberg, who was open to Williams' creative input
John Williams discusses the close collaborative relationship he had with Steven Spielberg during their work together, particularly highlighting their joint efforts on the film "E.T."
Spielberg's openness to Williams' creativity
Spielberg initially expressed skepticism when Williams first presented the simple, yet ominous two-note motif for the film "Jaws." However, through Williams' vision that the theme could work when played by an orchestra, Spielberg came to trust Williams. Williams explained that the motif could become very ominous and could change in pace as the shark approaches, becoming deafening when necessary.
In the case of "E.T.," Williams encountered challenges in synchronizing the music with the film's last 15 minutes, which was full with pivotal moments. When Williams expressed that he could not get the music to sync in a way that felt right, Spielberg showed extraordinary flexibility. Sean Hayes sets the scene by sharing that Spielberg loves a lot of music in his movies, which leads to Williams revealing how Spielberg re-edited the ending of "E.T." to better fit Williams' sweeping and emotive score. Spielberg suggested Williams record the music as he deemed musically satisfying with the film's visuals adjusted afterward. Spielberg recut the movie to the music Williams recorded, resulting in a more ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Williams' collaborations with directors and the dynamic between composer and filmmaker
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- John Williams, when faced with directors resistant to using music in their films, often had to delicately navigate their preferences by finding ways to demonstrate the value of his musical contributions. This could involve showcasing how music could enhance the emotional impact of a scene without overpowering it, or by proposing subtle ways in which the score could complement the visuals without being intrusive. Williams' approach in such situations may have involved building trust with the director over time, demonstrating the potential of music to elevate the storytelling without overshadowing the narrative. While specific exampl ...
Counterarguments
- While Spielberg was open to Williams' creative input, it could be argued that this level of collaboration is not unique to Williams and that many directors have similar relationships with their composers.
- The flexibility Spielberg showed by editing "E.T." to fit Williams' music might suggest a director's willingness to compromise visual storytelling for the sake of the score, which some could argue might not always serve the film's best interest.
- The assertion that some directors see music as secondary could be challenged by the idea that these directors may instead have a different vision for the role of music, seeking to use it in a more subtle or nuanced way rather than as a dominant force.
- Williams' navigation of directors resistant to using music to enhance scenes might be seen not as a challenge but as a normal part ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Williams' Musical Background and Training, and How it Influenced His Career
John Williams, the acclaimed composer, initially set his sights on becoming a concert pianist, but his career took a legendary turn toward film scoring due to his early exposure and various life experiences that shaped his distinctive musical style.
Williams' Journey from Piano Prodigy to Film Score Maestro
At a young age, Williams was already focused on a future as a concert pianist. However, his trajectory changed when he stepped into the world of film scoring, an interest that was sparked during his teenage years. He began observing Hollywood studio sessions, an opportunity that came his way thanks to his father.
Williams' Father: The Gateway to Film Scoring
John Williams shares that it was his father, a professional studio musician, who first exposed him to the art of film scoring. Accompanying his father to Hollywood orchestra sessions, young Williams was introduced to the craft and intricacies of composing music for the silver screen.
A Melting Pot of Musical Genres
William's background wasn't just rooted in one style; as a musician, he was versed in both jazz and classical music. This blend of genres equipped him with a versatile and sophisticated approach to composition, which later became evident in his diverse and elaborate film scores.
Military Influence on Williams' Orchestrations
Not only did his family background and musical education shape him, but John Williams' compositional style was also profoundly influenced by hi ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Williams' Musical Background and Training, and How it Influenced His Career
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
...
Actionables
- Explore a new creative field by attending local community arts events to broaden your exposure, similar to how Williams' early experiences shaped his career path. By visiting local film festivals, theater productions, or art exhibitions, you can immerse yourself in different artistic disciplines, which may inspire you to pursue a new hobby or career.
- Create a personal 'inspiration playlist' of music from various genres to foster versatility in your own projects. Just as Williams' background in jazz and classical music influenced his compositions, listening to and studying a diverse range of music can enhance your creative thinking and problem-solving skills in everyday tasks.
- Set a high standard for personal projects by adopting a 'mi ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
The emotional and universal impact of Williams' music
Jason Bateman, Will Arnett, and Sean Hayes all celebrate the profound, universal appeal and emotional depth of John Williams' scores, defining Williams’ creations as a unifying force in the world of music and storytelling.
Williams' scores have the power to transcend language and culture, tapping into a shared human experience
Williams’ scores, such as the iconic 5-note theme from "Close Encounters of the Third Kind," function as a musical language. John Williams discusses music's intrinsic roots in human structure, implying an instinctual level of understanding that transcends language—it is spiritual rather than linguistic. The hosts acknowledge Williams' impact on filmmaking, akin to silent films with music as a pivotal element. Williams describes music as not language-specific but universal, reaching people on an intellectual level that transcends linguistics.
The 5-note theme from Close Encounters functions like a musical "language," with the fifth note acting as a conjunctive
The 5-note theme from "Close Encounters" is highlighted for its linguistic-like approach where the final, fifth note serves as a conjunctive, an olive branch that does not require conscious thought to be understood. Williams portrays music as a hopeful force, capable of bridging gaps and connecting all of humanity intellectually.
Listeners, including the podcast hosts, describe feeling deeply moved and transformed by Williams' scores
Jason Bateman comments on the classic "Close Encounters" musical conversation scene, describing it as magically universal and timeless. As youngsters, both Arnett and Bateman understood the film's emotional content, testament to the power of Williams’ score. Likewise, Sean Hayes shares his personal admiration for Williams as an early inspiration to his ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
The emotional and universal impact of Williams' music
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While Williams' scores are indeed celebrated for their emotional depth, some critics argue that his style is derivative of earlier classical and film composers, suggesting a lack of originality in certain themes.
- The universality of Williams' music may not be absolute; some cultures may not resonate with his music in the same way, due to different musical traditions and emotional codifications.
- The idea that the 5-note theme from "Close Encounters" functions as a universal language could be seen as an oversimplification, as the interpretation of music is highly subjective and can vary greatly among individuals.
- Not all listeners may feel deeply moved or transformed by Williams' scores; emotional responses to music are personal and can be influenced by a multitude of factors, including individual taste and cultural background.
- While Williams' music has been ...
Actionables
- Create a personal playlist of film scores that evoke strong emotions to explore the impact of music on your mood. By selecting pieces that resonate with you, you can use this playlist to enhance your daily activities, whether it's to motivate you during a workout or to help you relax after a long day. For example, if you find the "Superman" theme empowering, include it in your morning routine to start your day with a sense of strength.
- Experiment with non-verbal communication by creating a simple melody to convey a message to friends or family. This could be as simple as assigning a specific tune to signal dinner time or to express appreciation. You might use a keyboard app on your phone to compose a short, 4-5 note sequence that has a particular meaning, and share it with your loved ones to see if they understand the emotion or message you're trying to convey.
- Engage with local community groups to organize a 'John Williams Listening Party' where par ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
