Podcasts > Significant Others > Hilary Liftin on the Art of Ghostwriting

Hilary Liftin on the Art of Ghostwriting

By Team Coco

Dive into the world of written words and uncredited expertise with "Significant Others," featuring a conversation with ghostwriter Hilary Liftin. In this episode, Liftin pulls back the curtain on the lesser-known partnership of ghostwriting, a meticulous collaboration where she and others like her craft compelling narratives that echo the true voices of their subjects. The discussion explores the symbiotic relationship between the writer and the subject, exposing the detailed process by which personal experiences are transformed into structured, themed stories, akin to the introspection encountered in a therapeutic setting.

Liza Powel O'Brien and Hilary Liftin delve into the practicalities and nuances of ghostwriting, shedding light on aspects like the quick turnarounds of 'rush books' and the distinctive challenges of capturing someone's narrative voice. The conversation encompasses the emotional depth of the ghostwriting process, its therapeutic parallels, and Liftin's adept ability to juggle multiple book projects, ensuring that each client feels singularly attended to. Listeners will gain an understanding of the dedication and skill required to weave a person's life into a narrative that resonates with readers, all while spotlighting the often-unacknowledged art of the ghostwriter.

Listen to the original

Hilary Liftin on the Art of Ghostwriting

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Feb 29, 2024 episode of the Significant Others

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Hilary Liftin on the Art of Ghostwriting

1-Page Summary

The nature of ghostwriting and the role ghostwriters play

Ghostwriting is a partnership where the ghostwriter collaborates closely with the book's subject to create a narrative that is faithful to their voice. Hilary Liftin, a ghostwriter, works with individuals who lack the time to pen their own stories, providing them the opportunity to share their experiences without the restrictions of brevity required by other media. This collaboration transforms raw material into a structured, thematic work reminiscent of the self-reflection found in therapy. Ghostwriters, like Liftin, may choose different levels of credit, with some preferring anonymity and others seeking a measure of recognition. Liftin advocates for public acknowledgment of ghostwriters to recognize the profession and the need of expertise in crafting a book.

The process and scope of ghostwriting a book

The timeline for ghostwriting can vary, with "rush books" completed within a few months. Unlike editing or book doctoring, which involves refining existing content, ghostwriting requires creating a book from scratch, often without an initial manuscript. Liftin contrasts these roles, highlighting the extensive and foundational contributions a ghostwriter makes to a project from inception.

Therapeutic aspect of ghostwriting

The process of ghostwriting offers therapeutic benefits, as it encourages subjects to reflect on and understand their lives through storytelling. Liftin describes this partnership as liberating and an exercise in self-discovery for clients. The end product—a book—serves to not only chronicle a subject's experiences but also enables them to gain insight and achieve personal clarity. This emotional exploration throughout the ghostwriting process can have a profound impact, offering clients a clearer perspective of their own narratives.

Capturing and developing a subject's narrative voice

Liftin faces the challenge of capturing a subject's narrative voice with minimal interaction, aiming to preserve their essence in writing. This task is intricate and includes converting spoken words into a written format that still conveys the subject's unique personality traits. Through intimate knowledge of the subject, collaborative review, and meticulous revision, a ghostwriter ensures that the voice on the page truly represents the individual, forging connections between the subject and readers.

Managing multiple book projects simultaneously

Liftin adeptly manages multiple book projects by capitalizing on her clients' availability and prioritizing tasks to keep all projects moving forward. She provides personalized attention, making each client feel like they are her only focus. Her strategy involves switching between various phases of different projects, such as interviewing for one while drafting another, demonstrating her skill in multitasking and project management. Despite the challenges, Liftin maintains productivity and ensures each project meets both the author's expectations and the editor's standards.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Ghostwriting partnerships involve a close collaboration between a ghostwriter and the book's subject to create a narrative that reflects the subject's voice authentically. The ghostwriter works to understand the subject's experiences, emotions, and perspectives to translate them into a cohesive written work. This partnership often requires trust, communication, and shared goals to ensure the final product captures the essence of the subject's story. Ghostwriters play a crucial role in shaping and structuring the narrative while maintaining the subject's unique voice throughout the writing process.
  • Ghostwriting involves creating a book from scratch based on the subject's input, while editing focuses on refining existing content for clarity and coherence. Book doctoring typically involves more extensive rewriting and restructuring of a manuscript to improve its overall quality and marketability. Ghostwriters work closely with the subject to capture their voice and story, while editors and book doctors focus on enhancing the manuscript's structure and content.
  • Ghostwriting can offer therapeutic benefits by prompting individuals to reflect on their experiences and gain personal insight through storytelling. The process of sharing one's story and working closely with a ghostwriter can be liberating and lead to self-discovery. By transforming raw material into a structured narrative, ghostwriting allows clients to explore their emotions and perspectives in a meaningful way. The end product, a book created through this collaborative process, not only chronicles their experiences but also helps them achieve clarity and understanding.
  • Capturing a subject's narrative voice in ghostwriting involves understanding their unique way of expressing themselves. The ghostwriter aims to convey the subject's personality and tone authentically in the written work. This process requires careful observation, deep listening, and empathy to translate spoken words into a written form that resonates with the subject's essence. Through collaboration, revision, and feedback, the ghostwriter ensures that the narrative voice on the page reflects the subject's true self.
  • Ghostwriter Hilary Liftin manages multiple book projects simultaneously by leveraging her clients' availability and prioritizing tasks effectively. She gives personalized attention to each project, ensuring progress by switching between different phases of various books. Liftin's strategy involves interviewing for one project while drafting another, showcasing her multitasking skills and project management expertise. Despite the challenges, she maintains productivity and ensures that each project meets both the author's expectations and the editor's standards.

Counterarguments

  • Ghostwriting can raise ethical concerns about authenticity and transparency, as readers may believe the named author wrote the content themselves.
  • The therapeutic benefits of ghostwriting may not be equivalent to professional therapy and should not be seen as a substitute for mental health treatment.
  • The practice of ghostwriting might perpetuate the idea that storytelling and writing are not accessible skills, potentially discouraging individuals from developing their own writing abilities.
  • Public acknowledgment of ghostwriters could potentially diminish the perceived value or authenticity of the book to some readers or critics.
  • The process of capturing a subject's voice might result in a loss of nuance or authenticity, as the ghostwriter's interpretation could influence the final narrative.
  • Managing multiple book projects simultaneously could lead to concerns about the quality of attention and focus given to each individual project.
  • The notion that ghostwriters should receive more recognition could conflict with the desires of clients who prefer the ghostwriter's role to remain discreet.
  • The idea that ghostwriting is akin to self-reflection in therapy might overstate the personal growth aspect and understate the commercial and transactional nature of the service.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Hilary Liftin on the Art of Ghostwriting

The nature of ghostwriting and the role ghostwriters play

Hilary Liftin, a seasoned professional in the field, provides insight into the collaborative and often invisible world of ghostwriting.

Working with book subjects to find and shape their stories

Liftin describes ghostwriting as a collaborative effort where the ghostwriter works intimately with the book's subject to weave their stories into a coherent narrative that remains true to their voice and manner of self-expression. She often works with smart, capable individuals who are too busy to write their own books, thus bringing in a ghostwriter to expedite the process.

Liftin enjoys enabling her clients to experience the romance of writing a book, particularly because these public figures need to manage their public statements carefully. In writing a book, they get a chance to express themselves without the limitations of censorship or the need to produce sound bites.

The process involves turning a "dump of material" into a structured and thematically consistent puzzle. Liftin finds pleasure in extracting themes from these stories, comparing the process to self-understanding in therapy.

Lack of credit and desire to remain invisible

Despite preferring the term "ghostwriter" for its clarity, Liftin acknowledges that she is technically a "collaborator" on such projects. After publication, she appreciates the ability to step away from the spotlight and avoid the publicity phase, focusing solely on the aspect of writing she enjoys.

Her contractual relationships are typically made directly with the book subject, which simplifies the process for all parties involved. Ghostwriters have a range of options for credit, from complete invisibility to acknowledgment on the title page or even the cover. Liftin herself prefers an acknowledgment on the title page for industry acknowledgment, but not ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The nature of ghostwriting and the role ghostwriters play

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Ghostwriting is a collaborative process where a writer works closely with a book's subject to bring their story to life. The ghostwriter's role is to capture the subject's voice and style while structuring the content into a coherent narrative. This collaboration allows busy individuals, such as public figures, to share their stories without the burden of writing themselves. The ghostwriter remains behind the scenes, helping the subject express themselves authentically while maintaining confidentiality and often choosing to stay invisible after the project is completed.
  • When a ghostwriter mentions turning a "dump of material" into a structured and thematically consistent puzzle, they are referring to the process of organizing and refining a large amount of raw content provided by the book's subject into a coherent and cohesive narrative. This involves sifting through the information, identifying key themes, and arranging the material in a logical and engaging manner to create a compelling story. The term "dump of material" suggests an initial unorganized collection of thoughts, stories, and information that needs to be shaped and polished into a finished manuscript. The ghostwriter's role is to transform this raw material into a well-crafted and cohesive piece of writing that reflects the author's voice and vision while ensuring consistency and coherence throughout the book.
  • Ghostwriters often choose to remain invisible after publication to maintain focus on the book's author and their story. This allows the author to take full credit and ownership of the work without distractions. Ghostwriters prioritize the integrity of the author's voice and narrative, preferring to support them behind the s ...

Counterarguments

  • While ghostwriting is collaborative, it can sometimes lead to ethical concerns about authenticity and transparency, as the reader may believe the named author wrote every word.
  • The notion that only "smart, capable individuals who are too busy" use ghostwriters might be an oversimplification, as there are various reasons someone might employ a ghostwriter, including lack of confidence in writing or desire for a professional touch.
  • The idea that ghostwriting allows for uncensored expression assumes that the ghostwriter's influence doesn't alter the original voice or message, which may not always be the case.
  • The comparison of ghostwriting to therapy might not resonate with everyone, as some may see it purely as a commercial transaction rather than a journey to self-understanding.
  • The preference for invisibility in ghostwriting is not universal; some ghostwriters and readers believe in the importance of transparency and credit for the work done.
  • The range of options for ghostwriter credit might not be as flexible in practice due to publishing industry norms or the desires of the named author.
  • The preference for acknowledgment on the title page but not on the cover could ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Hilary Liftin on the Art of Ghostwriting

The process and scope of ghostwriting a book

O'Brien and Liftin delve into the intricacies of ghostwriting, providing insights into both the expected timelines of ghostwriting a book and how the practice differs from editing or book doctoring.

Typical timeline to ghostwrite a book

Discussing the timeline of ghostwriting projects, they bring up historical precedents. For instance, George Palmer Putnam famously employed ghostwriters to quickly capitalize on public interest, exemplified by the rush to publish a book on Lindbergh's flight across the Atlantic, which a ghostwriter completed in a mere 11 days. Liftin notes that, in modern times, a "rush book" for her is from start to finish in three to four months, which she considers fast.

Difference from editing

When it comes to distinguishing ghostwriting from editing or book doctoring, Liftin clarifies that gho ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The process and scope of ghostwriting a book

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Ghostwriting involves writing a book from scratch on behalf of someone else, often without an existing manuscript. Editing focuses on refining and improving an already written piece of work. Book doctoring is a service where a professional helps shape and enhance existing material, providing guidance throughout the writing process. Each of these roles plays a distinct part in the book creation process, with ghostwriting being the most involved in terms of creating content from the ground up.
  • In the context of ghostwriting, a "rush book" typically refers to a project that needs to be completed quickly to capitalize on a timely topic or event. In modern times, a "rush book" can be completed from start to finish in three to four month ...

Counterarguments

  • While ghostwriting typically involves writing from scratch, there may be instances where ghostwriters work with some form of initial outline or concept provided by the credited author.
  • Editing and book doctoring can sometimes involve significant rewrites or additional writing, which can blur the lines between these services and ghostwriting.
  • The historical precedent of completing a book in 11 days is an extreme example and may not reflect the quality or depth expected of ghostwritten works today.
  • A three to four-month timeline for a "rush book" might still be too long for certain projects t ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Hilary Liftin on the Art of Ghostwriting

Therapeutic aspect of ghostwriting

Helping subjects understand their lives through storytelling

Ghostwriting, a collaborative effort often sought after by celebrities to pen their memoirs, transcends merely capturing and conveying an individual's life story. Liftin, an experienced ghostwriter, illuminates a deeper, more intrinsic benefit of the ghostwriting process—the therapeutic aspect of storytelling and self-expression.

Liftin emphasizes that the ultimate goal of ghostwriting is to encapsulate the subject's voice and experiences so authentically that they feel as though they wrote the book themselves. This intimate partnership between the ghostwriter and the subject is not just a transactional interaction; it has the capacity to be profoundly liberating for clients.

The act of ghostwriting provides a unique opportunity for subjects to explore and articulate their personal narratives comprehensively, often for the first time. Throughout this collaborative journey, as Liftin notes, subjects discover the therapeutic value of delineating their life's account. It's akin to therapy, where writing about life isn't just an exercise in recollection, but also one of self-discovery.

Clients often emerge from the ghostwriting process with ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Therapeutic aspect of ghostwriting

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Ghostwriting involves a writer (ghostwriter) creating content on behalf of someone else (author) who takes credit for it. It is a collaborative process where the ghostwriter works closely with the author to capture their voice and story accurately. The ghostwriter's role is to bring the author's ideas to life while maintaining confidentiality about their involvement. This collaborative effort aims to produce a final product that reflects the author's vision and experiences.
  • In ghostwriting, capturing the subject's voice authentically means writing in a way that reflects the subject's unique tone, style, and perspective. The ghostwriter aims to convey the subject's thoughts and emotions as if they were speaking or writing themselves. This involves closely studying the subject's speech patterns, vocabulary, and personal experiences to ensure the narrative feels genuine and true to the subject's identity. The goal is to create a seamless blend where the subject's essence shines through the written words, making the story feel like it is coming directly from them.
  • Ghostwriting, beyond just capturing stories, can be therapeutic for clients. It allows them to explore and express their personal narratives deeply. This process can lead to self-discovery and a clearer understanding of their own lives. The act of ghostwriting serves as a tool for introspection and can help clients share their journey with others.
  • In ghostwriting, exploring and articulating personal narratives involves delving into the subject's life experiences, emotions, and memories. The ghostwriter works closely with the subject to help them express their story authentically and comprehensively. This process often requires deep introspection and reflection on significant events and feelings. Through this collaborative effort, the subject's personal narrative is crafted into a cohesive and engaging story for readers to connect with.
  • Ghostwriting can be likened to therapy as it provides individuals with a platform to explore and express their personal narratives in a structured manner. Through the process of recounting their life experiences, subjects often gain insights and clarity about their own journey, similar to the introspective nature of therapy sessions. This self-reflection and storytelling can lead to a deeper understanding of oneself and the events that have influenced their lives, offering a form of catharsis and self-discovery. The act of articulating one's story through ghostwriting can be a transformative experience, allowing individuals to not only share their narrative with others but also to engage in a process of self-exploration and growth.
  • Ghostwriting can help individuals gain a clearer understanding of their lives by providing a structured platform to reflect on their experiences and emotions. Through the process of narrating their life stories with a ghostwriter, individuals can delve deeper into their past, emotions, and motivations. This introspection can lead to insights and self-discovery, as the act of articulating one's narrative can bring clarity and perspective to personal experiences. By engaging in the ghostwriting process, individu ...

Counterarguments

  • Ghostwriting may not always capture the subject's voice authentically due to the inherent differences in perspective and expression between the ghostwriter and the subject.
  • The therapeutic benefits of ghostwriting may not be universal, as some subjects might find the process stressful or invasive.
  • The process of ghostwriting could potentially lead to the oversimplification or alteration of events to fit a narrative arc, which might not reflect the true complexity of the subject's life.
  • The act of self-discovery through ghostwriting might be limited compared to other forms of therapy that involve direct interaction with a trained professional.
  • Clients may not always gain a clearer understanding of their lives; in some cases, they might rely on the ghostwriter's interpretation rather than t ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Hilary Liftin on the Art of Ghostwriting

Capturing and developing a subject's narrative voice

Challenge of translating spoken voice to the page

Capturing a client's narrative voice is a delicate and complex process for a ghostwriter, and for professionals like Liftin, it involves efficiently grasping the essence of a person's voice with limited interaction — sometimes as little as 10 hours. Liftin emphasizes the importance of embodying a voice that friends can recognize on the page, acknowledging that directly transcribing spoken language often fails to maintain the humor, emotion, or connection that the voice carries in conversation.

Liftin talks about the intricacies of her process, including spending considerable time with the person, absorbing their phrasing, and striving to create a written voice that resonates with who they truly are. She challenges herself to overcome obstacles such as clients who are reticent or emotionally guarded, aiming to still reflect their authentic narrative voice.

O'Brien reflects on how the ghostwriting process can give readers a strong connection to the written voice, such as in the case of Andre Agassi's "Open," which leads them to develop affection for the subject despite knowing they didn't do the actual writing. The ghostwriter's ability to capture and convey t ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Capturing and developing a subject's narrative voice

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Ghostwriting is a process where a writer creates content on behalf of someone else, often without receiving credit. In capturing a subject's narrative voice, ghostwriters aim to convey the essence of the person's speech and personality in written form. This involves spending time with the subject to understand their unique phrasing and style, ensuring the written voice reflects their true self. Ghostwriters face challenges in maintaining the authenticity and emotional depth of the subject's voice while translating spoken language into written text.
  • Capturing a client's narrative voice is crucial for ghostwriters to create authentic and engaging written content that reflects the client's personality and essence. It involves understanding the nuances of how the client speaks, thinks, and expresses themselves to ensure the written work resonates with readers as if the client were speaking directly to them. By capturing the client's narrative voice effectively, ghostwriters can maintain the emotional connection, humor, and authenticity that make the client's story compelling and relatable. This process requires careful observation, active listening, and skillful translation of spoken language into written form to convey the client's unique perspective and experiences accurately.
  • Translating spoken voice to writing involves capturing the essence of a person's unique way of speaking, including their tone, style, and personality. This process can be challenging as written text may not always fully convey the nuances, emotions, and connections present in spoken language. Ghostwriters often spend time with the subject to understand their speech patterns and phrasing, aiming to create a written voice that authentically represents the individual while en ...

Counterarguments

  • While capturing a client's narrative voice is indeed complex, some might argue that with the right techniques and tools, it can be systematized to a degree, making it less of an art and more of a replicable process.
  • The efficiency of grasping a person's voice with limited interaction could be questioned, as some might believe that truly capturing a voice requires extensive and prolonged engagement.
  • It could be argued that directly transcribing spoken language, with the right editorial skills, can indeed capture humor, emotion, or connection, especially if the transcriber is skilled in literary techniques that evoke spoken qualities.
  • The necessity of spending considerable time with the person to absorb their phrasing might be challenged by those who believe in the effectiveness of alternative methods, such as analyzing recorded interviews or written correspondence.
  • Some might question whether a written voice can ever truly resonate with who a person is, given that writing and speaking are inherently different modes of communication with different strengths and limitations.
  • The assertion that overcoming obstacles with reticent or emotionally guarded clients is crucial could be countered by the view that a ghostwriter's interpretation can also add value, potentially offering a different but equally valid perspective on the subject's voice.
  • The idea that the ghostwriting process can give readers a strong connection to the written voice might be met with skepticism by those who feel that knowing an author's genuine voice is essential to forming a true connectio ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Hilary Liftin on the Art of Ghostwriting

Managing multiple book projects simultaneously

Although Liftin does not explicitly detail her strategy for managing multiple book projects simultaneously, her experiences provide insight into her effective approaches.

Liftin shares that she indeed works on several projects at the same time and has a strategy for handling the complexity. She takes advantage of periods when her clients are less available to move forward with other projects. This juggling act allows her to stay productive without leaving any client feeling neglected.

Her prioritization skill is evident as she strives to make each author feel like they are her sole client, ensuring personalized and dedicated service. Liftin's experience with a particularly challenging project, which required three rewrites, showcases her ability to satisfy both the author's vision and the editor's requirements, a balancing act that surely benefits from her adept project management skills.

Furthermore, Liftin describes a dynamic workflow where ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Managing multiple book projects simultaneously

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Liftin is a professional who works with authors on their book projects, providing services such as editing, project management, and ensuring the author's vision aligns with editorial requirements. She juggles multiple projects simultaneously, handling tasks like conducting interviews, writing, and managing client interactions to ensure each author receives personalized and dedicated service. Her adaptability and efficiency shine through as she navigates the complexities of satisfying both the author's creative goals and the editorial standards across various book projects.
  • Liftin faces challenges in managing multiple book projects due to the need to balance varying client demands, timelines, and project complexities. Juggling different tasks simultaneously requires strong organizational skills and the ability to prioritize effectively. Adapting to shifting priorities and seamlessly transitioning between projects is crucial for maintaining productivity and ensuring quality outcomes. The dynamic nature of her workflow demands flexibility and efficient time management to meet the diverse needs of each project while providing personalized attention to every client.
  • Liftin's dynamic workflow involves multitasking by conducting interviews for one book while working on another, showcasing her ability to switch between different tasks efficiently. This approach allows her to make progress on multiple projects simultaneously, demonstrating her adaptability and time management skills. By engaging in various activities for different books concurrently, Liftin maintains productivity and ensures st ...

Counterarguments

  • While Liftin may work on several projects simultaneously, this approach might not be suitable for all writers or project managers, as it requires a high level of multitasking and may lead to burnout or decreased quality in some cases.
  • Taking advantage of periods when clients are less available assumes that these periods will align conveniently with the needs of other projects, which may not always be the case, potentially leading to scheduling conflicts or rushed work.
  • Ensuring personalized and dedicated service for each author is commendable, but it could be challenging to maintain the same level of personalization and dedication as the number of simultaneous projects increases.
  • Successfully managing a challenging project that required three rewrites demonstrates resilience and commitment, but it could also indicate initial planning or execution issues that necessitated the rewrites.
  • The ability to switch between different tasks and skill sets efficiently is a valuable skill, but constant switching could also hinder deep work or lead to a loss of focus on individu ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA