Podcasts > Shawn Ryan Show > #170 Mike Benz - USAID Funding CIA-Backed Mercenaries, Media Superweapons and Samantha Powers

#170 Mike Benz - USAID Funding CIA-Backed Mercenaries, Media Superweapons and Samantha Powers

By Shawn Ryan Show

In this episode of the Shawn Ryan Show, Mike Benz shares his perspective on the United States Agency for International Development (USAID) and its role in foreign affairs. Benz alleges that USAID has evolved from a civilian counterpart to the CIA into an organization that pursues regime change and political warfare through tactics like supporting opposition groups and civil societies. He argues that USAID's structure allows for covert activities and foreign interference with minimal oversight, impacting both US and foreign politics.

Benz further suggests that USAID collaborates with other agencies to shape media narratives and target critics, including US citizens. He explores how USAID's initiatives undermine national sovereignty while pursuing US foreign policy interests, operating in what he calls a "grey area" between overt and covert action.

#170 Mike Benz - USAID Funding CIA-Backed Mercenaries, Media Superweapons and Samantha Powers

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Feb 12, 2025 episode of the Shawn Ryan Show

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

#170 Mike Benz - USAID Funding CIA-Backed Mercenaries, Media Superweapons and Samantha Powers

1-Page Summary

History, Purpose, and Evolution of USAID

USAID was founded in 1961 by President Kennedy as a civilian counterpart to the CIA's covert capabilities, enabling initiatives without direct White House approval, according to Mike Benz. Over time, USAID's Office of Transition Initiatives (OTI) evolved to focus on post-Cold War political warfare and regime change, often circumventing traditional processes.

USAID's Role in Regime Change and Sovereignty Undermining

Benz suggests USAID weaponizes tactics like supporting opposition groups and civil societies through initiatives like the Arab Spring and "color revolutions" to influence foreign politics. He claims USAID targets populist threats, aiming to install US-aligned governments, while undermining national sovereignty.

USAID's Role with US Agencies to Bypass Oversight

Benz alleges USAID's structure allows covert actions and foreign interference without proper oversight. He cites examples like rerouting humanitarian funds and sidestepping approval processes. Benz positions USAID in a "grey area" of political warfare between overt and covert action.

USAID's Role in US Politics, Media Influence, and Citizen Targeting

Benz claims USAID funding influences US media coverage, think tanks, and institutions to shape narratives favoring US foreign policy. He suggests USAID may harass and silence critics, including Trump supporters, seen as foreign policy threats in collaboration with agencies.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • USAID's primary mission is to promote development and humanitarian assistance globally, not to serve as a tool for political warfare or regime change.
  • The Office of Transition Initiatives (OTI) is designed to support countries in transition towards democracy and peace, rather than to orchestrate political upheaval.
  • USAID's support for civil societies and opposition groups is often part of broader efforts to encourage democratic processes and human rights, rather than to weaponize these entities for US interests.
  • Claims that USAID targets populist threats to install US-aligned governments may overlook the agency's mandate to assist nations in achieving self-reliance and sustainable development.
  • USAID operates under the oversight of Congress, the Government Accountability Office (GAO), and its own Inspector General, which provides checks and balances against unauthorized activities.
  • The rerouting of humanitarian funds typically requires justification and oversight, and sidestepping approval processes would be against the agency's regulations and policies.
  • USAID's work is often transparent and publicly documented, which contradicts the notion of operating in a "grey area" between overt and covert action.
  • Funding from USAID to media, think tanks, and institutions is generally aimed at supporting independent journalism, research, and policy analysis, not at shaping narratives to favor US foreign policy.
  • Allegations that USAID may harass and silence critics would be inconsistent with US laws and the agency's commitment to democratic principles, including freedom of speech and political expression.

Actionables

  • You can enhance your critical thinking by analyzing the funding and affiliations of media sources and think tanks. When you read an article or report, take a moment to research who funded the work or the organization behind it. This will help you understand potential biases and the broader context of the information presented, allowing you to form a more informed opinion on global events.
  • Start a personal blog or social media page dedicated to discussing and dissecting foreign aid and its implications. By sharing your thoughts and findings on how foreign aid might be used for political purposes, you encourage others to consider the complexities of international relations and the impact of government actions on global politics.
  • Engage in community discussions or online forums to raise awareness about the importance of oversight in government agencies. By initiating conversations about the need for transparency and accountability, you contribute to a culture that values ethical practices in both domestic and international politics.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
#170 Mike Benz - USAID Funding CIA-Backed Mercenaries, Media Superweapons and Samantha Powers

History, Purpose, and Evolution of Usaid

The history and operational dynamics of the United States Agency for International Development (USAID) reflect its intricate role in foreign aid and covert operations.

Usaid, Founded In 1961 by President Kennedy, Provides International Aid and Development

USAID was established in 1961 by an executive order from President John F. Kennedy, marking a significant step in America's approach to international aid and development.

Usaid's Mandate now Includes Covert Political Warfare, Regime Change, and Foreign Intervention

Mike Benz touches upon the complex and sometimes opaque activities of USAID, intimating its involvement in funding research that might relate to contentious practices such as gain-of-function research, which suggests a capability for covert operations. Furthermore, USAID's Office of Transition Initiatives (OTI), created in 1993, has been particularly focused on post-Cold War political warfare. Its primary focus has been directed towards the former Soviet colonies in Eastern Europe, where it has been actively involved in efforts for regime change, political stabilization, and operates under the humanitarian aid umbrella, often circumventing the traditional approval processes.

Usaid Was Intended As a Civilian Counterpart to the Cia’s Covert Capabilities, With Flexibility to Bypass Oversight and Approval

JFK envisioned USAID as a civilian apparatus capable of operating with a degree of flexibility and autonomy not commonly associated with military and intelligence entities, ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

History, Purpose, and Evolution of Usaid

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • USAID's primary mission is to promote peaceful and equitable societies and to advance prosperity and stability through foreign aid, not to engage in covert operations or political warfare.
  • The agency operates with oversight and accountability, including to Congress, and its activities are subject to U.S. laws and regulations.
  • USAID works in collaboration with host country governments and local partners, and its initiatives are typically transparent and focused on development goals rather than covert or military objectives.
  • Characterizing USAID as a "switch player" with the ability to bypass oversight oversimplifies the complex interagency coordination and checks and balances that guide U.S. foreign policy and aid.
  • The Office of Transition Initiatives (OTI) is ...

Actionables

  • You can explore the impact of international aid by volunteering with a local organization that partners with USAID. By doing so, you'll gain firsthand experience of how policies and aid from large organizations trickle down to actual projects and communities. For example, find a local non-profit that implements USAID-funded programs and offer your time or skills to support their work.
  • Start a blog or social media page to raise awareness about the complexities of foreign aid and intervention. Use this platform to share insights, discuss the multifaceted roles of agencies like USAID, and encourage a nuanced conversation about their activities. This could involve creating infographics that explain the different roles of USAID, or writing articles that explore the ethical implications of foreign intervention.
  • Engage in citizen oversight by tracking USAID-funded pr ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
#170 Mike Benz - USAID Funding CIA-Backed Mercenaries, Media Superweapons and Samantha Powers

Usaid's Role in Regime Change and Sovereignty Undermining

The discussion led by Mike Benz explores the controversial activities of USAID, implicating the agency in foreign politics, privacy invasions, and supporting opposition groups to align governments with U.S. objectives.

Usaid Activities Influence Foreign Politics and Undermine Sovereignty

USAID has come under scrutiny for its involvement in activities that extend beyond traditional humanitarian assistance. Its operations include working with the U.S. Defense Department and special forces, suggesting a role in political activities that influence foreign politics and undermine national sovereignty.

Usaid Supports Opposition, Civil Society, and Media for "Color Revolutions" and Regime Change

Mike Benz comments on USAID's capacity for covert activity and political maneuvers, suggesting that the agency is weaponized and uses tactics that influence foreign politics. This includes support for CIA-backed mercenary groups, suggesting that USAID more than humanitarian aid is involved in regime change work, particularly through its Office of Transition Initiatives (OTI).

USAID's approach often involves targeting multiple sectors within a country, including media, social media, unions, worker groups, judiciaries, parliamentarians, cultural institutions, universities, and the commercial sector. They perform strategic assessments to identify gaps between existing assets in the region and the requirements to achieve a State Department foreign policy goal. After this, initiatives are funded to fill these gaps, aligning a country’s resources with U.S. foreign policy.

Mike Benz refers to past events where USAID was caught engaging in activities during the Arab Spring and various color revolutions. Notably, the Obama administration was seen as utilizing USAID and the National Endowment for Democracy (NED) to fund networks and train them on social media coordination for protests.

Internal USAID documents revealed a plan to create a "Cuban Spring" with orchestrated street protests and riots through social media, dubbed "smart mobs."

Usaid Targets Populist Movements Seen As Threats To Us Foreign Policy Interests, Regardless of Democratic Legitimacy

Usaid Interventions Aim For "Democracy" but Often Install Governments Aligned With Us Objectives

USAID has been implicated in Joe Biden's threat to Viktor Shokin regarding the removal of the prosecutor in Ukraine, an action suggesting leverage over foreign judicial outcomes. It targets election management bodies to influence court systems or task forces in election processes, particularly concerning disinformation.

The agency is also credited with significant asset seizures, policy changes, and the removal of government officials through media action. They are described as having caused regime change influence by leveraging connections between sponsored journalists and local prosecutors.

Mike Benz underscores the concern with USAID's flexibility, implying it handles activities too controversial for the CIA. He likens USAID’s current actions to the CIA’s historical involvement ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Usaid's Role in Regime Change and Sovereignty Undermining

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • You can enhance your critical thinking by researching the history and outcomes of foreign interventions. Start by looking at case studies of countries that have experienced significant political shifts and analyze the role of international aid organizations in those changes. This will help you understand the broader implications of foreign aid and its impact on sovereignty.
  • Develop media literacy by evaluating news sources on their coverage of international politics. Compare how different outlets report on the same event, especially in countries where foreign aid organizations are active. This practice will sharpen your ability to discern biases and recognize the influence of external entities on local media narratives.
  • Engage in community discussions to fost ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
#170 Mike Benz - USAID Funding CIA-Backed Mercenaries, Media Superweapons and Samantha Powers

Usaid's Role With US Agencies to Bypass Oversight

Concerns have been raised regarding the lack of oversight for USAID, suggesting that this could enable activities not approved through normal channels, potentially including covert action and foreign interference.

Usaid's Structure and Lack of Oversight Enable Covert Action and Foreign Interference Not Approved Through Normal Channels

Mike Benz points to the difficulties in auditing USAID, implying a lack of oversight that could allow it to fund initiatives typically reserved for the CIA, Defense, and State Department with less scrutiny. Benz references USAID's ability to carry out activities without a presidential finding, which is usually required for CIA covert actions, thereby enabling actions without as much government oversight.

USAID's structure as an "independent" agency allows it to navigate bureaucratic constraints more easily than agencies like the State Department, leading senior DOD leadership to express a preference for working with USAID. This is evidenced by Benz's mention of a "CIA back channel" and indications that USAID has funded entities implicated in foreign policy tactics not subject to the usual checks and balances, such as Creative Associates International.

For example, Benz discusses USAID’s ability to bypass standard approval processes, mentioning a loophole discovered by Trump's Inspector General for USAID that allows contractors to bypass restrictions on counterterrorism funds. Furthermore, USAID has been implicated in a scheme that rerouted humanitarian funds earmarked for Pakistan to fund a social media platform in Cuba, without presidential approval or Senate oversight.

Usaid's Role in the US "Political Warfare" Apparatus: Navigating the "Grey Area" Between Overt and Covert Action

The conversation suggests that USAID operates in a "grey area" between overt and covert action, serving as a swing player in US "political warfare." Benz hints that U.S. aid-funded networks were involved in the political instability in Ukraine, possibly influencing domestic political matters such as US elections or targeting citizens. These allegations raise concerns over USAID funding of groups such as ISIS and Al-Qaeda, suggesting the agency might be conducting activities without proper interagency approval procedures.

Benz also discusses the involvement of USAID-funded networks in events like the ousting of Viktor Yanukovych, the U ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Usaid's Role With US Agencies to Bypass Oversight

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • USAID is subject to oversight by multiple entities, including the Government Accountability Office (GAO), the USAID Inspector General, and Congressional committees, which regularly review its programs and expenditures.
  • The agency's activities are often in line with U.S. foreign policy objectives, which are set by the executive branch and overseen by Congress, ensuring a level of accountability and alignment with national interests.
  • USAID's work is primarily focused on development and humanitarian assistance, which is overt and transparent, rather than covert operations.
  • The agency's structure as an independent entity is designed to provide flexibility in responding to global development challenges, not to enable covert action or bypass oversight.
  • The claim that USAID funds groups like ISIS or Al-Qaeda is a serious accusation that would require substantial evidence, and there are strict legal frameworks in place to prevent such support.
  • The involvement of USAID in political events in other countries, such as Ukraine, is typically part of broader diplomatic efforts and support for democracy and governance, which is a public and often congressionally mandated aspect of its mission.
  • The assertion that USAID operates in a "grey area" between overt and covert action may overlook the agency's mandate for transparency and its efforts to report to Congress and the public.
  • The use of contractors and grantees is a common practice across many U.S. government agencies to implement programs, and these relationships are governed by federal acquisiti ...

Actionables

  • You can enhance your understanding of government oversight by tracking and analyzing USAID project data available to the public. Start by visiting the USAID website and examining their reports and data sets. Look for patterns in funding allocation, project types, and geographic focus. Use free online tools like Google Sheets to create a simple database where you can log this information and make notes on any anomalies or trends you observe.
  • Engage in citizen journalism by writing articles or blog posts that highlight your findings from the public data on USAID projects. Use platforms like Medium or WordPress to publish your insights. Focus on creating well-researched, fact-based content that raises questions about transparency and oversight. Share your work on social media to spark discussions and encourage others to take a closer look at these issues.
  • Participate in online forums and discussion ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
#170 Mike Benz - USAID Funding CIA-Backed Mercenaries, Media Superweapons and Samantha Powers

Usaid's Role in US Politics, Media Influence, and Citizen Targeting

Concerns regarding the influence of USAID on US media and politics, as well as its potential role in targeting US citizens considered threats to foreign policy, come to the forefront in a discussion with Mike Benz.

Usaid Has Funded US Media, Think Tanks, and Institutions, Often Influencing Their Coverage and Editorial Decisions

USAID funded the Tide Center with $27 million, the fiscal sponsor of the Black Lives Matter Foundation and Fair and Just Prosecutions (FJP), which is involved with Soros prosecutors, advising them on prosecutions and providing social media posts and talking points. Such funding suggests an ability to influence media coverage, potentially affecting the information landscape.

Shaped US Information Landscape, Promoting Narratives Favorable to US Foreign Policy and Undermining Alternatives

Benz points out that USAID grants may affect media outlets' content, detailing specific grants to Reuters while pointing out a perceived conflict of interest when these outlets report on figures like Trump and Elon Musk coincidently with actions against their companies.

Also, USAID's influence extends to think tanks, such as the Atlantic Council, which receives USAID funds and produces documents advising on how to sell and implement internet censorship. This extends to shaping narratives concerning disinformation, potentially influencing the political landscape and global perceptions.

In addition, USAID-funded entities like think tanks and media are implicated in performing statecraft and achieving US State Department ends supported by grant funding.

Usaid Harasses US Citizens Seen As Foreign Policy Threats, Collaborating With Agencies

Silencing Tactics Against Critics of US Foreign Policy

The discussion suggests that USAID may be involved in targeting US citizens seen as threats to foreign policy, potentially in collaboration with agencies like the State Department. This could manifest as harassment or silencing individuals, including Trump supporters, who have been branded as unwitting Russia sympathizers by groups funded by USAID.

The implication of this funding from agencies like USAID is that it influences the information landscape, promoting narratives in line with US foreign policy, and implementing silencing tactics against critics of that policy.

Benz alludes to example scenarios where USAID funds journalists who then create hit pieces that can lead to arrests, suggesting a direct line from this funding to media influence, which could shape media n ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Usaid's Role in US Politics, Media Influence, and Citizen Targeting

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • USAID's funding of media and think tanks is part of its mandate to promote development and democratic ideals, not necessarily to influence editorial decisions.
  • Grants to media and think tanks are often publicly disclosed, allowing for transparency and accountability in how the funds are used.
  • USAID's work is subject to oversight by Congress, which can investigate any alleged misuse of funds or undue influence on media and politics.
  • The fact-checking industry has multiple origins and contributors, not solely the US State Department, and aims to combat misinformation globally.
  • USAID's involvement in foreign countries is often at the invitation or with the consent of those countries, working in partnership rather than unilaterally imposing policies.
  • The support of legal advocates and academic thought leadership is a common practice among many international development agencies to strengthen ...

Actionables

  • You can diversify your news sources to mitigate the influence of potentially biased reporting by regularly seeking out international or independent media outlets that offer different perspectives on US foreign policy.
    • By doing this, you'll expose yourself to a variety of viewpoints and narratives, which can help you form a more balanced understanding of global events. For example, if you typically read news from a major US-based outlet, try following a reputable foreign publication or an independent investigative journalism platform to compare the coverage on the same issues.
  • Start a personal media literacy journal to critically analyze the content you consume, noting instances where coverage may be skewed or incomplete.
    • Keeping a journal encourages active engagement with the news rather than passive consumption. When you come across an article or report, write down the key points made and consider what might be missing or what interests might be served by the piece. This practice can sharpen your critical thinking skills and help you become more aware of potential biases or underlying agendas in media narratives.
  • Engage in conversations with peers about the impor ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA