In this episode of SERIALously, the focus lies on gripping true crime cases. Discussions cover the Delphi murders, where years later, a suspect received a guilty verdict, and the fatal shooting of Lauren Martin during an escalating conflict over an online feud. Instances of disappearances and suspected faked deaths are also explored, including the disappearance of Mackenzie Michalski and evidence suggesting Ryan Borgwart may have faked his own death for an online relationship.
The episode further examines tragic cases involving domestic disputes turning violent, including the quadruple murder-suicide in Duluth and the deaths of a couple in Longview. Throughout, the complex motives and impacts on families and communities are highlighted, reflecting the gravity of these true crime events.
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
After 7 years, the Delphi murder trial concluded with Richard Allen found guilty on all counts for the deaths of two victims. Prosecutors presented evidence like Allen's possession of flyers about the missing victims, while public opinion was divided on the verdict. The families felt relief at the guilty verdict that received public applause.
Savon Tyler fatally shot photographer Lauren Martin after a social media dispute over unsatisfactory work. The online feud escalated to a physical confrontation where Tyler killed Martin. Tyler was charged with first-degree homicide and her girlfriend faced accessory charges after initially not cooperating with authorities.
Authorities believe Ryan Borgwart faked his own death in Wisconsin. His belongings were found abandoned but evidence suggests he obtained a new passport, cleared his digital trail, and moved funds overseas, possibly to meet a woman from Uzbekistan he communicated with online. His family hopes he faces accountability.
In Budapest, Mackenzie Michalski from Oregon vanished after her travel companion left. Surveillance footage showed her with an Irish man who confessed to accidentally killing her during sex and disposing of her body, devastating Michalski's friends and family.
In Duluth, Anthony Nephew killed his ex-wife Erin, son Jacob, current wife Catherine, and son Oliver before taking his own life. Police found a history of Nephew's mental illness and financial troubles as potential motives in the tragic murder-suicide impacting the community.
In Longview, Juan Alvarado-Cínez and Cecilia Ochoa were found dead from gunshot and stab wounds after a domestic dispute, discovered by their child. With no signs of forced entry, police ruled out a third party, attributing the deaths to the couple's relationship issues they were considering separating over.
1-Page Summary
Two recent murder trials have captured the country's attention, showcasing the severity and public intrigue surrounding such high-profile legal battles.
The Delphi murder case, unresolved for seven years, finally concluded with a guilty verdict. During the 17-day trial, speculation and doubt clouded public opinion, leaving many uncertain about what outcome to anticipate. The results from public polls showed an even split among those who presumed a guilty verdict, those who foresaw a not guilty verdict, and those who expected a hung jury.
Richard Allen's role in the deaths was intensely scrutinized, and after 19 hours of jury deliberation, the verdict came in. Allen, a seemingly unassuming character who once worked at a local CVS and had printed flyers of the missing victims, was found guilty on all counts, including two counts of murder and two counts of felony murder.
When the verdict was read, the relief was palpable among the victim's families, who shed tears in the courtroom. Meanwhile, the public, having been deeply invested in the unfolding drama of this case, erupted in applause outside the courthouse.
A dispute that began on social media ended in a fatal confrontation and has now moved to the courts.
Savon Tyler, who had hired photographer Lauren Martin and later expressed dissatisfaction with the photos, resorted to criticizing Martin's work online. The strife intensified, leading to Tyler and her girlfriend confronting Martin. The confrontation turned physical and culminated with Tyle ...
High-profile murder cases and trials
In a startling series of events, authorities are investigating two separate cases: Ryan Borgwart's suspected faked death in Wisconsin and the tragic disappearance of Mackenzie Michalski in Budapest.
Ryan Borgwart's mysterious disappearance has led investigators to believe that he intentionally faked his own death. Borgwart was reported missing after he was supposed to go kayaking and fishing. Later, his capsized kayak, fishing rod, tackle box, wallet, keys, and license plate were found near Green Lake. However, despite initial fears and the community's and Sheriff's Office's dedicated search efforts, it was discovered that Borgwart was not dead.
Investigators uncovered that Borgwart had taken out a life insurance policy and was in communication with a woman from Uzbekistan. He took numerous steps to erase his digital presence, including replacing his laptop hard drive, clearing his browser history, and moving funds to a foreign account.
Further evidence, such as photos of his passport and the purchase of airline tickets, suggests that he is in Europe, potentially with the woman he met online. Canadian law enforcement found a passport run with his name shortly after he went missing. Although he reported his old passport as stolen or lost, it later emerged that it was at his house.
Borgwart's actions have had a substantial emotional impact on his family, who were misled to believe he had drowned. The family has expressed a deep longing for his return and hopes for Borgwart to be held accountable for the trauma he caused and the wastage of police resources.
Concurrently, in Budapest, Mackenzie Michalski, a nurse practitioner from Oregon, vanished under troubling circumstances.
Disappearances and suspected faked deaths
Recent events have highlighted the tragic outcomes of escalating confrontations that led to murder-suicides and unclear circumstances resulting in the deaths of multiple individuals, including children. The cases in Duluth, Minnesota, and Longview, Washington serve as grim examples of domestic altercations turning deadly.
A family tragedy unfolded in Duluth, Minnesota, as the community confronts the deaths of Anthony Nephew, his ex-wife Erin Abresom, their son Jacob, Nephew's current or second wife Catherine Ramsland, and their son Oliver. Erin and 15-year-old Jacob were found dead in their home after Erin did not show up for work, prompting a welfare check. They were discovered shot multiple times by the police, who arrived at Erin's home around 2 p.m.
Anthony was quickly identified as a suspect, and surveillance was set up at his home, located roughly a mile from Erin and Jacob's residence. Utilizing a drone, police found the bodies of Catherine and seven-year-old Oliver, both shot, and Anthony with a self-inflicted gunshot wound.
Although the motive remained murky, police disclosed Anthony's history of mental illness, with records revealing signs of psychosis. Anthony himself had written about mental health breakdowns potentially leading to suicide or homicide. Additionally, a GoFundMe had detailed his struggle with alcohol-induced psychosis, highlighting his attempts to seek treatment.
The victims had all been active community members. Erin was noted for her punctuality and consistent happiness during early morning runs with a running group, and Jacob participated in his high school's orchestra. Oliver contributed to his community by initiating a free toy library, which has now been transformed into a vigil in memory of him and Catherine.
The community reels from the events, struggling to ensure the memories of those lost endure, while police investigate the murders, examining factors such as mental health and financial troubles as possible motives.
In Longview, Washington, police and EMTs responding to a Halloween night emergency call at 6:05 p.m. encountered a grim and silent scene. Juan Antonio Alvarado-Cínez and Cecilia Robles Ochoa were found with severe injuries in their kitchen, both pronounced dead sho ...
Escalating confrontations leading to violence and homicide
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser