173: Teen House Party Turned Nightmare: The Very Suspicious Death of Noah Presgrove

Noah’s death was initially ruled an accident from a hit and run, but the autopsy revealed severe injuries, leading experts like Alina Burroughs and Dr. Stuart Fisher to suggest he may have been the victim of a brutal attack.

Law enforcement initially ruled Noah's death as a tragic hit-and-run accident based on the scene, but the autopsy report revealed much more severe injuries that contradicted this theory.

The Oklahoma Highway Patrol concluded Noah’s death as the result of a tragic hit-and-run incident. However, the autopsy results published later painted a much more sinister picture. The medical examiner’s report showed Noah suffered from extensive and severe injuries, raising suspicion that something other than a hit-and-run accident had occurred.

The autopsy found that Noah suffered from 10 broken ribs, a split skull, brain bleeding, punctured lungs, and numerous other fatal injuries that could not have resulted from a typical hit-and-run incident.

Noah's body exhibited 10 broken ribs, broken teeth, skin torn off to the skull bone, fingertips torn to bone, a split tongue, fractured vertebrae, broken neck, split skull, multiple skull fractures, a caved-in head, bleeding brain, punctured lungs, extensive damage to internal organs including the heart, spleen, and stomach, internal bleeding, and road rash on various upper body parts with no lower body injuries.

The absence of car parts or debris at the crime scene led the medical examiner to rule the cause of death as "undetermined," with multiple blunt force injuries as the mode.

Former crime scene investigator Alina Burroughs analyzed the autopsy findings and evidence, concluding that Noah's injuries were inconsistent with being struck by a vehicle.

Alina Burroughs, a former crime scene investigator, analyzed the findings and concluded that the injuries did not match what would be expected from a hit-and-run. Noah’s injuries were primarily to t ...

Investigations into the death of Noah face complexities as the accounts from attendees of the party he was last seen at are inconsistent and at times contradictory, raising suspicions about what really happened and who was involved.

Many of Noah's friends who were at the party provided drastically different stories about the events leading up to his death, raising suspicions about their involvement.

The events that transpired between September 1st and September 4th at the party where Noah was last seen alive remain murky, with pieced-together details from social media and testimony from friends and family. Concern is growing as Noah's friends, and even their parents, have shared different recounts on Facebook. Deborah Smith noted that some individuals have given varying accounts, with one person providing two different stories, while another gave three. Actions like deleting social media posts and wiping phones have further aroused suspicions, despite claims from the attendees that these actions were merely to "stay busy" or "help their kids," rather than to hide potential evidence.

Attendees deleted social media posts and wiped their phones, which they claimed was just to "stay busy" and "help their kids" rather than hide evidence.

It was discovered that all posts to social media related to the party were deleted and all phones belonging to attendees were completely wiped, actions that invite skepticism about the motives behind them.

One partygoer, Kayden, claimed he and other boys found Noah's body and took his black shorts off before the authorities arrived, contradicting other accounts.

Kayden provided an account that stood out, as he claimed that he and other boys came upon Noah's body in his red Cherokee truck. He alleged that they found Noah wearing black shorts, but Jack removed them and replaced them with white shorts. This contradicts other statements as well as the claims from the truck drivers who initially found Noah, asserting that they never saw any group of boys at the scene.

Jack Newton, Noah's best friend, has given multiple, conflicting accounts of his whereabouts and involvement the night of the incident.

Jack Newton, a figure central to the story, has provided inconsistent versions of his role on the night in question.

Jack initially claimed he went to bed early, but later said he found Noah's body on the road and called his father, Caleb, who arrived at the scene.

Initially, Jack claimed he went to bed early and was not awake when Noah reportedly crashed an ATV. ...

Many believe Noah's death was the result of foul play rather than a hit-and-run, given the severity of his injuries and the suspicious behavior of the partygoers.

Theories abound regarding the tragic and mysterious circumstances surrounding Noah's death, with many doubting the hit-and-run explanation due to the nature of his injuries and the actions of those at the party. Rumors have circulated that Noah unexpectedly walked in on his friend's dad, Caleb Newton, in a compromising situation, leading to suspicion about Caleb's involvement. Caleb reportedly went home, but uncertainty persists about his potential role in the events that night.

Theories suggest Noah was beaten, potentially by a group including his friend Jack and/or Jack's father Caleb, either at the party or in a nearby barn that was later burned down.

Tensions between Noah and his friend Jack, especially over an issue involving Carter Combs, have led to speculation that their physical fight might be connected to Noah's eventual death. Adding to the sinister overtones are rumors of a video showing girls caring for an unconscious Noah, perhaps after sustaining injuries from a "fight club," on ATVs, or in a more nefarious activity. Moreover, the discovery of golf clubs, which were seen being used at the party and later found in the trash during a clean-up, have only fueled speculation that a violent attack took place.

Annie Elise speculates there was an incident involving Noah that led to a panicked response by the kids at the party. Noah's cousin Lindsay believes that Noah was found on the side of the highway and suggests he was placed there postmortem, intimating that someone at the party knows the real story.

The discovery of golf clubs and Noah's missing belongings at the party house have fueled speculation that he was violently attacked.

The mention of golf clubs at the party, and in subsequent trash cleanup by someone named Caden, adds a grim layer to the speculation around Noah's death, insinuating the possible involvement of such implements in a violent attack on Noah.

Avery Combs, the host of the party, has also come under scrutiny, as the party was held at her home where minors were ...

The family of Noah, who tragically died under unclear circumstances, is enduring a heart-wrenching journey for answers and justice amidst the turmoil of conflicting stories and frustration with the investigation's lack of progress.

Noah's family has expressed deep frustration with the lack of progress in the investigation and the conflicting stories from the partygoers.

Noah's older brother, Dailen, has voiced his belief that someone at the party knows more than they're willing to say and should come forward with information.

Noah's older brother Dailen has been very vocal, appearing in numerous interviews, about his brother's death. He suggests that although some partygoers are willing to talk about certain aspects of the night Noah died, they are reluctant to share too much, potentially due to fear of hindering the investigation. Dailen's drive to where Noah was found, presenting a scene inconsistent with a typical hit-and-run accident, has fueled his conviction that people at the party know more than they have disclosed.

The family has started GoFundMe campaigns to hire a private investigator and offer a reward in the hopes of uncovering the truth about Noah's death.

Dailen expresses his hope that raising public awareness might prompt someone with information to come forward. Regrettably, the transcript does not mention the specific GoFundMe campaigns or rewards, but Noah's family's determination is evident in their actions to seek the truth, including starting campaigns to fund a private investigation.

Despite the initial ruling of a hit-and-run accident, Noah's family remains convinced that foul play was involved and is determined to uncover the real circumstances surrounding his demise.

Noah's sister, Madison, and cousin, Lindsay, have expressed their belief that an "accident" occurred at the party that the attendees are covering up, leading to Noah's tragic death.

Madison, Noah's sister, voiced her belief that something more than a hit-and-run occurred and suspe ...