The SERIALously podcast explores one of the most disturbing family dynamics and missing person cases in recent memory. It chronicles the unstable personal history and religious beliefs of Josh Powell's father, Steve, and their influence on Josh's eventual controlling behavior in his marriage to Susan.
Delving into the suspicious circumstances around Susan's 2009 disappearance, the summary details the unsettling evidence found in the home and the unusual custody battle that ensued. It culminates with Josh's premeditated act of murder-suicide in 2012, killing himself and the couple's two sons in a horrific explosion.
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
Susan and Josh Powell met at a Latter-day Saints (LDS) church event. While Susan grew up in a normal household, Josh's upbringing was troubled, influenced by his father Steve's disturbing views about women and pornography. According to detectives, Steve Powell became obsessively infatuated with Susan, stealing her underwear and secretly recording her.
Despite this concerning family background, Susan and Josh initially had a happy marriage with two sons. However, Josh exhibited controlling behaviors over finances and accrued significant debt.
On December 6, 2009, Josh claimed to have taken the boys camping in a blizzard, leaving Susan home alone, which was seen as highly suspicious. Police found concerning evidence in the house, including a wet spot on the carpet, Susan's missing phone, and unused camping supplies in Josh's van.
Susan's personal journals expressed marital issues and distrust towards Josh. Investigators also found Josh had previously made disturbing comments about disposing of bodies and had significant life insurance policies on Susan.
After Susan's disappearance, Steve and Josh's brother Michael engaged in a smear campaign against Susan's family, making unsubstantiated claims about her running away.
During the custody battle, the children exhibited disturbing behaviors, expressing harsh views about religion and making concerning sexual comments, indicating influence from Josh and his family. Authorities were further alarmed by the discovery of child pornography and violent materials in the household.
On February 5, 2012, during a supervised visit, Josh locked a social worker out before blowing up the home, killing himself and his sons Charlie and Brayden. As the medical examiner found, Josh had used a hatchet to inflict wounds on the children before the explosion, indicating premeditation. Josh had been planning the event, purchasing gasoline and making arrangements in the preceding days.
The deaths devastated Susan's family, who later received a multi-million dollar settlement from the state for negligence in handling the case. However, Susan's remains were never found, leaving the full truth about her disappearance and the Powell family's involvement unknown.
1-Page Summary
Susan and Josh Powell's marriage, which began with a whirlwind romance after meeting at a Latter-day Saints (LDS) church event, was overshadowed by troubling family dynamics and toxic influences.
Susan grew up in a relatively normal household, while Josh's upbringing was marked by a tumultuous divorce between his parents, combined with allegations of violence, pornography, polygamy, and troubling views about women. As an adolescent, Josh Powell exhibited deeply troubling behaviors. He once threatened his mother with a butcher knife, attempted suicide, killed his pet gerbils, and adopted disparaging views about women similar to those of his father.
After Josh and Susan were married, they moved in with Josh's father, Steve, in South Hill, Washington. During this time, Steve developed an eerie and obsessive infatuation with Susan. His inappropriate behavior escalated as he stole Susan's underwear, used her personal hygiene items for sexual gratification, and secretly recorded her, often zooming in on her during family recordings. Steve even installed hidden cameras to capture illicit footage of Susan and kept detailed journals and video journals of his fantasies about her. Detectives later described Steve Powell as narcissistic, self-absorbed, and delusional about Susan's feelings for him. Videos unveil Steve's lecherous behaviors, such as sniffing Susan's underwear and documenting his romantic obsession.
Despite Susan's confessions to Josh about his father's unsettling behavior, Josh appeared indifferent and failed to intervene or address his father's harassment towards Susan.
Susan Powell was the primary provider for the family, working full time, while Josh struggled to find and keep steady employment. He asserted control over the family finances to an excessive degree, instituting strict budgeting practices that required Susan to maintain detailed records of her spending. Josh's financial behaviors included forcing Susan to adhere to stringent budgets, scrutinizing each purchase, and causing ...
Background and dynamics of the Powell family
The disappearance of Susan Powell under mysterious circumstances on December 6, 2009, has triggered an investigation that scrutinizes her husband Josh Powell's dubious actions and inconsistencies in his narrative of events.
Josh Powell claimed to have taken his sons on a last-minute camping trip during a blizzard, a decision that was seen as highly unusual because of the weather and the peculiar choice to leave his wife Susan at home. When questioned by the police, Josh provided vague and inconsistent details about the camping trip. He was unclear about his route, the exact location of the campsite, and the activities they undertook.
After the police entered the Powell residence following Susan's disappearance, they discovered a wet spot on the carpet with two fans aimed at it, a metal crowbar, a circular saw, shovels, tarps, cans of gasoline, a box of plastic gloves, and other camping equipment and supplies in Josh's van, most of which appeared unused. Susan's cell phone was found in the van without its SIM card, and a bit of blood was found on a tile floor in the home, confirmed to be Susan's.
Despite these alarming findings and being the primary suspect, Josh remained uncooperative and evasive during police interviews, which further heightened suspicions of his involvement in Susan's disappearance.
Investigators found Susan's "last will and testament" in a safety deposit box where she indicated marital strife and distrust towards Josh, even mentioning that her death might not be accidental. She also had told a coworker that if something happened to her, Josh should be looked at.
Moreover, it was discovered t ...
The suspicious circumstances and investigation around Susan's disappearance
The disappearance of Susan Powell led to a grim custody battle over her children, Charlie and Brayden, involving disturbing behaviors and allegations.
Josh Powell and his father Steve used the website susanpowell.org, which appeared to be a resource for search updates, to assert that Susan's family was smearing Josh in the media. They claimed, without evidence, that this was an attempt to cover up alleged abuse by Susan's family against her. Steve Powell claimed Susan had run away to Brazil with a man named Steve Koecker, despite Susan not knowing him. Steve further planned to reveal Susan's teenage journals online, insinuating they would substantiate his claims, although there was no evidence to support any of these narratives. During this period, Michael Powell created a slanderous website shaming the West Valley City Police Department and Susan's parents, accusing them of being a danger to his nephews.
Despite the Powell family's claims on the website and in media appearances, these were widely rejected due to a total lack of evidence. After Steve Powell's arrest, some members of the Powell family claimed to the media that it was a setup by Susan's family.
During supervised visits, the social worker observed Charlie and Brayden expressing harsh comments about religion and Mormons, indicating a clear influence from their father, Josh. Charlie told the social worker that Mormons were trying to kidnap him and that his grandparents were abusing him and his father. Susan's father, Chuck, also reported disturbing behaviors from the boys, such as wanting to sleep naked and making unsettling sexual comments—a behavior they claimed their father allowed.
The boys had made troubling statements and exhibited behaviors that drew the attention of co ...
The custody battle and disturbing behaviors of the Powell children
The final chapter in the Powell family's story unfolded on February 5, 2012, when a court-ordered supervised visit ended in tragedy.
Josh Powell allowed his sons, Charlie and Brayden, into his new house but then locked the social worker out, mentioning he had a surprise for them. The social worker, smelling gasoline and concerned for safety, called emergency services and reported Josh Powell's refusal to let her in during the supervised visitation. She highlighted the high-profile nature of the case, given Josh was the husband of the missing Susan Powell. During the call, there was a perception of a life-threatening scenario as the social worker inquired about the response time for emergency assistance.
The house exploded, and the bodies of Charlie, Brayden, and Josh were found inside the home after the fire.
A medical examiner later determined that before the fire, Josh had inflicted chop-like wounds on the boys' heads and necks with a hatchet. The causes of death for Josh, Charlie, and Brayden were eventually confirmed as carbon monoxide poisoning.
Evidence later revealed that Josh had been planning the explosion. He sent an email ten minutes before, stating he could not live without his sons and could not go on. He had doused the house with ten gallons of gasoline, given away the boys' toys, and resolved his financial affairs.
The deaths of Charlie, Brayden, and Josh were a devastating culmination of events that shocked and grieved their family and the community.
The final tragic events leading to the deaths of Josh, Charlie, and Brayden
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser