In this SERIALously episode, the disturbing details surrounding the deaths of JJ Vallow and Tylee Ryan take center stage as the trial of Chad Daybell unfolds. The blurb delves into the forensic evidence uncovered by the FBI, including the gruesome discovery of the children's remains on Daybell's property.
It also explores the extreme religious beliefs shared by Chad Daybell and Lori Vallow, which allegedly led them to view their own children as "dark" spirits. New recordings and testimonies further reveal the couple's worsening extremism and perverse behavior, painting a chilling picture of the events leading up to the children's tragic demise.
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
FBI agent Steve Daniels testified on the disturbing discovery of JJ Vallow and Tylee Ryan's remains at Chad Daybell's property. Daniels described finding JJ's body encased in plastic, rocks, and wood, while Tylee's charred and dismembered remains were scattered in multiple bags.
The children's remains were in an advanced state of decomposition. However, evidence suggests JJ was suffocated with duct tape and plastic bags, according to the medical examiner. Due to the condition of Tylee's remains, the cause of her death could not be definitively determined.
Melanie Boudreau (now Pawlowski) testified that Lori Vallow and Chad Daybell believed her children, JJ and Tylee, were "dark" spirits. Chad designated individuals as "light" or "dark," with Lori adopting Chad's beliefs.
Zulema Pastenes, Chad's former sister-in-law, provided further insight into the couple's extreme religious beliefs. Chad claimed access to a "book of life" to evaluate people and believed those "exalted" in a previous life were exempt from righteousness. Rituals like "casting" aimed to rid Tammy Daybell of a "demon" before her death.
Recordings revealed the couple's worsening extremism, with Chad performing "blessings" and referencing an imminent "plague." Forensic evidence included DNA matching Tylee's remains to tools seized from Chad's property.
A disturbing text from Chad referencing his genitalia as a "raccoon" highlighted the perverse undertones of his doctrines and behavior.
1-Page Summary
The harrowing discovery of the remains of JJ Vallow and Tylee Ryan on Chad Daybell's property reveals a meticulous investigation by the FBI, and the disturbing condition of the children’s bodies provides a challenge in determining the exact causes of death.
FBI special agent Steve Daniels gave testimony on the methods employed during the excavation of the children's remains at Chad Daybell's property.
Daniels detailed the discovery process, beginning with the uncovering of rocks and wooden planks. Underneath, they found plastic wrapping, which led to the identification of JJ Vallow's burial site through the revelation of human hair after cutting the plastic. The fire pit area was processed to uncover bone fragments, organic material, and pieces of cloth amidst a strong odor of human decomposition. Further investigation near a pet cemetery and fire pit led to the discovery of large bones and a dismembered and melted mass of human remains, including a green bucket with part of a skull, which turned out to be Tylee. Tools such as a pickaxe, shovels, and saws were seized from a shed and garage, possibly used in the concealment of the bodies, and similar bricks to those found at Tylee's burial site were also taken into evidence. The result was a disturbing picture of Tylee's remains, described as "melted together in the ground."
The jury was shown graphic images of the children's final moments. JJ was found in a body bag, wrapped in a black, tarp-like material, wearing red pajamas and a nighttime diaper, with his entire body severely restricted by duct tape around his hands, wrists, and ankles, and two plastic bags over his head, secured further with duct tape across his face. Bruising and scratches around his wris ...
Forensic evidence and investigation into the discovery of JJ and Tylee's remains
In recent testimonies, insights have been revealed regarding the extreme beliefs and behaviors of Lori Vallow and Chad Daybell, touching on their involvement in the "Church of the Firstborn" and their categorizations of "light" and "dark" spirits.
Melanie Boudreau provided testimony indicating that Lori Vallow and Chad Daybell believed her children, JJ and Tylee, were "dark" spirits. Chad was identified as the person responsible for designating individuals as "light" or "dark." Boudreau described Lori as receiving all her information and beliefs from Chad, who claimed to have the ability to discern between these two types of spirits.
During a recorded conversation, Lori referred to Melanie as a valiant and faithful warrior with a mission to help bring forth children in a new Jerusalem. Chad and Lori expressed their belief in an imminent second coming, positioning themselves as "warriors" poised to cleanse the world.
Zulema Pastenes testified that Chad claimed to possess access to a "book of life," which purportedly allowed him to evaluate people's past, present, and future. This tool was supposedly used to tag people as "light" or "dark" spirits. Chad also taught that individuals "exalted" in a previous life were exempt from repentance or pursuit of righteousness in their current life since they already secured this status before.
Chad and Lori's belief system included preparations for a "casting" ritual aimed at freeing Tammy Daybell—an act that was presumed to rid her of a "demon" or "zombie" spirit. The alleged correlation between this ritual and Tammy's death was discussed, with Chad and Lori seeming unfazed by the latter's demise after their marriage.
Further unsettling aspects of their doctrine involved an instance where Melanie expressed that she wished her ex-husband Brandon would remain in fear for his life, hinting at the involvement of Alex in an attempt on Brandon's life.
Zulema recalled the atmosphere within the couple's close circle, referring to Chad as "dad" and noting t ...
Witness testimony revealing the extremist beliefs and behaviors of Lori Vallow and Chad Daybell
The trial of Chad Daybell has revealed disturbing evidence and details about the couple's extreme beliefs and the actions that followed, differing from what was seen in Lori Vallow's trial.
In an astonishing development, recordings from state's witness Ian, Melanie Boudreau's husband, were played in court. These recordings included conversations between Melanie and the couple, Chad Daybell and Lori Vallow. Ian described how Melanie held Chad and Lori in high parent-like esteem due to her belief that she was their child in a past life.
The recordings, captured at the request of law enforcement, documented Chad and Lori declaring their love for each other and discussing their planned departure from Rexburg following police inquiries about the whereabouts of Lori's children, JJ and Tylee. In the recordings, Lori is heard calling the police liars and expressing anger towards Melanie Gibb for cooperating with law enforcement, even suggesting that Gibb would face consequences and had lost her place in their group for contacting the authorities.
Chad and Lori urged Melanie to flee Rexburg amid warnings of a coming "plague" and "civil unrest," referencing Chad's supposed visions and powers. Chad, in particularly distressing audio, is heard performing a "blessing," claiming to witness angels in the room, declaring that Melanie and Ian were part of the "Genesis of the 144,000," and announcing the "beginning of a new terrestrial order."
Forensic advancements have ...
New developments in the Chad Daybell trial compared to Lori Vallow's trial
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser