Podcasts > Selected Shorts > Selected Shorts Goes to the Movies with the Tribeca Film Festival

Selected Shorts Goes to the Movies with the Tribeca Film Festival

By Symphony Space

Dive into the fascinating intersection of literature and film with Selected Shorts as they explore tales that have made the leap from the written word to the silver screen in conjunction with the Tribeca Film Festival. Notably, Meg Wolitzer and actors like Marin Ireland, Michael Stuhlbarg, and Andrea Martin lend their voices to bring these stories and their cinematic counterparts to life, illuminating the rich potential of short stories as springboards for visual storytelling.

Witness the captivating journey of Richard Matheson's "Button, Button" as it evolves from a printed page into gripping screen manifestations, including "The Twilight Zone" and "The Box", which offer viewers a profound exploration of morality under stress. Delve also into the whimsical world of Lewis Carroll's "Jabberwocky," as it augments the fantastical realm of "Alice in Wonderland" adaptations, and observe how Mary Orr's "The Wisdom of Eve" seamlessly transitions into the celebrated film "All About Eve," solidifying its protagonist as an iconic figure in the canon of memorable villains. These adaptations highlight the timelessness of narrative fiction and its thrilling reimaginings through the art of film.

Listen to the original

Selected Shorts Goes to the Movies with the Tribeca Film Festival

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Feb 22, 2024 episode of the Selected Shorts

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Selected Shorts Goes to the Movies with the Tribeca Film Festival

1-Page Summary

Short stories adapted into movies and other media

Short stories frequently serve as fertile ground for cinematic and media adaptations, often resulting in impactful storytelling across various platforms. The concise format of short stories allows for a clear and focused narrative that can resonate powerfully when translated onto the screen.

The story "Button, Button" by Richard Matheson adapted into The Twilight Zone and the movie The Box

"Button, Button," a gripping tale by Richard Matheson, transitions from print to screen as an episode of "The Twilight Zone" and later as the film "The Box." The story revolves around a mysterious box with a button that poses a moral dilemma: If pressed, it brings wealth but costs someone's life. The concept captivates audiences with its ethical quandary and psychological depth, making it an attractive candidate for adaptation.

How the mysterious box and button are compelling ideas for adaptation

The idea of the button, ensconced within a mundane object like a box, is irresistibly alluring due to its simplicity and the profound moral choice it represents. The moral struggle faced by the protagonists, reflecting universal themes of greed, consequence, and human nature, secures the story's place in the adapted media. These adaptations leverage the plot’s tension and ethical implications, inviting viewers to explore the outcomes of their own hypothetical choices.

The twist ending that made audiences gasp

The story culminates in Norma's decision to press the button, leading to the unforeseen demise of her husband. The twist ending leaves audiences aghast, echoing the unpredictability of life's consequences. The power of this ending lies not only in its shock value but also in its moral resonance, which is effectively retained across adaptations in both "The Twilight Zone" and "The Box."

Lewis Carroll's poem "Jabberwocky" and its role in Alice in Wonderland adaptations

Carroll's "Jabberwocky," embedded within the larger narrative of "Alice in Wonderland," emerges as an element in various adaptations of the story. Through its nonsensical words and imaginative flair, the poem enriches the fantastical setting and illustrates how poetic elements can enhance visual storytelling.

The story "The Wisdom of Eve" by Mary Orr that inspired the Bette Davis movie All About Eve

Mary Orr's "The Wisdom of Eve" paints the picture of the ambitious and duplicitous Eve Harrington in a way that naturally lends itself to a cinematic narrative.

The memorable villain Eve Harrington

Eve Harrington's deceptive ascent in the theater world is immortalized in Orr's short story, and her actions secure her a notorious place among fictional antagonists. Eve embodies a modern tale of ambition and betrayal, echoing the archetypal deceiver of biblical lore, Eve.

Eve's lies and manipulation to get ahead

Eve Harrington embodies the classic villain, seamlessly manipulating those around her. Her capacity to fabricate her past, exploit emotions like admiration, and strategically play on sympathies portrays a character of complex deceit. Her treachery includes shed tears and the opportunistic use of letters, all of which underline her calculating nature.

How the story translated well to film

The translation of "The Wisdom of Eve" to "All About Eve," a movie starring Bette Davis, presumably captures the essence of Orr's story, evidenced by the success and enduring acclaim of the film. While details about the adaptation process are unspecified, the film's notable impact may draw from the original tale's narrative potency. Moreover, the adaptability of the story is underlined by its further transformation into the musical "Applause," signifying Orr's work's wide-ranging appeal.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • "Button, Button" by Richard Matheson is a short story that revolves around a couple, Norma and Arthur, who receive a mysterious box with a button. They are told that if they press the button, they will receive a large sum of money but someone they do not know will die. The story delves into the moral dilemma faced by the characters and the consequences of their choices. The narrative unfolds with a compelling twist ending that leaves a lasting impact on the reader or viewer.
  • Lewis Carroll's poem "Jabberwocky" is a nonsensical and imaginative piece featured in his novel "Through the Looking-Glass." In the context of "Alice in Wonderland" adaptations, "Jabberwocky" often appears as a whimsical and iconic element that adds to the fantastical and surreal atmosphere of the story. The poem's unique language and vivid imagery contribute to the overall dreamlike quality of the "Alice in Wonderland" universe, making it a popular inclusion in various adaptations across different media.
  • Mary Orr's short story "The Wisdom of Eve" served as the inspiration for the movie "All About Eve." The story delves into the character of Eve Harrington, a cunning and ambitious individual who manipulates her way into the theater world. The film adaptation, starring Bette Davis, captures the essence of Orr's narrative, showcasing Eve's deceitful tactics and her rise to prominence through betrayal and manipulation. The movie's enduring acclaim highlights the successful translation of Orr's compelling story to the big screen.
  • Eve Harrington, the central character in "The Wisdom of Eve," is a complex and manipulative figure who deceives and betrays those around her to achieve her ambitions in the theater world. Her cunning nature is highlighted through her ability to fabricate stories, manipulate emotions, and strategically advance her own agenda at the expense of others. Eve's portrayal as a villain draws parallels to archetypal deceivers, adding depth to her character and emphasizing the moral complexities of ambition and betrayal in the narrative.

Counterarguments

  • While short stories can provide clear and focused narratives, the process of adaptation often requires significant expansion or alteration to fit the medium of film or television, which can sometimes dilute the original story's impact or intent.
  • The simplicity of the moral dilemma in "Button, Button" might not resonate with all audiences, as some may find it too contrived or lacking in nuance.
  • The universal themes of greed, consequence, and human nature in "Button, Button" are common in literature and film, and some viewers may feel that these themes have been explored too frequently, reducing their impact.
  • The twist ending of "Button, Button" might be predictable to some audiences familiar with the genre, and the shock value may not be as effective for those who anticipate such outcomes in psychological thrillers.
  • The nonsensical nature of "Jabberwocky" might be challenging to convey in visual media, and some adaptations may struggle to capture the poem's whimsical essence, potentially alienating viewers who appreciate the original literary form.
  • The character of Eve Harrington in "The Wisdom of Eve" and its adaptations could be criticized for perpetuating negative stereotypes about ambitious women, which some viewers might find problematic or outdated.
  • The success of "All About Eve" might be attributed to factors beyond the original story, such as the performances of the actors, the direction, and the screenplay, rather than the narrative potency of the source material alone.
  • Adaptations into different media, such as musicals, may not always preserve the original story's themes and characterizations, which could disappoint purists or fans of the original work.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Selected Shorts Goes to the Movies with the Tribeca Film Festival

Short stories adapted into movies and other media

The adaptation of short stories into movies and various other media forms has been a tradition for as long as both mediums have coexisted. The compact nature of short stories makes them ripe for cinematic exploration, as evidenced by several stories that have leaped from page to screen with considerable impact.

The story "Button, Button" by Richard Matheson adapted into The Twilight Zone and the movie The Box

"Button, Button," a short story by Richard Matheson, experienced life beyond the written word when it was adapted into a 1985 episode of "The Twilight Zone" and later into the film "The Box."

How the mysterious box and button are compelling ideas for adaptation

The simple yet intriguing premise involves a mysterious box delivered to Mr. and Mrs. Arthur Lewis containing a button that, if pushed, promises them financial gain at the cost of an unknown person's life. This compelling concept, ripe for adaptation, delves into the ethical and psychological dilemmas as the couple grapples with the temptation and the moral implications of their choice. The gripping narrative and the idea of the mysterious button hold a universal appeal for adaptation, inviting audiences to confront their own values and the price of their desires.

The twist ending that made audiences gasp

As the narrative climaxed with Norma's decision to press the button in a moment of anger and frustration, the shocking twist followed — her husband's death as a consequence, causing the live audience to gasp. This twist reinforces the chilling consequences of the couple's actions and provides a stark reminder of the implications of seemingly trivial decisions. The story's success in different media, including "The Twilight Zone" and the movie "The Box," lies partly in this haunting ending, which maintains its power to surprise and horrify audiences.

Lewis Carroll's poem "Jabberwocky" and its role in Alice in Wonderland adaptations

Lewis Carroll's poem "Jabberwocky," known for its nonsensical verse and playful language, has been a recurring element in various adaptations of "Alice in Wonderland." Its whimsical and imaginative nature offers a glimpse into the fantastical world Carroll created and serves as a key piece of the larger narrative puzzle in "Alice" adaptations, showcasing the transformative potential of poetry into visual storytelling.

The story "The Wisdom of Eve" by Mary Orr that inspired the Bette Davis movie All About Eve

"The Wisdom of Eve," by Mary Orr, is another testament to the impact of a short story when translated to film.

The memorable villain Eve Harrington

Orr introduced readers to the aspiring actress Eve Harrington, whose manipulative rise to stardom has earned her a place among the most memorable villains in literature. With qualities that echoed the Biblical Eve's cunning natu ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Short stories adapted into movies and other media

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • "Button, Button" by Richard Matheson is a short story where a couple receives a mysterious box with a button. They are told that if they press the button, they will receive money but someone they don't know will die. The story explores the moral dilemma and consequences of their decision to push the button. The twist ending reveals the shocking outcome of their choice.
  • Lewis Carroll's poem "Jabberwocky" is a whimsical and nonsensical verse featured in his book "Through the Looking-Glass." The poem is known for its playful language and imaginative imagery, adding to the fantastical world of Wonderland. "Jabberwocky" has been a recurring element in various adaptations of "Alice in Wonderland," showcasing the transformative power of poetry in visual storytelling. Its inclusion in adaptations helps capture the essence of Carroll's unique and surreal universe, contributing to the overall charm and whimsy of the narrative.
  • "The Wisdom of Eve" by Mary Orr is a short story that inspired the movie "All About Eve." The story revolves around Eve Harrington, a manipulative aspiring actress who uses deceit to climb the ladder of success. The film adaptation, "All About Eve," captures the essence of Orr's narrative, portraying Eve's cunning nature and her impact on the theater world. The movie showcases Eve's calculated manipulation and the consequences of her actions within the compe ...

Counterarguments

  • While short stories are often suitable for cinematic exploration, their compact nature can also lead to oversimplification or loss of depth when adapted to film, as movies require visual storytelling and may omit nuanced details present in the written narrative.
  • The concept of a mysterious box and button in "Button, Button" is indeed compelling, but some might argue that the adaptation process can dilute the original story's thematic complexity or alter its intended message.
  • The twist ending of "Button, Button" may have shocked audiences, but not all viewers or readers find twist endings satisfying; some may feel that such endings are gimmicky or undermine the story's build-up.
  • While "Jabberwocky" is a recurring element in "Alice in Wonderland" adaptations, its nonsensical nature might not resonate with all audiences, and its inclusion could be seen as confusing or irrelevant to the main narrative by some viewers.
  • The character of Eve Harrington in "The Wisdom of Eve" is indeed memorable, but some critics might argue that her portrayal reinforces negative stereotypes about ambitious women or could be interpreted as a one-dimensional villain.
  • The success of a ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA