In this episode of the Rachel Maddow Presents: Déjà News podcast, historians explore the often-overlooked role played by radical populists in securing American independence. They detail how this movement aimed for greater democracy and challenged the priorities of prominent Founding Fathers like Jefferson and Washington, who focused on building national power and wealth.
The historians argue that the prevailing narrative glorifies elite Founding Fathers while downplaying the populists' egalitarian visions and influence. They suggest recovering these suppressed histories provides nuance on the competing priorities shaping America's founding.
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
In Pennsylvania during the American Revolution, the radical populist movement orchestrated what historians describe as a "bloodless military coup" to overthrow the existing government. Seeking greater democracy, they managed to get independence passed by the Continental Congress, though their key role has largely been ignored in traditional accounts, according to historians.
While the radical populists aimed to leverage independence for securing power and economic/social equality, Founding Fathers like Jefferson, Washington, and Hamilton focused on building wealth and national power. Hogeland states they saw the populist "democracy" movement as a threat of "mob rule" to be suppressed, favoring the British industrialization model that exploited labor.
Historians argue the prevailing narrative glorifies elite Founding Fathers while ignoring their clash with the egalitarian populist activists crucial to independence. O'Donnell and Hogeland say this presents the Founding Fathers' views as inevitable when in fact alternative visions were suppressed. Recovering populist histories provides nuance on the competing priorities shaping America's founding.
1-Page Summary
The radical populist movement in Pennsylvania during the American Revolution played a significant, yet often ignored role in shaping the movement towards greater democracy.
In a remarkable act that has since been largely forgotten in mainstream historical narratives, the radical populists in Pennsylvania carried out what has been described as a bloodless military coup. With the force of the state's armed working class behind them, they didn't just overthrow the assembly, they dismantled the entire government system that William Penn had established.
The radical populists continued their push for change at a national level, managing to get a resolution of independence passed in the Continental Congress. Despite their central involvement in this seminal moment of American history, their contribution has been largely erased from the popularly accepted accounts of the founding of the United States.
The agenda of the radical populists extended beyond mere political restructuring. They aimed to leverage American independence to secure their newfound power and introduce reforms that would encourage social and economic equality.
The overlooked role of the radical populist "democracy" movement in the American Revolution
The Founding Fathers such as Jefferson, Washington, and Hamilton held particular views on democracy, economic policies, and the concept of equality, which shaped the early direction of the United States.
The term "equality," as invoked in the Declaration of Independence, meant different things to different people. Founders like Jefferson did not see creating equality as a central role for government, particularly when it came to regulating commerce.
There was a clear tension in Philadelphia in 1776. Many elite people sought independence from Britain but feared a social revolution that might disrupt the existing class structure in America. To them, democracy was equated with mob rule, and according to O'Donnell and Hogeland, figures like Washington and Hamilton viewed it as something to be suppressed.
The Founding Fathers' priorities and views on democracy, equality, and economic policies
The story of America’s Founding Fathers is deeply ingrained in the country’s national identity, yet historians suggest that this narrative has been crafted in a way that glorifies these figures and neglects the significant role of populist movements.
This prevailing narrative celebrates the elite framers while ignoring the clash between these celebrated figures and the egalitarian populist activists who played a crucial role in the fight for American independence. Historians have been criticized for their role in perpetuating a mythologized history that focuses on a small group of elites.
The significant contributions of radical populist movements are often expunged from the popular recounting of events like the Fourth of July. These groups held radical and democratic ideas that deeply influenced the path to independence, yet their stories are seldom told with the same reverence as those of the Founding Fathers.
Critics argue that the dominant narrative presents the establishment of the American government as a foregone conclusion, the natural outcome of the Founding Fathers' enlightened policies. However, this ignores the vibrant debate and the alternative, often more egalitarian visions for the nation that w ...
How the traditional narrative of the founding has been shaped to glorify the Founding Fathers and omit the populist movement
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser