Step into a pivotal moment in American history with Rachel Maddow Presents: Déjà News, as legal experts Andrew Weissmann and Mary McCord dissect the groundbreaking Colorado Supreme Court decision restrictions on Donald Trump's qualifications for the 2024 election. The court's landmark ruling, invoking the 14th Amendment's stance on insurrection, could chart a new course for the former President's political future as well as set consequential legal benchmarks across the nation. As they delve into the evidence and implications of this judicial determination, Weissmann and McCord unveil the complexities and potential ripple effects of this judicial action that extends far beyond the Colorado state line.
As the political and legal drama unfolds, the prospect of a U.S. Supreme Court review looms large, promising to escalate this case to the zenith of American jurisprudence. The two legal heavyweights engage in a thought-provoking discussion on Trump's intended appeal, exploring the procedural tactics and constitutional debates that might soon captivate the nation. With insights on the potential conflicts in Trump's legal strategies and the crucial due process considerations, this episode of Rachel Maddow Presents: Déjà News is an essential deep dive into the fabric of constitutional law and the contentious arena of presidential eligibility.
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
The Colorado Supreme Court has ruled that Donald Trump engaged in insurrection, thereby barring him from the 2024 Colorado primary ballot under Section 3 of the 14th Amendment. This landmark decision sets a precedent that may influence legal debates in other jurisdictions. The court's findings are based on undisputed evidence that Trump had direct involvement in the January 6th insurrection with the intent to disrupt the certification of the 2020 presidential election. Despite the implications of the ruling, a temporary stay allows Trump's name to remain on the ballot pending appeal. The decision has broader implications, as courts elsewhere grapple with the application of the 14th Amendment in similar contexts, making this case a point of reference for future legal considerations.
Donald Trump intends to appeal the Colorado Supreme Court ruling to the U.S. Supreme Court, focusing on procedural aspects. With the significance of the case to American democracy, the Supreme Court is expected to accept the petition quickly and proceed with an expedited briefing schedule. Alongside this case, the Supreme Court will address another case related to presidential immunity, presenting seemingly contradictory legal strategies adopted by Trump. The outcomes of Trump's cert petition may touch upon due process issues and the interpretation of "insurrection" under the Fourteenth Amendment, potentially reversing the decision of the Colorado court. The Supreme Court's engagement with these cases is unprecedented and may have lasting significance in defining the boundaries of constitutional law and presidential eligibility.
1-Page Summary
The Colorado Supreme Court has made a landmark ruling on the eligibility of Donald Trump for the 2024 presidential primary ballot in the state, setting a precedent that may influence other jurisdictions and the broader conversation about applying the 14th Amendment to candidates accused of insurrection.
Based on the evidence presented, much of it undisputed, the Colorado Supreme Court held that Donald Trump directly participated in the January 6th insurrection. This decision was an appeal from a trial court ruling which had found that despite determining Trump did engage in insurrection, Section 3 of the Fourteenth Amendment did not disqualify him.
The Supreme Court's ruling, with eight different legal conclusions, concluded that Trump's conduct, including incitement, constituted direct participation in the January 6th insurrection. The court found that he had the specific intent to incite imminent unlawful action and directed his supporters to march to the Capitol to prevent the certification of the 2020 presidential election.
The consequence of the court's ruling is that Trump is barred from the 2024 Colorado primary ballot under the 14th Amendment. The majority decision of the Colorado Supreme Court, without dissent on the factual findings, indicated that the former president's actions meet the conditions that would bar him from the Colorado primary ballot.
The court’s decision effectively disqualifies Trump from the 2024 Colorado primary ballot. However, because the Supreme Court stayed the ruling to allow Trump to appeal, his name will likely be on the ballot for Colorado's primary, as the case will still be pending by January 5th—the deadline when names must be certified on the ballot.
Trump's Eligibility for 2024 Election
Donald Trump is poised to seek the intervention of the U.S. Supreme Court following the ruling by the Colorado Supreme Court, which has significant implications for his eligibility and the interpretation of the Fourteenth Amendment.
In response to the Colorado Supreme Court's decision, Trump has indicated that he will seek review from the Supreme Court on procedural grounds. It's anticipated that the Supreme Court will act quickly to accept the petition, establish an expedited briefing schedule, and proceed to hear the case. The issue at stake, which concerns Trump's eligibility, is considered to hold great importance for American democracy.
The Supreme Court is expected to be significantly occupied with cases related to not only the Colorado case but also an additional case concerning presidential immunity. Notably, there seems to be a contradiction in Trump’s legal approaches: one seeks to decelerate the process with the presidential immunity case, while the other aims to speed up proceedings in the Colorado case.
The Colorado Supreme Court granted a temporary stay until January 4th, with an extension possible if Trump seeks review from the U.S. Supreme Court. Trump is anticipated to file a cert petition—a right he possesses—to the Supreme Court. There are a multitude of potential outcomes for the court to potentially reverse the Colorado Supreme Court's decision, involving issu ...
Path Forward to Supreme Court Review
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser