In a captivating episode of the PBD Podcast, join Patrick Bet-David and his insightful co-hosts, Adam Sosnick, Charlie Kirk, Vincent Oshana, and Tom Ellsworth, as they explore the evolving political leanings among the younger generation. The team dives into the latest trends revealing a stark divide between young men and women, with boys increasingly gravitating towards conservative figures and ideologies, while young women tend towards liberal views. This discussion sheds light on how the media, current events, and prominent cultural figures like Joe Rogan and Jordan Peterson are shaping tomorrow's voters.
Alongside this generational shift, the podcast delves into the heated debate over meritocracy and identity politics. As Kirk and Ellsworth critique Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) programs and critical race theory, they advocate for merit-based systems and challenge the implications of IBM's strategies and similar initiatives in public education. In addition, Kirk's bold assertion on the impact of conservatives ostensibly 'outbreeding' liberals prompts reflection on how family values and personal choices could influence future demographic landscapes, potentially reshaping the political map. This episode is a deep dive into the critical issues and cultural battles defining America's future.
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
The latest polls and observations suggest a growing divergence in the political leanings of young men and women. High school boys are showing an increased tendency towards conservative ideologies, marking the most significant shift in their political stance in the past fifty years. These young men are particularly drawn to content creators who embody an unapologetic, "alpha male" persona, such as Joe Rogan, Jordan Peterson, and Matt Walsh. This content, which often champions free speech and patriotism, is resonating strongly with them. In stark contrast, young women are more inclined towards liberal ideologies, indicating a potential influence of media and evolving political views among the younger generation.
Tom Ellsworth and Charlie Kirk have delved into the debate about the merits of meritocracy versus the adoption of Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) programs. The critics lambast DEI initiatives, alleging that they promote racism and discrimination by focusing on identity politics over individual competence. Criticism specifically targets how critical race theory labels people as inherently racist based on their race, and they point to instances such as IBM's DEI strategies that are perceived as anti-white. Oklahoma’s action to ban DEI programs in public colleges is praised, reflecting a broader call among the speakers for a return to merit-based advancement. They advocate eliminating DEI programs and decry these initiatives as a form of racism and sexism that threatens the founding principles of American society.
Charlie Kirk comments on the potential long-term demographic shift due to the lifestyle choices and values associated with liberals and conservatives. He notes that liberals may have fewer children, attributing this to higher abortion rates, the prevalence of same-sex relationships, and a de-emphasis on traditional family structures. On the other hand, Kirk predicts that conservatives, who tend to hold values that favor larger family units, will "outbreed" liberals. This, he speculates, will lead to a future demographic where conservative values may dominate due to their numerical superiority in population growth over liberals.
1-Page Summary
A poll from The Hill.com suggests high school boys are the most conservative they've been in fifty years, revealing a divide in political views among the younger generation.
Charlie Kirk mentions that high school boys are increasingly leaning toward conservative ideologies, marking a significant shift in the political landscape among the youth.
Young men are notably drawn to a genre of content characterized by its unapologetic, "alpha male" persona. These content creators embrace free speech and patriotic sentiment, which resonates with these young boys. High-profile figures such as Joe Rogan, Jordan Peterson, and Matt Walsh, who are prominent voices in this space, have become role models to them.
Differences in political views between younger men and women
In a recent discussion, Tom Ellsworth and Charlie Kirk scrutinize the trend toward Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) programs, echoing a call for a return to a meritocracy-based approach.
Critics of DEI programs such as Ellsworth and Kirk argue that these initiatives promote racism and discrimination by catering to identity politics, rather than assessing individuals based on their skills and competencies.
Ellsworth criticizes critical race theory, claiming it inherently labels individuals as racist based on their race. He argues for a meritocracy where only an individual's competence matters–for example, a doctor's ability in surgery. Similarly, Kirk referenced an incident at IBM where DEI was equated with anti-white sentiment, suggesting that such biases in AI development could perpetuate discriminatory practices.
Ellsworth recalls IBM's previous ethos of "respect for the individual" and contends that current DEI measures deviate from these principles. Kirk goes further, describing DEI as Marxist and anti-white, and aligns with Elon Musk's belief that DEI initiative are a new form of racism and sexism, and that they divide society.
The group praises actions taken by Oklahoma Governor Kevin Stitt for banning DEI programs at public colleges and urges other state governors to do the same. There's a consensus among the speakers that DEI programs, such as prioritizing monoclonal antibodies for people of color in New York City, are analogous to discrimination against white people.
The discussion also extends to the criticism of public school teachers having to sign a vow adjusting their behavior, a mandate they see as rooted in DEI initiatives. Kirk invokes the notion that ...
Discussion of merits of meritocracy versus identity politics
Charlie Kirk speaks on the demographic future, conjecturing that conservatives may "outbreed" liberals due to different lifestyle choices and values that impact family size and structure.
Kirk suggests that left-wing individuals may have fewer children due to factors such as higher rates of abortion and a greater prevalence of same-sex relationships within the community. He connects these choices to a broader liberal perspective that he perceives as not placing value on the traditional family structure.
Kirk predicts a long-term demographic shift as a result of these trends, speculating tha ...
Praise for conservatives having more children long-term
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser