Podcasts > PBD Podcast > LIVE from TPUSA's "America Fest 2023" w/ @RealCharlieKirk | PBD Podcast | Ep. 340

LIVE from TPUSA's "America Fest 2023" w/ @RealCharlieKirk | PBD Podcast | Ep. 340

By Patrick Bet-David

In a captivating episode of the PBD Podcast, join Patrick Bet-David and his insightful co-hosts, Adam Sosnick, Charlie Kirk, Vincent Oshana, and Tom Ellsworth, as they explore the evolving political leanings among the younger generation. The team dives into the latest trends revealing a stark divide between young men and women, with boys increasingly gravitating towards conservative figures and ideologies, while young women tend towards liberal views. This discussion sheds light on how the media, current events, and prominent cultural figures like Joe Rogan and Jordan Peterson are shaping tomorrow's voters.

Alongside this generational shift, the podcast delves into the heated debate over meritocracy and identity politics. As Kirk and Ellsworth critique Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) programs and critical race theory, they advocate for merit-based systems and challenge the implications of IBM's strategies and similar initiatives in public education. In addition, Kirk's bold assertion on the impact of conservatives ostensibly 'outbreeding' liberals prompts reflection on how family values and personal choices could influence future demographic landscapes, potentially reshaping the political map. This episode is a deep dive into the critical issues and cultural battles defining America's future.

Listen to the original

LIVE from TPUSA's "America Fest 2023" w/ @RealCharlieKirk  | PBD Podcast | Ep. 340

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Dec 16, 2023 episode of the PBD Podcast

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

LIVE from TPUSA's "America Fest 2023" w/ @RealCharlieKirk | PBD Podcast | Ep. 340

1-Page Summary

Differences in political views between younger men and women

The latest polls and observations suggest a growing divergence in the political leanings of young men and women. High school boys are showing an increased tendency towards conservative ideologies, marking the most significant shift in their political stance in the past fifty years. These young men are particularly drawn to content creators who embody an unapologetic, "alpha male" persona, such as Joe Rogan, Jordan Peterson, and Matt Walsh. This content, which often champions free speech and patriotism, is resonating strongly with them. In stark contrast, young women are more inclined towards liberal ideologies, indicating a potential influence of media and evolving political views among the younger generation.

Discussion of merits of meritocracy versus identity politics

Tom Ellsworth and Charlie Kirk have delved into the debate about the merits of meritocracy versus the adoption of Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) programs. The critics lambast DEI initiatives, alleging that they promote racism and discrimination by focusing on identity politics over individual competence. Criticism specifically targets how critical race theory labels people as inherently racist based on their race, and they point to instances such as IBM's DEI strategies that are perceived as anti-white. Oklahoma’s action to ban DEI programs in public colleges is praised, reflecting a broader call among the speakers for a return to merit-based advancement. They advocate eliminating DEI programs and decry these initiatives as a form of racism and sexism that threatens the founding principles of American society.

Praise for conservatives having more children long-term

Charlie Kirk comments on the potential long-term demographic shift due to the lifestyle choices and values associated with liberals and conservatives. He notes that liberals may have fewer children, attributing this to higher abortion rates, the prevalence of same-sex relationships, and a de-emphasis on traditional family structures. On the other hand, Kirk predicts that conservatives, who tend to hold values that favor larger family units, will "outbreed" liberals. This, he speculates, will lead to a future demographic where conservative values may dominate due to their numerical superiority in population growth over liberals.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Joe Rogan, Jordan Peterson, and Matt Walsh are prominent figures known for their conservative viewpoints and outspoken commentary on various social and political issues. Joe Rogan is a popular podcast host who interviews a wide range of guests, often discussing controversial topics. Jordan Peterson is a clinical psychologist and author known for his critiques of political correctness and advocacy for individual responsibility. Matt Walsh is a conservative writer and commentator who frequently shares his opinions on culture, politics, and societal norms.
  • The debate between meritocracy and Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) programs revolves around the balance between rewarding individual merit and promoting diversity and inclusivity in workplaces and society. Critics of DEI programs argue that they can sometimes prioritize identity over qualifications, potentially leading to discrimination and undermining the principle of merit-based advancement. Proponents of DEI initiatives advocate for creating more equitable opportunities for underrepresented groups and addressing systemic biases that may hinder their progress. The discussion often involves weighing the benefits of fostering diversity against concerns about fairness and meritocratic principles.
  • Criticism of critical race theory involves concerns that it promotes division by focusing on race, labeling individuals based on their race, and attributing racial disparities to systemic issues rather than individual actions. Critics argue that it can lead to discrimination, perpetuate racial tensions, and undermine the principles of meritocracy by emphasizing group identity over individual merit. This critique often targets how CRT interprets societal structures through a lens of race, highlighting disparities and injustices while downplaying individual agency and personal responsibility. Critics also raise objections to how CRT views race as a social construct and challenges the idea of color-blindness in law and policy.
  • Oklahoma's ban on DEI programs in public colleges was a legislative action that prohibited the implementation of Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion initiatives in state-funded educational institutions. Critics of DEI programs argue that they prioritize identity politics over individual merit and can lead to discrimination. This ban reflects a broader debate on the role of such programs in promoting equality and addressing systemic issues within educational and workplace environments. The decision to ban DEI programs in public colleges in Oklahoma was part of a larger national conversation on the balance between promoting diversity and maintaining merit-based systems.
  • Charlie Kirk predicts that conservatives, who typically prioritize traditional family values, will have more children compared to liberals. This could lead to a future demographic shift where conservative values become more prevalent due to their larger population growth. Kirk suggests that factors like abortion rates, family structures, and values influence the differing birth rates between conservatives and liberals. He argues that this trend may result in a society where conservative ideals dominate over time.

Counterarguments

  • The inclination of high school boys towards conservative ideologies may not solely be due to the influence of specific content creators; other factors such as family background, community values, and personal experiences could also play significant roles.
  • The trend of young women leaning more towards liberal ideologies could be reflective of broader societal changes and not just media influence, including education on gender equality and social justice issues.
  • DEI programs are designed to address historical and systemic inequalities, and proponents argue that they enhance fairness by giving underrepresented groups equal opportunities to succeed.
  • Critical race theory is a complex academic concept that examines the relationship between race and law; it does not label individuals as inherently racist but rather looks at the structural aspects of racism in society.
  • The ban on DEI programs in Oklahoma could be seen as a step back from efforts to create inclusive environments that reflect the diversity of the population.
  • DEI initiatives can be viewed as complementary to meritocracy, aiming to ensure that all individuals have the opportunity to compete on a level playing field.
  • The prediction that conservatives will "outbreed" liberals does not account for the complexity of demographic changes, which can be influenced by a multitude of factors including economic conditions, cultural shifts, and policy changes.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
LIVE from TPUSA's "America Fest 2023" w/ @RealCharlieKirk | PBD Podcast | Ep. 340

Differences in political views between younger men and women

A poll from The Hill.com suggests high school boys are the most conservative they've been in fifty years, revealing a divide in political views among the younger generation.

Young high school boys becoming more conservative

Charlie Kirk mentions that high school boys are increasingly leaning toward conservative ideologies, marking a significant shift in the political landscape among the youth.

Boys gravitating towards unapologetic, alpha male content creators

Young men are notably drawn to a genre of content characterized by its unapologetic, "alpha male" persona. These content creators embrace free speech and patriotic sentiment, which resonates with these young boys. High-profile figures such as Joe Rogan, Jordan Peterson, and Matt Walsh, who are prominent voices in this space, have become role models to them.

...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Differences in political views between younger men and women

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The shift towards conservatism among high school boys is attributed to their attraction to content creators who embody an unapologetic, "alpha male" persona. Figures like Joe Rogan, Jordan Peterson, and Matt Walsh, known for promoting free speech and patriotic values, serve as influential role models for these young men. This appeal to traditional masculinity and values resonates with high school boys, leading them to adopt more conservative ideologies. The influence of these prominent voices in the media landscape contributes to shaping the political views of the younger male demographic.
  • The "alpha male" content creators typically embody traits like assertiveness, confidence, and a strong sense of individualism. They often promote traditional values, free speech, and patriotism in their content. These creators tend to challenge mainstream narratives and advocate for personal responsibility and self-improvement. Young men are drawn to their unapologetic style and messages that resonate with themes of masculinity and independence.
  • The text suggests that high school boys are becoming more conservative, while girls tend to lean more towards liberal ideologies. This indicates a notable disparity in political views between young boys and girls. The extent of this disparity is not quantified in the text but is implied to be significant based on the contrasting trends observed among the ...

Counterarguments

  • The poll from The Hill.com may not be representative of the entire population of high school boys, as it could have a limited sample size or geographic scope.
  • The popularity of "alpha male" content creators among young men does not necessarily indicate a shift towards conservative ideologies, as individuals may be drawn to these figures for various reasons unrelated to politics.
  • The assertion that girls tend to be more liberal might oversimplify the political views of young women, ignoring the complexity and diversity of their opinions.
  • The idea of a growing divide in political views among the younger generation could be overstated, as young people's views are often fluid and can change over time.
  • The influence of media on youth political views is complex and m ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
LIVE from TPUSA's "America Fest 2023" w/ @RealCharlieKirk | PBD Podcast | Ep. 340

Discussion of merits of meritocracy versus identity politics

In a recent discussion, Tom Ellsworth and Charlie Kirk scrutinize the trend toward Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) programs, echoing a call for a return to a meritocracy-based approach.

Criticism of DEI (Diversity, Equity and Inclusion) programs

Critics of DEI programs such as Ellsworth and Kirk argue that these initiatives promote racism and discrimination by catering to identity politics, rather than assessing individuals based on their skills and competencies.

DEI programs seen as promoting racism and discrimination

Ellsworth criticizes critical race theory, claiming it inherently labels individuals as racist based on their race. He argues for a meritocracy where only an individual's competence matters–for example, a doctor's ability in surgery. Similarly, Kirk referenced an incident at IBM where DEI was equated with anti-white sentiment, suggesting that such biases in AI development could perpetuate discriminatory practices.

Ellsworth recalls IBM's previous ethos of "respect for the individual" and contends that current DEI measures deviate from these principles. Kirk goes further, describing DEI as Marxist and anti-white, and aligns with Elon Musk's belief that DEI initiative are a new form of racism and sexism, and that they divide society.

The group praises actions taken by Oklahoma Governor Kevin Stitt for banning DEI programs at public colleges and urges other state governors to do the same. There's a consensus among the speakers that DEI programs, such as prioritizing monoclonal antibodies for people of color in New York City, are analogous to discrimination against white people.

The discussion also extends to the criticism of public school teachers having to sign a vow adjusting their behavior, a mandate they see as rooted in DEI initiatives. Kirk invokes the notion that ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Discussion of merits of meritocracy versus identity politics

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Critical race theory is an academic framework that examines how systemic racism is embedded in laws and institutions. It suggests that racism is not just individual prejudice but is also present in societal structures. Critics argue that it can lead to labeling individuals as inherently racist based on their race, which can be a point of contention in discussions about diversity and inclusion.
  • DEI programs aim to create more diverse, equitable, and inclusive environments by addressing systemic biases and promoting fairness for all individuals, regardless of their background. Specific practices within DEI programs can include implementing policies to ensure equal opportunities for underrepresented groups, providing training on unconscious bias, and fostering a culture of respect and belonging within organizations. These programs often focus on increasing representation, removing barriers to advancement, and promoting a sense of belonging for all individuals, regardless of their race, gender, sexual orientation, or other characteristics. The ultimate goal of DEI initiatives is to create environments where everyone has an equal chance to succeed and contribute to the organization's success.
  • The association of DEI with Marxism and anti-white sentiments stems from the belief that Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion initiatives are seen as promoting equality through a lens that some critics view as prioritizing certain groups over others based on identity, which they argue can lead to discrimination against those not included in the prioritized groups. This perspective links DEI efforts ...

Counterarguments

  • DEI programs aim to address systemic inequalities that meritocracy alone may not resolve, as meritocracy can sometimes perpetuate existing disparities if not all individuals have equal access to opportunities.
  • Critical race theory is an academic framework that examines the intersection of race and law to understand systemic racism, rather than labeling individuals as racist.
  • DEI initiatives can enhance a company's performance by bringing diverse perspectives and experiences, which can lead to better problem-solving and innovation.
  • The ethos of "respect for the individual" can be compatible with DEI efforts, as these programs strive to ensure that every individual has the opportunity to succeed regardless of their background.
  • DEI programs are not inherently Marxist or anti-white; they seek to level the playing field for historically marginalized groups.
  • Prioritizing healthcare resources like monoclonal antibodies for communities disproportionately affected by a crisis can be a matter of public health equity, not discrimination.
  • DEI training for educators can be seen as a commitment to creating an inclusive environment that benefits ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
LIVE from TPUSA's "America Fest 2023" w/ @RealCharlieKirk | PBD Podcast | Ep. 340

Praise for conservatives having more children long-term

Charlie Kirk speaks on the demographic future, conjecturing that conservatives may "outbreed" liberals due to different lifestyle choices and values that impact family size and structure.

Liberals seen as not valuing having children

Kirk suggests that left-wing individuals may have fewer children due to factors such as higher rates of abortion and a greater prevalence of same-sex relationships within the community. He connects these choices to a broader liberal perspective that he perceives as not placing value on the traditional family structure.

Prediction that conservatives will "outbreed" liberals over time

Kirk predicts a long-term demographic shift as a result of these trends, speculating tha ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Praise for conservatives having more children long-term

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Charlie Kirk is a conservative political commentator and the founder of Turning Point USA, a conservative nonprofit organization. He is known for his outspoken views on conservative values, youth activism, and American politics. Kirk often appears on various media platforms to discuss and promote conservative ideologies and policies. His views on demographics and family values align with traditional conservative beliefs.
  • Charlie Kirk is suggesting that conservatives may have more children than liberals due to differences in lifestyle choices and values. These differences could include views on abortion, same-sex relationships, and the importance placed on traditional family structures. Kirk believes that these factors may lead to a long-term demographic shift where conservative families, who he implies prioritize larger families, could outnumber liberal families.
  • The connection between abortion rates, same-sex relationships, and the number of children individuals have is complex. Abortion rates can impact family size by affecting the decision to have children. Same-sex relationships may not naturally lead to biological children, potentially influencing family size choices. These factors can contribute to differences in family planning and size among individuals with varying beliefs and lifestyles.
  • The potential demographic shift towards conservative values suggests that if conservatives have more children than liberals over time, it could lead to a larger population of individuals with conservative beliefs and values. This shift could impact societal norms, policies, and political landscapes as the population makeup changes. It's a speculat ...

Counterarguments

  • The assumption that political ideology is inherited and will remain static across generations is not necessarily accurate; children often develop their own beliefs, which may differ from their parents.
  • The idea that liberals do not value having children is a generalization that may not hold true for all individuals who identify as liberal.
  • Family size and the decision to have children can be influenced by a variety of factors, including economic conditions, personal choice, and access to education and family planning resources, not just political ideology.
  • The correlation between political beliefs and family size does not account for the complexity of political views within families, where there can be a mix of conservative and liberal values.
  • The prediction of demographic shifts based on current trends does not take into account potential changes in societal norms, policies, and individual preferences that could occur over time.
  • The focus on the number of children as a metric for the success of a political ideology overlooks the importance of the quality o ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA