In this episode of NPR's Book of the Day, author Tochi Onyebuchi examines the internet's transformation from the mid-2000s to the present day. He discusses how online spaces shifted from being primarily focused on information sharing and community building around shared interests to becoming platforms for political discourse, activism, and social movements.
The discussion explores specific turning points in this evolution, such as the Trayvon Martin case and Gamergate, which illustrate how the internet became more politically charged and polarized. Onyebuchi shares his perspective on the challenges of modern online spaces, including the spread of misinformation and the impact of AI, while suggesting ways to navigate these digital environments by creating and choosing spaces aligned with one's values.

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
In this discussion, author Onyebuchi explores the dramatic evolution of the internet from its mid-2000s incarnation to its present state. He describes how the internet transformed from an open, joyous space for sharing information to a platform marked by division and intense political debate.
During the mid-2000s, Onyebuchi recalls, the internet represented a "beautiful utopia" where users could freely exchange information and tips, particularly about shared interests like video games. However, this perception shifted dramatically around 2012, following the Trayvon Martin case. Onyebuchi noticed an emergence of diverse and troubling opinions online, particularly regarding race, that hadn't been visible before. The internet evolved into a hub for activism and political discourse, facilitating the organization of protests and enabling more voices to contribute to social and political conversations.
While the internet proved crucial for organizing activism around cases like Trayvon Martin's, Onyebuchi notes that it also contributed to increased polarization and radicalization. He points to events like Gamergate as examples of how the post-2010 internet became more prone to negativity and conflict. These developments highlight the internet's dual capacity to unite people for causes while simultaneously deepening societal divisions.
Onyebuchi contrasts the "old" internet's helpful, collaborative nature with today's more serious, news-focused, and polarized environment. He notes how platforms like Twitter evolved from spaces for casual interaction to hubs for serious discussion and news. Despite these challenges, Onyebuchi sees potential for positive change, particularly after what he predicts will be a difficult period dealing with AI-related challenges like deepfakes and misinformation. He suggests that improving the internet involves creating and choosing curated spaces aligned with one's values rather than withdrawing completely.
1-Page Summary
The internet's perception has evolved from an open, joyous space for sharing in the mid-2000s to, after 2012, becoming a platform fraught with divisions and intense debates about social and political issues.
In the mid-2000s, for those with a broadband connection, the internet was perceived as an embodiment of freedom—a beautiful utopia where community and information sharing thrived. It was a space where one could feel like a skinless, raceless entity, joyously exchanging tips and tricks for video games such as getting through the water dungeon in "Zelda."
The perception shifted drastically around the time of Trayvon Martin's death in 2012. Onyebuchi began noticing a spectrum of opinions online that hadn’t been evident before, particularly on issues of race. The internet revealed a greater diversity of opinion, including people who found nothing wrong with the outcome of Trayvon Martin's case, which was shocking to Onyebuchi and marked a departure from the utopia they once exper ...
From "Beautiful Utopia" to Intense Reality: Changing Internet Perception
The internet's pivotal role in amplifying movements and activism, as seen in the response to Trayvon Martin's case, has also led to increased polarization and radicalization.
The internet served as a key tool for disseminating information and organizing activism surrounding the case of Trayvon Martin. Social media and other online platforms were used to coordinate protest locations, rally support, and provide spaces for collective writing and expression. This connectivity allowed for widespread engagement and helped bring the issue of racial injustice to the forefront of public consciousness.
However, the same digital environment that facilitated informational sharing and community-building also had darker consequences. Onyebuchi touches on the reaction to the acquittal of George Zimmerman, especially among young people on the right, as a radicalizing moment. This suggests that the internet, while spreading awareness, also served to polarize users and contribute to more extreme viewpoints on either side of ...
The Internet's Impact on Movements Like Trayvon Martin
The internet has undergone significant changes over the years, with many longing for the days when it was a simpler, kinder place for sharing information. This sense of nostalgia is contrasted with the current state of the internet, which is often focused on serious news and political polarization, according to author Onyebuchi.
Onyebuchi recalls the early internet as a kinder and more helpful environment. Forums and message boards were places where individuals eagerly provided assistance and shared information around common interests. This version of the internet had a positive "pH balance," as Onyebuchi describes it, a space where people were not engaged in conflict but in collaborative and generous exchanges.
The move away from these more amiable interactions is clear in platforms like Twitter, which have seen a significant shift in their use. Twitter was once a platform for jokes and casual interaction but has become a go-to place for news and serious discussions. This evolution marks a less satisfying and more contentious internet experience, which Onyebuchi notes.
Despite the negatives, the internet's transformation has had a positive impact on social and political change. Indeed, the author predicts that things may worsen before they get better. He discusses the collective "tech lash," or backlash against technology, that has become more pronounced in recent years. People are no ...
Contrast Between "Old" and "New" Internet and Nostalgia For When Internet Was More Helpful, Less Focused on Serious News and Anger
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
