Podcasts > NPR's Book of the Day > 'Great Black Hope' is a character study of a young, Black, queer man in high society

'Great Black Hope' is a character study of a young, Black, queer man in high society

By NPR (podcasts@npr.org)

In this episode of NPR's Book of the Day, the discussion centers on a character study of Smith, a member of the Southern Black bourgeoisie navigating New York's elite white social circles. The summary examines how Smith's privileged background influences his experiences as both an insider and outsider in high society, while exploring his struggle with addiction and the pressures of maintaining a carefully curated image.

The episode delves into themes of intergenerational progress, as Smith represents his family's journey from sharecropping to Ivy League education. It also addresses how class privilege affects perceptions of addiction and recovery, particularly through the lens of race, and follows Smith's development into someone who examines the implications of his own privilege while seeking to create positive change.

Listen to the original

'Great Black Hope' is a character study of a young, Black, queer man in high society

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Jun 24, 2025 episode of the NPR's Book of the Day

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

'Great Black Hope' is a character study of a young, Black, queer man in high society

1-Page Summary

Class, Race, and Privilege in "Great Black Hope"

In "Great Black Hope," Smith navigates the complex intersection of his Southern Black bourgeoisie background and New York's elite white social circles. Despite his privileged background, Smith's acceptance in these exclusive circles comes with conditions, as he serves as a multicultural novelty among his wealthy white peers while struggling with feelings of being an outsider.

Smith's Social Navigation and Personal Struggles

As the protagonist, Smith faces intense pressure to maintain a carefully curated image while moving through high society. He grapples with internal conflicts of rage, sadness, and guilt, complicated further by an addiction that threatens to destabilize his delicate social balance.

Family Legacy and Social Progress

Smith represents the third generation of his family's remarkable journey from sharecropping to Ivy League education. However, his story illustrates the fragility of social progress for Black Americans, as generations of achievement can be swiftly undermined. Smith shoulders the weight of his family's legacy while adhering to exhausting standards of "respectability."

Addiction, Race, and Class Intersections

Rob Franklin explores how Smith's class privilege influences perceptions of his addiction and recovery. While his privileged background provides certain protections, Smith's eventual imprisonment highlights the stark disparities in how the "War on Drugs" impacts Black communities. Franklin portrays Smith's evolution into a politically engaged, self-aware individual who seeks to address the implications of his privilege and make a positive impact.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • You can explore your own background by creating a visual timeline of your family's history, noting significant events and milestones that have shaped your identity. This activity helps you understand the layers of your heritage and the societal changes that have impacted your family. For example, you might include your grandparents' occupations, your parents' education levels, and any cultural shifts you've experienced, which can provide insight into your place within broader social narratives.
  • Start a journal to reflect on moments when you've felt like an outsider and how you've navigated those situations. Writing down these experiences can help you process feelings of otherness and identify patterns in your interactions with different social groups. For instance, after attending a social event where you felt out of place, jot down what made you feel that way, how you responded, and what you might do differently in the future to bridge the gap between you and the group.
  • Engage in local community discussions or online forums that focus on social progress and the impact of policies like the "War on Drugs." By participating, you can contribute to conversations about social justice and learn from others' experiences. For example, you might attend a town hall meeting discussing criminal justice reform or join a social media group dedicated to advocating for policy changes, where you can share your thoughts and learn from the lived experiences of others.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
'Great Black Hope' is a character study of a young, Black, queer man in high society

Class, Race, and Privilege in "Great Black Hope"

Smith Navigates Southern Black Bourgeoisie Roots and New York's High-Class White Party Scene

Smith finds himself balancing the nuances of his Southern Black bourgeoisie roots while trying to fit into New York's elite, predominantly white social circles.

Smith's Elite NY Social Circle Presence Conditional

His presence in these exclusive circles doesn't come without conditions. Smith is somewhat of a novelty to his wealthy white peers, bringing a "texture" to their lives that is sought after in an era where affluence and whiteness began to be seen as unfashionable unless adorned with a semblance of multiculturalism.

Feeling Like an Outsider ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Class, Race, and Privilege in "Great Black Hope"

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • Smith's experience may not be representative of all individuals who navigate between different cultural or social backgrounds, as personal experiences can vary widely.
  • The notion of being a "novelty" could be challenged by the idea that individuals from diverse backgrounds bring intrinsic value to social circles beyond being a mere "texture" or trend.
  • The feeling of being an outsider might be more complex and not solely based on race or family achievements; it could also involve personal identity, interests, and other social dynamics.
  • The text implies a monolithic view of "elite New York social circles," w ...

Actionables

  • You can explore your own cultural identity by creating a personal heritage map, detailing your family's history, traditions, and the communities you identify with. This activity helps you understand the unique blend of cultures that shape your identity. Start by researching your family tree, noting down significant cultural events, foods, languages, or traditions that have been part of your life. Share this map with friends or family to open up conversations about cultural identity and belonging.
  • Enhance your social adaptability by practicing code-switching in low-stakes environments, like book clubs or sports teams, where you can safely experiment with different cultural norms and communication styles. Code-switching is the practice of shifting the way you express yourself in different social contexts. For example, you might use certain colloquialisms with your sports team that you wouldn't use in a professional setting. This helps you navigate diverse social circles more comfortably.
  • Build empathy and understanding for feeling like an outsider by volunteering ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
'Great Black Hope' is a character study of a young, Black, queer man in high society

Protagonist Smith's Navigation of Social Worlds and Challenges

In the novel "Great Black Hope," Smith is a protagonist caught in a complex social struggle, attempting to float through the scenes of high society dominated by his affluent white friends.

Smith Is Torn Between Family Legacy and High-Society Pressures

Smith grapples with the heavy expectations placed upon him by his family legacy and the pressures from the elite circles he moves in.

Smith Battles Internal Conflict While Upholding a Curated Image and Avoiding Identity Complexities

Smith struggles to confront his own feelings of rage, sadness, hurt, and guilt. His social survival is predicated on maintaining a curated image that aligns with the expectations set by those around him, thu ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Protagonist Smith's Navigation of Social Worlds and Challenges

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • You can explore your own family legacy by creating a visual timeline that includes both the achievements and the pressures that come with them. Start by listing out significant events and expectations from your family history, then draw connections to how these have shaped your own goals and self-image. This can help you understand the influence of your family legacy on your personal identity and social interactions.
  • Develop a personal brand that feels authentic by journaling about your values, interests, and aspirations. Use this journal to craft a narrative that represents who you truly are, rather than what others expect you to be. Share this narrative with close friends or on a personal blog to reinforce your authentic self in social situations, which can be a step towards reconciling internal conflicts and societal pressures.
  • Address and manage emotions like rage, sadness, hurt, and g ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
'Great Black Hope' is a character study of a young, Black, queer man in high society

Family Legacy and "Respectability Politics" in Smith's Identity

Smith's lineage illustrates the fragility of socioeconomic progress for Black Americans and the pressure exerted by legacies of success.

Smith: Third-Generation Ascendancy From Sharecropping Roots To Ivy League

Smith stands as a third-generation testament to his family's remarkable climb from sharecropping roots to the upper echelons of academia. His grandmother's journey from working on a sharecropping farm to practicing law laid the foundation. Subsequently, his parents continued the educational legacy by attending prestigious Ivy League schools.

Smith Family's Upward Mobility Undone, Exposing Precarious Social Progress for Black Americans

The narrative around Smith's family's progress highlights a sobering reality: the ground gained over generations of striving and achievement can be lost swiftly, revealing the fragility of social progress for Black Americans. It underlines the unstable intersection of race and class, emphasizing how Black Americans often face a higher likelihood of regression compared to other groups, symbolizing the transient guarantee of upward mobility even for those who reach considerable heights.

Smith Struggles With His Family's Legacy Expectations

Smith bears the ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Family Legacy and "Respectability Politics" in Smith's Identity

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • You can explore your family history to better understand the socioeconomic shifts over generations. Start by interviewing older relatives and compiling a family tree that includes occupations and educational levels. This can provide a personal perspective on the broader societal trends discussed, and may help you appreciate the nuances of your own family's journey.
  • Create a personal reflection journal to examine the pressures of legacy and expectations. Write down your thoughts on how your family's achievements shape your own goals and the stress that may come with it. This exercise can help you identify areas where you might be putting undue pressure on yourself and find ways to set more realistic personal expectations.
  • Engage in conversations with peers about t ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
'Great Black Hope' is a character study of a young, Black, queer man in high society

Intersection of Addiction and Race/Class in Narrative

Rob Franklin's "Great Black Hope" delves into the complexities of addiction, particularly how race and class intersect in the recovery narrative of the protagonist, Smith.

Smith's Addiction Viewed Differently Due to Class Privilege, Allowing "Blasé Attitude" Towards Recovery Not Afforded Other Black Americans

Franklin elaborates on how Smith's class privilege affects perceptions of his addiction and recovery attitude. Smith's experience with addiction is shaded by the cultural weight of the word "addict" when applied to different bodies. It is suggested that because of his class, there is a different attitude towards his addiction and his journey toward recovery. The privilege insulates him to a degree, providing a safety net that manifests as a blasé attitude towards recovery.

Smith's Addiction Lands Him In Prison, Highlighting the "War on Drugs" Disparity in Black Communities

In an illustrative turn in the novel, Smith lands in prison, an event that underscores the ongoing disparity in the "War on Drugs" largely impacting Black communities. Smith's incarceration throws a stark light on the class and racial dynamics within drug policy and law enforcement. By exploring Smith's addiction alongside the penal system, Franklin makes a pointed political commentary on these discrepancies.

Smith's Fu ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Intersection of Addiction and Race/Class in Narrative

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • Reflect on your own background to understand biases by writing down how your upbringing and social status may have shaped your views on addiction and recovery. For example, if you grew up in a middle-class neighborhood, consider how this might influence your perception of drug use compared to someone from a less privileged background. This self-reflection can help you recognize and challenge any subconscious biases you may hold.
  • Volunteer with organizations that support marginalized communities to gain firsthand experience of the disparities in drug policy enforcement. By working with groups that provide legal aid or rehabilitation services, you can see the contrast in treatment between different social classes and races, which can deepen your understanding of the systemic issues at play. ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA