In 'Julie Chan Is Dead,' former influencer Liann Zhang takes a swipe at the industry
NPR's Book of the Day examines former beauty influencer Lian Zhang's novel about the dark side of influencer culture. Drawing from her own experiences in the industry, Zhang's story follows a protagonist who assumes her deceased twin sister's influencer identity, becoming part of an exclusive group led by an internet celebrity named Bella Marie.
The conversation explores how Zhang uses elements of mystery and horror to critique the influencer industry's hidden dangers. Set during a brand-sponsored retreat on an isolated island, the novel depicts the stark contrast between influencers' polished public personas and troubling behind-the-scenes realities, raising questions about exploitation and the need for accountability in digital spaces.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the May 13, 2025 episode of the NPR's Book of the Day
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
Lian Zhang's Experience With Influencer Culture Influencing Her Novel
Drawing from her teenage years as a "skinfluencer," Lian Zhang crafts a novel that offers unique insights into the beauty industry and influencer culture. Her work features the Belladonnas, a group of influencers led by internet sensation Bella Marie, serving as a metaphor for the superficial nature of influencer communities.
Satirical Portrayal of Influencer Culture
Zhang's novel follows protagonist Julie Chan, who assumes her deceased twin sister's identity and inherits her influencer status. Through Julie's journey, Zhang explores the lengths people go to achieve fame in the influencer world. The story incorporates brand-sponsored influencer retreats, where Zhang reveals the contrast between carefully curated public personas and the darker realities that exist behind the scenes.
Sinister Elements and Industry Critique
Zhang weaves elements of mystery, horror, and cult behavior into her narrative, using an island retreat as the setting for alarming events involving mysterious substances and possible animal sacrifices. Through these plot devices, Zhang expresses her concerns about the influencer industry's hidden dangers and exploitation. Her satirical approach serves to highlight the need for greater accountability and transparency in influencer culture, while exposing the potentially harmful consequences of this digital phenomenon.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- The portrayal of influencer culture as superficial may overlook the genuine connections and communities that can form within these spaces.
- The use of satire and horror elements to critique influencer culture might exaggerate issues and not accurately represent the experiences of all influencers.
- The depiction of influencer retreats as sites of hidden darkness could be seen as a narrative device that does not reflect the reality of most brand-influencer collaborations.
- The narrative's focus on the negative aspects of influencer culture may ignore the positive impacts, such as raising awareness for social issues, charity work, and empowerment through self-expression.
- The suggestion that influencer culture inherently involves exploitation and hidden dangers could be challenged by pointing out the existence of ethical and transparent influencer practices.
- The novel's critique might be interpreted as a generalization that does not account for the diversity within influencer communities, including those who strive for authenticity and positive influence.
- The emphasis on the need for greater accountability and transparency, while valid, may not acknowledge the efforts already being made by some influencers and brands to achieve these goals.
Actionables
- Reflect on your social media consumption by keeping a journal to document how influencer posts make you feel and why. This can help you become more aware of the impact influencer culture has on your emotions and self-perception. For example, after scrolling through your feed, jot down any feelings of inadequacy or inspiration and consider what triggered those feelings.
- Create a "reality check" bookmark folder in your web browser with articles and resources that discuss the behind-the-scenes of influencer marketing. When you find yourself getting too absorbed in the glamour of influencer posts, go through this folder to remind yourself of the curated nature of what you're seeing. This could include articles on the psychology of social media, interviews with former influencers about industry pressures, or studies on the effects of social media on mental health.
- Engage in mindful unfollowing by evaluating the influencers you follow and deciding whether they add value to your life or perpetuate harmful stereotypes. Make a conscious decision to unfollow those who contribute to negative self-image or unrealistic expectations and seek out content creators who promote authenticity, positivity, and transparency. You might replace influencers with accounts focused on educational content, mental health advocacy, or real-life skills.
Get access to the context and additional materials
Lian Zhang's Experience With Influencer Culture Influencing Her Novel
Lian Zhang's novel reflects her intimate understanding of influencer culture, drawing from her teenage years as a "skinfluencer." Her insights into the beauty industry and the dynamics within influencer communities inform the narrative and critique of her work.
Lian Zhang's Teen Years as a "Skinfluencer" Provided Skincare Insights
Zhang's teenage involvement with skincare, which earned her the title of a "skinfluencer," gives her a unique vantage point. Her novel takes a critical look at the beauty and skincare industry, reflecting on its superficiality through a fictional narrative.
Lian's Novel Critiques Superficial Industry
In Lian Zhang's novel, the Belladonnas, a group of influencers led by internet sensation Bella Marie, represent the allure and toxicity of influencer culture. It's a clever allusion by Zhang, inferring that although influencers might seem beautiful and appealing on the surface, there is an underlying harmfulness to their tightly-knit circles.
Lian's Insight Into Influencer Community Dynamics and Language
Zhang's insights into the echo-chamber nature of influencer interaction can be seen in the conversations she crafts within her novel. She taps into the repetitive and often insincere exchanges that cross the lines between supportive and superficial. It's a wor ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Lian Zhang's Experience With Influencer Culture Influencing Her Novel
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While Lian Zhang's personal experience as a "skinfluencer" may provide valuable insights, it could also introduce bias in her portrayal of influencer culture, potentially overlooking positive aspects or diversity within the community.
- The critique of the beauty and skincare industry's superficiality in Zhang's novel may not fully acknowledge the industry's efforts towards inclusivity, sustainability, and education.
- The representation of the Belladonnas as embodying the allure and toxicity of influencer culture might oversimplify the complex motivations and experiences of real influencers.
- The echo-chamber nature of influencer interactions depicted in the novel may not represent the entirety of influencer dynamics, as there are influencers who strive for authenticity and meaningful engagement.
- The conversations within influencer communities, while sometimes repetitive and insincere, could also be supportive and genuine, which may not be fully captured if the novel focuses ...
Actionables
- You can start a journal to reflect on your own social media interactions, focusing on authenticity versus performance. By regularly noting down your online conversations and the emotions behind them, you'll become more aware of how genuine you're being with your followers or friends. For example, after posting on social media, write about why you shared that content and how the interactions that followed made you feel.
- Create a book club with friends where you read and discuss novels that explore social media culture. This can help you understand different perspectives on influencer culture and its impact on society. Choose books from various authors who write about the digital age, such as "Fake Accounts" by Lauren Oyler or "No One Is Talking About This" by Patricia Lockwood, and compare their insights with your own exper ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Satirical Portrayal of Influencer Culture in the Novel
The novel presents a satirical depiction of the influencer world, with protagonist Julie Chan submerging herself into her late twin sister's life and illuminating the shallow, often materialistic aspects that underscore influencer culture.
Protagonist Impersonates Influencer Twin, Commenting On Shallow, Materialistic Culture
Julie Chan, the protagonist of the story, assumes the identity of her estranged deceased twin sister Chloe. This impersonation grants Julie instant fame as she inherits Chloe's followers and the apparent glamor that comes with life as a celebrated influencer. Within this narrative, the novel provides a commentary on the lengths individuals may go to achieve fame in the influencer world. It explores Julie's desire to outshine her sister and delve deeper into the influencer culture—a sphere depicted as being markedly shallow and materialistic.
The Novel Satirizes Brand-Sponsored Influencer Retreats
Further satirizing the influencer ecosystem, the novel offers a critical view of brand-sponsored influencer retreats.
Unfilmed Activities and Sinister Events on the Island Retreat Metaphorically Reveal the Darker Side ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Satirical Portrayal of Influencer Culture in the Novel
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- Influencer culture can have positive aspects, such as empowering individuals to become entrepreneurs and create content that inspires or helps others.
- Not all influencers are shallow or materialistic; many use their platforms to raise awareness about important issues and engage in philanthropic efforts.
- The portrayal of influencer culture as predominantly negative may overlook the diversity and complexity within the community.
- Brand-sponsored retreats can offer legitimate opportunities for networking, professional development, and creative collaboration among influencers.
- The novel's depiction of a sinister side to influencer retreats might not accurately re ...
Actionables
- Reflect on your social media use by journaling about the intentions behind your posts and the emotions they evoke. Write down your feelings before and after posting, and assess whether your online persona aligns with your true self. This can help you understand the impact of social media on your personal identity and well-being.
- Create a "reality check" photo series where you capture unedited, everyday moments alongside the typical curated images you might share online. Share these paired photos with friends or on social media to foster conversations about authenticity and the contrast between online image and reality.
- Volun ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Sinister Novel Elements and Their Relation to the Influencer World
Zhang's latest novel introduces a chilling exploration of the influencer industry through the lens of mystery, horror, and cult behavior, revealing the potential dangers and exploitations that lurk beneath its glittering surface.
Mystery, Horror, and Cult Behavior Explore Influencer Industry Dangers and Exploitation
In Zhang’s narrative, an island retreat for influencers becomes a stage where bizarre and alarming events unfold. Mystery envelopes the story as mysterious substances come into play alongside possible acts of animal sacrifice and the veneration of a mystical deity. These novel elements serve as a metaphor for Lian’s apprehension regarding the influencer world, where unethical practices are often concealed by an alluring façade.
Satirical Novel Exposes Influencer Lifestyle's Dark Consequences and Accountability Need
Through a satirical take on the inf ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Sinister Novel Elements and Their Relation to the Influencer World
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- The use of horror and cult elements might exaggerate the reality of the influencer industry, which for many is a legitimate and ethical career choice.
- The novel's depiction of influencers on an island retreat may not accurately represent the everyday experiences of most influencers, who often engage in more mundane activities.
- The metaphorical use of mysterious substances and animal sacrifice could be seen as sensationalizing and not reflective of the actual practices within the influencer community.
- While the novel critiques the influencer lifestyle, it could inadvertently contribute to the stigmatization of influencers by not acknowledging the positive impacts and genuine content creation that many contribute to the industry.
- The cal ...
Actionables
- You can critically evaluate influencer content by creating a "reality checklist" to discern the authenticity of posts. Start by noting down common traits of influencer posts that seem exaggerated or inauthentic. When you encounter new content, use your checklist to assess its credibility. For example, if an influencer is promoting a product with claims that seem too good to be true, check if similar claims have been debunked or if there's a pattern of such endorsements.
- Develop a habit of researching the backstory of viral trends or products before participating or purchasing. Whenever a new trend emerges, take a moment to look into its origins, who's promoting it, and whether there's any controversy or criticism surrounding it. This could involve reading articles, watching explanatory videos, or checking out reviews from multiple sources. For instance, if a new health supplement is trending, investigate the scientific evidence behind it, and read user experiences from various platforms.
- Engage in mindful consumption of social media by setting specific goals for your online activity. Decide on w ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
