'Paper Doll' documents trans TikTok creator Dylan Mulvaney's journey through girlhood
In this episode of NPR's Book of the Day, transgender creator Dylan Mulvaney discusses her memoir "Paper Doll," which documents her journey of gender identity from childhood through her transition at age 25. She shares how she chose to document her experiences on TikTok and explores the intersection of faith with her transgender identity.
The episode covers Mulvaney's response to public backlash following a 2023 Bud Light promotion, including its impact on her mental health. Through her memoir and other creative projects, such as writing a transgender romantic comedy, Mulvaney works to shift narratives around transgender experiences and envisions a future with equal opportunities for transgender individuals.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Apr 23, 2025 episode of the NPR's Book of the Day
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
Mulvaney's Personal Journey of Identity and Transition
Dylan Mulvaney's journey of gender identity began early in life when, at age four, she told her mother she felt like a girl trapped in a boy's body. Her path to self-discovery progressed through coming out as gay at 14, identifying as non-binary at 24, and finally embracing her identity as a transgender woman at 25.
Rather than making a dramatic announcement, Mulvaney chose to document her transition journey on TikTok, sharing both everyday experiences and moments of "trans joy." Through humor and authenticity, she connects with her audience while offering insights into her life through her content and memoir, "Paper Doll, Notes from a Late Bloomer."
Public Backlash and Mental Health of Transgender Figures
In April 2023, Mulvaney faced intense conservative backlash following a Bud Light promotional video celebrating her 365th day of womanhood. The incident, known as "Beer Gate," sparked violent threats and a widespread boycott led by public figures like Kid Rock. Mulvaney reveals that this period led to severe mental health struggles, including suicidal ideation and dissociation, making her wish she had prioritized mental health treatment sooner.
Faith and Religion in the LGBTQ+ Experience
Mulvaney openly discusses reconciling her Catholic upbringing with her transgender identity. While acknowledging that her childhood religion no longer aligns with her identity, she maintains that faith and being transgender aren't mutually exclusive. In her memoir, Mulvaney explores her belief that her transness is intentional, advocating that transgender individuals can find joy and fulfillment in spirituality.
Mulvaney's Resilience and Optimistic Outlook
Despite adversity, Mulvaney maintains an unwavering optimistic perspective, believing in the possibility of "1,001 great things" ahead. She actively works toward a future where transgender individuals can live safely and thrive with equal opportunities. As part of this vision, Mulvaney is writing a trans-led romantic comedy to showcase empowerment rather than victimhood, aiming to shift the narrative around transgender experiences.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Actionables
- You can explore your own identity by journaling your life experiences, noting moments of joy and challenge, and reflecting on how they shape your sense of self. Start with a simple notebook and dedicate time each day to write about your feelings, thoughts, and experiences. This practice can help you understand your identity better and see your own growth over time.
- Create a personal "joy list" to celebrate your unique experiences and milestones, similar to how Mulvaney celebrated days of womanhood. Write down small victories or moments that make you happy, and refer to this list whenever you need a reminder of the positive aspects of your life. This could be as simple as enjoying a cup of coffee in the morning or as significant as recognizing a moment of personal growth.
- Engage with your community by sharing your own stories of overcoming adversity or personal growth on social media, using platforms like TikTok or Instagram. Use hashtags to connect with others who might share similar experiences, and offer support and encouragement to those who are facing their own challenges. This can foster a sense of belonging and help build a supportive network.
Get access to the context and additional materials
Mulvaney's Personal Journey of Identity and Transition
Dylan Mulvaney's story is one of self-discovery and transparency, detailing her evolution of identity and gender transition, which she courageously documents and shares online.
Mulvaney's Realization and Coming Out As a Transgender Woman
Since childhood, Mulvaney grappled with gender identity. At the tender age of four, she confided in her mother about feeling like a girl trapped in a boy’s body. Her mother, aiming to console her, insisted that God does not make mistakes. This early experience foreshadowed Mulvaney's journey ahead.
Years passed and at 14, Mulvaney came out as gay, moved into a non-binary identification at 24, and finally, at 25, embraced her truth as a transgender woman.
Mulvaney's Realization and Coming Out As a Transgender Woman
At Age 4, Mulvaney Told Her Mother She Was a Girl in a Boy's Body, but Her Mother Reassured Her That God Does Not Make Mistakes
Mulvaney’s declaration to her mother at the age of 4 was a pivotal moment in her early life. Despite her mother's reassurance, Dylan carried the weight of this incongruence throughout her formative years, ultimately leading to her eventual transition.
Mulvaney: Gay at 14, Non-binary at 24, Transgender Woman at 25
Dylan's journey into self-acceptance took shape over time. Identifying as gay in her early teens, non-binary in her mid-twenties, and finally, a transgender woman, Dylan's experiences showcase the complexity and fluidity of gender identity.
Mulvaney Documents Her Transition Online
Dylan Mulvaney has chosen to take her followers along on her personal journey of transition, opting for an authentic and interactive narrative instead of a solitary, dramatic announcement.
Mulvaney Wanted to Share Her Transition Journey With Followers, Instead Of a Dramatic Coming-Out Video
Eschewing the theatrics, Mulvaney decided to document her transition on TikTok, providing a personal, real-time view of her experiences through tra ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Mulvaney's Personal Journey of Identity and Transition
Additional Materials
Actionables
- You can create a personal timeline to map out your own journey of self-discovery, mirroring the stages of realization and coming out that Mulvaney experienced. Start by jotting down significant moments in your life where you recognized something new about yourself, whether related to gender identity, sexual orientation, or any other aspect of your identity. This can help you see your growth over time and may guide future decisions or moments of self-reflection.
- Consider starting a private journal or a digital log to document your personal experiences and thoughts, akin to Mulvaney's online documentation but tailored to your comfort level with sharing. Use this space to express your feelings, challenges, and triumphs. Over time, this can become a powerful tool for understanding your journey and may even become something you choose to share with others in some form. ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Public Backlash and Mental Health of Transgender Figures
The story of Dylan Mulvaney and the "Beer Gate" incident highlights the intensity of public backlash against transgender individuals and its impact on their mental health.
The "Beer Gate" Incident and the Resulting Backlash
In 2023, Mulvaney's Bud Light Video Sparked Conservative Backlash
In April of 2023, Dylan Mulvaney, a transgender woman, celebrated Day 365 of womanhood in a sponsored video that featured a can of Bud Light with her face on it. This acknowledgment of her identity milestone by Bud Light sparked immediate and severe conservative backlash.
Backlash Included Vitriol, Violent Threats, and a Bud Light Boycott by Figures Like Kid Rock
The backlash quickly escalated to include vitriolic comments, violent threats against Mulvaney, and a widespread boycott of Bud Light. Public figures, including Kid Rock, targeted Bud Light, aligning themselves with the conservative response to the video.
Mulvaney's Mental Health Struggles During the Backlash
Mulvaney Faced Suicidal Ideation and Dissociation From Public Scrutiny
Amidst the scrutiny, Mulvaney suffered f ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Public Backlash and Mental Health of Transgender Figures
Additional Materials
Actionables
- You can support transgender individuals by educating yourself on their experiences through books, articles, and documentaries to foster empathy and understanding. By learning about the challenges faced by transgender people, you can become a more informed ally, able to engage in conversations with a deeper sense of compassion and knowledge. For example, reading "Transgender History" by Susan Stryker or watching the documentary "Disclosure" can provide historical and cultural context to the issues faced by the transgender community.
- Create a safe space for open dialogue among friends and family about the importance of mental health, especially for those facing public scrutiny or backlash. Start a monthly discussion group where you can share resources, personal experiences, and strategies for coping with stress and negativity. This could be as simple as a group chat or a regular meetup where everyone brings an article or idea to share and discuss.
- Advocate for brands and comp ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Faith and Religion in the LGBTQ+ Experience
Mulvaney shares her journey of reconciling her Catholic upbringing and faith with her transgender identity, addressing the complexities and beauty of her experience.
Mulvaney's Catholic Upbringing and Faith Relationship
Mulvaney's Faith No Longer Fits Her Transgender Identity
Mulvaney opens up about how the religion and church she was raised in no longer aligns with her identity as a transgender individual. This dissonance reflects the struggle many LGBTQ+ individuals face when their sense of self seems at odds with religious doctrines they grew up with.
Mulvaney Finds Beauty In Transness and Faith, yet Recognizes Religion's Harm To LGBTQ+ Individuals
Despite the challenges, Mulvaney still sees beauty in both her trans identity and faith. She holds onto her spiritual beliefs while acknowledging the harm that organized religion has historically inflicted upon queer and trans communities.
Mulvaney's Effort to Reconcile Faith and Identity
Mulvaney Included Her Faith and Belief In Her Transness Being Intentional in Her Memoir
Seeking to make sense of her experiences, Mulvaney's memoir explores her belief in a higher power's intentional design, including her own transness. Her writin ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Faith and Religion in the LGBTQ+ Experience
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- Some individuals may argue that personal faith and religious doctrine can be interpreted in various ways, and not all interpretations are necessarily incompatible with LGBTQ+ identities.
- There are religious communities and denominations that have become more inclusive and accepting of LGBTQ+ individuals, suggesting that the relationship between faith and LGBTQ+ identities can evolve.
- The idea that a higher power has an "intentional design" for individuals, including their transness, may be contested by those who believe in a non-interventionist deity or by atheists who do not subscribe to the concept of a higher power.
- Critics might suggest that while Mulvaney finds beauty in her faith and trans identity, this experience is subjective and may not resonate with a ...
Actionables
- You can journal about the intersections of your identity and beliefs to better understand how they coexist. Start by writing down aspects of your identity that you feel are important, then reflect on how each aspect relates to your personal beliefs or spirituality. This exercise can help you see the harmony between different parts of yourself, similar to how Mulvaney finds beauty in her trans identity and faith.
- Create a personal manifesto that outlines how you can honor both your LGBTQ+ identity and your spirituality. This could include affirmations, intentions, or actions that resonate with your understanding of being queer or trans and spiritual. For example, you might write, "I will seek out inclusive spiritual communities that celebrate my whole self," or "I will meditate on scriptures or teachings that affirm my identity."
- Engage in community service or volunteer work with organizations that ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Mulvaney's Resilience and Optimistic Outlook
Dylan Mulvaney exemplifies an unwavering resilience and maintains a positive outlook, even in the face of adversity.
Mulvaney's Commitment to a Positive and Hopeful Perspective
Amidst challenges, Mulvaney remains steadfastly optimistic, consciously choosing to focus on the prospect of discovery and the belief in a brighter future.
Mulvaney Chooses Optimism and Discovery Over Pessimism, Even In Adversity
Mulvaney has articulated a preference for optimism, asserting that while a thousand negative outcomes might loom, the potential for one thousand and one remarkable achievements exists and, in fact, many have already come to pass.
Mulvaney Believes 1,001 Great Things Are Possible and Will Chase Opportunities
Reflecting this attitude, Dylan Mulvaney channels their energy into seeking new opportunities and experiences, embracing a sense of perpetual discovery and positivity. This hopeful stance characterizes Mulvaney's approach to life and resonates as an inspiration to always seek the silver lining.
Mulvaney's Hopes for the Future
In envisioning the future, Mulvaney's aspirations extend beyond personal well-being to encompass the broader trans community.
Mulvaney Hopes For Safety and Equal Opportunities For Trans People to Thrive
Dylan Mulvaney envisions a future where trans individuals are met with safety and presented with equal chan ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Mulvaney's Resilience and Optimistic Outlook
Additional Materials
Actionables
- You can start a daily optimism journal to cultivate a positive outlook by writing down three things you're hopeful about each morning. This practice encourages you to begin your day with a forward-thinking mindset and trains your brain to identify opportunities for growth and positivity, similar to how Mulvaney focuses on discovery and a brighter future.
- Create a "Silver Lining" social media challenge where you share a personal challenge and how you're finding strength or a positive aspect in it. Encourage friends to participate by tagging them, creating a ripple effect of resilience and optimism online. This mirrors Mulvaney's approach to inspiring others and promotes a community of support and empow ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
