Podcasts > NPR's Book of the Day > Two new novels explore a world where technology has even greater access to our minds

Two new novels explore a world where technology has even greater access to our minds

By NPR (podcasts@npr.org)

In this episode of NPR's Book of the Day, Scott Tong and book authors Audrey Lee and Laila Lalami explore the vulnerability of human memory. They discuss how modern technologies like virtual reality and surveillance can distort and manipulate memories, blurring the lines between reality and fabrication.

Lee's novel "the Mechanics of Memory" centers on a protagonist grappling with a memory gap and undergoing questionable therapy that casts doubt on her recollections. Lalami's "The Dream Hotel" examines a dystopian society where the government monitors citizens' dreams through implants, raising privacy and freedom concerns. Both stories serve as cautionary tales about the misuse of technology to access and alter our most personal experiences.

Listen to the original

Two new novels explore a world where technology has even greater access to our minds

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Apr 11, 2025 episode of the NPR's Book of the Day

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Two new novels explore a world where technology has even greater access to our minds

1-Page Summary

The Vulnerability and Manipulability of Human Memories

Memories Are Not as Reliable as We Think

Scott Tong and Audrey Lee reveal that our memories can be significantly distorted by social pressure, biases, and time, according to cognitive research. Audrey Lee says the more she studied memory, the more she realized its unreliability and the potential for misuse through manipulation.

Protagonist in "the Mechanics of Memory" Struggles With Reality vs. False Memories

In Lee's novel, the protagonist faces a year-long memory gap and questions whether her recollections are authentic. She enters a facility and undergoes questionable therapy that sows doubt about her memories. Ultimately, the protagonist and other patients uncover the facility's practices of manipulating memories.

Exploiting and Altering Memories With VR and Surveillance Technology

Lee's "Mechanics of Memory" and Lalami's "The Dream Hotel" explore the alarming potential of virtual reality (VR) and surveillance tech to manipulate memories.

"Mechanics of Memory" Facility Uses Virtual Reality to Alter Memories

At the facility, Hope undergoes VR treatments that make her question her memories' veracity. In a twist, the narrative reveals another patient created the VR system used to feed manipulated experiences.

Surveillance Tech Controls Individuals' Experiences in "The Dream Hotel"

In Lalami's novel, the government monitors characters' dreams via implants, leading to detainment and loss of privacy and freedom for the protagonist who fights the surveillance state.

Implications of Surveillance State Accessing Dreams

Lalami's "The Dream Hotel" depicts a dystopian future of government-controlled dream monitoring, sparking concerns about trading liberty for security.

"Dream Hotel" Author More Aware of Tech's Privacy Intrusion

Working on the novel made Lalami more conscious of technology's privacy intrusions. She's reducing her reliance on apps to regain autonomy, warning readers to carefully consider sacrificing liberty for safety under pervasive surveillance, as her protagonist does.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • Cognitive research does indicate that memories can be distorted, but it's also important to recognize that not all memories are equally susceptible to distortion, and some can be remarkably accurate, especially when they are emotionally salient or repeatedly reinforced.
  • While Audrey Lee points out the unreliability of memory, it's also worth noting that memory can be a robust tool for learning and survival, and its adaptability can sometimes serve a functional purpose.
  • The protagonist's struggle with memory authenticity in "The Mechanics of Memory" highlights the fallibility of human recollection, but in real life, there are often external corroborations and evidence that can help validate personal memories.
  • The narrative of memory manipulation in "The Mechanics of Memory" raises ethical concerns, but it also opens up a discussion about the potential therapeutic uses of memory alteration, such as in the treatment of PTSD.
  • The use of virtual reality to alter memories in the novel presents a cautionary tale, but VR also has positive applications, such as in education, training, and therapy, which are not addressed in the text.
  • Surveillance technology, as depicted in "The Dream Hotel," is shown to have negative consequences, but there are also instances where surveillance can enhance security and safety without infringing on privacy.
  • The dystopian future presented in "The Dream Hotel" serves as a warning, but it is also important to consider the role of informed consent and democratic oversight in the development and deployment of such technologies.
  • Lalami's increased awareness of privacy intrusions and her decision to reduce reliance on apps is one approach, but others might argue that the benefits of technology, when used responsibly, can outweigh the risks.
  • The caution against sacrificing liberty for safety is a valid concern, but there are also arguments that some trade-offs can be justified if they are transparent, regulated, and designed to protect the public from harm.

Actionables

  • You can start a personal memory journal to track how your recollections change over time. Write down detailed accounts of significant events as soon as they happen, and revisit these entries periodically to note any shifts in your memory. This practice can help you understand the fluidity of memory and recognize the factors that might influence changes in your recollections.
  • Create a digital privacy checklist to safeguard your personal information online. Include actions like regularly updating passwords, reviewing app permissions, and disabling unnecessary location tracking on your devices. By actively managing your digital footprint, you'll be better equipped to protect your privacy against potential surveillance technologies.
  • Engage in mindful media consumption by critically analyzing the content you interact with, especially when it involves futuristic technology. Before accepting the premises presented in movies, books, or articles, take a moment to reflect on the implications for privacy and personal freedom. This habit can help you develop a more nuanced understanding of the balance between safety and liberty in the context of technological advancements.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Two new novels explore a world where technology has even greater access to our minds

The Vulnerability and Manipulability of Human Memories

Scott Tong and Audrey Lee delve into the delicate nature of human memory and how susceptible it is to distortion and manipulation by external factors.

Memories Are Not as Reliable as We Think

Cognitive Research: Memory Is Distorted by Social Pressure, Biases, and Time

Scott Tong introduces the topic by stating that our recollections can be manipulated by various factors, including bias, time, stress, or technology. Audrey Lee supports this notion by discussing how easily our memories can be swayed due to our inherent desire to conform to social pressures, to belong, and to please others. Audrey reveals that the more she delved into memory research, the more she realized just how unreliable our memories are and how they can be significantly distorted. This finding brings her to a disturbing insight into the potential for misuse if someone could harness the power to manipulate another's mind.

Protagonist in "the Mechanics of Memory" Struggles With Reality vs. False Memories

Audrey Lee discusses her novel "The Mechanics of Memory", which follows a protagonist grappling with a year-long gap in memory and wrestling with the authenticity of her own recollections.

Protagonist Enters Facility, Subjected To Questionable Therapy That Sows Doubt About Memories

The main character of the novel finds herself unable to remember the past year and faces the challenge of discerning fact fro ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The Vulnerability and Manipulability of Human Memories

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While memories can be influenced by external factors, not all memories are equally susceptible to distortion; some can be remarkably stable and accurate, especially those reinforced by repeated recall or associated with strong emotions.
  • The adaptability of memory can be seen as an evolutionary advantage, allowing individuals to reframe experiences in a way that can be psychologically beneficial or conducive to learning.
  • The extent to which memories are distorted by social pressures may vary greatly among individuals, with some exhibiting strong resistance to conformity and maintaining independent recollections.
  • The reliability of memory can be improved through certain techniques and practices, such as mindfulness, corroborating events with physical evidence, or using mnemonic devices, suggesting that memory's unreliability is not an absolute condition.
  • The idea that memories can be easily manipulated might be overstated in some contexts; there are ethical and methodological limitations to how much influence external factors can have on an individual's memory.
  • The portrayal of memory manipulation in "The Mechanics of Memory" is a fictional representation and may not accurately reflect the complexities and limitations of real-world psychological and neurological interventions.
  • The concept of identity being solely reliant on memory is a philosop ...

Actionables

  • You can create a personal memory journal to track how your recollections change over time. Start by writing down a detailed account of a recent event or conversation as soon as possible after it occurs. Revisit and rewrite the memory after a week, a month, and then several months, noting any changes or shifts in your recollection. This exercise will help you understand the fluidity of your own memories and the factors that may influence them.
  • Develop a habit of questioning the source of your memories by asking yourself critical questions whenever you recall something significant. For example, when a memory comes to mind, especially one that shapes your beliefs or identity, pause to consider where it came from: Was it something you experienced firsthand, something you were told, or something you've pieced together from various sources? This practice can help you become more aware of potential distortions in your memories.
  • Engage in role-reversal ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Two new novels explore a world where technology has even greater access to our minds

Exploiting and Altering Memories With VR and Surveillance Technology

The unsettling potential of virtual reality (VR) and surveillance technology to manipulate and exploit memories is explored in different narrative contexts.

"Mechanics of Memory" Facility Uses Virtual Reality to Alter Memories

At Wilder Sanctuary, Hope undergoes VR treatments that make her question the veracity of her memories. The process involves recalling fragments of her life through the technology, but the information presented also casts doubt on what she’s been told.

Patients Use VR For Altered Memories

In "The Mechanics of Memory," Hope is a patient forced to wear a VR headset in a mental institution. The headset feeds her certain images that might not correspond with her actual experiences, which becomes evident as she gains more insight into her therapy.

Patient Revealed As Creator of Facility's VR System

Through the progression of VR therapy, clues start to surface that what Hope is experiencing may not be in line with reality. The narrative twist reveals that the creator of the facility's sophisticated VR system is, in fact, another patient at Wilder Sanctuary.

Surveillance Tech Controls Individuals' Experiences in "The Dream Hotel"

Laila Lalami's novel "The Dream Hotel" introduces a world where dreams are not private but are subject to surveillance.

Government Monitors Protagonist's Dreams Via Implant, Leading To ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Exploiting and Altering Memories With VR and Surveillance Technology

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • You can explore the impact of technology on your perception by keeping a dream journal to track any recurring themes or changes in your dreams after using electronic devices before bed. This could reveal if and how your tech usage influences your subconscious thoughts, similar to how the characters' dreams are monitored in "The Dream Hotel."
  • Start a conversation with friends or family about the ethical implications of memory manipulation by creating hypothetical scenarios where they have to choose whether to alter a memory for the betterment of their mental health. This activity can help you understand different perspectives on the morality of altering human experiences, akin to the VR treatments in the podcast narrative.
  • Engage in a self-re ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Two new novels explore a world where technology has even greater access to our minds

Implications of Surveillance State Accessing Dreams

"The Dream Hotel," a novel by Laila Lalami, explores a dystopian future where the government can access and monitor people’s dreams, raising critical questions about privacy and freedom.

"Dream Hotel" Depicts a Future With Government-Controlled Dream Monitoring

In this cautionary tale, the protagonist feels distant from the surveillance state at first but becomes deeply entangled as the plot unfolds.

Protagonist Fights to Preserve Freedom and Identity Under Invasive Surveillance

Sara Hussein, the protagonist, becomes a victim of the surveillance state after being detained because her dreams indicate she may commit a crime. This narrative thread exemplifies the struggle to maintain personal freedom and identity in the face of invasive surveillance. The story unfolds as her life unravels after an encounter with agents from the risk assessment administration, who check the implant that monitors her dreams.

"Dream Hotel" Author More Aware of Tech's Privacy Intrusion

Laila Lalami's work on "The Dream Hotel" has heightened her consciousness about the privacy intrusions of technology in our lives.

Reducing Reliance on Apps to Protect Autonomy

Lalami shares that she's been contemplating the role of technology for the past decade. Consequently, she is attempting to disconnect from as many apps as possible and reduce her online presence in order to reclaim a sense of autonomy and ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Implications of Surveillance State Accessing Dreams

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The concept of a government accessing dreams may be technologically implausible and could detract from addressing realistic privacy concerns in current surveillance technologies.
  • The narrative of being detained for pre-crime based on dreams could be criticized for potentially stigmatizing mental health issues or the content of dreams, which are not indicative of real-life behavior.
  • While reducing reliance on apps and technology can protect privacy, it could be argued that technology also offers benefits in safety, convenience, and connectivity that can enhance autonomy and quality of life.
  • The dichotomy between liberty and security presented in the novel may be oversimplified, as some would argue that a balance can be struck where both are preserved to a reasonable extent.
  • The effective ...

Actionables

  • You can start a digital detox challenge with friends to reduce reliance on technology and increase awareness of privacy issues. Create a set of rules for the challenge, such as no social media or non-essential app usage for a week, and discuss the experience and any changes in your perception of privacy and autonomy afterward.
  • Engage in creative writing exercises that explore themes of surveillance and freedom. Write short stories or journal entries from the perspective of a character living in a surveillance state, which can help you empathize with the implications of such a society and reflect on the value of privacy in your own life.
  • Implement privacy-protecting measures on your devices, like using search ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA