Authors of two new novels draw inspiration from history in wildly different ways
In this episode of NPR's Book of the Day podcast, two novelists share their approaches to historical fiction. Emma Donoghue discusses her research into an 1895 Paris train crash, which inspired her novel "The Paris Express." She describes the process of blending fact and fiction, meticulous research, and plausible invention to create authenticity in her storytelling.
Bob the Drag Queen presents a unique twist on the historical figure Harriet Tubman. His book "Harriet Tubman Live In Concert" reimagines Tubman as a rapper in the present day, using hip hop to share her revolutionary spirit with new audiences. The episode explores how writers can leverage surprising perspectives and unconventional formats to breathe new life into pivotal moments and individuals from history.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Apr 4, 2025 episode of the NPR's Book of the Day
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
Using Historical Events and Figures For Fiction
Historical events and figures inspire writers to craft compelling fiction. Authors find intriguing bits of history to serve as a springboard for their narrative imagination, as Emma Donoghue explains.
Emma Donoghue Inspired by 1895 Paris Train Crash Photo
Emma Donoghue stumbled upon a captivating 1895 photograph of a Paris train crash, which sparked the idea for her novel "The Paris Express." Donoghue explores themes of mortality and the implications of policies that prioritize speed over safety, leading to disasters.
Bob the Drag Queen Reimagines Harriet Tubman as a Rapper
In "Harriet Tubman Live In Concert," Bob the Drag Queen casts the historical figure Harriet Tubman as a rapper, blurring past and present. Bob believes Tubman would embrace modern music to continue her liberating work, allowing new audiences to connect with her revolutionary spirit.
Blending Fact and Fiction in Historical Novels
Donoghue undertakes meticulous historical research to ensure authenticity in her storytelling. For "The Paris Express," she explored records, newspapers, and photos to uncover details surrounding the 1895 train crash central to the novel's premise.
When records lack information, Donoghue takes "pleasure in inventing plausible scenarios" to fill the gaps, she says. She populates her novels with diverse characters reflective of the era, such as "Cambodian students, North African coffee sellers, expats, American painters, troublemakers, anarchists, lowlifes in Paris, inventors, writers, queers, and feminists."
Reimagining Historical Figures and Stories
Bob the Drag Queen merges Tubman's historical legacy with hip hop elements, as he explains: "Invoking Tubman's use of song in her abolitionist activities, Bob convincingly merges past and present by suggesting that if Tubman were here today, she would likely embrace modern music as a continuation of her work."
In the storyline, Bob performs verses blending Tubman's mission with a modern perspective, "projecting her as the original black superhero" but with "true historical virtue." Through hip hop's "universal language," Bob provides Tubman "the flowers she so profoundly deserves," captivating new audiences with her timeless impact.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- Historical accuracy can be compromised when authors take creative liberties, potentially misleading readers about real events and figures.
- The reimagining of historical figures in modern contexts, such as Harriet Tubman as a rapper, might be seen as anachronistic or disrespectful to the seriousness of their historical context.
- While historical fiction can bring attention to lesser-known events or figures, it can also overshadow the true complexity of historical narratives by focusing on dramatized or fictionalized aspects.
- The use of historical figures in fiction can sometimes lead to the oversimplification of their legacies, reducing complex individuals to single traits or roles.
- The blending of fact and fiction might confuse readers who are not well-versed in history, making it difficult for them to discern what is true and what is invented.
- The portrayal of diverse characters reflective of the era might not always be accurate or might perpetuate stereotypes if not handled with care and deep understanding of the historical context.
- The idea that a historical figure would embrace modern trends or technology can be seen as a projection of contemporary values onto the past, which might not align with the individual's true beliefs or intentions.
- The notion that hip hop or any modern art form is a "universal language" could be challenged on the grounds that not all audiences engage with or interpret art in the same way due to cultural and personal differences.
Actionables
- You can create a short story or piece of art by choosing an intriguing historical event and imagining a "what if" scenario. For example, if you're fascinated by the invention of the telephone, you might write a story exploring what would happen if the technology had fallen into the wrong hands during its inception. This encourages creative thinking and connects you to historical events in a personal way.
- Start a themed playlist that combines music from a historical period with modern genres that share similar themes or emotions. If you're moved by the Renaissance era, curate a playlist that transitions from classical compositions to contemporary songs that embody the spirit of rebirth and innovation. This can deepen your appreciation for both historical and modern music.
- Engage in a role-playing exercise where you take on the persona of a historical figure in today's world. Imagine you're Leonardo da Vinci attending a modern-day tech conference, or Cleopatra navigating the world of social media. Write down how these figures might react to current events or technologies, which can help you understand their perspectives and challenges in a modern context.
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Using Historical Events and Figures For Fiction
Historical events and figures provide a rich tapestry of inspiration for writers. This relationship between actual past events and the creative process can result in compelling and thought-provoking fiction.
Novelists Can Use History to Craft Compelling Fiction
Authors often find intriguing bits of history that serve as a springboard for their narrative imagination.
Author Emma Donoghue Was Inspired by an 1895 Photograph of a Paris Train Crash to Write "the Paris Express."
Emma Donoghue stumbled upon a captivating photograph from 1895, showing a steam locomotive that had crashed through a railroad terminal. This striking image served as the seed for her novel "The Paris Express." She delves into the event that inspired "The Paris Express," contemplating mortality and the wider implications of corporate policies—such as the insistence on speed to remain on schedule—that can lead to disasters.
Bob the Drag Queen Wrote "Harriet Tubman Live In Concert," a Story About Harriet Tub ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Using Historical Events and Figures For Fiction
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- Historical accuracy can be compromised when writers take too many creative liberties with real events and figures, potentially misleading readers.
- The use of historical figures in fiction can sometimes be seen as disrespectful or insensitive, especially if those figures are depicted in a way that contradicts their known beliefs and actions.
- There is a risk of anachronism when historical figures are placed in modern contexts, which can detract from the authenticity of the portrayal.
- The reinterpretation of historical events and figures might overshadow the real historical narratives and the lessons they hold.
- Some audiences may prefer historical fiction that adheres closely to the known facts and may not appreciate the blending of history with speculative or ...
Actionables
- Dive into your local history to spark a creative project by visiting your town's museum or historical society and jotting down intriguing facts or stories that you can weave into a short story, poem, or artwork.
- For example, if you discover an old map of your town with forgotten landmarks, you could create a fictional adventure where characters from the present uncover secrets from the past, using the landmarks as pivotal plot points.
- Transform a family heirloom or tradition into a modern narrative by writing a blog post, recording a podcast episode, or creating a video that reinterprets the significance of the heirloom or tradition in today's context.
- Suppose your family has an antique locket passed down through generations. You could create a fictional vlog series where the locket grants insights into ancestors' lives, connecting past wisdom to modern-day challenges.
- Use social media to blend historical and contemporary voices by creating a Twitter ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Blending Fact and Fiction in Historical Novels
Emma Donoghue Conducts Historical Research for Accurate Storytelling
Emma Donoghue undertakes meticulous research to ensure her historical storytelling is as authentic as possible.
Donoghue Explored Records, Newspapers, Photos to Reveal Events Behind "the Paris Express"
For her novel "The Paris Express," Donoghue delved into a variety of historical sources, including records, newspapers, and photographs. She sought to bring to light the events surrounding the train crash depicted in an 1895 photograph that is central to the narrative. Her extensive research ensures that the setting and events described in the novel are grounded in historical reality.
Filling Historical Gaps With Plausible Details
When it comes to the parts of history that the records don't cover, Donoghue takes pleasure in inventing plausible scenarios to fill these gaps. She believes in the importance of creating parts of her story that could have feasibly taken place even though they are not documented. This approach allows her to flesh out a more complete and vibrant picture of the past.
Donoghue creates a rich tapestry of characters to populate her novels, drawing from the di ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Blending Fact and Fiction in Historical Novels
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While meticulous research is commendable, it can sometimes lead to an overemphasis on historical detail at the expense of narrative flow and character development.
- The use of various historical sources is crucial, but it's important to acknowledge that sources can have biases or inaccuracies that may affect the portrayal of events.
- Filling historical gaps with plausible details is a creative approach, but it can blur the line between fact and fiction, potentially misleading readers about historical accuracy.
- Creating a diverse range of characters is important for inclusivity, but it must be done carefully to avo ...
Actionables
- You can start a personal project to write a short story incorporating historical accuracy by researching a specific event or era. Begin by choosing a historical event that intrigues you, then visit your local library or use online archives to gather information. As you learn, take notes on the small, vivid details that could bring your story to life, such as the fashion of the time or the colloquial language used. Use these details to create a backdrop for your characters, ensuring that the setting feels authentic.
- Create a character collage using images and descriptions from various time periods to inspire diverse character development. Look for portraits, fashion plates, or photographs from different cultures and social groups throughout history. Cut these out and arrange them on a large piece of paper or a digital canvas. Write down imagined backstories, professions, and personalities for these characters. This exercise can help you think outside your usual scope and develop a cast of characters as varied as those mentioned in the podcast.
- Engage in a creative writin ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Reimagining Historical Figures and Stories in Modern Ways
Bob the Drag Queen explores a creative fusion of Harriet Tubman's historical legacy with the contemporary beats of hip hop, presenting a fresh narrative that bridges past and present.
Bob the Drag Queen's "Harriet Tubman Live In Concert" Merges the Abolitionist's Work With Modern Hip Hop Elements
Bob the Drag Queen approaches Harriet Tubman's historical persona with a revolutionary twist: imagining the notable abolitionist as the front-runner of a hip hop album.
Tubman's Bravery, Leadership, and Drive For Freedom Are Reimagined For Today, Allowing Bob to Introduce Her Story Anew
In "Harriet Tubman Live in Concert," Bob the Drag Queen embraces Tubman's enduring principles of bravery, leadership, and the tireless quest for freedom. Bob intends to honor Tubman's legacy by imparting her tale to today's generation through a compelling and accessible musical format. With a strong belief in Tubman's place as perhaps the most remarkable individual to have ever lived, Bob credits her with supernatural foresight and unwavering success in guiding slaves to freedom via the Underground Railroad.
Tubman As Rapper: Her Revolutionary Spirit and Quest For Liberation Resonate Today
Bob's innovative rendition crafts Tubman's narrative within a hip hop context, drawing parallels between her revolutionary spirit and the genre's essence of liberation and resistance. Invoking Tubman's use of song in her abolitionist activities, Bob convinc ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Reimagining Historical Figures and Stories in Modern Ways
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- The fusion of historical figures with modern cultural elements can sometimes lead to historical inaccuracies or oversimplifications.
- Some may argue that reimagining historical figures in such a way could detract from the gravity of their struggles and achievements.
- There is a risk that the entertainment value of the performance might overshadow the educational aspect of Harriet Tubman's story.
- Critics might suggest that the portrayal of Tubman as a rapper could be seen as anachronistic and potentially disrespectful to the time period and context in which she lived.
- The comparison of Harriet Tubman to fictional superheroes like Spider-Man might be considered inappropriate by some, as it could trivialize her real-life heroism.
- While hip hop ...
Actionables
- Create a playlist that combines historical speeches with modern beats to explore the past through today's music. Start by selecting famous speeches or quotes from historical figures you admire. Use a simple audio editing app to overlay these speeches onto instrumental hip hop tracks. This can help you connect with historical narratives in a rhythm that resonates with the present.
- Write a short story or comic strip where a historical figure has a modern-day adventure. Imagine someone like Marie Curie or Leonardo da Vinci in today's world, using their unique skills to solve contemporary problems. This exercise can deepen your understanding of their contributions and challenges by placing them in a context you're familiar with.
- Host a themed dinner party where each dish is ins ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
