In NPR's Book of the Day podcast, "Unassimilable" by Bianca Mabute-Louie proposes a radical approach to Asian identity in America. Reflecting on her childhood in an Asian immigrant enclave, Mabute-Louie rejects the pressure to conform to whiteness. Instead, she encourages Asians to embrace "unassimilability" as a source of power, building identity and community among themselves rather than seeking validation from the dominant culture.
Mabute-Louie envisions solidarity transcending ethnic boundaries, fostered by shared experiences of marginalization. She advocates for a broader collective resistance against systemic oppression, rejecting narrow identity politics in favor of collective liberation for all oppressed groups. Her perspective challenges traditional notions of assimilation and belonging, offering a provocative framework for reimagining Asian identity in America.
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
Author Bianca Mabute-Louie reflects on growing up in San Gabriel Valley, an Asian immigrant enclave where her grandmother, who moved there in her 70s, thrived without assimilating or learning English - something that initially "horrified" the young Mabute-Louie. Despite being immersed in this Asian community, Mabute-Louie felt pressure to conform to whiteness and Western values.
Mabute-Louie proposes "unassimilability" as a source of power for Asian identity in America, separate from whiteness. She argues that Asians should build identity and community within themselves rather than seeking validation from the dominant culture.
According to Mabute-Louie, embracing unassimilability frees Asians from having to assimilate or justify their presence. She rejects the idea that respect depends on aligning with whiteness, suggesting Asians rethink who they want to belong to beyond state institutions.
Mabute-Louie envisions solidarity built not on ethnic identity, but on shared experiences of marginalization. She gives the example of joining political and mutual aid groups in the South based on a collective experience of oppression, not Asianness.
Feeling "unassimilable" can inspire broader solidarity with all facing systemic oppression, beyond the Asian diaspora. Mabute-Louie hopes her son finds belonging with the "oppressed masses" and rejects narrow identity politics in favor of collective liberation through resistance.
1-Page Summary
Bianca Mabute-Louie, an author who shares insights into her personal journey and reflections about the concept of assimilation, particularly in the context of growing up in an Asian immigrant community in the United States.
Describing the San Gabriel Valley as a haven for Asian immigrants where assimilation is not the norm, Mabute-Louie reflects on her own family's experiences. Her grandmother moved to the enclave in her 70s and managed to live vibrantly without having to learn English or assimilate into the mainstream culture.
As a child, Mabute-Louie admits she was initially horrified by her grandmother's resistance to assimilation. This was due to her own desire to blend in and be accepted by the broader society, which often meant adhering to the dominant cultural norms.
Despite being surrounded by her own A ...
Author's Experiences and Upbringing Related To Assimilation
Bianca Mabute-Louie articulates a powerful concept of "unassimilability" for Asian identity in America, framing it as a source of community and power that exists independently of whiteness.
Mabute-Louie emboldens the Asian American community to build identity and solidarity within itself rather than seeking validation from or proximity to whiteness.
"Unassimilability" takes a stand against dominant culture's expectations, proposing that the Asian community can and should define itself on its own terms. Mabute-Louie discusses how historically, efforts to assimilate have been tied to whiteness, often leading to harmful impacts such as the perpetuation of the model minority stereotype and the rise in anti-Asian hate crimes. She argues that by embracing unassimilability, Asians in America can find belonging and identity distinct from these pressures.
Embracing "unassimilability" allows Asian Americans to exist autonomous of the need to assimilate and justify their pr ...
Central Argument for "Unassimilability" and Its Implications
The author of "Unassimilable," Bianca Mabute-Louie, casts a vision for solidarity that transcends assimilation and focuses on community building with those oppressed by systemic structures.
Mabute-Louie discusses the idea of building communities not defined by state institutions or norms, but by shared experiences of marginalization.
She gives a concrete example of how this plays out by mentioning her involvement in political and mutual aid organizations in the South. These groups come together in the aftermath of events like hurricanes. The focus is not on whether participants share an Asian identity but on their shared experience of marginalization.
Mabute-Louie introduces the concept that feeling "unassimilable" can inspire broader solidarity with those subjected to systemic oppression, far exceeding the confines of Asianness or any narrow ethnic identity.
The author embeds her philosophy into the names of her son, Kapwa and Ga-in, which reflect in ...
Author's Views on Community and Solidarity Beyond Assimilation
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser