Podcasts > NPR's Book of the Day > Alizah Holstein writes about the complex echelons of academia in 'My Roman History'

Alizah Holstein writes about the complex echelons of academia in 'My Roman History'

By NPR (podcasts@npr.org)

In this episode about Alizah Holstein's book "My Roman History," NPR's Book of the Day explores Holstein's lifelong fascination with Rome, sparked by Dante's writings as a teenager. Holstein recounts her immediate sense of belonging during her first visit to the city and her enduring creative connection to it, even after leaving academia.

The episode also delves into the challenges faced by women in academia, such as the lack of mentorship across generations and the complications personal relationships can pose for career advancement. Additionally, it touches on Holstein's journey of pursuing her true calling as a writer, a childhood dream she rediscovered after her unconventional path through academia and entrepreneurship.

Listen to the original

Alizah Holstein writes about the complex echelons of academia in 'My Roman History'

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Dec 18, 2024 episode of the NPR's Book of the Day

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Alizah Holstein writes about the complex echelons of academia in 'My Roman History'

1-Page Summary

Holstein's Lifelong Fascination with Rome

A Teenage Passion Sparked by Dante

As a teenager, Alizah Holstein became captivated by the symbols and historical figures in Dante's writings, particularly the "Divine Comedy." This inspired her to learn Italian and develop a deep curiosity about medieval Italy and Rome, despite Dante hailing from Florence.

An Immediate Sense of Belonging

At age 18, Holstein experienced a profound feeling of belonging when she first visited Rome, describing it as a "place where I felt at home." Continued research visits only strengthened this bond with the city's living history.

An Enduring Creative Connection

Even after leaving academia, Holstein's emotional ties to Rome persevered. While she associates Rome with her family's Italian roots, the city itself continues to inspire her scholarly and creative pursuits.

Challenges for Women in Academia

Lack of Mentorship Across Generations

Holstein realized too late the importance of mentorship in her academic career. Comparing her journey to that of Caroline Bynum, a former professor, Holstein found striking similarities in the lack of guidance faced by women across generations.

Personal Relationships Complicating Advancement

A brief relationship with an older professor had lasting impacts on Holstein's academic progress. After their breakup, he claimed victimhood despite the power imbalance, leaving Holstein without proper advisement and narrowing her opportunities, as Bynum describes.

Pursuing Her True Calling as a Writer

A Childhood Dream Rediscovered

Despite pursuing an academic path, Holstein realized her lifelong dream was to be a writer—a passion that dates back to age 9. Her "failure" to secure a tenured position was an opportunity to embrace this calling.

An Unconventional Journey

After leaving academia, Holstein founded a successful children's clothing company—an endeavor seemingly at odds with writing. Yet she views this period as a necessary step towards her true vocation, enabled by her academic experience.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Alizah Holstein's fascination with Rome was sparked by Dante's "Divine Comedy," where she found inspiration in the symbols and historical figures depicted in the work. This led her to learn Italian and develop a deep curiosity about medieval Italy and Rome, despite Dante being from Florence. The themes and imagery in Dante's writings resonated with Holstein, igniting her passion for the city and its rich history. The "Divine Comedy" served as a gateway for Holstein to explore Rome's cultural and historical significance, shaping her lifelong connection to the city.
  • Holstein's relationship with an older professor had lasting impacts on her academic progress due to the power imbalance and lack of proper advisement after their breakup. This situation complicated her advancement in academia, narrowing her opportunities and affecting her scholarly pursuits.
  • Holstein's founding of a children's clothing company may seem unrelated to her writing aspirations. However, this venture provided her with valuable entrepreneurial skills and insights. This experience complemented her creative pursuits and ultimately contributed to her journey towards embracing writing as her true calling.

Counterarguments

  • Holstein's sense of belonging in Rome might be romanticized or influenced by her prior exposure to Italian culture and literature, rather than an innate connection to the city.
  • The challenges faced by women in academia, while significant, may not be universal and can vary depending on the institution, field of study, and individual circumstances.
  • The lack of mentorship in academia could be a broader issue affecting both men and women, although it may manifest differently due to gender dynamics.
  • Personal relationships complicating advancement in academia is not exclusive to women, though the power dynamics may often disadvantage women more severely.
  • Holstein's transition from academia to writing and entrepreneurship could be seen not as a failure but as a reflection of the evolving nature of career paths and personal growth.
  • The success of Holstein's children's clothing company might be due to a combination of factors, including skills and knowledge gained outside of her academic experience, such as business acumen or market understanding.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Alizah Holstein writes about the complex echelons of academia in 'My Roman History'

Holstein's lifelong fascination with and connection to Rome

Alizah Holstein's enduring connection to Rome is a tale that spans decades, filled with academic exploration, personal discovery, and deep emotional ties to the ancient city.

Holstein's early love for Rome, sparked by Dante's Divine Comedy and a high school English teacher

Holstein's journey to Rome began in her teenage years, ignited by Dante's "Divine Comedy" and its rich tapestry of symbols and historical references. Compelled to delve deeper, she learned Italian to gain a better grasp of Dante's masterpiece and the figures within it. Despite Dante hailing from Florence, his work became Holstein's gateway to medieval Italy and Rome.

As a teenager, Holstein became captivated by the symbols and historical figures in Dante's writings, which led her to start studying Italian and develop a deep curiosity about Rome and its history.

Her early fascination with the literary depictions of Rome set her on a path of curiosity and study that would define much of her life.

Holstein's transformative experiences visiting Rome as a young adult

At the age of 18, Holstein's first encounter with Rome was momentous, sparking a profound feeling of belonging. She describes how the city immediately felt like home to her—a place that resonated with her on a deep and personal level.

Holstein felt a profound sense of belonging and wonder when she first visited Rome at age 18, describing it as a "place where I felt at home."

Continued visits for research only strengthened her bond, allowing her to immerse herself further into Rome's storied past. The city's history remains alive in its streets, a testament to the enduring human narrative that Holstein feels an inexorable part of.

Holstein's lasting emotional and creative ties to Rome

Even outside ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Holstein's lifelong fascination with and connection to Rome

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • Explore your own city as if you're a tourist to develop a deeper connection with your surroundings. Start by visiting landmarks, museums, and historical sites you've never been to before. Take guided tours to learn the stories behind these places. Document your experiences through photos or a journal to reflect on the emotional responses these places evoke in you.
  • Create a personal project inspired by a work of literature that resonates with you. If a particular book or poem has made an impact on you, use it as a springboard for a creative endeavor. This could be writing your own stories or poems, starting a themed blog, or even creating artwork. The key is to let the themes and emotions of the literature guide your project, helping you explore your interests more deeply.
  • Plan a 'staycation' themed around a city or culture you're ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Alizah Holstein writes about the complex echelons of academia in 'My Roman History'

Challenges and obstacles faced by women in academia

The journey of women in academia is often marked by struggles, as explored through the experiences of Holstein and her interactions with Caroline Bynum, her former professor, highlighting the persistent challenges in mentorship and personal relationships that can impact academic careers.

Lack of mentorship and support for women in academia

Holstein realized the profound impact of mentorship too late in her career. Initially believing the quality of her work would ensure success, she later understood that guidance was crucial, especially in the male-dominated field of academia.

Consistent lack of guidance across generations

Her experience reflects a broader issue where many other women in academia resonate with her story, facing similar structural obstacles. Holstein and Bynum, comparing their academic journeys, found startling similarities between conditions faced by Holstein in the 1990s and early 2000s and those Bynum experienced in the 1960s. These ongoing conversations underscore the persistence of these structural obstacles.

The impact of personal relationships on women's academic careers

Holstein's academic progress was further complicated by her personal relationships, particularly with a prominent, older professor while at Cornell.

Personal relationships complicating professional advanceme ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Challenges and obstacles faced by women in academia

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While mentorship is important, individual effort and merit also play significant roles in academic success.
  • Some women in academia have reported positive mentorship experiences, suggesting that the lack of mentorship is not universal.
  • Structural obstacles may be diminishing over time due to increased awareness and institutional efforts to promote gender equality.
  • Personal relationships can complicate careers for individuals of any gender, not exclusively women.
  • The dynamics of personal relationships in academia are complex and can vary widely; not all relationships result in negative professional consequences.
  • Power dynamics in academia are an issue for all junior scholars, regardless of gender, though they may manifest differently.
  • The challenges faced by ...

Actionables

  • Create a peer mentorship group to foster support among women in academia by connecting with colleagues at your institution or through academic social networks like ResearchGate or Academia.edu. Start by reaching out to individuals who share similar research interests or career stages and propose regular virtual meet-ups to discuss challenges, share resources, and offer mutual guidance.
  • Develop a personal advisory board composed of professionals from various fields and backgrounds by contacting potential mentors through LinkedIn or professional organizations. Aim for diversity in expertise and experience to gain a broad perspective on career development and to mitigate the impact of any single relationship on your academic trajectory.
  • Advocate for transparent mentorship programs within your academi ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Alizah Holstein writes about the complex echelons of academia in 'My Roman History'

Holstein's decision to leave academia and become a writer

Alizah Holstein made a profound shift in her professional life by leaving a budding career in academia to embrace her long-standing aspiration to be a writer, a dream that can be traced back to her earliest memories.

Holstein's realization that she had always been a writer at heart

Holstein reflects on her childhood passion for writing. Despite spending her academic career with the end goal of becoming a historian of medieval Rome, she realized that her true calling was that of a writer, which had been a dream of hers since she was nine years old. Her "failure" to secure a tenured position in academia, she realized, was actually an opportunity that redirected her to her true passion—writing.

Holstein's transition to a new career path

After her departure from academia, Holstein did not immediately jump into writing. Instead, she founded a successful children's clothing company—an endeavor that seemed at odds with both academia and her dream of writing. Hol ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Holstein's decision to leave academia and become a writer

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • Holstein's decision to leave academia might not be solely due to her passion for writing; other factors such as job market conditions or personal circumstances could have influenced her decision.
  • The narrative that her failure to secure a tenured position was an opportunity might be an example of post-rationalization, where one reinterprets less favorable outcomes as beneficial after the fact.
  • Founding a successful children's clothing company could be seen as a significant career in its own right, not just a stepping stone to writing.
  • The skills and experiences gained in academia might not directly contribute to her writing career, and the connection between the two could be overstated.
  • The idea that her time in academia was not a failure but a pivotal experience could be challenged by considering alternative paths she might have taken that could have led to a successful writing career without the detou ...

Actionables

  • You can explore your childhood interests by creating a vision board with images and quotes that reflect your early passions, helping you visualize a path to integrate them into your current life.
    • Start by gathering magazines, printouts, or drawings that resonate with your childhood dreams. Place them on a board in a way that inspires you. This visual representation can serve as a daily reminder and motivation to pursue those interests in small, manageable steps, such as enrolling in a local writing workshop if you've always loved storytelling.
  • Identify a skill or hobby that complements your main passion and start a small project or side business around it to gain experience and confidence.
    • For example, if you're passionate about writing but also enjoy crafting, consider starting an Etsy shop selling handmade bookmarks or journals. This allows you to engage with a community that values creativity, build entrepreneurial skills, and potentially fund your writing endeavors.
  • Reflect on your current or past professional experiences to find skills that can b ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA