Podcasts > NPR's Book of the Day > Bonnie Kistler's new thriller explores ageism from the lens of a murder

Bonnie Kistler's new thriller explores ageism from the lens of a murder

By NPR (podcasts@npr.org)

In NPR's Book of the Day podcast, host Paul Tran discusses Bonnie Kistler's new thriller "Shell Games." The novel centers on Kate, a 70-year-old real estate mogul, who believes her husband Charlie confessed to being the Tylenol murderer. However, Kate's credibility is undermined when her claims are dismissed as signs of dementia—a situation exploring the concept of "gaslighting" and societal ageism.

As Kate's daughter Julie grapples with whether to believe her mother or stepfather, the novel delves into the complex dynamics of the mother-daughter relationship. Kistler draws inspiration from her own surreal dream to explore themes of psychological manipulation and the tendency to undermine the credibility of older adults, making for a gripping, thought-provoking read.

Listen to the original

Bonnie Kistler's new thriller explores ageism from the lens of a murder

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Nov 25, 2024 episode of the NPR's Book of the Day

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Bonnie Kistler's new thriller explores ageism from the lens of a murder

1-Page Summary

The Plot of "Shell Games"

"Shell Games" centers on Kate, a 70-year-old real estate developer, who believes her new husband Charlie confessed to being the Tylenol murderer. However, when Kate tries to report this to the police, Charlie denies the confession and her son-in-law claims Kate is suffering from dementia, leading to her daughter Julie's struggle to decide whether to believe her mother or stepfather.

Psychological Manipulation and Ageism

The novel explores the concept of "gaslighting"—psychological manipulation where an individual's claims are dismissed due to their age. When Kate attempts to report Charlie's alleged confession, her credibility is undermined by accusations of dementia, a situation inspired by author Bonnie Kistler's own surreal dream about a husband's confession and subsequent denial.

The Protagonist Kate

A self-made billionaire real estate mogul and political force in Florida, Kate has raised her daughter Julie in the shadow of her formidable success and reputation, resulting in a complex mother-daughter relationship. Despite her achievements, Kate faces the uphill battle of being believed due to societal tendencies to dismiss the concerns of older adults.

Kistler's Writing Process

Departing from her usual realism-based approach, Kistler was inspired by a personal dream to write "Shell Games" and explore issues of gaslighting and ageism through crime fiction. The novel delves into how forgetfulness in the elderly is too often ascribed to dementia or Alzheimer's, eroding their credibility.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The portrayal of Kate's son-in-law as someone who quickly jumps to the conclusion of dementia could be seen as a one-dimensional representation of how family members respond to concerns raised by older adults.
  • The struggle of Julie to decide whether to believe her mother or stepfather might oversimplify the complex dynamics and emotional turmoil involved in such family situations.
  • While the novel aims to address ageism and gaslighting, it could inadvertently reinforce stereotypes about the elderly and dementia if not handled with nuance.
  • The concept of a self-made billionaire protagonist might not resonate with all readers, as it represents a very small, elite portion of the population, potentially limiting the relatability of the character.
  • The use of a dream as inspiration for a novel's plot might be criticized for lacking in the rigorous character and plot development that some readers expect from realism-based crime fiction.
  • The novel's exploration of gaslighting and ageism through the lens of crime fiction could be seen as trivializing these serious issues if the genre's conventions overshadow the novel's thematic intentions.
  • The idea that society dismisses the concerns of older adults could be challenged by pointing out the growing awareness and advocacy for the rights and dignity of the elderly.
  • The assertion that forgetfulness in the elderly is too often ascribed to dementia might be contested by medical professionals who emphasize the importance of early diagnosis and intervention for cognitive impairments.

Actionables

  • You can start a book club focused on novels that tackle social issues to foster discussions on topics like ageism and gaslighting. By selecting books that explore these themes, you and your group can gain a deeper understanding of the experiences of older adults and the impact of gaslighting. This can lead to increased empathy and awareness in your personal and professional interactions.
  • Create a personal journal where you document instances where you feel your voice isn't heard or when you witness others being marginalized. This reflective practice can help you identify patterns and situations where ageism or gaslighting may be occurring, allowing you to develop strategies to address and counteract these behaviors in your daily life.
  • Volunteer with organizations that support the elderly, such as senior centers or legal aid services, to directly engage with older adults and advocate for their concerns. Through volunteering, you can help amplify the voices of older individuals, ensuring their stories and experiences are acknowledged and respected, countering the societal tendency to dismiss their concerns.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Bonnie Kistler's new thriller explores ageism from the lens of a murder

The plot and premise of the novel "Shell Games"

"Shell Games" is a gripping thriller centered around the suspicions of a 70-year-old real estate developer named Kate.

The story centers around a 70-year-old real estate developer named Kate who believes her new husband Charlie confessed to being the notorious Tylenol murderer, but Charlie later denies making any such confession.

On their wedding night, Charlie brings up the Tylenol murders and seemingly confesses to the crime. However, when Kate is sober and attempts to take this information to the police, Charlie rebuffs the accusation, claiming she hallucinated the entire ordeal. With no one to corroborate her story, and the police reporting Charlie has an alibi, she faces an uphill battle to be believed.

When Kate tries to report Charlie's alleged confession to the police, her son-in-law claims she is suffering from dementia, leading to a dilemma where Kate's daughter Julie must decide whether her stepfather is a criminal or if her mother is truly losing her mind.

Kate's predicament is further complicated by accusations of dementia from her son-in-law, effectively gaslighting her and contributing to a growing sense of isolation and helplessness. Caught in the crossfire is Kate’s daughter Julie, who is placed in the impossible situation of discerning whether her new stepfather Charlie is a criminal mastermind or if her mother, Kate, is the one suffering from a decline in her mental faculties.

The novel explores the concept of "gaslighting" and the psychological manipulation that can occur when someone's claims are dismissed due to their age.

Inspired by the author Bonnie Kistler's own surreal dream, the novel takes a de ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The plot and premise of the novel "Shell Games"

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • You can start a journal to document your daily experiences and interactions, which can serve as a personal record to reference if your memory is ever questioned. By keeping a detailed account, you create a tangible way to affirm your experiences and can provide evidence to support your recollections, especially in situations where your credibility might be challenged.
  • Engage in role-playing exercises with friends or family to practice recognizing and responding to gaslighting behaviors. This can help you develop the skills to maintain your perspective and assert your reality when faced with psychological manipulation. For example, have a friend act out scenarios where they deny a shared experience or question your memory, and practice how you would respond to affirm your truth.
  • Create a " ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Bonnie Kistler's new thriller explores ageism from the lens of a murder

The protagonist's character and background

Kate is a self-made billionaire real estate developer in her 70s who has built a successful career and become a powerful figure in Florida politics.

Kate, a self-made billionaire in her 70s, has carved out a formidable reputation as a real estate developer along the coastal regions of Florida. Known as a force of nature, she has not only built a towering career in the competitive realm of property development but has also emerged as an influential figure within the political landscape of Florida. Her success story, marked by sheer determination and acute business acumen, makes her an iconic and respected figure in the realms of both commerce and governance.

Despite her impressive accomplishments, Kate has raised her daughter Julie in her own formidable shadow, leading to a complex mother-daughter dynamic.

Despite her vast accomplishments and the respect she commands, Kate's relationship with her dau ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The protagonist's character and background

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While Kate is a self-made billionaire, it's important to consider the broader social and economic factors that may have contributed to her success, such as market conditions, timing, and possibly existing networks or resources.
  • Success in real estate development often involves complex negotiations and dealings, which may raise questions about ethical practices and the impact of such developments on local communities and environments.
  • Being a powerful figure in politics can sometimes lead to conflicts of interest, especially when one's business interests may intersect with public policy decisions.
  • The term "force of nature" can be seen as glorifying aggressive business tactics that may not always be socially responsible or sustainable.
  • Influence in politics suggests a level of power that could be used to sway decisions in one's favor, which might not always align with the public good.
  • Respect in commerce and governance does not necessarily equate to ethical or fair practices; it could simply reflect success in terms of wealth accumulation and political maneuvering.
  • The complex relationship with her daughter could be indicative of potential neglect or prioritization of career over family, which so ...

Actionables

  • Reflect on your own family dynamics to better understand personal and professional influences by writing a journal entry about how your family has shaped your ambitions and work ethic. This can help you identify patterns or traits you may have inherited and how they affect your career choices, similar to how Julie navigates Kate's legacy.
  • Develop a personal brand that reflects your unique strengths by creating a list of your top five personal and professional qualities and finding ways to showcase them on social media or in networking opportunities. This mirrors Kate's formidable reputation and can help you establish a strong presence in your field of interest.
  • Engage in local politics or community ini ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Bonnie Kistler's new thriller explores ageism from the lens of a murder

The author's inspiration and writing process

Author Bonnie Kistler shares insights into the unique inception of her latest novel and how a dream led her to explore complex societal issues within the scope of her fiction.

Bonnie Kistler's Dream-Based Inspiration

Bonnie Kistler, a former lawyer with a penchant for realism in her writing, found the inspiration for her novel "Shell Games" in a rather unusual way. Contrary to her typical approach grounded in real-world experiences, the story's premise came to her in a vivid dream. This marked a significant departure for Kistler, who generally leans towards a more realistic mode of fiction writing.

Exploring Gaslighting and Ageism in Crime Fiction

In her dream, Kistler was struck by a certain "gaslighting" scenario. Finding this element of psychological manipulation captivating, she decided to take this kernel of an i ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The author's inspiration and writing process

Additional Materials

Actionables

- Explore your dreams for creative inspiration by keeping a dream journal next to your bed and jotting down any vivid dreams upon waking; these could become the seeds for your own stories, art projects, or personal reflections on themes like gaslighting or ageism.

  • Educate yourself on gaslighting and ageism by reading articles, watching documentaries, and then writing a short story or essay that incorporates these themes, helping you to understand and articulate the complexities of these issues.
  • ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Bonnie Kistler's new thriller explores ageism from the lens of a murder

The theme of ageism and how it affects the novel's story

In "Shell Games," readers are drawn into protagonist Kate's fight against ageism, a battle that is at the heart of the novel’s narrative.

The novel examines how society's tendency to dismiss the concerns of older individuals

"Shell Games" scrutinizes society’s inclination to quickly dismiss the worries of the elderly as symptoms of cognitive diseases like dementia or Alzheimer's. This can unjustly erode their credibility and disregards their legitimate assertions.

Kate's son-in-law's quick dismissal of her allegations against Charlie

Kate’s struggle showcases the challenges faced by older individuals. When she tries to report a murder confession by her husband Charlie, her claims are not taken seriously. Her son-in-law is hasty in attributing her accusations to supposed mental decline. This reveals how ageism serves as a tool to discredit the elderly – an injustice particularly stark when the discredited are as capable as Kate.

K ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The theme of ageism and how it affects the novel's story

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While "Shell Games" portrays ageism as a central theme, it's possible that the novel also inadvertently reinforces stereotypes by focusing on a protagonist who is battling against the perception of cognitive decline.
  • The narrative might be seen as a single story among many, and while it highlights an important issue, it may not represent the diverse experiences of all older individuals.
  • The son-in-law's dismissal of Kate's allegations could be interpreted as a complex character flaw rather than a straightforward example of societal ageism, suggesting that individual relationships and personalities also play a significant role in the story.
  • The novel's focus on ageism might overshadow other equally important themes or social issues that are present in the lives of older adults, such as economic challenges, healthcare access, or social isolation.
  • The portrayal of forgetfulness in older adults as a sign of cognitive disease might be challenged by the argument that forgetfulness is a normal part of aging and not always indicative of a medical condition.
  • The book's depiction of ageism could be critiqued for potentially lacking nuance or failing to acknowledge instances where concerns about an ol ...

Actionables

  • You can start a conversation with an older family member or friend about their experiences and actively listen without making assumptions about their mental state. By doing this, you're acknowledging their credibility and giving them space to share their thoughts without the filter of ageist preconceptions. For example, if an elderly relative expresses concern about a financial matter, instead of brushing it off, engage with them to understand their perspective and offer support in finding solutions.
  • Create a personal rule to challenge your own thoughts whenever you find yourself attributing an older person's behavior to age-related decline. Each time you catch yourself thinking this way, pause and consider alternative explanations that aren't age-related. For instance, if an older colleague forgets a meeting, instead of assuming it's due to their age, consider that they might be juggling multiple tasks or facing the same distractions that affect people of all ages.
  • Volunteer to ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA