'What If We Get It Right?' envisions new possibilities for our climate future
In NPR's Book of the Day, author Ayanna Elizabeth Johnson challenges the prevalent apocalyptic rhetoric around climate change and champions a solutions-oriented mindset. Her book, "What If We Get It Right?", envisions a world of abundant possibilities if we take proactive steps to nurture a sustainable future.
Drawing inspiration from the resilience of West African grandmothers during the transatlantic slave trade, Johnson urges us to reject despair in the face of adversities. She advocates strategically utilizing existing economic systems to incentivize climate-friendly technologies—harnessing the profitability of renewable energy to drive widespread adoption. Through reframing the narrative and embracing viable solutions, Johnson instills hope and inspires collective action in tackling this global challenge.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Sep 26, 2024 episode of the NPR's Book of the Day
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
The power of hope and faith in the future
Ayanna Elizabeth Johnson emphasizes how even in bleak circumstances like the transatlantic slave trade, West African grandmothers braided seeds into their descendants' hair - an act symbolizing hope and nurturing future growth. Johnson implores maintaining this spirit, refusing a "doomer quitter mentality" towards climate change, and instead fostering seeds of solutions to actively cultivate a sustainable future.
The role of economic systems and markets
While overhauling capitalism may not be immediately feasible, Johnson advocates leveraging current economic systems to incentivize climate-friendly technologies through steps like promoting profitable renewable energy. She cites how economic interests aligning with sustainability goals, like wind power's job creation in conservative states, drives green adoption irrespective of politics.
Shapiro and Johnson emphasize reframing climate action's narrative around viability and opportunity rather than just doom. Highlighting renewable energy's economic appeal, they suggest, can significantly impact diverse groups' perceptions and foster broader climate solution acceptance.
Changing the narrative around climate change
In "What If We Get It Right?", Johnson aims to shift the prevalent apocalyptic climate change rhetoric to one showcasing viable solutions through examples of individuals and communities already taking effective action.
Rather than instilling helplessness, Johnson rejects the "sad face" and "quitter mentality", ushering a proactive, solutions-oriented mindset where people join the "winning team" implementing practical climate steps. Her framing moves beyond hypotheticals to indicate real, achievable progress happening now.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While hope and faith are important, they must be coupled with concrete policy actions and systemic changes to address the root causes of climate change effectively.
- Leveraging current economic systems may not be sufficient to achieve the necessary scale of transformation required for sustainability, as these systems often prioritize short-term gains over long-term environmental health.
- Economic incentives for renewable energy are beneficial, but they may not be enough to overcome entrenched interests of fossil fuel industries without stronger regulatory frameworks.
- The narrative of climate action as an opportunity can be compelling, but it might also downplay the urgency and severity of the crisis, potentially leading to complacency.
- Highlighting the economic appeal of renewable energy is important, but it should not overshadow the need for equity and justice in climate policies, ensuring that the benefits of green technologies are accessible to all, including marginalized communities.
- Shifting the narrative to focus on viable solutions is positive, but it is also important to acknowledge and address the legitimate fears and concerns that people have about climate change impacts.
- The concept of joining a "winning team" for climate action may inadvertently create an "us versus them" dynamic, which could hinder collaborative efforts across different groups and stakeholders.
- Emphasizing real and achievable progress is valuable, but it is also critical to recognize the scale of the challenge ahead and the possibility that current efforts may still fall short without increased global cooperation and commitment.
Actionables
- You can start a "Hope for the Planet" journal where you document positive environmental news and personal steps you're taking to live sustainably, reinforcing a solutions-oriented mindset.
- Keeping a journal like this serves as a personal reminder that progress is being made and that your actions contribute to a larger movement. For example, you might write about a local business that has started using biodegradable packaging or your decision to start composting at home.
- Create a "Green Influence" book club with friends or family to read and discuss books that showcase successful sustainability stories and climate solutions.
- This encourages a collective focus on positive narratives and practical solutions. You could start with books like "Drawdown" by Paul Hawken, which outlines 100 substantive solutions to reverse global warming, and then meet monthly to discuss the ideas and how you might implement them in your own lives.
- Develop a habit of supporting businesses and products that align with sustainability goals, such as purchasing from companies that use renewable energy or offer climate-friendly products.
- This consumer behavior reinforces the economic appeal of green initiatives. For instance, you might choose to buy from a clothing brand that uses organic materials and renewable energy in their manufacturing process, or switch to a bank that invests in clean energy projects.
Get access to the context and additional materials
The power of hope and faith in the future despite the challenges of climate change
Ayanna Elizabeth Johnson speaks to the resilience of the human spirit, emphasizing how hope and determination can persist even in the face of great adversity.
Adversity and hardship can inspire a resilient spirit of hope and determination
Ayanna Elizabeth Johnson discusses how, during the transatlantic slave trade, West African grandmothers braided seeds into the hair of those who were about to be forced across the Middle Passage. This act of love and foresight allowed enslaved Africans to carry hope and the potential for new growth into an unimaginably challenging and grim future. This anecdote illustrates that even in the bleakest of circumstances, a steadfast belief in a better future can be maintained through practical and symbolic steps to preserve life and possibility for generations to come.
Maintaining hope and a commitment to the future is essential for addressing climate change
Johnson implores us not to succumb to what she terms the "doomer quitter mentality" in the face of climate change. She questions what it would mean to act as if we deeply loved the future, urging an unwavering refusal to give up on our communities and the planet, even when the challenges become daunting. ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
The power of hope and faith in the future despite the challenges of climate change
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While resilience is important, it is also necessary to acknowledge that not everyone has the same capacity for hope and determination in the face of adversity, and this can be due to a variety of factors including mental health, socio-economic status, and past traumas.
- The inspiration that comes from adversity and hardship is not universal; some individuals or communities may feel overwhelmed or defeated by challenges rather than inspired.
- The act of braiding seeds into hair as a symbol of hope may not resonate with everyone, and some may argue that it romanticizes a deeply traumatic experience.
- There is a risk that emphasizing hope and a steadfast belief in a better future could lead to complacency or inaction, with the assumption that positive outcomes will occur without sufficient effort.
- The concept of avoiding a "doomer quitter mentality" might inadvertently dismiss or invalidate the legitimate concerns and emotional responses of those who are deeply worried about the future in the face of overwhelming evidence about climate change.
- The idea of acting as if we deeply loved the future could be seen as too abstract or vague to motivate concrete action or policy change.
- The metaphor of bringing "the seeds" might oversimplify the complex and multifaceted nature of climate change solutions.
- While ...
Actionables
- You can start a personal "hope journal" where you document daily actions you've taken toward sustainability, no matter how small. This could be as simple as choosing to walk instead of drive, buying a product with less packaging, or even starting a conversation about climate change with a friend. The act of writing these down reinforces your commitment and belief in a better future, serving as a personal record of resilience and action.
- Create a "future garden" by planting native species in your yard or community space that are known to be beneficial for the local ecosystem. This hands-on activity connects you to the earth and serves as a living symbol of your investment in the future. As the garden grows, it becomes a visual representation of hope and the potential for positive change that you are nurturing.
- Develop a "sustainability swap" habit, where you commit to replacing o ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
The role of economic systems and markets in addressing climate change
The discussion between Shapiro and Ayana Elizabeth Johnson delves into whether capitalism aids or impedes progress on climate change, exploring ways to harness economic systems for environmental benefit.
Capitalism and profit motives can be leveraged to drive climate solutions, even if capitalism is not the entire solution
Utilizing Current Economic Systems for Climate Action
While Ayana Elizabeth Johnson acknowledges that completely unraveling capitalism might be impractical in the near term, she advocates for working within the existing framework to promote climate-friendly technologies and practices. This approach includes practical steps to incentivize and profit from sustainable solutions.
Economic Alignments with Environmental Goals
Aligning economic interests with ecological sustainability proves key. Johnson cites how renewable energy, particularly wind power, is making headway in conservative states like Iowa and Texas. Profitability and job creation in the wind sector is occurring irrespective of political beliefs, exemplifying how economic incentives can drive green technology adoption.
Changing the narrative around climate change to focus on opportunity and feasibility, rather than just doom and gloom
Fostering a Positive and Opportunistic Outlook
Shapiro and Johnson emphasize the importance of reshaping the climate change narrative to spotlight the economic and practical viability of ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
The role of economic systems and markets in addressing climate change
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- Capitalism may inherently prioritize short-term profits over long-term sustainability, potentially undermining climate solutions.
- The existing framework of capitalism might have structural issues that inherently discourage the kind of rapid and large-scale changes needed to address climate change effectively.
- Incentives for sustainable solutions may not be sufficient to overcome the entrenched interests of fossil fuel industries without significant regulatory changes.
- Aligning economic interests with ecological sustainability assumes that market forces will adequately value environmental goods, which historically has not always been the case.
- The success of renewable energy in certain states may not be easily replicable everywhere due to geographical, political, or economic differences.
- Job creation in the green sector might not fully compensate for job losses in traditional energy sectors, leading to economic dislocation and resistance to change.
- Economic incentives alone may not be enough to drive green technology adoption at the speed and scale necessary to meet climate targets.
- Focusing o ...
Actionables
- You can start a blog or social media page focused on profiling local businesses that are adopting green technologies, to showcase how sustainability is profitable and practical. By interviewing business owners and sharing their stories, you'll highlight the economic benefits of climate action and inspire others to follow suit.
- Consider switching to a green energy provider for your home or advocating for your workplace to do the same, emphasizing the potential cost savings and environmental impact. This personal action serves as a microcosm of the larger economic shift towards sustainability and can influence others in your network to make similar changes.
- Create a simple on ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Changing the narrative around climate change and "getting it right"
Ayanna Elizabeth Johnson's book, "What If We Get It Right?", embodies an effort to alter the prevalent conversation around climate change into one that showcases the viable solutions we have at our disposal, steering clear of the defeatist doomsday rhetoric.
Shifting from a "doomer" mentality to a proactive, solutions-oriented mindset
Ayanna Elizabeth Johnson emphasizes the importance of leaving behind the old narrative that predicts a climate apocalypse and instills a sense of helplessness. Instead, Johnson champions a transition toward believing that progress is achievable through the implementation of existent climate change solutions.
The old narrative of climate apocalypse and a sense of helplessness must be replaced with a belief that we can and will make progress through implementation of available solutions.
Johnson’s approach is not just about rejecting the doomer mentality but about providing a fresh narrative that asks, "What if we get it right?" This question suggests a new perspective that underscores the viability and effectiveness of available solutions to combat climate change.
Rejecting the "sad face" and "quitter mentality" in favor of a determination to take practical steps and join the "winning team" of climate action.
Johnson's narrative encourages a shift from despondency to an empowered, mobilized stance where individuals and communities are encouraged to discard the quitter mentality in exchange for a resolute attitude determined to take practical steps in joining what she refers to as the "winning team" of climate action.
Portraying climate action as a worthwhile and achievable endeavor
Johnson aims to highlight how individuals and communities are already "getting it right," shining a light on various climate solutions to exhibit that climate action is both feasible and valuable.
Highlighting examples of individuals and communities already "getting it right" through various climate solutions can demonstrate the feasibility and value of climate action.
Johnson's book presents interviews with 20 individuals who are actively and successfully partaking in climate action, demonstrating th ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Changing the narrative around climate change and "getting it right"
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While shifting the narrative to focus on solutions is positive, it's important to maintain a balance and not understate the severity of the climate crisis, as a sense of urgency is necessary to drive action.
- The belief in progress through existing solutions may overlook the need for innovation and the development of new technologies to address climate change effectively.
- A solutions-oriented mindset is valuable, but it must be coupled with critical thinking to assess which solutions are most effective and sustainable in the long term.
- The question "What if we get it right?" might imply a singular approach to climate action, whereas the reality is that a multifaceted and diverse set of actions is required to address different aspects of the crisis.
- Encouraging a "winning team" mentality could inadvertently create an "us vs. them" dynamic, which may hinder collaborative efforts that are essential for global climate action.
- Highlighting examples of successful climate action is important, but it's also necessary to critically evaluate and learn from less successful initiatives to understand the complexities and challen ...
Actionables
- Start a personal "climate success diary" where you jot down positive environmental news and your own eco-friendly actions each week. This habit reinforces the idea that progress is being made and that your contributions matter. For example, if you read about a new renewable energy project or you successfully reduce your waste, record it and reflect on these successes to maintain a solutions-oriented mindset.
- Create a "What if we get it right?" vision board in your living space, using images and quotes that represent successful climate initiatives. Seeing this daily can help shift your focus from problems to solutions. You might include pictures of thriving coral reefs that have been restored or quotes from leaders in sustainability, serving as a visual affirmation of positive change.
- Engage in "solution conversations" with friends and family, where ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
