'Us, After' and 'A Haunted Girl' tackle mental health
NPR's Book of the Day explores two books that tackle mental health and suicide through personal stories and fictionalized accounts. Rachel Zimmerman discusses her memoir "Us, After," grappling with the aftermath of her husband's suicide and reflecting on the challenges of portraying suicide's mindset authentically.
Naomi Sacks and Ethan Sacks share how their graphic novel "A Haunted Girl" uses metaphorical monster battles and supernatural elements as a protective layer when addressing themes of mental illness and suicidal thoughts. Both works underscore the importance of mental health awareness through poignant narratives that balance dark realities with hope and guidance.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Aug 23, 2024 episode of the NPR's Book of the Day
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
Personal experiences with suicide and mental illness
Rachel Zimmerman grappled with the aftermath of her husband Seth's suicide
Zimmerman was devastated when her husband Seth, an MIT professor, ended his life. Despite their seemingly happy family life, she was left wondering why they weren't enough to keep him from suicide. Zimmerman reflects on Seth's struggle with tinnitus and the higher genetic risk of suicide now facing her children. She describes her grieving process, noting that Seth's presence remains through their daughters wearing his clothes.
Naomi Sacks, drawing from her own mental health challenges, aimed to present an authentic account of anxiety and returning to school after hospitalization in her graphic novel "A Haunted Girl." She modeled the therapist character after her own warm, approachable therapist to counter stereotypes.
The challenges of writing about suicide and mental health
Zimmerman's Personal Connection to Suicide
Zimmerman found writing about suicide's incomprehensible mindset overwhelming. She learned to move past asking "why wasn't I enough?" realizing suicidal ideation stems from mental illness, not choice. Zimmerman immersed herself in the reality that those untouched by depression cannot fully grasp a suicidal perspective. She emphasizes seeking support when struggling.
The Sacks' Fictional Narrative Approach
Ethan and Naomi Sacks used fantastical, supernatural motifs in "A Haunted Girl" to gently explore mental health, avoiding overtly triggering depictions. They aimed to offer hope while providing resources and guidance.
The use of fiction/fantasy elements to explore mental health themes
"A Haunted Girl" and metaphorical battles
In "A Haunted Girl," Ethan and Naomi Sacks depict the protagonist Cleo battling metaphorical "monsters" representing her mental illness and suicidal thoughts. The fantastical elements create distance from harsh realities to reduce triggering readers.
Supernatural as a protective layer
Ethan Sacks integrated supernatural horror to broach mental health and suicide sensitively, creating a buffer for the reader, per Naomi Sacks.
Balancing darkness with humor
While tackling profound topics, "A Haunted Girl" incorporates humor, like the therapist joking about insurance not covering supernatural experiences. Naomi Sacks highlights how laughter often plays a role in the therapeutic journey, countering cold stereotypes.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Actionables
- You can create a personal reflection journal to process complex emotions, using prompts like "What feelings am I holding onto today?" or "How can I honor a lost loved one in my actions?" This helps you navigate grief or mental health struggles by providing a structured way to articulate and understand your feelings, similar to how Zimmerman processed her experiences.
- Start a book club focused on graphic novels and literature that address mental health, selecting titles like "A Haunted Girl" that use creative storytelling techniques. This encourages open discussions about mental health in a supportive environment and can help destigmatize mental illness through shared experiences.
- Develop a habit of writing letters to yourself during challenging times, offering compassion and understanding as if you were speaking to a friend. This self-supportive practice can reinforce the idea that mental health struggles are not a choice and remind you of your intrinsic value, echoing Zimmerman's journey of self-realization.
Get access to the context and additional materials
Personal experiences with suicide and mental illness
In the wake of unimaginable tragedy, Rachel Zimmerman grapples with the aftermath of her husband Seth’s suicide and its profound impact on her family, illustrating the complex and painful journey through grief and the search for answers.
Rachel Zimmerman grappled with the aftermath of her husband Seth's suicide and the immense grief and unanswerable questions it left behind
Zimmerman was thrown into despair when a state trooper arrived at her door to inform her that her husband Seth’s car was found abandoned on the Tobin Bridge with a suicide note inside. She was shocked and saddened by the sudden loss. Despite her husband's success as an MIT professor and their seemingly idyllic family life, Zimmerman was left with an aching question: Why weren’t they, including their two young daughters who were eight and eleven at the time, enough to keep Seth from ending his life?
She recalls the morning of Seth's death with painful clarity, lingering on the regret of simple actions like stopping for coffee, wondering if that time could have made a difference. Her husband's death made her acutely aware of the higher genetic risk for suicide that now shadowed her children and emphasized the harrowing nature of mental illness. Zimmerman reflects on Seth’s struggle with tinnitus and his appointment with a specialist set for the week after his death.
Zimmerman shares her grieving process, noting how Seth's presence remains interwoven in their lives. Important events and new relationships do not overwrite his memory, and her children keep his presence alive, such as through wearing his clothes. Zimmerman describes Seth as a dreamer, someone who dearly loved teaching and adored his daughters, ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Personal experiences with suicide and mental illness
Additional Materials
Actionables
- Create a memory box to honor loved ones and process grief by gathering items that remind you of them, such as photographs, letters, or personal belongings. This tangible activity can help you and your family members acknowledge the loss and celebrate the person's life, providing a physical space to connect with memories and emotions.
- Develop a personal mental health emergency plan by listing warning signs, coping mechanisms, and support networks. This plan can serve as a quick reference guide for you or your loved ones during challenging times, ensuring that everyone knows how to act swiftly and effectively to seek help or provide support.
- Start a journal to exp ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
The challenges of writing about suicide and mental health
The complexities of addressing suicide and mental health in writing are multifaceted and emotionally fraught. Rachel Zimmerman and the duo Ethan and Naomi Sacks each adopted unique perspectives to engage with such sensitive topics.
Zimmerman's Personal Connection to Suicide
Rachel Zimmerman found the writing process to be an overwhelming endeavor as she delved into the incomprehensible mindset of someone contending with suicidal thoughts.
Learning to Ask the Right Questions
In her journey, Zimmerman learned to move past the question of "why wasn't I/our family enough?" which reflects a common but mistaken belief that suicidal ideation is a matter of choice or about the value of relationships. She came to understand that such ideation is a symptom of mental illness, not a rational decision. Seeking guidance and insight from experts and others affected by suicide, Zimmerman came to realize the fathomless pain that accompanies suicide, a realm of agony that is nearly impossible to grasp for those who have not experienced such depths of despair.
Zimmerman immersed herself in the stark reality that, for individuals untouched by depression, truly grasping the perspective of someone suicidal may be insurmountably challenging. The crucial takeaway from her experience is the pressing need to seek support when struggling. Zimmerman also highlights the relentless impact of coping with the suicide of a loved one through her own story—the unending quest to understand and reconcile with the loss. Moreover, she addresses common misconceptions by quoting a survivor, debunking the notion that suicide is a choice. She emphasizes that it is a compulsive act, bound intricately with mental illness.
Through the lens of her husband Seth’s struggle with mental health, Zimmerman revisits his encounter with the healthcare system where he was prescribed antidepressants and encouraged to seek therapy—a course of action he regrettably did not pursue, shedding light on the oft-misunderstood nature of mental illne ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
The challenges of writing about suicide and mental health
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While Zimmerman's approach to understanding suicide through personal experience and expert consultation is valuable, it may not encompass all perspectives, as experiences with suicide and mental illness are highly individual.
- The assertion that suicidal ideation is not a rational decision could be nuanced by acknowledging that while it is often a symptom of mental illness, individuals' reasoning processes are complex and can't be universally categorized.
- The idea that understanding someone suicidal is nearly impossible for those untouched by depression might be too absolute; empathy and understanding can be fostered through education and open dialogue, even among those without personal experience.
- Zimmerman's emphasis on the need to seek support is crucial, but it's also important to recognize systemic barriers that may prevent individuals from accessing the help they need.
- The narrative that coping with a loved one's suicide is an unending quest for understanding might not resonate with everyone, as some may find peace or closure in different ways.
- The depiction of suicide as a compulsive act linked to mental illness might oversimplify the issue, as it can also be influenced by a multitude of social, cultural, and individual factors.
- Zimmerman's recounting of her husband's experience with the healthcare system highlights important issues but could also explore the complexities of why individuals may choose not to follow through with recommended treatments.
- The Sacks' use of allegory and metaphor in "A Haunted Girl" to discuss mental health might not be effecti ...
Actionables
- Create a personal journal to explore your feelings about mental health, using creative writing to process complex emotions. By writing fictional stories or poems that touch on themes of mental health, you can explore your own understanding and feelings in a safe, controlled environment. For example, you might write a short story from the perspective of a character dealing with mental health challenges, which can help you empathize with those experiences without becoming overwhelmed.
- Develop a small, private book club with friends or family focused on reading and discussing literature that deals with mental health themes. Choose books that use allegory and metaphor to approach the topic gently, similar to how "A Haunted Girl" does. This can foster a supportive community where you can share insights and personal experiences related to the subject matter, providing mutual support and deepening your collective understanding.
- Volunteer for a mental health awareness campaign, focusing on sharing resources ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
The use of fiction/fantasy elements to explore mental health themes
The graphic novel "A Haunted Girl" by Ethan and Naomi Sacks presents an imaginative way of confronting mental health issues. Utilizing elements of fantasy, the novel offers a unique lens through which to understand and empathize with mental illness.
"A Haunted Girl" and metaphorical battles
"Ethan and Naomi Sacks discuss the poignant journey of Cleo, the protagonist of "A Haunted Girl," who combats metaphorical "monsters" representing her struggle with mental illness and suicidal thoughts. These fantastical elements create distance from the harsh realities of such conditions, aiming to reduce the risk of triggering those who face similar challenges.
Supernatural as a protective layer
Ethan Sacks chose to integrate supernatural horror into the graphic novel as a means of gently broaching the topics of mental health, hospitalization, and suicide. This indirect approach serves as a protective buffer for the reader, creating a safe space to engage with and empathize with Cleo’s struggles without facing a mirror of their own experiences.
Balancing darkness with humor
Amidst tackling profound subjects, "A Haunted Girl" doesn't shy away from moments of light-heartedness, thanks to the touch of Ethan and Naomi Sacks. Specifically, they introduce a therapist character who, with humor and levity—includ ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
The use of fiction/fantasy elements to explore mental health themes
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While fantasy elements can provide a unique lens for understanding mental illness, they may also oversimplify complex conditions, potentially leading to misunderstandings about the nature of mental health issues.
- The metaphorical battle against monsters might inadvertently reinforce the stigma that mental illness is something to be fought against, rather than an experience to be understood and managed.
- The protective buffer created by supernatural elements could prevent some readers from fully confronting and processing their own experiences with mental health.
- The use of humor in discussing mental health can be therapeutic, but it might also be perceived as trivializing the severity of mental illness for some readers.
- The indirect approach to mental health topics might not resonate with all readers, some of whom may prefer more direct and realistic portrayals of mental health struggles.
- The balance of darkness and humor is subjective and may not strike the right ...
Actionables
- You can create a personal journal using fantasy storytelling to process your emotions, where you assign different characters or creatures to represent various feelings or challenges you're facing. For example, if you're dealing with anxiety, you might imagine it as a shadowy figure that you have to outwit or negotiate with in your writing, turning your emotional management into a creative and engaging activity.
- Start a book club focused on graphic novels and literature that use fantastical elements to explore real-life issues, encouraging members to share their interpretations and personal connections to the stories. This can foster a supportive community where discussing mental health becomes more accessible through the shared experience of reading.
- Engage in role-playing games (RPGs) that allo ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
