In 'Five-Star Stranger,' a man gets hired on an app to pretend to be a girl's father
NPR's Book of the Day explores the emerging phenomenon of "rental strangers"—people hired through apps like Japan's Rental Stranger to fulfill roles like mourners, dates, or even family members. The summary delves into author Kat Tang's experience of renting a "father" figure in Japan to gain novel insights, prompting her to reevaluate her relationship with her own father.
It also examines the complex relationships at the heart of Tang's novel, "Five-Star Stranger." A young girl, Lily, innocently accepts a rented stranger as her real father, while her mother sacrifices her own contentment for her daughter's emotional well-being. The stranger himself grapples with maintaining boundaries as he grows invested in his "roles."
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Aug 13, 2024 episode of the NPR's Book of the Day
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
The Rise of "Rental Strangers"
The emerging trend of hiring "rental strangers" to assume various roles in one's life, like mourners, dates, or even fathers, has gained traction through apps like Japan's Rental Stranger.
Clients' Diverse Motivations
Kat Tang suggests clients may initially seek rental strangers to alleviate loneliness or satisfy social pressures. However, the reality often reveals a deeper desire for authenticity that strangers cannot fulfill.
The Author's Rental "Father" Experience
Renting a "Father" for Novel Insight
To better understand her novel's themes, Tang rented a "father" in Japan, asking intimate questions she had never posed to her own father.
Reevaluating Her Real Father Relationship
This experience made Tang recognize how she takes her relationship with her actual father for granted, prompting her to reevaluate her approach.
Complex Relationships in the Novel
The Young Girl and Her "Father"
A central plot involves a young girl, Lily, who believes the stranger is her real father, contrasting her innocent acceptance with the truth.
The Mother's Understanding and Sacrifice
Meanwhile, Lily's mother Mari knows the stranger benefits Lily but not herself, sacrificing her own contentment for her daughter's emotional welfare, which the Stranger secretly admires.
The Stranger's Internal Conflict
Despite efforts to remain detached, the Stranger finds himself emotionally invested in his "roles," privately questioning if he can maintain boundaries between his fictional responsibilities and personal inclinations.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- Clients may hire rental strangers not just to alleviate loneliness or satisfy social pressures, but also for practical reasons such as professional networking or to navigate social events more comfortably.
- The desire for authenticity might be met in unexpected ways through interactions with rental strangers, as these interactions can sometimes lead to genuine moments of connection and insight.
- Renting a "father" or any other role may not always lead to a greater appreciation of one's real family; for some, it might reinforce negative feelings or highlight the shortcomings of their actual relationships.
- The novel's portrayal of Lily's belief in the stranger as her real father could be seen as an oversimplification of child psychology and the complexity of family bonds.
- The mother's sacrifice for Lily's emotional welfare might be criticized for perpetuating the idea that a mother must always put her child's needs before her own, potentially at the cost of her own well-being.
- The Stranger's admiration for the mother's sacrifice could be interpreted as a romanticized view of selflessness, which might not always be healthy or desirable in real-life relationships.
- The Stranger's internal conflict and emotional investment in his roles could be seen as a professional hazard rather than a personal dilemma, questioning the sustainability of such a job rather than the individual's emotional capacity.
Actionables
- You can deepen your appreciation for genuine relationships by writing a letter to a family member expressing your gratitude for their presence in your life, highlighting specific instances where their support was invaluable.
- Writing letters encourages reflection on the importance of authentic connections and can help you recognize the value of the people who are genuinely invested in your life. It's a tangible way to acknowledge the difference between a hired role and a naturally developed bond.
- You can explore the impact of social roles by volunteering as a companion for the elderly or socially isolated individuals in your community.
- Volunteering provides firsthand experience with the feelings of loneliness and the desire for companionship that some people face. It also offers a perspective on how authentic interactions can alleviate these feelings, contrasting with the temporary fix provided by rental strangers.
- You can evaluate your own emotional investments by keeping a journal where you document your feelings after significant social interactions for a month.
- Journaling about your emotional responses to various social roles can help you understand your own capacity for emotional investment and the boundaries you might have. It's a reflective practice that can reveal insights into how you perceive and value authentic emotional connections.
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
The concept of "rental strangers" and their varied roles and motivations
The emerging trend of "rental strangers," where individuals are hired to play specific roles in the lives of others, has garnered attention through real-life programs and fictional portrayals alike.
The business of renting out strangers to play different roles in people's lives
In Japan, real-life initiatives have sparked the creation of apps like Rental Stranger, through which clients can hire individuals to perform a range of roles, mirroring the themes found in the novel "Five Star Stranger." The stranger may assume the role of a mourner at a funeral, a celebrant at a party, a boyfriend, a drunk friend, the best man at a wedding, or even a father to a young girl. This service is transactional, with the rental stranger's performance being remunerated with a fee and appraised with a rating from clients.
The diverse motivations clients have for hiring rental strangers
Clients turn to "rental strangers" for various reasons. Some might seek to alleviate loneliness or the social pressure of attending event ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
The concept of "rental strangers" and their varied roles and motivations
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- The term "rental strangers" refers to a trend where individuals are hired to act out specific roles in the lives of others, often for a fee. These hired individuals can play various roles like a friend, family member, or companion for events or scenarios where the client needs someone to fill a specific role temporarily. This concept blurs the lines between reality and performance, allowing people to engage with others in a scripted or temporary capacity for various personal or social reasons. The motivations behind hiring rental strangers can vary widely, from alleviating loneliness to fulfilling social expectations or exploring different experiences without long-term commitments.
- In Japan, the concept of "rental strangers" involves individuals being hired to play specific roles in people's lives. These roles can include acting as mourners at funerals, celebrants at parties, boyfriends or girlfriends for social events, drunk friends for gatherings, best men or bridesmaids at weddings, or even surrogate fathers or mothers for various occasions. This service allows clients to fill social roles temporarily with paid strangers to meet specific needs or expectations.
- In the context of renting strangers, the transactional nature involves clients paying a fee for the services provided by the rented individuals. This fee serves as remuneration for the performance of specific roles, such as being a mourner at a funeral or a celebrant at a party. Additionally, clients often provide ratings or feedback on the rented stranger's performance, which can influence their reputation and future opportunities in this line of work.
- The concept of hiring rental strangers involves individuals paying for companionship or specific roles to fulfill social needs like companionship, avoiding social pressu ...
Counterarguments
- The commodification of human interaction through "rental strangers" could be seen as a symptom of societal issues, such as increased loneliness and social isolation, rather than a solution.
- There may be ethical concerns about the authenticity of relationships and the psychological impact on both the clients and the hired individuals.
- The transactional nature of these services might reinforce the idea that emotional support and companionship can be bought, potentially devaluing genuine relationships.
- The rating system for rental strangers could lead to the objectification of individuals, reducing complex human interactions to a customer service metric.
- The reliance on "rental strangers" might discourage individuals from forming real, lasting relationships and addressing the root causes of their loneliness or social anx ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
The author's personal experience of renting a "father" and how it impacted her perspective
Kat Tang traveled to Japan and engaged in the novel experience of renting a "father." This experience was not only for her to step into an unusual scenario but also to gain a deeper understanding for her novel.
Kat Tang's decision to rent a "father" in Japan after writing the novel to better understand the experience
Kat Tang was motivated to rent a "father" in Japan to bring authenticity and depth to her writing. During her encounter with the rental "father," Tang took the opportunity to ask intimate and significant questions—questions she had never thought to ask her own father.
Tang asked the rental "father" questions she had never asked her own father, gaining new insights
In her interaction with the rental "father," Tang sought advice on life and relationships. These were conversations she had not previously considered having with her biological father, giving her a rare insight into such a formalized yet personal interaction.
The experience made Tang reconsider her own relationship with her real father
Tang's time with the rental "father" turned into a mirror reflecting her relationship with her actual father. She found that in everyday life, she was taking her relat ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
The author's personal experience of renting a "father" and how it impacted her perspective
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- Renting a "father" may not provide a truly authentic experience that can be directly translated into a novel, as the interactions are inherently artificial and based on a commercial transaction.
- The insights gained from a rental "father" might not be universally applicable or reflective of genuine paternal relationships, which are complex and deeply personal.
- Reconsidering one's relationship with a real parent based on a single experience with a rented "father" could be seen as a simplistic approach to addressing familial dynamics.
- The act of renting a family member could be criticized for commodifying personal relationships and emotional experiences.
- The experience of asking a rental "father" intimate questions might not necessarily lead to a deeper understanding of one's own parental relationship, as the context and emotional stakes are significantly different.
- The noti ...
Actionables
- You can deepen your understanding of relationships by writing letters to your loved ones as if they were strangers, asking questions you've never dared to ask before. This exercise can reveal unexplored aspects of your relationships and encourage more meaningful conversations in the future. For example, write a letter to your parent or friend asking about their life dreams or fears, as if you didn't know them well, and see what new insights emerge when they respond.
- Engage in role-reversal exercises with a trusted friend where you each act as an important figure in the other's life, such as a parent or mentor, and allow for a candid exchange of thoughts and questions. This can provide a safe space to explore feelings and questions that might be difficult to address directly with the actual person. For instance, you might discover that you've been seeking approval in areas of your life where you need to trust your own judgment more.
- Create a personal "character study" by obse ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
The complex relationships and dynamics between the main characters in the novel
The novel delves deep into the intricate connections and unique dynamics among the central figures, exploring themes of sacrifice, identity, and emotional bonds.
The relationship between the young girl Lily and the stranger who plays her "father"
A pivotal element of the story revolves around Lily, a young girl who is oblivious to the fact that the man she believes is her father is, in reality, a stranger. This ignorance leads to a complicated and evolving dynamic between Lily and the man, as her innocent acceptance of him as a paternal figure stands in stark contrast to the truth of their connection.
The understanding between the mother Mari and the stranger
Meanwhile, Mari, Lily's mother, is fully aware that the stranger is beneficial for her daughter but not for herself. This realization showcases Mari's maternal instinct and the extent of her willingness to sacrifice her own contentment for Lily’s benefit. Her ability to separate her personal needs from Lily’s illustrates a profound commitment to her daughter’s emotional welfare, even if it means inviting a stranger to fill the paternal void.
Mari’s choice reflects an understanding of the complexities of her situation; she grasps the necessity of having a father figure for Lily and accepts the emotional cost to herself. This poignant sacrifice is not lost on the Stranger, who secretly admires Mari for the love and bravery she shows for her child, albeit he compares it to his own strained relationship with his mother.
The stranger's own internal struggle to maintain his emotional distance while getting increasingly invested in his "roles"
The character of the Stranger is at the heart of the narr ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
The complex relationships and dynamics between the main characters in the novel
Additional Materials
Actionables
- Reflect on your own relationships by journaling about the roles and sacrifices each person makes. Write down instances where you or someone else in your life has made a sacrifice, like Mari did for Lily, and consider the emotional costs involved. This can help you appreciate the complexities of your relationships and the depth of emotional bonds.
- Create a "relationship map" to visualize the dynamics in your life. Draw a diagram with you at the center, connecting lines to the key people in your life, and label each line with the nature of the dynamic, such as "mentor," "protector," or "stranger." This can help you understand the various roles people play in your life and how they contribute to your sense of identity.
- Practice empathy exercises to better understa ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
