Podcasts > NPR's Book of the Day > M.T. Anderson's 'Nicked' follows a heist to steal the bones of Saint Nicholas

M.T. Anderson's 'Nicked' follows a heist to steal the bones of Saint Nicholas

By NPR (podcasts@npr.org)

In this episode of NPR's Book of the Day, M.T. Anderson discusses his novel "Nicked," inspired by the historical theft of Saint Nicholas's remains by Italian pirates. The book centers around a conspiracy by monks to steal these holy relics, believing their possession could bestow miracles and prosperity on their city.

Anderson explores themes of belief versus skepticism, inviting readers to ponder the delicate balance between humanity's longing for the wondrous and the fear of falsehoods. He also delves into the dynamic between an upright monk overseeing the heist and a cunning relic hunter executing it. With "Nicked" marking his adult fiction debut, Anderson engages mature themes, signaling his authorial shift to a wholly adult readership.

Listen to the original

M.T. Anderson's 'Nicked' follows a heist to steal the bones of Saint Nicholas

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Aug 8, 2024 episode of the NPR's Book of the Day

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

M.T. Anderson's 'Nicked' follows a heist to steal the bones of Saint Nicholas

1-Page Summary

The Historical Basis of "Nicked"

M.T. Anderson's novel "Nicked" is based on the true event of Italian pirates stealing the remains of St. Nicholas and transporting them to the city of Bari. According to Anderson, the widespread belief was that possessing these holy relics could bestow miraculous healing properties and attract pilgrim traffic, boosting a city's esteem and prosperity.

Plot: Stealing the Saint's Bones

The novel centers around a scheme by monks conspiring to steal St. Nicholas's bones and bring them to Bari, driven by a desire to secure the Saint's esteemed presence and associated boons for their city. Anderson grounds this plot in the educational yet enigmatic historical context.

Faith, Miracles, and Human Belief

Anderson explores the tension between skepticism and humanity's longing to believe in miracles. Through Brother Niciphaerus, he captures one's inner conflict between critical doubt and a wish for the wondrous, haunted by dreams compelling him to transport the Saint's relics. Anderson wades into the ambiguity over miracles' divine nature versus elaborate charades, inviting readers to ponder belief's delicate balance with a fear of falsehoods.

Drawing from his experience with a "haunted" house, Anderson underscores how belief in the supernatural persists even amid logical doubt's shadow, reflecting the irresistible charm of the impossible which the protagonist grapples with regarding the relics.

Character Dynamic: Monk vs. Relic Hunter

The storyline unfolds the relationship between Dicephorus, the upright monk overseeing the relic theft, and Tayon, the cunning relic hunter executing the heist. Despite mutual suspicion, Anderson depicts their wary yet strangely magnetic attraction as they navigate intrigue and deception under perilous circumstances.

Adult Fiction Debut

"Nicked" marks Anderson's initial adult fiction work, departing from his crossover appeal by focusing on more mature themes like mortgages rather than catering to teen readers as before. Anderson clarifies this book was deliberately crafted not to interest teens, signaling his authorial shift to engage an entirely adult audience.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The belief in the miraculous power of relics might be overstated and not universally accepted; some may argue that the historical significance is more cultural or political rather than spiritual.
  • The plot's focus on monks stealing bones could be seen as perpetuating negative stereotypes about religious figures being involved in deceitful practices.
  • The tension between skepticism and belief in miracles might not resonate with all readers, particularly those who are non-religious or who have a more nuanced understanding of faith.
  • The character of Brother Niciphaerus could be criticized for potentially reinforcing the trope of the tormented believer, which might oversimplify the complexities of faith.
  • The questioning of miracles' divine nature versus being elaborate charades could be offensive to some religious readers who hold these events as sacred truths.
  • The parallel between the protagonist's supernatural experiences and the allure of the impossible might not be compelling to readers who prefer more grounded or realistic narratives.
  • The dynamic between Dicephorus and Tayon could be criticized for possibly romanticizing manipulative relationships or for not adequately exploring the ethical implications of their actions.
  • The decision to target an adult audience with mature themes might alienate fans of Anderson's previous works who are accustomed to and appreciate his crossover appeal.

Actionables

  • You can explore the impact of belief in your community by starting a book club focused on historical fiction dealing with themes of faith and skepticism. Choose titles that delve into the tension between the supernatural and the rational, similar to the themes in "Nicked," and facilitate discussions that encourage members to share personal experiences and perceptions of miracles in modern times.
  • Enhance your understanding of the human attraction to the impossible by keeping a journal where you document instances in your life when you've hoped for or witnessed events that defy explanation. Reflect on these moments to gain insight into your own balance of skepticism and belief, paralleling the protagonist's journey in "Nicked."
  • Develop a deeper appreciation for mature-themed literature by creating a reading challenge for yourself that includes a mix of adult fiction works, like "Nicked," and other genres that explore complex relationships and moral dilemmas. Set goals to read and reflect on how these themes resonate with your personal experiences and worldview.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
M.T. Anderson's 'Nicked' follows a heist to steal the bones of Saint Nicholas

The historical basis and premise of the novel "Nicked"

Author M.T. Anderson ventures into historical fiction with "Nicked," a novel grounded in the fascinating true event of the theft of Saint Nicholas’s remains and their subsequent transportation to the city of Bari.

The true historical event of the theft of St. Nicholas's remains by Italian pirates and their transportation to the city of Bari

The novel's reimagining is based on the historical occurrence that involved Italian pirates, or perhaps less glamorously, some pious merchants, spiriting away the bones of St. Nicholas, widely known as the figure behind the myth of Santa Claus. St. Nicholas was infamous for his penchant for secret gift-giving and was also the patron saint of sailors. Anderson’s retelling confirms that the remains were indeed stolen and transported back to Italy, a revelation that roots the narrative in factual soil.

The belief that St. Nicholas's remains possessed miraculous healing properties and could attract a lucrative stream of pilgrim traffic to the city that possessed them

At the heart of this occurrence was the widespread belief in the Saint’s ability to perform miracles, which went from pacifying tempests to saving individuals from the briney deep. This belief held that the possession of such holy relics, in particular the bones of St. Nicholas, could bestow miraculous healing properties and, by extension, lure a steady and lucrative stream of pilgrim traffic. Thus, the city that harbored these remains stood to gain both in esteem and economic prosperity, as sailors often sought the Saint’s blessings before embarking on perilous voyages. ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The historical basis and premise of the novel "Nicked"

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • You can explore the impact of historical events on your local community by researching a significant event and its long-term effects on your town or city, similar to how the theft of St. Nicholas's remains influenced Bari.
    • Start by visiting your local library or historical society to gather information about a historical event that shaped your community. Consider how this event might have brought people together, changed the economy, or altered the city's reputation. Share your findings with friends or through social media to spark conversations about your community's heritage and its ongoing influence.
  • You might create a themed treasure hunt for friends or family, inspired by the monks' quest in "Nicked," to engage with history in an interactive way.
    • Design a treasure hunt around your neighborhood or city, using historical facts and legends as clues. Each clue could lead to a location that's historically significant or tied to a local myth. This activity not only provides entertainment but also educates participants ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
M.T. Anderson's 'Nicked' follows a heist to steal the bones of Saint Nicholas

Themes of faith, miracles, and the human desire to believe

Anderson delves into the complex interplay between skepticism and the innate human longing to believe in the miraculous, presenting a nuanced exploration of faith and incredulity.

The tension between the characters' rational skepticism and their yearning to believe in the impossible and miraculous

Through the story of Brother Niciphaerus, Anderson encapsulates the inner conflict faced by many: a dichotomy between rational disbelief and a deep-seated wish for the wondrous. Despite being characterized as an unbeliever praying for faith, Brother Niciphaerus is haunted by dreams compelling him to move St. Nicholas's remains to Italy. This tension is reflective of the broader human struggle between critical inquiry and the desire to hold on to a sense of enchantment.

Anderson skillfully wades into the ambiguity of miracles, posing the question of their true divine nature or if they are elaborate charades. The readers are left to ponder the delicate balance between an enchanting possibility of miracles and the fear of succumbing to falsehoods, a theme deeply rooted in the protagonist monk's predicament regarding the saint's relics.

The author's exploration of how belief in miracles and the supernatural can persist even in the face of logical doubt

M.T. Anderson brings a personal touch to this theme by drawing a parallel between his experience living in a so-called haunted house and the overarching sentiment of the novel. He humorously navigates the irony of his skepticism about ghosts against the ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Themes of faith, miracles, and the human desire to believe

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The protagonist monk in the text contemplates the miraculous power of relics, which are objects associated with saints or holy figures believed to possess supernatural qualities. The ethical dilemma arises from the potential theft of these relics, as their removal could disrupt the spiritual significance and reverence attached to them. This internal conflict highlights the tension between the protagonist's desire to witness miracles and t ...

Counterarguments

  • The exploration of skepticism and belief in miracles may not account for the full spectrum of religious experiences and the diversity of faith traditions.
  • Rational skepticism and longing for the miraculous are not necessarily in conflict; some individuals find a harmonious integration of faith and reason.
  • The character of Brother Niciphaerus might oversimplify the complexity of religious belief and the personal journey of faith.
  • The tension between critical inquiry and the desire for enchantment could be viewed as a false dichotomy, with many individuals finding critical inquiry to be an enchanting pursuit in itself.
  • The ambiguity of miracles could be interpreted differently by those who have a firm belief in their faith, seeing miracles as clear signs rather than ambiguous events.
  • The persistence of belief in miracles despite logical doubt may overlook the role of personal experience and testimony in shaping belief, which can be compelling beyond logical arguments.
  • Anderson's personal experience with skepticism and the supernatural might not resonate with ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
M.T. Anderson's 'Nicked' follows a heist to steal the bones of Saint Nicholas

The dynamic between the central characters of the honest monk and the cunning relic hunter

The narrative unfolds an absorbing dynamic between two central characters—the upright monk, Dicephorus, and the wily relic hunter, Tayon. Their interaction gives rise to a storyline charged with tension and an unexpected connection.

The wary, yet strangely magnetic, relationship that develops between the monk tasked with overseeing the relic theft and the experienced, unscrupulous relic hunter hired to execute the heist

Brother Nesephorus, the monk assigned to watch over the valuable relics, finds himself in a perplexing bind. Despite his suspicions towards Tayon, the seasoned relic hunter whose craft lies in the dark art of thievery, Dicephorus cannot deny the allure the cunning man exerts over him.

The underlying attraction and mutual suspicion between the two men as they are forced to work together in dangerous circumstances

The narrative delves into the layered complexities of their relationship—there is an undeniable gravitational pull between the two men, which ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The dynamic between the central characters of the honest monk and the cunning relic hunter

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • Explore the dynamics of trust by journaling your interactions with a colleague or friend where trust might be an issue. Write down instances where you feel suspicious or attracted to their ideas and reflect on how these feelings influence your collaboration. This can help you understand the complexities of your own relationships and how they evolve under different circumstances.
  • Create a short story or role-play scenario where you and another person have conflicting interests but must work together. This exercise can help you navigate and resolve real-life situations where you have to cooperate with someone you don't fully trust. By acting it out or writing it down, you can experiment with different outcomes and strategies for managing complex relationships.
  • Practice mindfulness ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
M.T. Anderson's 'Nicked' follows a heist to steal the bones of Saint Nicholas

Anderson's background as an author of both adult and children's fiction

M.T. Anderson, a writer known for his stories for adults, children, and teens, has ventured into new literary territory with his latest novel, "Nicked." This work is his initial foray into writing exclusively for an adult audience.

"Nicked" as a departure from crossover fiction

Anderson's novel "Nicked" represents a significant departure from the crossover appeal of his previous works.

Focusing on adult themes

Anderson has discussed how "Nicked" distinctly differs in tone and content from his writing for younger readers by focusing on more mature themes and experiences. This new book is specifically intended to resonate with adult readers and touches upon adult concerns such as mortgages, signaling that it's been written without consideration for t ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Anderson's background as an author of both adult and children's fiction

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While "Nicked" is intended for an adult audience, it's possible that mature teens could still find value in its themes, as the distinction between adult and young adult fiction is often fluid.
  • The assertion that "Nicked" has been written without consideration for teen interests might overlook the fact that many teens are capable of engaging with and appreciating mature content.
  • The idea that "Nicked" represents a significant departure from crossover fiction could be seen as an oversimplification, as elements of crossover appeal might inadvertently remain, given Anderson's experience in writing for varied age groups.
  • The novel's focus on adult themes does not necessarily preclude it from being of interest to younger readers, as the definition of what constitutes an "adult theme" can be subjective and culturally variable.
  • The claim that Anderson's past works were ...

Actionables

  • Explore the evolution of an author's work by reading their earliest and latest books back-to-back to understand the shift in themes and writing style. This can give you a deeper appreciation for how writers develop over time and how their target audience can change. For example, if you've read J.K. Rowling's "Harry Potter" series, you might follow up with her "Cormoran Strike" novels to see the transition from children's fantasy to adult crime fiction.
  • Create a book club focused on authors who have transitioned from writing for young audiences to adult audiences. This can foster discussions about the differences in narrative techniques, themes, and content that cater to different age groups. You could start with M.T. Anderson's works and then include other authors like Neil Gaiman, who has written both children's books like "Coraline" and adult novels like "American Gods."
  • Write a reflective journal entry aft ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA