In this episode of NPR's Book of the Day, economist William Hoagland examines Alexander Hamilton's innovative views on public debt. He reveals how Hamilton saw national debt as a strategic tool to unite the states and attract allegiance from wealthy citizens by ensuring they received interest payments from the federal government.
Hoagland explores Hamilton's perspective that borrowing creates a "pool" to rapidly fund infrastructure, wars, and expansion, shifting power from lenders to the borrowing government. The episode showcases how borrowing empowered Hamilton's vision of growing America's power and prosperity, and how such debt dynamics play out on the global stage today.
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
Historian William Hoagland has shed light on how Alexander Hamilton viewed public debt as a strategic tool to strengthen the new U.S. government and bind wealthy citizens' interests to the nation's success.
According to Hoagland, Hamilton believed the federal government's assumption of state debts from the Revolutionary War would unify the country and tie the economic interests of rich creditors to the national government. By ensuring creditors received regular interest payments, Hamilton aimed to attract their loyalty.
Hamilton deliberately nourished a robust national debt, as he saw it as key to maintaining strong credit that could fund emergencies, expansion, and development. In contrast to opponents who viewed debt negatively, Hamilton perceived it as a "massive opportunity" to increase U.S. power and prosperity.
Hoagland examines how borrowing can empower governments over lenders. Hamilton envisioned making creditors "comfortable" and "connected" to the federal government through debt, aligning their interests to ensure support for federal over state policies.
Similar dynamics apply to foreign debt-holders like China: Their investments incentivize them to desire U.S. success and stability.
Historically, debt has empowered governments to launch major infrastructure, wars, and territorial expansion without waiting for tax revenue. Hoagland notes Hamilton was influenced by how Britain and France used borrowed funds for growth.
Borrowing creates an on-demand "pool" enabling rapid action on roads, development, wars, and expansion - eliminating constraints of project-specific tax increases. This "unleashes power," as Hamilton recognized.
1-Page Summary
Historian William Hoagland has illuminated Alexander Hamilton's innovative view of public debt, revealing how it played a crucial role in consolidating the nascent United States and binding the interests of its wealthiest citizens to the federal government.
Hamilton’s financial prowess led him to believe that the federal government’s assumption of the debts of the original 13 states would not only unify the country but also anchor the economic interests of rich Americans to the national government. Hoagland details Hamilton's plan, whereby the wealthy class, who had loaned the money to the states during the Revolution, would become tied to the nation's success through the desire for regular interest payments.
Hamilton's financial actions were designed to nourish a prosperous national debt, ensuring that the United States maintained robust credit. This capable handling of the debt would allow it to borrow more funds, if needed, for emergencies, infrastructure developments, and expansion programs. Hamilton saw this mechani ...
Hamilton's views on public debt and its role in consolidating and strengthening the new U.S. government
In an insightful examination of the nature of government debt, Hoagland discusses the counterintuitive way in which borrowing can empower the borrower—in this case, the government—rather than the lenders. This perspective sheds light on the strategic financial foresights of one of the United States' Founding Fathers, Alexander Hamilton.
Hoagland delves into Alexander Hamilton's vision of shifting the power dynamic between the federal government and the lending class. By tying the lending class to the federal government through the instrument of debt, Hamilton sought to align their interests with those of the national government. This maneuver was crafted to make the lending class "really comfortable" and "really connected" to the government, thus ensuring that the lenders' prosperity hinged on the federal government's success. By doing so, Hamilton intended to empower the central government at the expense of the individual states', ensuring the lenders would support federal initiatives and policies over state ones.
How debt can empower the government rather than the lenders
Historically, debt has played a pivotal role in allowing governments to embark on substantial, long-term projects which would have been otherwise impossible if they solely relied on tax revenues. This financial strategy has been essential in fueling initiatives that have shaped the nations.
When governments need to invest in large-scale projects, they often don’t have the luxury of waiting for the slow accumulation of tax revenues. Borrowing funds enables governments to take on these significant initiatives, unleashing the power to expand and fund infrastructure projects, wage wars, and even support territorial acquisitions.
Hogeland notes that borrowing money creates an on-demand “pool of loaned money”, which is crucial for funding essential undertakings such as roads construction, development of infrastructure, financial backing for wars, and expansion into new territories. It eliminates the constraint of having to set individual taxes for each project, thereby streamlining and expediting the government’s ability to action its plans.
How debt can be used to fund national projects and expansion
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser