Podcasts > NPR's Book of the Day > Carys Davies tackles communication, isolation and the Scottish Clearances in 'Clear'

Carys Davies tackles communication, isolation and the Scottish Clearances in 'Clear'

By NPR (podcasts@npr.org)

In this episode of NPR's Book of the Day, the discussion centers on Carys Davies' novel "Clear," which explores themes of communication, isolation, and the historical context of the Scottish Clearances. The novel contrasts different perspectives on the Clearances, when landowners displaced tenant farmers to pursue more profitable sheep farming.

Davies delves into the unique bond formed between an isolated Norn speaker and a Presbyterian minister, brought together by circumstance. Their lack of distractions compelled them to confront difficult truths, fostering an unlikely connection through their communication efforts. The novel highlights the challenges of bridging linguistic divides and the power of human connection, even in the face of overwhelming isolation.

Listen to the original

Carys Davies tackles communication, isolation and the Scottish Clearances in 'Clear'

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Jun 27, 2024 episode of the NPR's Book of the Day

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Carys Davies tackles communication, isolation and the Scottish Clearances in 'Clear'

1-Page Summary

Historical and Social Context: The Scottish Clearances

In the 1840s, Scottish landowners pursued higher profits by replacing tenant farmers with more lucrative sheep farming, leading to the "clearance" of many Scots from their ancestral lands. Author Carys Davies contrasts the differing perspectives within the Ferguson household: John Ferguson, a Presbyterian minister, respected landowners' legal rights to clear their estates, while Mary Ferguson held a more humanitarian view, skeptical of the justifications for displacing people.

Language and Communication: Bridging the Divide

Davies depicts the communication challenges faced by Ivar, the last speaker of the extinct Norn language, and Reverend John Ferguson, an educated Scot with no knowledge of Norn. Initially relying on primitive gestures and Ivar teaching Ferguson Norn words, the two men gradually developed a rudimentary pidgin language over time, blending Norn and English. Davies highlights Norn's rich vocabulary for nuanced concepts, which aided their communication.

Character Development and Relationships: An Unlikely Bond

Davies explores the deep bond that formed between the isolated Ivar and Ferguson, brought together by circumstance. She notes that their isolation and lack of distractions allowed them to confront aspects of life they might otherwise avoid, fostering a connection that defied logical explanation. The absence of diversions compelled them to engage with uncomfortable truths, facilitating personal discovery and understanding through their relationship.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While John Ferguson respected the legal rights of landowners, one could argue that legality does not always equate to morality, and the ethical implications of such clearances merit scrutiny.
  • The notion that Mary Ferguson's humanitarian view is more ethical than John's legalistic perspective could be challenged by arguing that property rights are fundamental to the structure of a society and that respecting them can lead to overall societal benefits.
  • The development of a pidgin language between Ivar and Ferguson, while significant, might be critiqued for potentially oversimplifying the complexity of language acquisition and the depth of communication possible between speakers of vastly different languages.
  • The idea that isolation necessarily leads to confronting uncomfortable truths could be countered by suggesting that isolation can also lead to a narrow worldview and reinforce existing biases.
  • The bond between Ivar and Ferguson, described as defying logical explanation, might be critiqued by those who believe that all human relationships can be understood through psychological or sociological analysis.
  • The suggestion that the relationship between Ivar and Ferguson facilitated personal discovery might be met with skepticism by those who argue that personal growth is not solely dependent on interpersonal relationships but also on individual introspection and experiences outside of such bonds.

Actionables

  • Explore the impact of historical events on your local community by visiting a nearby historical society or museum to learn about the changes in land use and population over time. This can give you a deeper appreciation for the forces that have shaped your own environment, similar to how the Scottish Clearances reshaped Scotland.
  • Foster understanding through language by learning a few phrases of a language that's new to you or at risk of dying out. Websites like Endangered Languages Project offer resources to get started. Engaging with another language can open up perspectives on how language shapes thought, much like the Norn language did for Ivar and Ferguson.
  • Reflect on your relationships by writing a letter to someone you have a complex relationship with, addressing misunderstandings and shared experiences. This exercise can help you discover new layers of your relationship and may lead to personal growth, akin to the bond between Ivar and Ferguson.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Carys Davies tackles communication, isolation and the Scottish Clearances in 'Clear'

Historical and social context (the Scottish Clearances in the 1840s)

In the 1840s, a significant social transformation took place in Scotland known as the Scottish Clearances, fundamentally altering the relationship between land, economy, and people.

The Scottish Landowners' Efforts to Maximize Profits Led to the Clearance of Tenant Farmers

In pursuit of higher profits, Scottish landowners began to replace their tenant farmers with sheep farming. This policy of agricultural "improvement" started around the middle of the 18th century and progressively hastened by the 1840s. Described as a "sheep frontier," the phenomenon continued to move northwards, displacing many Scots from lands that their families had worked for generations.

The clearances began in the middle of the 18th century, as landowners sought to replace unprofitable tenant farmers with more lucrative sheep farming

The initiative to clear estates of poor, unprofitable tenants in favor of lucrative sheep farming commenced in the mid-1700s. Landowners aimed to transform their estates into more profitable ventures, often at the expense of the tenant farmers’ livelihoods.

By the 1840s, the clearances had moved further north, displacing more and more Scots from their ancestral lands

As the 1840s approached, the clearances reached further into the northern regions, uprooting countless Scottish families from the land they had lived on and farmed for centuries.

Mary Ferguson's Compassionate Views Contrast with Her Husband's Conservative Stance on the Clearances

The differing perspectives on the Scottish Clearances within the Ferguson household illustrate the complex views toward this historical event.

John Ferguson, a Presbyterian minister, harbored a conservati ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Historical and social context (the Scottish Clearances in the 1840s)

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The clearances, while economically motivated, could be seen as part of a broader trend of agricultural modernization that was happening across Britain and Europe, which some argue was necessary for the development of a more efficient agricultural system.
  • The displacement of tenant farmers may have been part of a painful but inevitable economic transition from feudal agricultural practices to a market-oriented economy, which some could argue laid the groundwork for Scotland's participation in the Industrial Revolution.
  • John Ferguson's support for the landowners' rights might be contextualized within the legal and social norms of the time, which emphasized property rights and the autonomy of landowners to manage their lands as they saw fit.
  • While Mary Ferguson's humanitarian view is sympathetic, some might argue that it overlooks the potential long-term benefits of economic development and the possibility that the clearances, despite their immediate hardship, could have contributed to the eventual modernization and economic growth of Scotland.
  • It could be arg ...

Actionables

  • Explore the impact of historical land use changes on your local community by visiting a historical society or local library. By researching how land use has evolved in your area, you can gain a deeper understanding of the socio-economic forces that have shaped your community, similar to the Scottish clearances. You might discover, for example, that certain neighborhoods were once industrial areas that have since been converted to residential or commercial use, reflecting shifts in economic priorities over time.
  • Engage in ethical consumerism by researching the sourcing practices of your favorite products. Just as Mary Ferguson took a humanitarian view of the clearances, you can apply a similar perspective by choosing to support companies that prioritize fair labor practices and sustainable land use. This might involve checking for certifications like Fair Trade or Rainforest Alliance on items like coffee or chocolate, indicating ethical sourcing.
  • Write a letter to a local representative expressing your views ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Carys Davies tackles communication, isolation and the Scottish Clearances in 'Clear'

Language and communication (the challenges and gradual development of a shared language between the two characters)

In an account of language's barriers and bridges, the communication evolution of two distinctly different characters, Ivar and the Reverend John Ferguson, unfolds.

The Characters Initially Struggle to Communicate Due to the Language Barrier

Ivar, the last speaker of the extinct Norn language, and the Reverend John Ferguson, an educated Scot, have no common tongue

John Ferguson, a Presbyterian minister, and Ivar, the sole inhabitant of an island, initially cannot communicate due to the absence of a shared language. Carys Davies brings to life their early interaction challenges, where the two characters face a significant language barrier that compels them to find alternate means of communication.

They resort to pointing, gesturing, and Ivar teaching Ferguson Norn words for objects and concepts

In the beginning, their attempts at mutual understanding are primitive and unrefined. Davies describes the process: Ivar points to objects, gesticulates wildly, while John takes notes on the names of objects, animals, and colors as Ivar teaches him words from the Norn language—an extinct tongue known only to Ivar.

Over Time, the Characters Develop a Rudimentary Shared Language

Through patient effort, the men gradually build a pidgin language, blending Norn and English

As the narrative progresses, the characters, through patience and determination, begin to bridge the gap between them. Over about a month, Davies observes that the two start to communicate in a pieced-together manner, forging a rudimentary pidgin language that blends elements of Norn and English. This new hybrid l ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Language and communication (the challenges and gradual development of a shared language between the two characters)

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The assumption that a pidgin language can convey surprising depth may be overly optimistic, as pidgins are typically limited in expression and primarily serve basic communication needs.
  • The idea that the Norn language's specificity inherently aids in nuanced communication could be challenged by the argument that a rich vocabulary is not the sole determinant of communicative precision; context, grammar, and mutual understanding also play crucial roles.
  • The narrative may oversimplify the process of language learning and pidgin development, which in reality can be much more complex and take significantly longer than the text suggests.
  • The text implies a romanticized view of the extinct Norn language's capabilities without acknowledging that all languages have their own unique ways of expre ...

Actionables

  • You can enhance your non-verbal communication skills by practicing charades or Pictionary with friends, focusing on conveying complex ideas without words. This activity sharpens your ability to express thoughts through gestures and expressions, similar to how Ivar and Reverend John Ferguson communicated. For example, try to explain a concept like 'democracy' or 'sustainability' in a game setting without using verbal language.
  • Start a language exchange partnership with someone who speaks a language you're unfamiliar with to develop a blended vocabulary. Set up regular meetings where you teach each other words from your respective languages and use them to build sentences together. This mirrors the way the characters created a rudimentary shared language, and it can be a fun way to learn new linguistic concepts and cultural nuances.
  • Create a personal dictionary of foreign words that capture ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Carys Davies tackles communication, isolation and the Scottish Clearances in 'Clear'

Character development and relationships

The relationship between the characters in Carys Davies' narrative serves as a prime example of the personal and emotional bond that forms between two very different individuals brought together by circumstance.

The Characters' Isolation and Shared Vulnerability Facilitate a Connection

The connection between Ivar and Ferguson is rooted in their shared sense of isolation. Ivar, having lived alone on a remote island for years, meets Ferguson, an outsider to the island. This mutual isolation, compounded by the lack of everyday distractions, allows the men to confront their solitude directly. It is within this backdrop that an unexpected bond is formed.

Carys Davies underscores the fundamental role that their aloneness plays in forming their bond. The characters' shared experiences and the stark environment strip away superficial layers, forcing them to face elements of their lives they might otherwise avoid. Without the usual diversions of daily life, the two are almost compelled to connect on a deeper level.

The Deepening Relationship Defies Logical Explanation

Carys Davies notes the "mystery" inherent in the burgeoning relationship between Ivar and Ferguson. The logical reasons behind the depth of their rapport are not entirely clear, esp ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Character development and relationships

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While shared isolation can facilitate a deep connection, it is not the only pathway to forming strong relationships; people also bond over shared interests, values, or experiences in bustling communities.
  • The idea that isolation strips away superficial layers assumes that distractions are inherently superficial, which may not always be the case; daily life and its diversities can also provide meaningful contexts for relationships to develop.
  • The notion that the depth of Ivar and Ferguson's relationship defies logical explanation could be challenged by psychological theories that might provide insights into why and how such bonds form.
  • The text suggests that the characters' bond is a direct result of their isolation, but it is possible that their unique personalities and choices play a more significant role in their connection than the text acknowledges.
  • The assertion that human connections often transcend easy explanation might overlook the extensive research in social psychology that seeks to understand the dynamics of interpersonal relationships.
  • The implication that distractions are detrimental to forming deep connections could be countered by arguing that life's distractions can also ...

Actionables

  • You can explore the impact of isolation on personal growth by scheduling a "digital detox" weekend. Turn off your phone, computer, and other electronic devices for two days to remove everyday distractions. Use this time to engage in self-reflection, perhaps through journaling or meditation, to uncover and confront personal truths or challenges you might typically avoid.
  • Engage in a shared activity with someone that requires cooperation but minimal external input, like assembling a complex puzzle or building a piece of furniture without instructions. This encourages a focus on the interaction and communication between you two, potentially leading to a deeper understanding and connection as you work together to solve a problem.
  • Start a conversation club with a small gr ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA