Dive into the intricacies of asset allocation and the choice between funds and stocks with NerdWallet's Smart Money Podcast, hosted by Sean Pyles and Alana Benson. In this episode, the team takes a nuanced look at how to adjust your investment strategy to balance risk with potential rewards. They discuss the basic tenet of maintaining an asset mix aligned with one's risk tolerance and investment timeframe, extending from aggressive stock-heavy portfolios for the long-term investor to more conservative bond-focused strategies as retirement nears.
The episode further explores the pros and cons of investing in individual stocks versus investment funds, elaborating on the potential of stocks like NerdZone to generate profits or dividends versus their innate price volatility. Funds, on the other hand, are appraised for providing valuable diversification to cushion against individual asset failures. Additionally, the podcast breaks down the differences among ETFs, index funds, and mutual funds—providing a primer on their characteristics and potential impacts on investment expenses and strategy. Whether you're a seasoned investor or new to the market, this episode of NerdWallet's Smart Money Podcast presents an informative discussion on optimizing your investment choices.
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
Asset allocation serves as a risk mitigation technique in investment strategies, which is significantly influenced by individual circumstances such as the timeline to retirement and risk tolerance levels. Benson supports the idea that for individuals with a longer time horizon, a more aggressive allocation favoring stocks could be beneficial, suggesting an 80/20 split between stocks or stock funds and bonds. Rebalancing is highlighted as an essential measure to maintain one's preferred risk level over time. For example, if an initially desired 80/20 stock-to-bond allocation skews due to market performance, selling some stock holdings to rebalance back to the intended ratio is recommended.
Considering a person's retirement timeline is crucial, with Pyles pointing out that those closer to retirement should potentially adopt a more conservative allocation, heavily weighted towards lower-risk assets like bonds. Moreover, Benson stresses that asset allocation should align with personal risk tolerance, which can evolve with changes in financial circumstances and as individuals age.
The discussion differentiates between investments in individual stocks and investment funds, touching on the aspects of ownership benefits and price volatility associated with stocks, and the diversification and cost benefits offered by funds. Owning stocks, represented by the example of NerdZone, provides a form of company ownership and can lead to profit if the company's stock price increases, and by implication, can also yield dividends.
Stocks, however, carry the risk of volatile price changes and potential losses. The unpredictability of individual stock performance is evident from the contrasting destinies of companies like Amazon and Blockbuster.
Funds are promoted for their ability to diversify investments across various assets, which can help mitigate risk. This diversification reduces the impact of an individual investment's failure within the broader fund portfolio. Additionally, it allows easier investment in specific industries of interest and, indirectly, suggests benefits of lower expenses compared to the investment in high-priced individual stocks like Amazon.
Funds are further categorized, with ETFs highlighted for their trading nature on exchanges and attractively low expense ratios. Index funds are praised for their passivity and low cost, as they aim to replicate the performance of benchmark indexes like the S&P 500. Mutual funds, being actively managed, come with higher costs due to the expertise employed in seeking to beat market performance, in contrast to the passive approach of index funds.
1-Page Summary
Alana Benson and Sean Pyles provide insights into how appropriate asset allocation can reduce risk in investment strategies and how individual factors play a critical role in deciding asset distribution.
A strategy to reduce investment risk involves dividing investments across various asset classes, such as stocks and bonds. Alana Benson suggests that for someone with a longer time horizon until retirement, a riskier investment strategy could be beneficial. She proposes an initial allocation ratio of 80% in stocks or stock funds and 20% in bonds.
Benson further describes rebalancing as the process of adjusting investment holdings over time to align with one’s risk tolerance and financial goals. If stocks outperform and an investor’s stock allocation exceeds the targeted ratio (e.g., reaching 85% instead of the planned 80%), rebalancing by selling some stock holdings can help maintain the preferred 80/20 ratio.
When deciding on asset allocation, individual factors such as retirement timelines and risk tolerance are crucial to consider.
Sean Pyles mentions the importance of considering one’s timeline to retirement when determining asset allocation. The close ...
Asset Allocation
Benson and Pyles discuss the differences between investing in individual stocks and in various types of funds, emphasizing ownership benefits and volatility risks of stocks as well as the diversification benefits and lower expenses of funds.
Benson explains that purchasing stocks gives you a slice of ownership in a company. Using NerdZone, a hypothetical sock company, as an example, she illustrates that if you buy stock in NerdZone, you gain part ownership in the company. This allows you to benefit from increases in the company's stock price, potentially earning a profit from your investment.
While dividends were not directly discussed, having ownership in a company like NerdZone implies the potential to receive dividends, which are a form of profit sharing from the company's earnings.
Pyles addresses the risk associated with stocks by noting that they can be volatile and lead to losses. The future performance of stocks is unpredictable, illustrated with examples like the success of Amazon and the downfall of Blockbuster. This volatility means that the value of an individual stock investment can fluctuate significantly.
Investing in funds can mitigate risk through diversification, as funds hold a variety of assets such as stocks, bonds, and others. Benson emphasizes that diversifying across multiple industries, geographies, and company sizes is essential to withstand changes in the market. She also points out that if one investment, like Blockbuster, fails, the impact is lessened by investments in other companies within the fund.
Though not explicitly stated, the ability to invest in industries of interest is implied in the conversation about the benefits of diversification that funds offer.
While fund costs were not directly mentioned, the conversation suggests that funds can provide a more balanced portfolio and be easier to manage, indirectly implying lower costs in comparison to p ...
Funds vs. Stocks
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser