Podcasts > Navigating Narcissism with Dr. Ramani > Abandoned by a Narcissistic Father with Dr. Lily Dunn

Abandoned by a Narcissistic Father with Dr. Lily Dunn

By iHeartPodcasts

Join Dr. Ramani Durvasula as she delves into the poignant nuances of dealing with a narcissistic parent on "Navigating Narcissism with Dr. Ramani." Alongside guest Lily Dunn, they unpack the layered difficulties of maintaining love for a harmful parent. The conversation offers insight into Dunn’s personal confrontation with her father's abandonment and narcissistic traits—juggling the disparate feelings of affection, betrayal, and a yearning to be cared for. The podcast delves deep into the emotional landscape of resilience versus recognition of harm, laying bare the complexity of emotions faced by children of narcissistic parents and the identity shaped from such relationships.

The episode further explores how narcissistic parents can manipulate and sustain emotional attachments with their children using unpredictable kindness and unfulfilled promises. Dunn's candid sharing of her longing for a real connection illustrates the strong influence a narcissistic parent can wield. Dr. Ramani emphasizes the importance of facing the toxic dynamics to break away from this unhealthy bond. They also discuss the concept of "future faking," a certain manipulation that keeps the child hopeful, underscoring the emotional exploitation these parents can inflict. This leads to a broader examination of imminent intergenerational trauma, as Dunn contemplates her family's cycle of abandonment and how these deeply rooted behaviors challenge individuals seeking to confront and alter their familial narrative.

Listen to the original

Abandoned by a Narcissistic Father with Dr. Lily Dunn

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Sep 7, 2023 episode of the Navigating Narcissism with Dr. Ramani

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Abandoned by a Narcissistic Father with Dr. Lily Dunn

1-Page Summary

Struggle to accept a narcissistic parent as "bad"

Lily Dunn and Durvasula discuss the internal conflict of loving a parent who has been hurtful, highlighting the difficulty children face in acknowledging a parent's narcissism. Dunn's emotional turmoil stems from her father's abandonment and narcissistic behaviors, leading to a complex mix of love, betrayal, and a longing for care. Despite observing her father's charisma and weakness, she grapples with the negative impact of his actions and the confusion they brought since childhood. Durvasula further explains how children of narcissistic parents may feel resilient yet struggle to see their parent's behavior as detrimental, conflicted by the years of love and identity formed as their child.

The power of the narcissistic parent to manipulate attachment

Dunn describes the manipulative tactics her father used to keep her emotionally attached, such as unpredictable pleasant experiences and the carrot dangling of money and promises. Despite the hurtful pattern of her father's behavior, Dunn held on to a hope for an emotional connection, highlighting the powerful hold a narcissistic parent can have over their child. Durvasula emphasizes that children must confront their parent's toxic behavior to break free from this dependence. The concept of "future faking" is explored, where Dunn's father made grand but rarely fulfilled promises, which kept her hoping for a more genuine relationship and underlined the emotional manipulation exhibited by narcissistic parents.

The echoing intergenerational losses and traumas

Dunn reflects on the cyclical nature of abandonment and trauma within her family, starting with her father's own abandonment at a boarding school and his subsequent abandonment of his children. Despite her understanding of these patterns, Dunn experienced a similar situation when she separated from her children's father, inadvertently perpetuating the cycle of trauma at the same pivotal age. Durvasula and Dr. Lilly note that even with awareness, individuals can still fall victim to these destructive intergenerational patterns, indicating the resilience of such behaviors and the challenge in breaking free from the deep roots of familial trauma. Dunn's experience underlines how complex and entrenched intergenerational trauma can be, even for those who are aware of and seeking to change the pattern.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Future faking is a manipulative tactic where promises of a better future are made without genuine intent to follow through, keeping the recipient hopeful and emotionally attached. This behavior is often used by narcissistic individuals to maintain control and manipulate others' emotions. It involves creating false expectations and illusions of a positive outcome to keep the person engaged in the relationship or situation. The term highlights the deceptive nature of such promises and the impact they have on the individual's perception and emotional well-being.
  • Narcissistic behaviors and traits are characterized by a grandiose sense of self-importance, a constant need for admiration, and a lack of empathy for others. Individuals with narcissistic traits often exhibit manipulative and controlling behaviors to maintain their self-image and power over others. They may have fragile self-esteem masked by outward arrogance and may exploit relationships for personal gain. Understanding narcissistic behaviors can help recognize and navigate complex dynamics in relationships affected by such traits.
  • Narcissistic parents often use manipulative tactics to control their children, such as offering unpredictable positive experiences, making grand promises they rarely fulfill, and using emotional manipulation to maintain a hold over their child's emotions and actions. These tactics can create a sense of dependency and confusion in the child, making it challenging for them to break free from the toxic dynamic. The concept of "future faking" involves making promises of a better future to keep the child hopeful and engaged, despite the lack of genuine intention to follow through. Understanding these manipulative behaviors is crucial for children of narcissistic parents to recognize and address the unhealthy dynamics in their relationships.
  • Intergenerational trauma refers to the transmission of trauma and its effects across generations within a family. This trauma can manifest in various ways, impacting individuals' behaviors, relationships, and mental health. It highlights how experiences of trauma from past generations can influence the present and future well-being of family members. Understanding intergenerational trauma involves recognizing the complex interplay between historical events, family dynamics, and individual experiences.

Counterarguments

  • While acknowledging a parent's narcissism can be difficult, some individuals may not view their parent's behavior through the lens of clinical narcissism and may instead attribute it to personality flaws or other factors.
  • Emotional turmoil from a parent's abandonment and narcissistic behaviors can vary greatly among individuals, and some may find ways to cope or reconcile without experiencing long-term turmoil.
  • The conflict felt by children of narcissistic parents is not universal; some may come to terms with their parent's behavior more readily and move on without a lasting sense of conflict.
  • Not all children of narcissistic parents will hold on to hope for an emotional connection; some may recognize the unhealthy patterns early on and detach themselves emotionally to protect their well-being.
  • The concept of "future faking" is not exclusive to narcissistic parents and can be a behavior exhibited by individuals with various personality types or in different contexts.
  • The power of a narcissistic parent over their child can be mitigated by other supportive relationships in the child's life, such as with other family members, mentors, or therapists.
  • The cyclical nature of abandonment and trauma is not inevitable; some individuals break the cycle through conscious effort, therapy, and support systems.
  • Awareness of destructive intergenerational patterns does not necessarily mean an individual will fall victim to them; proactive measures and support can lead to positive change.
  • Breaking free from familial trauma, while challenging, is possible and has been achieved by many individuals through various means, including therapy, education, and personal growth.
  • Intergenerational trauma is a complex issue, but it is not an insurmountable one; resilience, healing, and transformation are possible for those affected.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Abandoned by a Narcissistic Father with Dr. Lily Dunn

Struggle to accept a narcissistic parent as "bad"

The challenging journey of acknowledging a parent's narcissism is explored by both Lily Dunn and Durvasula, illustrating the internal conflict of loving someone who is capable of deep hurt.

Pain of realizing you have a bad parent and what it says about yourself

Dunn reveals her struggle with her father's abandonment and narcissism, which causes significant emotional turmoil. She expresses the conflict within her, the desire to care for and protect someone who has been hurtful and unresponsive to her needs for care. Dunn also reflects on the pain and confusion from childhood, resulting in a heartfelt longing.

Durvasula adds to the conversation, explaining the complexity of emotions experienced when recognizing a parent's damaging behavior. She points out that having a narcissistic parent doesn't determine one's future but instead shows their resilience. Dunn grapples with the difficulty of seeing her father as needy, weak, and charismatic, which complicates the feelings of love and betrayal she endures.

Pedestal the narcissistic parent is placed on as a result of their unavailability and invalidation

Durvasula discusses how the need for attachment might evoke shame in a narcissistic parent, and a child's emotional expressions can be a reminder of the parent's shortcomings. The child's efforts to fulfill attachment needs are met with harmful interactions, contributing to the unavailability and invalidation that places the narcissistic parent on a pedestal.

As a result, Dunn admits it's hard to understand why she held on, indicating that the inherent yearning for her father's presence is due to a natural desire for connection. This struggle is exemplifi ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Struggle to accept a narcissistic parent as "bad"

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Narcissism in a parent-child relationship involves a parent displaying self-centered, manipulative, and emotionally abusive behaviors that prioritize their own needs over their child's well-being. This dynamic can lead to the child feeling neglected, invalidated, and constantly seeking the parent's approval. The narcissistic parent often struggles to provide emotional support, empathy, and genuine care to their child, creating a challenging environment for healthy emotional development. Children of narcissistic parents may experience confusion, self-doubt, and emotional distress due to the inconsistent and often damaging interactions with their parent.
  • When a child has a narcissistic parent, it can significantly impact their emotional well-being. The child may experience feelings of invalidation, neglect, and confusion due to the parent's self-centered behavior. This can lead to challenges in forming healthy relationships, low self-esteem, and difficulties in expressing emotions. Overall, growing up with a narcissistic parent can create long-lasting emotional scars that may require therapy and self-work to heal.
  • In the context of a narcissistic parent, attachment needs can trigger shame due to their own emotional limitations. The parent's inability to meet the child's attachment needs may evoke feelings of inadequacy and unworthiness in the parent. This can lead to a cycle where the child's attempts to seek emotional connection are met with invalidation, reinforcing the parent's sense of shame. Ultimately, this dynamic can contribute to the parent's unavailability and the child's emotional distress.
  • The internal conflict of loving a parent who is hurtful and unresponsive can be complex and emotionally challenging. It involves feelings of loyalty, attachment, and a deep-seated desire for parental love and approval despite the parent's negative behaviors. This conflict often stems from a mix of childhood conditioning, societal ...

Counterarguments

  • While Dunn's feelings are valid, it's important to consider that her father's behavior might stem from his own unresolved issues or mental health struggles, which could offer a different perspective on his actions.
  • The concept of a "bad" parent is subjective and can be influenced by cultural, societal, and personal values; what is considered harmful or narcissistic in one context may not be viewed the same way in another.
  • Durvasula's point about resilience could be expanded to acknowledge that some individuals may not feel resilient and might struggle with self-esteem or mental health issues as a result of their upbringing.
  • The idea that a child's emotional expressions can remind a narcissistic parent of their shortcomings could be seen as an oversimplification of complex parent-child dynamics and may not apply to all situations.
  • The narrative that a child places a narcissistic parent on a pedestal due to unavailability and invalidation might not capture the full range of reasons why children maintain attachments to their parents, including biological instincts, societal expectations, and hope for change.
  • The struggle to understand why one holds on to a relationship with an emotionally inaccessible parent could also be influenced by factors such as financial dependency, fear of abandonment, or lack of alternative support systems, not solely by a desire for connection.
  • The assertion that recognizing a parent's damaging behavior doesn't determine one's future might benefit from acknowledging that for some, the impact of a narcissistic parent can have long-lasting effects that do shape their future in significant ways.
  • The idea that seeing onesel ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Abandoned by a Narcissistic Father with Dr. Lily Dunn

The power of the narcissistic parent to manipulate attachment

Lily Dunn’s personal account provides insight into how a narcissistic parent can manipulate their children's attachment through a cycle of promises and emotional roller coasters.

The carrot dangling of money and promises to keep children attached

Even when starting her book, Dunn did not see her father as a cruel narcissist, highlighting the difficulty in recognizing the manipulative behavior of a narcissistic parent. Durvasula identifies her father's pattern of providing pleasant experiences unpredictably as typical to narcissistic relationships. Dunn shares how her father splurged on expensive items for her and her siblings but frequently withheld promised funds, leaving them chasing after him.

Lily Dunn’s lifelong hope for an emotional connection with her father stood in stark contrast to the pattern of betrayal and hurt that characterized their relationship. Dunn recounts feeling manipulated into believing they shared a special bond, despite evidence to the contrary. Durvasula stresses that only by confronting the parent for their toxic behavior can the child begin to break free from the emotional dependence.

The hope for emotional connection and "having" the narcissistic parent, despite repeated harm

Dunn speaks of the emotional highs and lows associated with her father's visits, which were characterized by a buildup of excitement followed by a period of winding down into sadness. Dunn’s cycle of anticipation for her father's affection and inevitable disappointment after each visit exhibits the emotional turbulence of a child yearning for connection with an unavailable parent.

The realization that her love could not transform her father's harmful behavior inflicted significant emotional harm on Dunn. Her need for emotional connection gave her father power over her, and this dynamic went unchanged, even as he was dying.

"Future faking" of grand promises that are rarely delivered

A key manipulation tactic used by Dunn's father was "future ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The power of the narcissistic parent to manipulate attachment

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • A narcissistic parent is someone who displays narcissistic traits, such as an excessive need for admiration and a lack of empathy, which can lead to manipulative behaviors. They often prioritize their own needs over their children's well-being, using tactics like manipulation, emotional abuse, and control to maintain power and influence over their children. This can result in a toxic dynamic where the child feels emotionally dependent on the parent, despite experiencing harm and betrayal. The manipulative behaviors of a narcissistic parent can create a cycle of emotional turmoil and instability for the child, impacting their sense of self-worth and emotional well-being.
  • "Future faking" is a manipulation tactic commonly used by narcissists to maintain control over others. It involves making grand promises or commitments with the intention of securing ongoing contact or emotional dependence, even though these promises are rarely fulfilled. This tactic creates false hope and keeps the victim engaged in the relationship, despite the lack of follow-through on the promises made. By dangling the prospect of a better future or fulfilling certain desires, the manipulator can keep the victim emotionally invested and under their influence.
  • Emotional dependence on a narcissistic parent often stems from a child's deep desire for love and approval from a parent who is emotionally unavailable or manipulative. This dependency can develop due to a child's longing for a meaningful connection with their parent, despite repeated disappointments and hurtful behavior. The narcissistic parent may use tactics like manipulation, false promises, and intermittent reinforcement to maintain control over the ...

Counterarguments

  • Narcissistic behavior is complex and can be interpreted in various ways; not all actions that seem manipulative are necessarily due to narcissism.
  • Some parents may unintentionally engage in behaviors that resemble "future faking" due to circumstances beyond their control, rather than a deliberate attempt to manipulate.
  • The concept of emotional manipulation can be subjective, and what one child perceives as manipulation, another might see as flawed yet genuine attempts at parenting.
  • The idea that confronting the narcissistic parent is crucial for breaking free may not be applicable or safe for everyone, and alternative coping strategies could be more effective for some individuals.
  • The cycle of anticipation and disappointment could also stem from the child's own psychological patterns and expectations, not solely from the parent's behavior.
  • The narrative may not account for the possibility of a narcissistic parent's capacity for change or the potential for positive aspects within the parent-child relationship.
  • The impact of a narcissistic parent on a child can vary greatly; some children may develop resilience and coping mechanisms that mitigate the long-term effects.
  • The term "narcissistic parent" is a clinical label that should be used cautiously, as it ca ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Abandoned by a Narcissistic Father with Dr. Lily Dunn

The echoing intergenerational losses and traumas

Lily Dunn sheds light on the painful repetition of abandonment and trauma that has reverberated through generations of her family.

Father abandoned by his parents to abusive boarding school at age 7; he abandoned his children at same milestone age

Dunn's father was sent to an abusive boarding school at the early age of seven, where he faced bullying and harsh treatment. This period of his life was so traumatic that he decided never to love his parents again. Years later, Dunn's father replicated this abandonment when he left Dunn and her brother around the same milestone age to join the Bhagwan Rajneesh Sanyasin cult, echoing the trauma he experienced as a child.

Divorce from child's father recreated traumatic split when she was the same age her dad left

Similar patterns of abandonment haunted the next generation, as well. Dunn recounts her own experience; despite her awareness of her family history, she inadvertently replicated the cycle of trauma. She separated from her children's father when her own children were about the same age as she and her father were when they experienced their familial splits. This parallel highlights the stubbornness of destructive intergenerational patterns.

Despite awareness, still falling victim to destructive intergenerational patterns

Even though Dunn is conscious of he ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The echoing intergenerational losses and traumas

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Narcissistic behavior patterns involve self-centeredness, a need for control, and a lack of empathy towards others, particularly in the context of parenting. This behavior can lead to emotional abuse, manipulation, and a focus on fulfilling the parent's needs over the child's well-being. I ...

Counterarguments

  • Awareness and understanding of intergenerational trauma can sometimes lead to breaking the cycle, as individuals may seek therapy or other interventions to change their behavior.
  • Not all individuals who experience childhood trauma will go on to replicate those patterns; some may become more empathetic and nurturing as a result of their experiences.
  • The narrative may oversimplify the complexity of human behavior by attributing actions directly to past traumas without considering other factors such as personal choice, resilience, and external support systems.
  • The concept of narcissistic behavior patterns being reinforced by childhood trauma is not universally accepted and may not apply to all individuals or situations.
  • The story of one family's experience with intergenerational trauma may not be generalizable to all families or cultures, as there are diverse responses to trauma based on a ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA