Podcasts > Myths and Legends > 355: Greek/Roman myth: There's Something About Ares

355: Greek/Roman myth: There's Something About Ares

By Jason Weiser, Carissa Weiser

Delve into the intricate tapestry of classical mythology with "Myths and Legends" as Jason and Carissa Weiser explore the transformative impact of Roman culture on Greek myths. Their discussion reveals how the Romans reimagined Greek stories through their own societal lens, resulting in fascinating variations that continue to shape our understanding of these ancient narratives. The podcast examines the extent to which Roman adaptations have left an indelible mark on the traditional roles and perceptions of revered mythic figures, showing the deep roots of Roman influences in the enduring legacy of classical lore.

In this episode, the speakers also engage with the eternal struggle of artists to balance realism with their search for a deeper truth, as exemplified by the enduring myth of Pygmalion. Addressing the figure of Ares, the Weisers reflect on the god’s symbolic representation of the darker, violent elements of human nature and society's complex relationship with its own belligerent inclinations. The conversation traverses the realms of art, love, and the essence of creative expression, offering insights into the mercurial relationship between mythological representation and the multifaceted human condition.

Listen to the original

355: Greek/Roman myth: There's Something About Ares

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Feb 7, 2024 episode of the Myths and Legends

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

355: Greek/Roman myth: There's Something About Ares

1-Page Summary

Roman Influence on Greek Myths

The Roman interpretations and adaptations of Greek myths have significantly altered the original narratives, leading to a nuanced relationship between Roman and Greek mythological traditions. Romans reshaped Greek legends through their cultural lens, effectively transforming the perception and roles of mythic figures over time. The Roman versions of Greek gods and stories persisted for centuries, demonstrating their lasting influence on classical mythology.

The role of the artist

Artists grapple with the challenge of choosing between producing works of strict realism or interpreting reality to reveal deeper truths. The myth of Pygmalion is a potent example of this creative tension, critiquing the artistic drive for lifelike representation. The tale of Pygmalion's love for his creation underscores the complexity in the artist's quest for perfect realism, and it highlights the nebulous boundary between artistic expression and the realistic entities it attempts to capture. This narrative serves as a historical commentary on the artist's position in society, addressing themes of creation, affection, and the delicate interplay between art and reality.

Ares and human nature

Ares symbolizes the destructive aspect of human nature, notably our propensity for violence. The general disdain for Ares in mythology reflects societal rejection of warfare and its associated brutality. However, the persistence of Ares as a mythic figure acknowledges the uncomfortable reality that violence is an inextricable part of humanity. The continuous presence of Ares in mythology, despite his negative reputation, points to an acknowledgment of humanity's warlike tendencies that are as despised as they are undeniable.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The nuanced relationship between Roman and Greek mythological traditions stems from the Roman reinterpretations and adaptations of Greek myths through their cultural lens. Romans reshaped Greek legends, altering the perception and roles of mythic figures over time. This interplay between the two traditions led to the persistence of Roman versions of Greek gods and stories for centuries, showcasing the lasting influence of Roman culture on classical mythology.
  • The myth of Pygmalion revolves around a sculptor who falls in love with his own creation, a statue brought to life by the goddess Aphrodite. This story highlights the tension between the artist's desire for perfection in their work and the blurred line between art and reality. It symbolizes the artist's pursuit of ideal beauty and the transformative power of art in bringing imagination to life. The myth serves as a commentary on the artist's struggle to balance realism with the idealized visions they seek to portray.
  • Ares, the Greek god of war, symbolizes the destructive and violent tendencies inherent in human nature. His character embodies the darker aspects of conflict, aggression, and the chaos that war brings. Through myths and stories, Ares serves as a personification of the brutal and aggressive side of humanity, reflecting the complexities and challenges of dealing with violence and warfare in society.

Counterarguments

  • While Roman interpretations of Greek myths did alter the narratives, it can be argued that they also preserved and disseminated Greek culture, acting as a bridge to later generations.
  • The Romans did not merely reshape Greek legends; they also contributed original ideas and gods to their mythology, which were not direct adaptations of Greek myths.
  • The influence of Roman versions of myths on classical mythology is significant, but it is also important to recognize the continued influence of the original Greek versions in modern times.
  • The dichotomy between strict realism and interpreting reality is not the only challenge artists face; they also contend with political, social, and personal influences on their work.
  • The myth of Pygmalion can also be interpreted as celebrating the power of imagination and the artist's ability to bring life to inanimate matter, rather than solely critiquing the pursuit of realism.
  • The themes addressed in the tale of Pygmalion are not limited to creation, affection, and art versus reality; they also include the nature of desire and the consequences of obsession.
  • Ares, while often associated with the destructive aspects of human nature, can also be seen as a representation of necessary force and the protection of community and nation, which are sometimes required for survival.
  • Societal rejection of warfare and brutality as reflected in the disdain for Ares is not universal; some cultures and historical periods have revered martial prowess and celebrated war gods.
  • The continuous presence of Ares in mythology could also be interpreted as a recognition of the complexity of human nature, which encompasses both creative and destructive impulses.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
355: Greek/Roman myth: There's Something About Ares

Roman Influence on Greek Myths

The intertwining of Roman and Greek myths reveals a complex relationship where Roman interpretations and adaptations of Greek legends have left a long-lasting impact on mythological narratives.

Mythical Backstories Created by Artists

Contrast between Ares and Mars

Dionysus highlights a fascinating transformation in the reception of a god when he moves from Greek to Roman mythology. The Greek god Ares, often despised for representing the brutal aspect of warfare, undergoes a remarkable rebranding in Roman culture. As the Roman god Mars, he is venerated for nearly a thousand years, loved for embodying martial valor and virtue.

Mythical Couples

Pygmalion and His Statue

The transcript touches on the tale of ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Roman Influence on Greek Myths

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The intertwining of Roman and Greek myths signifies the blending and interaction between the mythologies of ancient Rome and Greece. This connection involves the sharing, adaptation, and reinterpretation of gods, stories, and themes between the two cultures. Roman myths often drew inspiration from Greek mythology, incorporating Greek deities and narratives into their own belief system. This interplay between Roman and Greek myths has influenced art, literature, and cultural beliefs throughout history.
  • When a god transitions from Greek to Roman mythology, their characteristics and attributes can undergo significant changes due to cultural differences and societal values. This transformation often results in the deity being perceived and revered differently in the new cultural context, reflecting the unique interpretations and priorities of the Roman civilization compared to the Greek tradition.
  • The story of Pygmalion, a sculptor who falls in love with a statue he created, is a well-known myth from ancient Greek mythology. Ovid, a Roman poet, i ...

Counterarguments

  • While Roman interpretations of Greek myths are significant, it's important to recognize that the Greeks themselves continuously adapted and reinterpreted their own myths over time, so changes in narratives are not solely due to Roman influence.
  • The veneration of Mars in Roman culture does not necessarily imply that Ares was universally despised in Greek culture; different city-states and writers had varying perspectives on the gods, and Ares had his own temples and devotees in Greece.
  • The enrichment of the Pygmalion sto ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
355: Greek/Roman myth: There's Something About Ares

The role of the artist

The discourse around the role of an artist often lands at the intersection of representing realism and interpreting reality.

Realism vs reality

In the pursuit of their craft, artists may strive to depict realism, faithfully reproducing the visual world, or they may choose to convey reality through a more subjective lens, capturing the essence or underlying truths behind the facade of the physical world.

Pygmalion myth as criticism

The Pygmalion myth serves as a critique of these artistic endeavors. It raises questions about the nature of creation and the creator's relationship with their work. The myth suggests that an artist's pursuit to perfectly replicate realism—in thi ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The role of the artist

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The statement highlights how artists navigate between portraying realism, aiming for accurate visual representation, and interpreting reality, capturing deeper truths and meanings beyond surface appearances. Artists often balance these two approaches in their work, deciding whether to focus on faithfully depicting the physical world or conveying abstract concepts and emotions. This intersection reflects the ongoing debate within the art world about the purpose and impact of artistic expression.
  • The Pygmalion myth, originating from ancient Greek mythology, tells the story of a sculptor who falls in love with his own creation, a statue he crafted. This myth is often interpreted as a reflection on the relationship between art and reality, exploring themes of artistic creation, idealization, and the blurred lines between the artist's work and the real world. It raises questions about the nature of artistic representation and the emotional connection artists may develop with their creations. The myth serves as a cautionary tale about the potential consequences of blurring the boundaries between art and life.
  • The phrase "the nature of creation and the creator's relationship with their work" delves into the fundamental aspects of how artists bring their creations to life and the emotional, intellectual, and personal connections they form with their art. It explores the intricate process of transforming ideas and concepts into tangible forms of expression, highlighting the deep bond artists often develop ...

Counterarguments

  • The distinction between realism and reality in art is not always clear-cut, and many artists integrate both elements in their work, challenging the binary opposition of the two concepts.
  • The Pygmalion myth can also be interpreted as a celebration of the artist's skill and the power of imagination, rather than solely as a critique of the pursuit of realism.
  • The role of the artist is not limited to the dichotomy of imitation versus creation; artists also serve as innovators, educators, activists, and cultural commentators, which the text does not address.
  • The impact of an artist's work is not solely determined by their intention to replicate or interpret reality but also by the audience's perception and the co ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
355: Greek/Roman myth: There's Something About Ares

Ares and human nature

Reflection of the uglier aspects of humanity

Ares as a reflection of violence

Ares, the god of war, serves as a stark embodiment of the uglier aspects of humanity, particularly our inclination towards violence. The sentiment that "everyone hates Ares" speaks volumes about the aversion people have to the war god, which may mirror their disdain for the violence he represents. Despite this widespread detestation, the unavoidable truth that the pod ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Ares and human nature

Additional Materials

Clarifications

...

Counterarguments

  • Ares could also be seen as a symbol of necessary force and protection, not just mindless violence, reflecting the complexity of human nature.
  • The idea that "everyone hates Ares" might be an overgeneralization; different cultures and individuals have varied perspectives on war deities.
  • Human nature is multifaceted, and focusing solely on Ares overlooks the many other aspects of humanity that gods and myths represent, such as love, wisdom, and justice.
  • The interpretation of Ares as an embodiment of humanity's darker side could be influenced by cultural biases, particularly from sources that vilify him, rather than a balanced view of historic ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA