She put his head in a bucket?! WTF is wrong with Taylor Schabusiness!! | Mystery & Makeup
Dive into the chilling intersection of true crime and beauty with Bailey Sarian's unique podcast, 'Murder, Mystery & Makeup.' In this gripping episode, Bailey unveils the shocking case from Green Bay that left a community reeling. With her distinctive approach, Sarian discusses the chilling details of a grizzly murder amidst her captivating makeup tutorial, crafting an unforgettable narrative that holds listeners spellbound.
From the harrowing discovery of a severed head to the arresting courtroom drama, Bailey narrates the disturbing tale of Taylor Coronado, aka Taylor Schabusiness, and her tragic life trajectory. As Sarian paints both her face and a vivid picture of methamphetamine's dark influence on lives, she delves into the depths of human behavior, touching upon the role of mental health in criminal responsibility. The listeners are left with a haunting reflection on the complexities behind the brutal acts and a call to engage in a broader conversation about the intersection of crime, punishment, and psychological issues.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Oct 16, 2023 episode of the Murder, Mystery & Makeup
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
Introduction to 'Murder, Mystery, and Makeup'
Unveiling Bailey Sarian's Unique Show Format
Bailey Sarian hosts 'Murder, Mystery, and Makeup Monday,' where she merges her interests by discussing true crime stories during makeup tutorials.
Gruesome Discovery in Green Bay
The Heinous Crime: Unraveling the Initial Case Details
In one episode, she shares a harrowing account from Green Bay, Wisconsin, involving a disturbing murder and the impact of the city's methamphetamine problem. Bailey describes the case that unfolded on February 23, 2022, when a man named Steve called emergency services, reporting that his partner Tara was distressed over her son's decapitated head supposedly being in a bucket in the basement. As police arrived, Tara was incoherent with distress, but Officer Alex Blanish discovered the gruesome truth in their basement—a severed head concealed by a beach towel, a bloodied mattress, and proof that the head belonged to Tara's son, Shad.
Tragic Trajectory: The Life of Taylor Schabusiness
From Loss to Lawlessness: Taylor's Early Life and Struggles
Bailey narrates Taylor Schabusiness's life, revealing her real name as Taylor Coronado and recounting the trauma of losing her mother Marla to alcohol-induced cirrhosis at age eleven and her father Arturo's swift remarriage. The loss led Taylor to exhibit behavioral challenges, including school fights and an attempted suicide.
A Descent Into Darkness: Taylor's Decline and Drug Abuse
Despite medication for mental health issues, Taylor's problems persisted, resulting in expulsion and a move to Texas. Her return to Green Bay at nineteen marked a descent into heavy drug use, including meth, her tumultuous relationship with her romantic partner and meth dealer, Warren Shabow, characterized by infidelity and manipulation.
The Fateful Relationship and Heinous Act
Dysfunctional Dynamics: Taylor and Shad's Lethal Bond
Bailey Sarian curates a disturbing scene where Shad, under the influence of methamphetamines, encourages Taylor to use dog choke collars to enhance their experience. Following Shad's death, Taylor, driven by a morbid quest for pleasure, engaged in necrophilic acts with his body.
The Murder That Shocked the Community: Details of the Crime
Officer Wanish encountered a scene of extreme dismemberment; Shad's body was mutilated, his limbs and head found in bloody bags. The disturbing nature of the crime was indicated by blood patterns and drug paraphernalia present at the scene.
The Arrest and Investigation
Macabre Revelations: Arresting Taylor Schabusiness
Taylor's frenzied state led to a panicked attempt to clean up the gruesome tableau, but exhaustion and hunger impeded her. The discovery was made by Shad's mother Tara, who alerted the authorities, leading to Taylor's arrest as police located her through footprints in the snow.
Chilling Confession: Taylor's Account of the Dismemberment
Taylor detailed her methods of severing and dismembering Shad's body to the police, describing the actions and the drugs' hallucinogenic effects that made her perceive his limbs as regenerating.
Legal Battles and Courtroom Drama
Judicial Process: Taylor's Competency and Trial Behavior
Taylor was discovered with bloodied clothing and detained, leading to the find of Shad's remains. In custody, she exhibited strange and detached behavior. Despite Taylor attacking her lawyer and demonstrating odd behavior, the judge deemed her competent to stand trial.
Evidence and Sentencing: The Jury's Verdict and Aftermath
Bailey discusses Taylor's courtroom behavior and legal interpretations, leading to Taylor's swift conviction by a jury on all charges, resulting in a mandatory life sentence.
Mental Health and Criminal Responsibility
Analyzing the Role of Psychological Issues in the Trial
The jury took note of Taylor's internet search history and testimonies shaping the courtroom narrative. Their verdict reflected the legal stance on criminal actions even when mental illness or drug use is involved.
The Debate: Should Mental Health Have Graver Consideration?
Sarian touches upon Warren Shabow's social media activities and reflects on the crime’s brutality, questioning whether mental health issues should have weighed more heavily in Taylor's trial.
Reflections and Concluding Thoughts
Beyond the Case: Engagement and Opinions from the Audience
Sarian closes the episode by inviting listeners to ponder the case's complexities and encourages the audience to stay safe and make good choices. She solicits interest in the beauty products featured during the episode.
A Call for Awareness: Bailey Sarian's Parting Message
Bailey Sarian asks for future story suggestions and wishes her audience well, urging them to express their opinions on the complexities of the Taylor Schabusiness case.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- Bailey Sarian's unique show format involves discussing true crime stories while simultaneously doing makeup tutorials. This combination of true crime narration and makeup application has garnered a significant following on her platform. Sarian's approach blends storytelling with beauty content, creating a distinctive and engaging viewing experience for her audience. The juxtaposition of these seemingly unrelated topics has sparked interest and intrigue among viewers, contributing to the show's popularity.
- Bailey Sarian discusses a murder case in Green Bay involving Taylor Schabusiness and Shad. The case unfolds with a disturbing discovery of a severed head in a basement, leading to the unraveling of a gruesome crime scene. The characters involved include Taylor, Shad, Tara, and Officer Alex Blanish. The discovery of the severed head and other evidence paints a chilling picture of the crime.
- Taylor Schabusiness, originally named Taylor Coronado, faced significant challenges after losing her mother to alcohol-induced cirrhosis at a young age. This loss led to behavioral issues and struggles with mental health, eventually leading to heavy drug use, including methamphetamine. Her relationship with Shad involved disturbing dynamics, including drug-fueled activities and ultimately culminated in a heinous crime that shocked the community.
- After Shad's death, Taylor engaged in necrophilic acts, which involve sexual activities with a deceased person's body. This behavior is considered taboo and highly disturbing in society due to its extreme nature. Necrophilia is a rare and abnormal paraphilic disorder that is often associated with psychological issues and criminal behavior. Taylor's actions post-mortem were a significant factor in the legal proceedings and the public's shock surrounding the case.
- Taylor Schabusiness was arrested after her attempt to clean up the crime scene was interrupted by exhaustion and hunger. During her confession to the police, she described in detail the dismemberment of Shad's body and mentioned hallucinogenic effects from drugs. In custody, Taylor exhibited strange and detached behavior, including attacking her lawyer. Despite her behavior, the judge deemed her competent to stand trial, where she was swiftly convicted and sentenced to life in prison.
- Taylor's competency evaluation assessed her mental state to determine if she was capable of understanding the legal proceedings and assisting in her defense. Despite exhibiting unusual behavior, the judge found her competent to stand trial. Taylor's sentencing resulted in a mandatory life sentence after she was convicted on all charges by a jury. The legal process involved considerations of evidence, courtroom behavior, and the impact of mental health issues on criminal responsibility.
- Consideration of mental health issues and drug use in a trial involves assessing how these factors may have influenced a defendant's actions and state of mind at the time of the crime. This evaluation can impact legal proceedings by influencing the determination of criminal responsibility and sentencing. The court may consider evidence of mental illness or substance abuse when determining a defendant's culpability. Ultimately, the presence of mental health issues or drug use can be significant in shaping the legal outcome of a trial.
- Bailey Sarian's reflections at the end of her episodes involve summarizing the case discussed, inviting audience opinions, and encouraging reflection on the complexities of the story. Her prompts for audience engagement typically include asking for future story suggestions and well wishes for her viewers.
Counterarguments
- The format of discussing true crime stories during makeup tutorials could be seen as trivializing serious and sensitive issues.
- The show's focus on gruesome details may sensationalize violence and could be distressing for some viewers or those personally connected to the cases.
- The narrative might not fully capture the complexity of mental health issues and their impact on criminal behavior.
- The show could potentially bias the audience against the accused by presenting the story in a certain light before the legal process is fully resolved.
- The discussion of the case on such a platform might not provide a balanced perspective, as it primarily entertains rather than informs.
- The invitation for audience engagement on such serious topics could lead to uninformed opinions and speculation that might not contribute to a constructive conversation.
- The call for story suggestions could inadvertently encourage the glamorization of crime stories for entertainment purposes.
Learn more
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Introduction to 'Murder, Mystery, and Makeup'
Unveiling Bailey Sarian's Unique Show Format
Bailey Sarian hosts 'Murder, Mystery, and Makeup Monday,' where she merges her interests by discussing true crime stories during makeup tutorials.
As a conscientious host, she begins her episodes with a content warni ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Introduction to 'Murder, Mystery, and Makeup'
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- Bailey Sarian's show 'Murder, Mystery, and Makeup Monday' combines true crime storytelling with makeup tutorials. In each episode, she delves into a different true crime case while simultaneously doing her makeup. Sarian's unique format involves discussing the details of the case, providing her insights, and engaging with her audience. The show offers a blend of entertainment, education, and creativity, catering to viewers interested in both true crime and makeup content.
- Bailey Sarian merges true crime stories with makeup tutorials by narrating the details of real-life criminal cases while applying makeup. This unique format combines storytelling with the visual element of makeup application, creating an engaging and unexpected viewing experience. Sarian's approach involves discussing the cases in a respectful and informative manner, ensuring that the focus remains on the storytelling rather than the makeup itself. The juxtaposition of true crime narratives with the typically light-hearted nature of makeup tutorials adds a layer of intrigue and complexity to her content.
- Bailey Sarian starts each episode with a content warning to alert viewers about the graphic and disturbing nature of the true crime stories she discusses. This warning serves to prepare the audience for potentially distressing content and allows them to make an informed decision about whether to continue watching. It demonstrates her consideration for the emotional well-being of her viewers and ensures they can engage with the content responsibly. The content warning ...
Counterarguments
- While Bailey Sarian does provide a content warning, some might argue that discussing violent crimes in a casual setting like a makeup tutorial could be seen as trivializing the seriousness of the crimes.
- There could be a concern that the format of 'Murder, Mystery, and Makeup Monday' might not be respectful to the victims and their families, as it combines entertainment with real-life tragedies.
- Some viewers might feel that the show's format is inappropriate, as it juxtaposes the lighthearted activity of applying makeup with the dark themes of murder and crime.
- The show's unique format might not be to everyone's t ...
Learn more
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Gruesome Discovery in Green Bay
The Heinous Crime: Unraveling the Initial Case Details
The scene described in the basement was one of chaos, with blood patterns smeared in swirls on the floor, appearing as though someone had attempted a frantic but aborted cleanup. An assortment of blood-stained knives was scattered around the area, with the collection ranging from kitchen utensils to a specifically mentioned bread knife, indicating the use of common household items as weapons in the crime.
Most disturbingly, multiple bags were found, each containing various dismembered body parts and internal organs, showcasing the perpetrator's gruesome thoroughness.
...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Gruesome Discovery in Green Bay
Additional Materials
Clarifications
...
Counterarguments
...
Learn more
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Tragic Trajectory: The Life of Taylor Schabusiness
From Loss to Lawlessness: Taylor's Early Life and Struggles
Bailey narrates Taylor Schabusiness's life, once known as Taylor Coronado, delving into her early semblance of middle-class normality before facing the trauma of her mother Marla's death due to alcohol-induced cirrhosis at age eleven. The premature death shook her world deeply.
Her behavior became a challenge, with early signs attributed to adolescent mood swings. A critical point came with an attempted suicide at age 12, revealing deep-seated issues that beckoned for professional intervention.
The difficulties in Taylor's life were compounded by her husband's incarceration for methamphetamine distribution.
A Descent Into Darkness: Taylor's Decline and Drug Abuse
Bailey narrates Taylor Schabusiness's life, once known as Taylor Coronado, delving into her early semblance of middle-class normality before facing the trauma of her ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Tragic Trajectory: The Life of Taylor Schabusiness
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- The text discusses Taylor Schabusiness's life events, including her mother's death, her suicide attempt at age 12, and her husband's incarceration for drug distribution. The timeline is not explicitly clear, but it suggests a sequence of traumatic events shaping Taylor's life from childhood to adulthood.
- Taylor Schabusiness's struggles following her mother's death are linked to the profound emotional impact of losing a parent at a young age, which can lead to significant psychological challenges. The trauma of her mother's death may have triggered a downward spiral in Taylor's mental health, contributing to her subsequent struggles and risky behaviors. This traumatic event could have intensified existing vulnerabilities and contributed to her difficulties in coping with life's challenges. The loss of her mother may have disrupted Taylor's sense of stability and security, leading to a period of turmoil and distress in her life.
- Taylor's husband's incarceration for methamphetamine distribution is a significant event in her life that impacted her deeply. This sudden mention highlights a key aspect of Taylor's struggles and the challenges she faced due to her husband's actions. The incarc ...
Counterarguments
...
Learn more
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
The Fateful Relationship and Heinous Act
Dysfunctional Dynamics: Taylor and Shad's Lethal Bond
Bailey Sarian paints a disturbing portrait of the relationship between Taylor and Shad, highlighting their shared history of methamphetamine use.
A particularly risky consensual activity both found pleasurable was their engagement in erotic asphyxiation, which on a fateful occasion was intensified by the introduction of dog choke collars suggested by Shad. This detail underscores the dangerous and escalating nature of their bond.
The Murder That Shocked the Community: Details of the Crime
In a chilling recount based on Taylor's drug-affected confession, Bailey Sarian delineates the grim twist in Taylor and Shad's sexual encounters. As Taylor constricted the dog choke collar around Shad's neck, she was consumed by an obsession with the visible changes in his complexion and the morbid pleasure she derived from the necrophilic acts that followed.
Despite observing signs of grave danger such as Shad expelling blood and ex ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
The Fateful Relationship and Heinous Act
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- Erotic asphyxiation is a sexual practice involving deliberate oxygen restriction to enhance arousal. It can be dangerous and even fatal due to the risks associated with oxygen deprivation. This activity is considered a paraphilia, a type of sexual interest classified by mental health professionals. The practice has historical roots dating back to the 17th century.
- Necrophilic acts involve sexual attraction or engagement with corpses. This behavior is considered a paraphilia by mental health diagnostic manuals. It has historical roots and has been sporadically documented throughout history.
- Taylor's cognitive disorientation suggests a state where her mental processes, such as thinking, perception, and awareness, were significantly disturbed or confused. This could hav ...
Counterarguments
...
Learn more
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
The Arrest and Investigation
Macabre Revelations: Arresting Taylor Schabusiness
Taylor's frenzied state led to a panicked attempt to clean up the gruesome tableau, but exhaustion and hunger impeded her. The discovery was made by Shad's mother Tara who alerted the authorities, leading to Taylor's arrest as police tracked her through footprints in the snow.
She was found garbed in black and made up with cosmetics, an eerie composure about her despite the blood stains on her clothing which led the police to her van. Crucial evidence linked her to the crime scene, with traces of blood leading from a van, inside which was a crockpot box and presumably dirty clothes, directly to Taylor's residence.
Shortly thereafter, Taylor was apprehended outside her apartment, her startled reaction immortalized on the officers' body cameras.
Chilling Confession: Taylor's Account of the Dismemberment
During the interrogation, Taylor detailed her methods of severing and dismembering Shad's body to the police, where her bizarre mix of forge ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
The Arrest and Investigation
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- A "gruesome tableau" typically refers to a scene or situation that is shockingly unpleasant, often involving violence, death, or horror. It describes a disturbing or horrifying display that evokes strong emotions of fear, disgust, or revulsion. In this context, it suggests a disturbing and unsettling sight that Taylor Schabusiness attempted to clean up after a violent incident.
- Taylor being "garbed in black and made up with cosmetics" suggests that she was dressed in dark clothing and had applied makeup to her face. This detail could indicate an intentional choice of attire and appearance, possibly to conceal her emotions or create a specific impression. The use of cosmetics might have been a deliberate effort to present herself in a certain way during the events described.
- "Eerie composure" in this context describes Taylor's unsettling calmness and self-possession despite being in a situation that would typically evoke fear or distress. It suggests a disturbing contrast between her outward demeanor and the gruesome circumstances surrounding her arrest.
- Traces of blood leading from a van suggest that there were visible marks or stains of blood originating from the van and extending towards another location, indicating a potential path of movement or transfer of blood. This detail could be crucial evidence in linking the van to the crime scene or the suspect's actions. The presence of such traces could help investigators establish a connection between the vehicle and the events under investigation. The blood trail from the van might have played a significant role in the investigation and in understanding the sequence of events related to the case.
- Apprehended outside her apartment: Taylor was captured by the authorities near her residence, just outside the building where she lived. This means she was taken into custody by law enforcement officers in close proximity to her home.
- The phrase "startled reaction immortalized on the officers' body cameras" means that the police officers captured Taylor's surprised response to her arrest on their body-worn cameras, preserving the moment as video evidence. This recording could be crucial for documenting her initial behavior and demeanor during the arrest. The use of body cameras by law enforcement is common practice to record interactions with suspects and ensure transparency in police activities. The footage ...
Counterarguments
...
Learn more
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Legal Battles and Courtroom Drama
Judicial Process: Taylor's Competency and Trial Behavior
Taylor was discovered with bloodied clothing and detained by authorities. The evidence found at her residence provided clear indications of her involvement in the crime.
Taylor's unusual demeanor in the courtroom, which included inappropriate laughter and an apparent fixation with the courtroom cameras, was noted as particularly concerning. Despite this and the violence she directed towards her lawyer, the judge deemed her competent to stand trial.
Evidence and Sentencing: The Jury's Verdict and Aftermath
Bailey discusses Taylor's courtroom behavior and legal interpretations, leading to Taylor's swift conviction by a jury on all charges, resulting in a mandatory life sente ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Legal Battles and Courtroom Drama
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- Taylor's unusual behavior in the courtroom, such as inappropriate laughter and a fixation with the cameras, raised concerns about her mental state and demeanor during the trial. Despite these behaviors and reports of violence towards her lawyer, the judge ruled her competent to stand trial, indicating that her actions did not render her unable to participate in the legal proceedings.
- Warren Shabow is Tay ...
Counterarguments
- The presence of bloodied clothing and evidence at Taylor's residence may suggest her involvement, but it does not conclusively prove her guilt without considering other explanations or the possibility of evidence being planted or misinterpreted.
- Taylor's unusual behavior in the courtroom could be a sign of a mental health issue or extreme stress, which might call into question the judge's assessment of her competency to stand trial.
- The judge's decision to deem Taylor competent to stand trial despite her behavior could be challenged if there were not a thorough psychiatric evaluation to support the decision.
- The jury's swift conviction could be criticized for potentially being influenced by Taylor's courtroom behavior rather than solely the evidence presented, raising concerns about the fairness of the trial.
- The mandatory life sentence could be seen as overly harsh if there were mitigating circumstances or if Taylor's mental state at the time of the crime was not adequately considered.
- Warren Shabow's use ...
Learn more
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Mental Health and Criminal Responsibility
Analyzing the Role of Psychological Issues in the Trial
The jury took note of Taylor's internet search history and testimonies shaping the courtroom narrative. Their verdict reflected the legal stance that mental illness aggravated by drug use does not excuse criminal actions.
This stance is one that Sarian later echoed in her analysis.
The Debate: Should Mental Health Have Graver Consideration?
Sarian touches upon Warren Shabow's social media activities and reflects on the crime’s brutality, questioning whether mental health issues should have weighed more heavily in Taylor's trial ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Mental Health and Criminal Responsibility
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- In legal terms, mental illness aggravated by drug use is generally not considered a complete defense for criminal actions. Courts often require a high threshold of proof to establish that a defendant's mental health significantly impacted their ability to understand the nature or consequences of their actions. The legal system typically balances the need for accountability with considerations for me ...
Counterarguments
- Mental illness and drug use can impair judgment and decision-making, potentially mitigating criminal responsibility.
- The legal system may need to better integrate mental health evaluations into the determination of criminal responsibility.
- The rarity of such crimes by women should not influence the legal assessment of an individual's actions.
- The severity of a crime should not overshadow the need to consider the defendant's mental state during the trial.
- Social media activities may not always provide a complete or accurate picture of an individual's mental health.
- There could be a need for more nuanced legal frameworks that balance accountability with the appropriate treatment for mental health i ...
Learn more
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Reflections and Concluding Thoughts
Beyond the Case: Engagement and Opinions from the Audience
Sarian closes the episode by inviting listeners to ponder the case's complexities. She encourages the audience not just to stay safe and make good choices but also to suggest future stories for discussion, showing her commitment to audience engagement and interest in their perspectives.
A Call for Awareness: Bailey Sarian's Parting Mes ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Reflections and Concluding Thoughts
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- Bailey Sarian is a popular YouTuber known for her "Murder, Mystery, and Makeup" series where she discusses true crime cases while doing her makeup. In her videos, she delves into various criminal cases, providing he ...
Counterarguments
...
Learn more
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
1-Page Summary- Introduction to 'Murder, Mystery, and Makeup'
- Gruesome Discovery in Green Bay
- Tragic Trajectory: The Life of Taylor Schabusiness
- The Fateful Relationship and Heinous Act
- The Arrest and Investigation
- Legal Battles and Courtroom Drama
- Mental Health and Criminal Responsibility
- Reflections and Concluding Thoughts
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
