Podcasts > Morning Wire > What's Behind Europe’s Surge to the Right? | Sunday Extra

What's Behind Europe’s Surge to the Right? | Sunday Extra

By The Daily Wire

The latest European parliamentary elections saw a surge in support for right-wing, conservative, and populist parties across the continent. While these political forces secured surprising victories in nations like Italy, France, and Germany, left-leaning socialist and green parties experienced major losses.

The Morning Wire podcast explores the key factors driving this rightward shift, including concerns over mass migration, rejection of "left-wing elitism" and costly climate policies, as well as growing Euroscepticism and demands to curb EU power. The episode also examines the potential implications of this political realignment, such as its effect on immigration, economic, and environmental policymaking within the EU—changes that could strain transatlantic relations on global issues.

Listen to the original

What's Behind Europe’s Surge to the Right? | Sunday Extra

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Jun 16, 2024 episode of the Morning Wire

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

What's Behind Europe’s Surge to the Right? | Sunday Extra

1-Page Summary

Conservative and Populist Gains in Europe

In the recent European parliamentary elections, conservative and populist parties achieved significant gains across the continent, largely at the expense of left-leaning political forces.

Right-Wing Electoral Victories

According to the summary, right-wing and nationalist parties secured surprising victories, with substantial vote shares in Italy, France, and Germany. Italy's Brothers of Italy party quadrupled its support base, the summary reports. Similarly, Marine Le Pen's National Rally in France received over 30% of the vote, nearly double that of President Macron's party. In Germany, the right-wing AfD gained close to 20% of the European vote.

Left-Wing and Green Party Losses

Meanwhile, the summary notes that ruling socialist and green parties suffered major losses, contributing to a wider political shift away from left-wing dominance. French President Macron's party received only about 15% of votes, and Germany's ruling socialists led by Scholz attracted roughly 14% of the vote, with the German Green Party securing about 12%.

Driving Forces Behind the Shift

The summary identifies several underlying factors motivating the political change:

  • Concerns over mass migration and threats to cultural identity, with voters seeking tighter border controls and a crackdown on migrant-related issues, according to the summary.

  • Rejection of "left-wing elitism" and opposition to costly green policies like net zero emissions targets, the summary states.

  • Growing Euroscepticism and desire to limit the power of EU institutions, as conservative parties aim to preserve national sovereignty, the summary reports.

Potential Implications

The summary suggests the European election results could make the Biden administration uneasy, as sentiments driving the right-wing pivot resonate with some American voters as well.

Additionally, the rightward shift could significantly impact EU policymaking on immigration, the economy, and the environment, potentially straining transatlantic relations on global issues like climate change, the summary notes.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The rise of right-wing parties may not necessarily reflect a broad societal shift but could be the result of specific local issues or dissatisfaction with the current government's performance.
  • The success of the Brothers of Italy and other similar parties could be attributed to effective campaigning and political strategy rather than a wholesale endorsement of their policies by the electorate.
  • The reported losses for left-wing and green parties might not account for the complexities of coalition politics in Europe, where smaller parties can still wield significant influence.
  • The interpretation of the election results as a rejection of "left-wing elitism" could be an oversimplification, ignoring other factors such as economic concerns or the personal appeal of candidates.
  • Concerns over mass migration and cultural identity might be overstated or influenced by media narratives, and not all voters who support tighter border controls necessarily do so for cultural or identity reasons.
  • Euroscepticism and the desire to limit EU power could be driven by a variety of factors, including economic concerns and a desire for local governance, rather than a straightforward opposition to the EU.
  • The impact on the Biden administration and transatlantic relations may be more nuanced, with room for negotiation and compromise on various issues.
  • The shift in the European Parliament might not have a uniform impact on EU policymaking, as the EU operates on a consensus basis and many policies require the agreement of multiple institutions and member states.

Actionables

  • You can deepen your understanding of political shifts by starting a journal to track and analyze political trends in your own country. Write down any significant political events, election results, or policy changes, and reflect on how they might mirror the trends mentioned, such as shifts to the right or changes in public sentiment towards immigration and environmental policies. This will help you recognize patterns and understand the underlying causes of political movements.
  • Engage in conversations with peers from different political backgrounds to explore the impact of political changes on everyday life. Approach these discussions with an open mind, aiming to understand their perspectives on issues like national sovereignty, immigration, and environmental policies. This exchange of views can offer a more nuanced understanding of the political landscape and its effects on various communities.
  • Volunteer with a local organization that works on issues related to immigration, the environment, or national sovereignty to see firsthand the impact of policies and public sentiment. Through volunteering, you'll gain practical experience and insight into how these issues are managed at the community level, which can inform your perspective on the broader political trends and their local implications.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
What's Behind Europe’s Surge to the Right? | Sunday Extra

Results and outcomes of the recent European parliamentary elections

The recent European parliamentary elections have marked a significant shift in the continental political landscape, demonstrating a clear move toward conservative and populist parties.

Conservative and populist parties gained major ground across Europe, largely at the expense of left-leaning political forces

The elections resulted in what some are calling a political earthquake, with a pronounced rejection of the socialist ruling elites who have dominated much of Europe’s political scene. Conservative parties celebrated resounding victories in several countries, which indicated a wider political shift away from left-wing dominance.

Right-wing and nationalist parties secured surprising victories, with significant vote shares in countries like Italy, France, and Germany

Right-wing and nationalist parties across Europe such as Brothers of Italy and National Rally in France have seen an upsurge in support. These groups campaigned on securing borders and limiting migration, a stance that resonated with a substantial portion of the electorate. In specific terms, Brothers of Italy quadrupled its support, while National Rally managed to double the vote share of President Macron’s party.

In Germany, the AfD also made significant gains, securing close to 20% of the vote, while the Christian Democrats commanded nearly a third of the vote, reinforcing the trend toward conservative politics.

Ruling socialist and green parties suffered major losses, contributing to a wider political shift away from left-wing dominance

The ruling socia ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Results and outcomes of the recent European parliamentary elections

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The shift towards conservative and populist parties may not necessarily reflect a continental trend, as voter turnout and regional differences can significantly impact election results.
  • The success of conservative and populist parties could be a cyclical reaction to current events rather than a long-term ideological shift.
  • The framing of the election as a rejection of socialist elites may oversimplify complex voter motivations, which can include economic concerns, security issues, and individual party policies.
  • The increase in support for right-wing and nationalist parties might be attributed to a variety of factors, not solely their stance on borders and migration.
  • The results for parties like Brothers of Italy and National Rally could be influenced by local political dynamics and personalities, rather than a broad continental shift.
  • The performance of the AfD in Germany and the Christian Democrats may reflect specific national issues or the effectiveness of their campaigns rather than a general conservative surge.
  • The losses suffered by socialist and green parties might be due to internal party issues or leadership challenges, rather than a wholesale rejection of progressive politics.
  • The vote shares of Macron's and Scholz's ...

Actionables

  • You can deepen your understanding of political trends by starting a journal to track and analyze shifts in your local elections. Observe the candidates, their platforms, and the election outcomes in your area. Compare these with the trends mentioned, noting similarities or differences, and reflect on how these changes might affect your community.
  • Engage in conversations with peers from different political backgrounds to gain a broader perspective on why certain political movements are gaining traction. Approach these discussions with an open mind, aiming to understand the underlying concerns and values that might be driving support for various parties, rather than trying to debate or convince others of your views.
  • Volunteer with a local political campa ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
What's Behind Europe’s Surge to the Right? | Sunday Extra

Key conservative/populist parties and figures driving the rightward shift in Europe

The political landscape in Europe has seen a significant shift to the right as several conservative and populist parties and figures gain influence and challenge the established political order.

Italy's Brothers of Italy party, led by Giorgio Meloni, emerged as a major force, quadrupling its support

In Italy, Giorgio Maloney's Brothers of Italy party dramatically increased its standing in the European elections. The right-wing party managed to quadruple their previous levels of support, signifying a shifting sentiment among the Italian electorate towards more conservative policies.

Marine Le Pen's National Rally in Temp France secured over 30% of the vote, nearly double that of President Macron's party

In France, Marine Le Pen's National Rally made a formidable showing in the polls, securing over 30% of the vote, a striking contrast that was nearly double the size of the vote for President Emmanuel Macron's centrist party. This surge in support for Le Pen's party suggests a growing appeal of nationalist and populist ideologies in France.

In Germany, the right-wing AfD party gained close to 20% of the European vote, while the ruling socialists and Green ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Key conservative/populist parties and figures driving the rightward shift in Europe

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The increase in support for conservative and populist parties may not necessarily reflect a long-term ideological shift but could be a response to specific current events or dissatisfaction with the status quo.
  • The success of parties like the Brothers of Italy, National Rally, and AfD could be attributed to effective campaigning and messaging rather than a fundamental change in public opinion.
  • The performance of President Macron's party in France might be influenced by a variety of factors, including domestic policies and his administration's popularity at the time of the election, rather than a straightforward endorsement of National Rally's policies.
  • The poor performance of the socialists and Greens in Germany could be due to internal party issues, leadership challenges, or policy decisions that are not aligned with voter priorities, rather than a wholesale rejection of their ideologies.
  • The results of the European elections might no ...

Actionables

  • You can deepen your understanding of political trends by tracking local election results and comparing them with the broader European context. Start by accessing public records of past and current election results in your area, then create a simple spreadsheet to note patterns and shifts in voter behavior. This will give you a clearer picture of how local trends might mirror or diverge from the European shifts mentioned.
  • Engage in conversations with peers to explore the underlying reasons for political shifts. Organize informal discussion groups where you and your friends can talk about what factors might be influencing voter decisions. Focus on understanding the motivations behind why people might be drawn to different political parties, without trying to change anyone's mind. This can help you appreciate the complexities of political dynamics.
  • Develop critical thinking skills by analyzing political campaign strategie ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
What's Behind Europe’s Surge to the Right? | Sunday Extra

Underlying factors and issues motivating the political change

Europe recently witnessed a significant political shift as conservative parties gained ground. The change is largely driven by concerns over mass migration, cultural identity, opposition to left-leaning economic policies, and growing Euroscepticism.

Concerns over mass migration and cultural identity were central driving forces behind the conservative gains

The issue of mass migration emerged as the primary concern for many Europeans who fear that the continent has accepted too many migrants. This has led to a fundamental rejection of mass migration and open borders policies. Conservative parties have risen in popularity by promising to secure borders, limit the influx of migrants, and address the perceived issue of migrant-related crime. Additionally, there is a fight against the concept of Islamification in Europe, with right-leaning parties seeing it as a threat to European cultural identity.

Rejection of "left-wing elitism" and opposition to expensive green policies like net zero emissions targets

Right-leaning parties have also positioned themselves against what they view as left-wing elitism, particularly regarding economic and environmental policies. Expensive green policies that aim to achieve net zero emissions have been criticized by conservative groups. They believe that these policies are driven by ideology rather than practical considerat ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Underlying factors and issues motivating the political change

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • Concerns over mass migration need to be balanced with the recognition of the benefits of diversity and the humanitarian obligation to help refugees.
  • Tighter border controls may not effectively address the root causes of migration, such as global inequality and conflict.
  • The term "Islamification" is often used in a pejorative way that can stigmatize Muslim communities and overlook the positive contributions of Islam to European culture.
  • Left-wing economic policies are not inherently elitist and can be aimed at reducing inequality and providing social safety nets.
  • Green policies, including net zero emissions targets, are often supported by scientific consensus on th ...

Actionables

  • You can deepen your understanding of immigration policies by volunteering with a local organization that works with immigrants. This direct involvement will give you a firsthand look at the challenges and benefits of immigration, allowing you to form a more informed opinion on border control and cultural integration.
  • Engage in community discussions or online forums dedicated to local and national policies to express your views on green initiatives. By participating, you contribute to the conversation on the balance between environmental concerns and economic implications, potentially influencing policy decisions on a grassroots level.
  • Start a blog or social media page f ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
What's Behind Europe’s Surge to the Right? | Sunday Extra

Potential impact and implications of these trends, both in Europe and the United States

The recent European election results indicate a shift that could have profound effects on both sides of the Atlantic, influencing political dynamics, policymaking, and international relationships.

The European election results are likely to make the Biden administration uneasy

The European electorate's movement away from what has been labeled as "woke left-wing elitism" suggests a political climate change that resonates with a substantial number of American voters. These developments are likely to cause concern for the Biden administration, which may find itself facing comparable sentiments and a possible parallel shift in the political landscape within the United States. Eligible American voters seem to share similar concerns to their European counterparts, highlighting issues that are driving electoral decisions on both continents.

The rightward pivots in Europe could have significant geopolitical and policy implications

The rightward shift in several European countries could have major implications for the future of the European Union and its policies. It may signal changes in the EU's political trajectory, potentially impacting legislation and reforms on a variety of issues includin ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Potential impact and implications of these trends, both in Europe and the United States

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The assumption that the European electorate's shift away from "woke left-wing elitism" will make the Biden administration uneasy may not necessarily hold true, as the administration may be confident in its policies and political strategy.
  • The idea that rightward shifts in Europe will have significant geopolitical and policy implications assumes that right-leaning governments will not maintain or form new cooperative relationships with the US and other allies, which is not always the case.
  • The impact of the EU's political trajectory on legislation and reforms is complex and may not be solely determined by the shift to the right, as there are multiple factors and stakeholders involved in the policymaking process.
  • The assertion that political shifts in Europe could impact the transatlantic relationship may overlook the resilience and long-standing nature of these relationships, which have withstood various political changes over time.
  • The suggestion that voter attitudes in Europe and the US are similar and driving electoral decisions on both continents may oversimplify the unique political, cu ...

Actionables

  • You can deepen your understanding of global political trends by starting a personal journal to track and analyze political events and their potential impacts on your life. Begin by noting down recent political changes, like the European election results, and speculate on how they might affect your job, community, or personal interests. For example, if you work in an industry sensitive to trade policies, consider how shifts in political power could influence regulations that affect your business.
  • Enhance your cultural and political empathy by engaging with individuals from different political backgrounds through language learning platforms. Choose a language from a European country that has experienced significant political shifts and use apps like Duolingo or Tandem to learn the basics. As you progress, seek out conversation partners from that country to discuss how the political changes are affecting their lives, which can provide you with a more nuanced perspective on the ripple effects of elections.
  • Protect your investments by educating yourself on int ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA