Podcasts > Morbid > Episode 623: Fan Favorite: The Violent Deaths of Bog Bodies

Episode 623: Fan Favorite: The Violent Deaths of Bog Bodies

By Morbid Network | Wondery

In this Morbid podcast episode, the hosts delve into the fascinating preservation properties of bogs and the well-preserved ancient bog bodies discovered in these unique natural environments. They examine the chemical and environmental conditions that halt decomposition, allowing remarkably preserved human remains to be unearthed thousands of years later.

The episode explores case studies of several famous bog bodies, like the Elling Woman and Tollund Man from Denmark, and the Cloney Cave-in Man and Old Crogan Man from Ireland. The hosts shed light on the violent, ritualistic deaths these individuals suffered and the clues their remains provide about ancient European social hierarchies, belief systems, and power structures.

Episode 623: Fan Favorite: The Violent Deaths of Bog Bodies

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Dec 2, 2024 episode of the Morbid

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Episode 623: Fan Favorite: The Violent Deaths of Bog Bodies

1-Page Summary

The Unique Preservation Properties of Bogs

Bogs are natural environments with anaerobic, acidic, and low-oxygen conditions that significantly slow decomposition, allowing ancient human remains to be preserved for millennia, as the hosts explain.

Bogs' Anaerobic and Acidic Conditions Halt Decay

The lack of oxygen and acidic waters in bogs prevent the rapid breakdown of organic matter like bodies. Sphagnum moss, prevalent in bogs, releases compounds like sphagnan that tan and preserve soft tissues. Additionally, fallen bog oak trees contribute to the preservation process through chemical interactions.

Case Studies of Well-Preserved Bog Bodies

The Elling Woman and Tollund Man

The Elling Woman (c. 280 BCE), found in Denmark, was meticulously preserved with intricate braids and signs of strangulation, suggesting she was a ritualistic sacrifice. Her well-nourished state and careful grooming indicated high social standing. The Tollund Man (c. 375-210 BCE), also from Denmark, had a peaceful expression despite being hanged. His diet of grains and fish pointed to elite status.

The Cloney Cave-in Man and Old Crogan Man

These two Irish bog bodies were brutally killed and mutilated, with severed heads, bisected bodies, and nipples removed - theorized to symbolically strip them of kingship eligibility as punishment. Their well-maintained appearances and rich diets signaled upper-class status.

Theories on Ritualistic Killings and Sacrifices

Hosts reveal that many bog bodies show signs of ritualistic, sacrificial killings within ancient belief systems. Staking down bodies may have trapped souls in the bog as punishment or offering. Careful preservation and personal adornments suggest victims were of high status. Mutilations like nipple removal could signify failed kingship. The discoveries offer insights into complex rituals, social hierarchies, and power structures of pre-Christian European societies.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Sphagnum moss, commonly found in bogs, releases compounds like sphagnan. These compounds have tanning properties that help preserve soft tissues by slowing down decomposition. This preservation process contributes to the remarkable state of ancient human remains found in bogs.
  • The fallen bog oak trees release tannins and other compounds that aid in the preservation of organic matter in bogs. These chemicals help in tanning and preserving soft tissues of ancient remains. The interaction of these compounds with the environment contributes to the unique preservation properties of bogs. This process helps slow down decomposition and contributes to the remarkable preservation of bog bodies over millennia.
  • The Elling Woman and Tollund Man are well-preserved bog bodies found in Denmark. The Elling Woman displayed signs of ritualistic sacrifice and high social standing, while the Tollund Man had a peaceful expression despite his violent death and indicated elite status through his diet. These individuals provide insights into ancient societies' beliefs, rituals, and social structures through their remarkable preservation and accompanying archaeological evidence.
  • The Cloney Cave-in Man and Old Crogan Man were two Irish bog bodies discovered with severe injuries such as severed heads, bisected bodies, and removed nipples. These injuries were believed to be symbolic acts to strip them of kingship eligibility as a form of punishment. Despite the brutal nature of their deaths, their well-preserved appearances and rich diets indicated they were individuals of high social status.
  • Ritualistic killings and sacrifices associated with bog bodies in ancient belief systems were often linked to religious or social practices. These acts were believed to have symbolic meanings, such as offerings to deities or attempts to influence natural forces. The careful preservation and adornments found on these bodies suggest they were individuals of high status within their communities. Mutilations like nipple removal may have held specific cultural or ritualistic significance, possibly related to concepts of power, kingship, or spiritual beliefs.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Episode 623: Fan Favorite: The Violent Deaths of Bog Bodies

The unique preservation properties of bogs and how they preserve ancient human remains

Bogs serve as natural preservatives for ancient human remains due to their specialized environments. Hosts reveal that the anaerobic, acidic, and low-oxygen conditions of bogs significantly slow decomposition, allowing bodies to remain intact for millennia.

Bogs as specialized environments

Bogs are formed when plants and other organic debris accumulate in shallow water bodies and decompose very slowly due to oxygen deprivation, creating peat over time. This lack of oxygen in the bogs is crucial for the preservation of organic materials like human remains because it prevents the usual rapid decomposition.

The anaerobic, acidic, and low-oxygen conditions of bogs slow decomposition

The transcript discusses how the hair on bog bodies can be so well-preserved that it sometimes appears to be a wig. The low-oxygen environment of the bogs preserves these organic materials in a suspended state for extensive periods. These conditions are so effective that a human skull found in a bog was once mistaken for a recent murder victim, highlighting the high level of preservation.

Sphagnum moss in bogs releases compounds that tan and preserve skin, hair, and other soft tissues

Sphagnum moss, prevalent in bogs, dies and releases sphagnan, which tans and preserves the skin, hair, and soft tissues of bodies within the bog. This tanning process gives the skin a leathery texture and turns hair a distinctive copper ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The unique preservation properties of bogs and how they preserve ancient human remains

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Anaerobic conditions are environments with little to no oxygen present. In such conditions, certain processes like decomposition occur at a much slower rate compared to aerobic environments. Bogs provide anaerobic conditions that help preserve organic materials like human remains by slowing down decomposition significantly. The absence of oxygen in bogs is crucial for the exceptional preservation of these materials over long periods.
  • Sphagnan is a compound released by decaying Sphagnum moss in bogs. It has tanning properties that help preserve skin, hair, and soft tissues of bodies in the bog. This process gives the skin a leathery texture and imparts a distinctive coppery red color to the hair. The tanning effect of sphagnan contributes to the remarkable preservation of organic materials in bog environments.
  • Bog oak trees, unique to bog environments, contribute to the preservation of remains through chemical interactions ...

Counterarguments

  • While bogs do preserve organic materials, they can also be selective in what is preserved, often resulting in the loss of certain tissues or materials that do not withstand the acidic conditions.
  • The preservation of human remains in bogs is not always complete; bones can be dissolved by the acidic water, which means that the skeletal remains are not always intact.
  • The unique conditions of bogs can sometimes make it difficult to date the remains accurately due to the complex chemical interactions that can affect the standard dating methods.
  • The tanning process by sphagnum moss can also distort the features of the bodies, which might lead to incorrect interpretations of the physical characteristics of the preserved individuals.
  • The preservation in bogs is not a universal process; it can vary greatly depending on the specific conditions of each bog, which means that not all bogs are equally effective at preserving remains.
  • The focus on bog bodies can sometimes oversh ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Episode 623: Fan Favorite: The Violent Deaths of Bog Bodies

Specific case studies and analyses of well-preserved bog bodies, including details about their physical appearances, presumed causes of death, and social status

Researchers use remarkably preserved bog bodies to study ancient people, their belongings, and their social statuses. The intimate details of physical appearances and the brutal circumstances of their deaths provide insights into the rituals and cultural practices of their times.

The Elling Woman, a 2,000-year-old bog body found in Denmark, was meticulously preserved with intricate braids in her hair and evidence of violent strangulation.

The Elling Woman was found in Denmark in 1938 by Jens Zacharisen, believed to be from 280 BCE, during the Iron Age. At the time of her death, she was approximately 25 years old and adorned with a sheepskin cloak and a cowhide blanket. She also had a woolen belt and fabric made from cowhide wrapped around her lower body. Her back was nearly perfectly preserved, and she had long hair styled in intricate braids. A leather rope with a slipknot was found tied around her neck, and further testing indicated she had been hanged. Her well-nourished state and careful grooming suggested she was of high social standing and possibly used as a ritualistic fertility sacrifice by her village.

The Elling Woman's body showed signs of having been hanged, with a deep laceration around her neck, suggesting a ritualistic sacrifice.

The deep laceration around her neck where the rope was tied provides evidence that she was hanged, consistent with the theory that her death was a sacrificial act.

Analyses of her well-nourished state and carefully styled hair indicated she was likely of high social standing in her community.

Her overall well-preserved condition, nourishment status, and the care taken in styling her hair suggest that she was likely a prominent member of her community.

The Tollund Man, another exceptionally well-preserved bog body from Denmark, was found naked but with a peaceful facial expression, despite having been violently killed.

The Tollund Man was discovered by peat cutting farmers in Denmark, in the same bog as the Elling Woman, but 12 years later. He was estimated to be 30 to 40 years old at his time of death and was found naked save for a pointed cap, with a serene facial expression, suggesting a peaceful slumber. A braided leather noose around his neck pointed to a ritual sacrifice. He had recently consumed porridge made of grains and fish—a high-quality meal that indicated his high status.

The Tollund Man's body showed evidence of strangulation, with a braided leather noose around his neck, and he had recently consumed a meal of porridge and fish.

His cause of death was evidenced by the noose still present around his neck when found, and his stomach contents revealed his last meal.

The Tollund Man's pristine appearance and high-quality diet suggested he was likely a member of the elite class in his society.

The quality of his final meal, along with his preserved appearance, suggests he enjoyed a high social status.

The Cloney Cave-in Man and the Old Crogan Man, two bog bodies found in Ireland, were brutally murdered and mutilated, with their nipples cut off and their bodies staked down in the bogs.

Both the Old Crogan Man and the Cloney ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Specific case studies and analyses of well-preserved bog bodies, including details about their physical appearances, presumed causes of death, and social status

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The interpretation of high social status based on well-nourished states and careful grooming could be challenged by the fact that bog bodies' preservation can sometimes give a misleading impression of their life conditions.
  • The idea that intricate hair braids or well-preserved appearances are indicators of high social status could be contested by suggesting that these could have been part of ritualistic preparation for sacrifice, rather than a reflection of their everyday status.
  • The peaceful facial expression of the Tollund Man could be argued to be a result of the preservation process rather than an indication of his status or the nature of his death.
  • The assumption that a high-quality meal indicates high social status could be questioned by proposing that the meal might have been part of a sacrificial ritual, given to victims regardless of their social standing.
  • The theory that the removal of nipples was a symbolic act related to kingship could be disputed by suggesting alternative interpretations, such as it being a form of punishment not necessarily related to failed kingship or a different ritualistic practice with a n ...

Actionables

  • You can explore the historical significance of hairstyles by trying out ancient braiding techniques and sharing them on social media to spark discussions about cultural practices and status symbols. Start by researching historical hairstyles, practice creating them with online tutorials, and then post your results with a brief description of their historical context. This can lead to a deeper appreciation of how personal grooming has been a marker of social standing throughout history.
  • Create a simple home garden to understand the dietary habits of historical elites. Choose plants that were considered high-quality foods in ancient times, such as barley, legumes, and root vegetables. As you tend to your garden, reflect on the nutritional value and cultivation efforts these foods would have required, gaining insight into the diets of historical figures of high status.
  • Engage in a creative writing exer ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Episode 623: Fan Favorite: The Violent Deaths of Bog Bodies

Theories around the ritualistic nature of many bog body deaths and their significance in ancient cultures

The preserved remains of individuals from ancient times, known as bog bodies, reveal signs of ritualistic and sacrificial killings, offering a window into the belief systems of Iron Age and pre-Christian European societies.

Many bog bodies show signs of ritualistic, sacrificial killings, suggesting they were viewed as offerings or punishments within the belief systems of their societies.

The act of dismembering or staking down bodies in the bogs, often observed in the remains, indicates an intent to trap the souls of the deceased in the liminal space of the bog, perhaps to prevent them from moving on to the afterlife. This could signify punishment or a symbolic anchoring to the world of the living. The appearance of anguish on many bog bodies' faces supports the notion that they were ritually killed. However, the peaceful expression of the Tollund Man, who was carefully placed in the bog after death by hanging, implies a ritualistic aspect differing from those of violent end.

The practice of staking down or dismembering the bodies and leaving them in the bogs was likely intended to prevent the souls of the victims from leaving the in-between space of the bog and moving on to the afterlife.

Some bodies in the bogs were staked down, sometimes through their limbs while they were alive. This may have served as a punishment by preventing the decomposition of the body and the soul's departure, leaving them in a state of suspension between life and death.

The careful preservation of the bodies, often with personal adornments like jewelry or styled hair, indicates the victims were likely of high social status and importance within their communities.

Personal adornments and the careful placement of the bodies suggest that the victims were of high social status, potentially nobles or kings or those in line of succession. The Elling Woman, for instance, is believed to have possibly been offered as a ritualistic sacrifice to the gods by her village.

The practice of mutilating the body in specific ways further underscores their cultural significance. For example, cutting off a king's nipples would have rendered him ineligible for kingship both in this world and the next. This mutilation could signify a failed kingship or ritual sacrifice due to eve ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Theories around the ritualistic nature of many bog body deaths and their significance in ancient cultures

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The interpretation of bog bodies as ritualistic sacrifices is not universally accepted; some researchers argue that these could be the remains of executed criminals, victims of murder, or individuals who died accidentally and were subsequently placed in the bogs.
  • The expression of anguish on the faces of bog bodies could be a result of the decomposition process rather than an indication of ritual killing.
  • The peaceful expression of the Tollund Man might not necessarily indicate a ritualistic death; it could also be due to natural decomposition processes that relaxed his facial features after death.
  • The presence of personal adornments and careful placement does not conclusively prove high social status; these could also be part of funerary customs for individuals from various social strata.
  • The mutilation of bodies, such as cutting off nipples, might have explanations other than ritual significance, such as post-mortem alterations by peat-digging tools or natural peat decomposition processes.
  • The interpretation of bog bodies as nobles or kings is speculative and may not reflect the true social status or rol ...

Actionables

  • You can explore the historical context of your own family by creating a genealogical map that includes any known rituals or traditions. Start by interviewing older relatives and compiling records from online databases to trace back your lineage. Look for patterns or recurring practices that may have been significant to your ancestors, and document these findings in a visual map or family tree.
  • Enhance your understanding of social hierarchies by observing and noting the status symbols in your community. Pay attention to how people dress, the cars they drive, or the technology they use, and consider how these symbols might parallel the adornments found on bog bodies. Keep a journal of your observations, reflecting on what these symbols say about the values and status within your own society.
  • Develop a deeper appreciation for cultural preservation ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA