Episode 611: Preston Murr and the Boise Murder Mansion
In the Morbid podcast's exploration of the case of Preston Murr, listeners get a disturbing glimpse into the gruesome 1987 murder that took place inside the infamous "Boise Murder Mansion."
Hosts detail the grisly crime as well as the issues surrounding the emergency response, botched prosecution of the perpetrators, and controversies regarding their vastly different sentences. The episode also delves into the creepy lore surrounding the house itself, uncovering claims of paranormal activity as locals recount unexplained noises and alleged ghost sightings that fueled the mansion's "haunted" reputation after Murr's killing.
While not confirming whether spirits lurk within, the summary lays bare the harrowing facts of the case as well as the enduring legacy of terror left by Murr's murderers and their gruesome acts. Listeners intrigued by true crime, the macabre, or eerie local legends are sure to be enthralled.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Oct 21, 2024 episode of the Morbid
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
The Murder of Preston Murr
On June 30, 1987, Clinton Sparks witnessed a violent altercation with someone banging on his door screaming "let go of me." Though Sparks called 911, the dispatcher delayed sending officers, Barbaro reports.
Next day, police discovered blood leading to Daniel and Katherine Rogers' home. They found drug activity and blood spatter evidence of a violent crime. Through testimony and ballistics, investigators determined Daniel Rogers and Darren Cox murdered 21-year-old Preston Murr, dismembering his body.
Rogers received life for first-degree murder, but Cox got just 5 years for being an accessory, a widely criticized decision. The case highlights issues with emergency response and need for diverse representation among operators.
Rogers' Trial and Prosecution
Rogers had a violent past, including a prior murder conviction prosecutors wanted to present. His defense repeatedly sought mistrials, arguing media coverage and revelation of prior crimes biased the jury.
But the prosecution presented strong evidence: witness testimony, forensic analysis tying Rogers' gun to the crime scene, and Rogers' fingerprints on the gun and ammunition, Sanger-Katz says. They linked the unique barrel markings on bullets to Rogers' gun, proving it was the murder weapon.
Paranormal Rumors Surrounding the Crime Scene
The Linden Street house had a history of natural deaths of elderly residents before the murder. New owners like Deanne Davis reported unexplained noises, especially in the basement, fueling "haunted" rumors.
Neighbors and ex-residents claim seeing figures like a woman screaming from an upstairs window, Barbaro notes. Though owners haven't experienced paranormal events, the "murder mansion" reputation has brought interest for possible future ghost tours.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- The dispatcher's delay in sending officers might have been due to a high volume of calls or a misjudgment of the situation's urgency, rather than incompetence or systemic issues.
- The sentence disparity between Rogers and Cox could be justified if Cox's involvement was significantly less or if he provided substantial assistance to the prosecution.
- The need for diverse representation among operators is important, but it is not clear from the text how this diversity would have changed the outcome of the emergency response.
- The introduction of Rogers' past crimes could be seen as prejudicial and not necessarily indicative of his guilt in this specific case.
- The defense's concerns about media coverage and the revelation of prior crimes potentially biasing the jury are legitimate issues that the court system must address to ensure a fair trial.
- Forensic evidence, while strong, is not infallible and can sometimes be contested based on the methods used or the potential for contamination.
- Paranormal rumors and sightings are not substantiated by empirical evidence and could be attributed to psychological phenomena like pareidolia or the power of suggestion.
- The interest in ghost tours, while understandable from a business perspective, could be seen as insensitive to the tragedy that occurred and the victim's family.
Actionables
- You can enhance your personal safety by creating a neighborhood watch program that includes training on proper emergency response protocols. By organizing regular meetings with your neighbors, you can discuss and practice how to effectively report incidents to 911, ensuring that dispatchers receive clear, concise information for a swift response. This could involve role-playing scenarios based on real-life events to improve communication skills and response times.
- Improve your understanding of forensic science by conducting simple experiments at home, like fingerprinting or analyzing different types of fabrics under a black light. This hands-on approach can give you a basic grasp of how evidence is collected and analyzed, which can be useful in understanding real-life crime investigations. For example, you could use a basic fingerprinting kit to learn how to lift prints from various surfaces or use a black light to see how different bodily fluids react, simulating the forensic process.
- Foster community interest in local history by starting a digital storytelling project that documents the stories and legends of your neighborhood. Using a simple website or social media platform, you can collect and share anecdotes, photos, and historical facts about the area, including any infamous events or folklore. This not only preserves local heritage but also provides a resource for those interested in the social dynamics and historical context of their community. For instance, you could interview long-time residents about their experiences and memories, then share these stories online to build a rich, interactive community archive.
Get access to the context and additional materials
The murder of Preston Murr
The gruesome murder of Preston Murr in 1987 is a stark case of violence and delayed justice due to a significant delay in the police response. The investigation revealed a shocking crime involving drugs, betrayal, and a failure of the emergency response system.
On June 30, 1987, Clinton Sparks witnessed a violent altercation outside his home, with one person banging on his door desperately and someone yelling "let go of me."
In the early hours of June 30, 1987, Clinton Sparks was woken by shouting outside his window and observed a violent episode unfold. Someone frantically banged on his door and a man’s voice cried out in a desperate plea, "let go of me." Although Sparks hesitated, he eventually decided to call the police after observing a large smear of blood on his storm door. By then, the persons involved had disappeared.
Though Sparks called 911, the dispatcher did not initially send officers to investigate, causing a significant delay in the police response.
Sparks reported the incident to 911 about ten minutes after witnessing it, but the dispatcher prioritized a fire across town and did not flag his call as an emergency. An officer was assigned, but since he was busy and the call was not reassigned by the dispatcher, help did not arrive promptly.
The next day, a large amount of blood was discovered on the street and at nearby homes, leading police to the home of Daniel and Katherine Rogers.
The aftermath of the earlier altercation became evident when a neighbor reported a large amount of blood in the street. Officers followed a trail of blood that led to the door of Daniel and Katherine Rogers' home. Inside, they discovered evidence of drug activity and significant blood spatter, indicating a violent crime had occurred.
Investigators determined that Daniel Rogers and his accomplice Darren Cox had confronted and murdered 21-year-old Preston Murr, dismembering his body and disposing of the remains in multiple locations.
Through witness testimony and forensic evidence, including ballistic analysis, detectives linked Daniel Rogers to the murder. Daniel Roger ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
The murder of Preston Murr
Additional Materials
Actionables
- You can enhance your personal safety by setting up a neighborhood watch program to monitor and report suspicious activities. By collaborating with your neighbors and local law enforcement, you create a network of vigilance that can deter crime and ensure faster response times in emergencies. For example, use social media groups or apps like Nextdoor to communicate in real time about any unusual occurrences in your area.
- Improve your emergency preparedness by taking a basic first aid course and keeping a well-stocked first aid kit at home. Knowing how to handle medical emergencies can be crucial in situations where there is a delay in emergency response. Practice scenarios with family or friends to build confidence in your ability to manage until professional help arrives.
- Advocate for better community resources by pa ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
The police investigation and trial of the suspects
Daniel Rogers had a violent criminal history, including a previous conviction for second-degree murder, which the prosecution sought to introduce as evidence.
Rogers' defense team repeatedly attempted to have the trial moved or declared a mistrial, citing concerns about media attention and the revelation of his prior crimes.
The Ada County prosecutor filed an additional charge against Daniel Rogers for his role in the beating of another individual, which further expanded his list of violent crimes. In his opening statement, Prosecutor Greg Bauer gave the jury a brief overview of Rogers' criminal history, even though the judge had expressly forbidden such information. This led Rogers to attempt to have his verdict overturned and petition for a new trial multiple times. He claimed that the court had abused its discretion by revealing his criminal past and alleged that the jury was biased due to media coverage.
Rogers' defense team objected to the inclusion of certain witness statements and requested that the proceedings be closed to the media. Moreover, they made efforts to have the trial moved to a different county and sought a mistrial after the prosecutor mentioned Rogers' custody for other charges when he was arrested for the murder in question.
The prosecution presented a strong case, including testimony from police officers, crime scene technicians, and witnesses, as well as forensic evidence linking Rogers to the murder.
At the trial, multiple people testified at the preliminary hearing, and multiple police officers and crime scene technicians gave evidence for the prosecution. Officer Mike Majors spoke about the search of Rogers' home, where the team ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
The police investigation and trial of the suspects
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- A mistrial occurs when a trial is terminated before its normal conclusion due to a significant problem that affects the fairness of the proceedings. This could be due to errors in legal procedure, misconduct by participants, or other circumstances that prevent a fair trial. Mistrials can be declared by the judge in response to motions from either the defense or prosecution. When a mistrial is declared, the case may need to be retried with a new jury.
- Ada County is a county located in the state of Idaho, USA. It is home to the city of Boise, which is the state capital and the most populous city in Idaho. Ada County is known for its diverse economy, outdoor recreational opportunities, and cultural attractions. The county seat of Ada County is Boise.
- A preliminary hearing is a legal proceeding held to determine if there is enough evidence to proceed to trial after a criminal complaint has been filed. It allows the court to assess the strength of the case and decide if a trial is warranted. During this hearing, the defendant may be represented by a lawyer and the prosecution may present evidence and call witnesses. If the court fin ...
Counterarguments
- The introduction of Rogers' criminal history could be seen as prejudicial and not necessarily indicative of his guilt in the current case.
- The defense's concerns about media attention could be valid if the media coverage was pervasive and potentially influenced the jury's impartiality.
- The additional charge for the beating of another individual, while expanding Rogers' list of violent crimes, may not be directly relevant to the murder charge and could risk prejudicing the jury.
- The prosecutor's mention of Rogers' criminal history, if against a judge's orders, could be grounds for an appeal on the basis of prosecutorial misconduct.
- The defense's requests for closed proceedings and a change of venue could be based on legitimate concerns for Rogers' right to a fair trial.
- The defense's objection to certain witness statements could be justified if those statements were hearsay, irrelevant, or obtained improperly.
- The strong case presented by the prosecution could still be subject to scrutiny if the forensic evidence was ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
The haunting rumors and speculation surrounding the Linden Street house
The Linden Street house, where several natural deaths occurred followed by the murder of a young man named Preston Murr, is now at the center of eerie rumors and ghost stories.
The Home's Mysterious History of Deaths
The Linden Street house where the murder took place has a history of resident deaths, including several elderly individuals who passed away of natural causes.
Before the house became infamous due to the murder, it had witnessed the natural deaths of its elderly residents. Birdie Sexton passed away at the age of 91 in June of 1952 after residing in the house for 44 years. Following Birdie, John, aged 71, died in the house in 1958, and shortly after, Ellen Marker, aged 89, also passed away within its walls.
The home's new owners have experienced a sense of unease and heard unexplained noises, particularly in the basement, leading to rumors of the house being haunted.
The new owner, Deanne Davis, has noticed peculiar happenings despite not finding the house particularly scary or haunted. However, one of Davis’s daughters has felt an unsettling presence in the basement, to the point of avoiding it due to fear. This sense of unease has contributed to the home's chilling reputation.
The Echo of Paranormal Activity
Numerous accounts of odd experiences have emerged from neighbors and former residents of the haunting Linden Street house.
Numerous people, including neighbors and former residents, have reported seeing and hearing strange occurrences in the home, such as a woman screaming in an upstairs window.
Michelle Hart has collected various anecdotes about the house, one of which involves a sighting of a woman dressed in 1800s attire standing at a window. Additionally, there are tales ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
The haunting rumors and speculation surrounding the Linden Street house
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- The deaths in the house, while numerous, may not be statistically unusual given the age of the residents and the time they occurred.
- Feelings of unease and unexplained noises can often be attributed to more mundane causes such as house settling, plumbing, or even psychological suggestion.
- The stories collected by Michelle Hart, while intriguing, are anecdotal and lack empirical evidence to support the claims of paranormal activity.
- The reputation of the house as haunted could be influenced by cultural narratives and the human tendency to find patterns or meaning in random events.
- The interest from paranormal enthusiasts does not validate the su ...
Actionables
- You can explore local history by visiting your town's historical society or archives to learn about any notable events or figures connected to your area, similar to the stories collected about the Linden Street house.
- Delving into local history can give you a sense of connection to your community and its past. You might discover fascinating tales or significant events that have shaped your town. For example, you could find out about a historic building's original purpose or learn about influential residents from the past.
- You can create a themed walking tour of your neighborhood focusing on historical and potentially supernatural lore, inspired by the interest in the Linden Street house tours.
- This can be a fun way to engage with your community and share intriguing stories. You don't need to be an expert; just gather interesting facts and anecdotes about various locations. For instance, you might tell the story of a local legend or point out architectural features that are rumored to have mysterious origins.
- You can start a journal to document any unusual ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
