Podcasts > Morbid > Episode 571: Lost Children of the Alleghenies

Episode 571: Lost Children of the Alleghenies

By Morbid Network | Wondery

In this episode of the Morbid podcast, listeners learn about the harrowing search efforts to find two missing boys in the treacherous Allegheny Mountains of Pennsylvania. The local community mobilized a massive rescue, combing the rugged terrain for days, before a farmer's eerie dreams led to the tragic discovery of the boys' bodies.

Despite suspicion initially falling on the parents, investigations revealed no wrongdoing—only hypothermia claiming the young lives. Now, a memorial stands at the site of their last embrace, with some reporting paranormal occurrences honoring their memory in the folklore of the Alleghenies.

Episode 571: Lost Children of the Alleghenies

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Jun 6, 2024 episode of the Morbid

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Episode 571: Lost Children of the Alleghenies

1-Page Summary

The Dangerous Allegheny Mountains

The Allegheny Mountains of Pennsylvania were once among the most treacherous regions to traverse, characterized by steep gorges, ravines, and rapidly shifting inclines that posed risks to travelers, as noted by Charles Dickens.

Community Search for Missing Boys

When two boys went missing, the local community mobilized a vast search effort of over 200 neighbors scouring the woods. The search persisted for days, with thousands involved despite freezing temperatures and heavy snow, until boundaries were set based on the assumption the boys hadn't crossed a stream.

Farmer's Prophetic Dreams Lead to Bodies

Local farmer Jacob Deibert had vivid, prophetic dreams depicting precise details of a scene with a dead deer, fallen log over a stream, and a distinctive birch tree—which led him and his brother-in-law to discover the boys' bodies huddled at that very spot, having succumbed to hypothermia. While initially suspected, Ash Kelley reports the parents were ultimately cleared after thorough investigation yielded no evidence of foul play.

Memorial and Haunting Legacy

A memorial funded by the community now stands at the site, though requiring protection from vandals. Alaina Urquhart highlights the area has become a place of reflection, with reported ghostly occurrences like children's voices and footprints. The tragedy was immortalized in the bluegrass song "Jacob's Dream" by John Pennell and Julie Lee, keeping the well-known tale alive in local Allegheny folklore, as affirmed by Lee's relation to the story.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Jacob Deibert, a local farmer, had vivid dreams that accurately depicted the location where the boys' bodies were found. The dreams included specific details like a dead deer, a fallen log over a stream, and a distinctive birch tree. These details guided Jacob and his brother-in-law to the exact spot where the boys had tragically succumbed to hypothermia. The dreams played a crucial role in the discovery of the boys' bodies, providing a significant breakthrough in the search effort.
  • "Jacob's Dream" is a bluegrass song that immortalizes the tragic event of the missing boys in the Allegheny Mountains. Written by John Pennell and Julie Lee, the song captures the essence of the story and its impact on the local community. It serves as a cultural tribute, keeping the memory of the boys and the events surrounding their disappearance alive in the folklore of the region. The song adds a layer of emotional depth and remembrance to the historical narrative, resonating with those familiar with the haunting tale.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Episode 571: Lost Children of the Alleghenies

The dangerous and treacherous environment of the Allegheny Mountains

The Allegheny Mountains of Pennsylvania, with their steep and challenging terrain, have historically been recognized as a formidable obstacle for travelers.

The Allegheny Mountains were known as one of the most perilous regions to traverse in Pennsylvania.

Travel through the Allegheny Mountains was once considered among the most dangerous journeys in Pennsylvania. The mountains' landscape is shaped by large and steep gorges, ravines, and inclines, caused by natural rock formation and erosion from running water. These features create sharply dipping paths, making any form of travel through the region extremely hazardous.

Terrifying terrain encountered by travelers

The treacherous terrain of the Allegheny Mountains is characterized by steep gorges, ravines, and rapidly shifting inclines. Travelers of the past had to navigate through these natural obstacles, which posed a significant risk to their safety.

Noted by Charles Dickens as "sufficiently disconcerting"

Even Charles Dickens, the ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The dangerous and treacherous environment of the Allegheny Mountains

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The Portage Railroad was a historic railway in Pennsylvania built to transport goods and passengers over the challenging terrain of the Allegheny Mountains. It served as a crucial link for travelers navigating the treacherous landscape, providing a safer alternative to traditional overland routes. The railway was a significant engineering feat of its time, designed to overcome the steep slopes and rugged terrain of the region. The Portage Railroad played a vital role in facilitating transportation and trade through the Allegheny Mountains during the 19th century.
  • The engineering efforts like the railroad mentioned in the text are referring to the construction of the Portage Railroad in the Allegheny Mountains. This railroad was built to provide a safer and more efficient means of transportation through the challenging terrain of the region. It was a significant engineering feat of its time, designed to navigate the steep slopes and rugged landscape of the mountains. The railroad played a crucial role in facilitating travel and transportation through the Allegheny Mountains, offering a solution to the treacherous conditions faced by travelers.
  • Charles Dickens, the renowned author, traveled through the Allegheny Mountains in Pennsylvania during his visit to the United States in the mid-19th century. He journeyed on the Portage Railroad, an engineering marvel of its time that helped traverse the challenging terrain of the region. Dickens' experience highlighted the treacherous nature of the Allegheny Mountains and the impact of the landscape on travelers during that era.
  • The Allegheny Mountains in Pennsylvania have a rich historical significance due to the ...

Counterarguments

  • While the Allegheny Mountains were historically challenging to traverse, modern infrastructure and technology have significantly reduced the dangers associated with traveling through this region.
  • The text may overemphasize the perilous nature of the terrain without acknowledging the advancements in transportation and safety measures that have been implemented over time.
  • The description of the terrain as "extremely hazardous" may not account for the varying experiences and capabilities of different travelers, some of whom may have found ways to safely navigate the landscape.
  • The account of Charles Dickens' experience is anecdotal and may not represent the experiences of all travelers who passed through the Allegheny Mountains.
  • The historical context of travel through the Allegheny Mountains is not fully explored, which could provide insight into how th ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Episode 571: Lost Children of the Alleghenies

The search efforts by the local community to find the missing boys

The local community showed remarkable solidarity and determination in its extensive efforts to locate the missing boys, although the search was marred by harsh weather conditions and some emerging distrust.

The local community immediately mobilized a vast search effort after the boys went missing.

After the boys disappeared, their parents quickly sought help from their neighbors. The community responded immediately, leaving their work to assist. More than 200 neighbors from the surrounding community dedicated themselves to the search, scouring the woods and calling out for the boys. This immense search effort included lighting fires and torches, which may have been an attempt to guide the boys or aid the search during the night.

Despite these initial efforts characterized by community solidarity and support, tensions eventually emerged, with accusations among neighbors suggesting the parents could have harmed their children and invented a story to cover it up.

The search went on for days, with the community refusing to give up hope of finding the boys alive.

The extensive search operation persisted day and night as the local community refused to give up hope. The forest resonated with the sound of the boys' names being called by searchers fanning out in all directions. Ash Kelley reports at one point, thousands o ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The search efforts by the local community to find the missing boys

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The accusations among neighbors regarding the parents' involvement suggest suspicions that the parents might have harmed their children and fabricated a story to conceal any wrongdoing. These accusations can arise in high-stress situations when there is uncertainty about the circumstances of a disappearance. Such suspicions can strain community r ...

Counterarguments

  • The mobilization of over 200 neighbors, while impressive, may not have been coordinated effectively, leading to potential overlaps or gaps in the search areas.
  • Lighting fires and torches could be a double-edged sword; while they provide light and possibly warmth, they could also pose a fire hazard or inadvertently signal that an area has been searched when it has not.
  • Accusations among neighbors about the parents' involvement could reflect underlying community tensions or a lack of effective communication from law enforcement about the nature of the investigation.
  • The persistence of the community is commendable, but without professional search and rescue guidance, their efforts may have been inefficient or even counterproductive.
  • The involvement of thousands of people indicates a strong community response, but without proper search training, such large numbers could potentially contaminate evidence o ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Episode 571: Lost Children of the Alleghenies

The strange circumstances around how the boys were eventually found dead

In a turn of events that sounds like it was pulled straight from a mystery novel, a local farmer's prophetic dreams brought closure to the harrowing search for two missing boys.

A local farmer, Jacob Deibert, had a series of vivid, prophetic dreams that led him to the exact location of the boys' bodies.

Jacob Deibert experienced chillingly prophetic dreams which led to a crucial breakthrough in a devastating case of two missing boys. Deibert's dreams, which repeated themselves for three consecutive nights, compelled him to believe that they held significance. The dreams consistently depicted the precise details of a unique scene — a distinctive birch tree with the top cut off, a fallen log crossing over a stream, and a lifeless deer lying in the vicinity.

Deibert's dreams depicted the precise details of the scene, including a dead deer, a fallen log over a stream, and a distinctive birch tree.

Taking action after the third occurrence of the dream, Deibert reached out to his brother-in-law, Harrison Ysong. Together with Jacob's wife Sarah, the trio recognized the setting from the dreams as being close to their childhood memories. Motivated by this realization, Jacob and Harrison set out to investigate the familiar area.

When Deibert and his brother-in-law investigated, they discovered the boys' bodies huddled at the base of the birch tree, having succumbed to hypothermia.

To their disbelief, they encountered the very scene that had been haunting Jacob’s sleep — the dead deer, the log over the stream, and particularly, the distinctive birch tree. Beneath the birch tree lay the bodies of George and Joseph, the tragically lost boys, who had succumbed to the cold, confirming Deibert's haunting visions.

The community was initially suspicious of the parents, but ultimately there was no evidence of foul play.

While the discovery brought a tragic end to the search, it also directed ungainly susp ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The strange circumstances around how the boys were eventually found dead

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The dreams depicted a scene with a distinctive birch tree missing its top, a fallen log over a stream, and a dead deer nearby. These recurring visions were crucial in guiding Jacob Deibert to the location of the boys' bodies. The vivid details in the dreams matched the actual setting where the boys were found, aiding in the discovery. The dreams played a significant role in the resolution of the mystery surrounding the boys' disappearance.
  • The birch tree, fallen log, and dead deer in Jacob Deibert's dreams were significant because they were key elements that helped him identify the location of the missing boys' bodies. These specific details acted as markers that guided Deibert to the exact spot where the boys were found, providing crucial clues that ultimately led to the resolution of the search.
  • The community's initial suspicion towards the parents stemmed from the mysterious disappearance of the boys and the lack of clarity surrounding their whereabouts. This uncertainty led to neighbors questioning the parents' involvement, a common reaction in cases of missing children until more information is revealed. The absence of concrete evidence linking the parents to any wrongdoing eventually shifted the community's focus towards supporting the grieving family. The suspicion dissipated as the circumstances of the boys' tragic demise became clearer.
  • The ...

Counterarguments

  • The idea that Deibert had "prophetic" dreams could be challenged by suggesting that the dreams were coincidental and that human brains often seek patterns or connections where none may exist.
  • The specificity of the details in Deibert's dreams could be questioned, as memory is often unreliable, and details of dreams can be inadvertently filled in or reinforced by subsequent events or suggestions.
  • The discovery of the boys' bodies by Deibert and his brother-in-law could be seen as a result of a subconscious recollection of the area rather than a supernatural or prophetic experience.
  • While hypothermia is stated as the cause of death, without medical or investigative details, there could be alternative explanations for the boys' demise that are not covered in the text.
  • The community's suspicion of the parents, while unfounded, could be understood as a natural, though regrettable, reaction to a lack of information and the human tendency to seek someone to ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Episode 571: Lost Children of the Alleghenies

The continuing legacy and impact of the story, including a memorial and haunting reports

The legacy of the lost boys from the Allegheny Mountains remains a potent part of local folklore, continuing to resonate both physically through a memorial and culturally through music.

A memorial was later erected at the site where the boys were found, honoring their memory.

Alaina Urquhart highlights that a memorial, created through community-raised funds to honor the memory of the boys, now stands at the site where they were found. Unfortunately, this memorial has needed protection due to past vandalism; it’s encased in a structure with a roof and surrounded by a chain-link fence. The hosts discuss the disrespect shown by vandals to such a solemn monument.

The memorial site has become a place of reflection, with reports of strange occurrences and ghostly sightings.

The area around the memorial has become a place for reflection and has gathered its own eerie lore over time. People report strange sensations, hearing the giggles and conversations of children, and seeing small footprints surrounding the monument in the snow, suggesting ghostly visitations and a haunted aura that clings to the site.

The story of the lost children has become a poignant part of the region's folklore.

A bluegrass song called "Jacob's Dream" was written about the tragedy, further immortalizing the tale.

The tale of the lost boys has transcended into music, becoming a part of regional folklore storytelling. "Jacob's Dream," a bluegrass song written by John Pennell and Julie Lee, ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The continuing legacy and impact of the story, including a memorial and haunting reports

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The memorial erected at the site where the lost boys were found serves as a tribute to their memory and a place for reflection. It has faced vandalism in the past, leading to protective measures like a structure and a chain-link fence. The memorial site has gained a haunting reputation, with reports of ghostly sightings and eerie occurrences, adding to its significance in local folklore.
  • The memorial site where the lost boys were found has gathered a reputation for strange occurrences and ghostly sightings. Visitors have reported experiencing unusual sensations, hearing children's laughter and conversations, and observing small footprints in the snow near the monument, suggesting ghostly visitations and a haunted atmosphere surrounding the area. These reports contribute to the eerie lore that has developed around the site, adding to its mystique and significance in local folklore.
  • The bluegrass song "Jacob's Dream" was inspired by the tragic story of the lost boys from the Allegheny Mountains. Written by John Pennell and Julie Lee, the song recounts the harrowing tale from the boys' perspectives, immortalizing their story in music. The song serves as a poignant tribute to the boys and has become a part of the regional folklore surround ...

Counterarguments

  • The effectiveness of a memorial in honoring the memory of individuals can be debated, as some may argue that it does not address the underlying issues that led to the tragedy.
  • While the memorial is intended to be a place of reflection, the need for protective measures like a chain-link fence could be seen as detracting from its intended purpose of solemn remembrance.
  • Reports of strange occurrences and ghostly sightings can be met with skepticism, as such phenomena often lack empirical evidence and can be attributed to psychological factors like pareidolia or the power of suggestion.
  • The transformation of a tragic event into folklore and music, while serving to memorialize the event, could also be critiqued for potentially romanticizing or trivializing the actual suffering that occurred.
  • The claim that the story is widely known and remembered might be ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA