Episode 568: Listener Tales 86
In this episode of Morbid, hosts Alaina Urquhart and Ash Kelley delve into eerie listener tales of haunted houses, ghostly figures, and disturbing historical events. They unpack the tragic 1887 murder of Lily Field on a Minnesota pig farm and the subsequent paranormal activity reported by visitors to the site.
Urquhart and Kelley react with intrigue and empathy to these chilling stories, encouraging listeners to share further updates. The episode also touches on nostalgia for cultural touchstones of the past and the deeply appreciative bond between the hosts and their devoted listeners.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the May 30, 2024 episode of the Morbid
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
Listeners Share Paranormal Stories
Alaina Urquhart and Ash Kelley discuss a variety of eerie listener tales, from haunted houses with unexplained presences to ghostly figures on remote trails. One listener fled their home at 3 a.m. due to ghostly activity. Another discovered her property may be haunted by a murdered pregnant woman through recurring dreams and an investigation into the land's history, Urquhart and Kelley share.
The 1887 Pig Farm Murder and Hauntings
They recount a grim story of Lily Field's 1887 murder on a rural Minnesota pig farm by a scorned suitor. Visitors have since reported paranormal activity like ghostly apparitions and anguished screams, Urquhart and Kelley explain.
Hosts' Personal Reactions
Empathy, Shock, and Intrigue
Urquhart and Kelley react with empathy and shock to the tragic stories, like Lily's murder for rejecting a man's advances. They relate to elements of paranormal sensitivity and excitement over unexplained phenomena.
Encouraging Further Investigation
When unsettling tales remain unresolved, like the recurring nightmare linked to a property's history, the hosts urge the listeners to provide updates, eager to learn more.
Nostalgia for the Past
Kelley and Urquhart fondly recall cultural touchstones from their pasts, like renting VHS tapes and printing MapQuest directions before GPS. They lament the loss of certain intimate social practices that fostered closeness, like kids riding in truck beds and mailing photos to friends.
Listener Appreciation and Engagement
Listeners express deep admiration for the hosts, calling them "spirit animals." Some eagerly anticipate having their stories featured on the show, while another thanks the hosts for keeping her entertained, Urquhart and Kelley share.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- Reports of paranormal activity at Lily Field's murder site suggest that visitors have witnessed ghostly apparitions and heard anguished screams. These eerie occurrences are believed to be linked to the tragic events surrounding Lily Field's 1887 murder on a rural Minnesota pig farm. The site has become a hotspot for those interested in the supernatural, with various accounts of unexplained phenomena adding to its mysterious reputation. The presence of these ghostly manifestations has contributed to the lore and haunting reputation of the location.
- Renting VHS tapes was a common practice before the rise of digital streaming services, where people would visit video rental stores to borrow movies on VHS cassettes for a limited time. Printing MapQuest directions was a way to obtain printed maps and step-by-step directions for navigating from one location to another before the widespread use of GPS navigation systems. These practices were prevalent in the past but have become less common with the advancement of technology.
- The term "spirit animal" is often used in a metaphorical sense to describe a person's inner character or qualities that they identify with. It can symbolize traits, behaviors, or strengths that resonate with an individual. In this context, listeners expressing admiration by calling the hosts their "spirit animals" suggests a deep connection or appreciation for the hosts' personalities, values, or the way they present themselves on the show.
Counterarguments
- While the hosts encourage belief in the paranormal, skepticism is a valid stance. There is no scientific evidence to support the existence of ghosts or hauntings, and experiences can often be explained by psychological, environmental, or other natural factors.
- The encouragement of further investigation into paranormal activity could be seen as promoting pseudoscience if not approached with a critical and scientific mindset.
- Recalling and romanticizing the past can sometimes overshadow the benefits and advancements of modern technology and social practices.
- While listener engagement is positive, it's important to ensure that the stories shared do not exploit personal tragedies or sensationalize sensitive historical events for entertainment.
- Describing the hosts as "spirit animals" could be considered culturally insensitive, as the term has specific significance in some Indigenous cultures and may be used inappropriately or out of context.
- The focus on eerie and tragic stories might not provide a balanced view of the past or the locations discussed, potentially leading to stigma or unfounded fears.
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Paranormal/unexplained listener stories
Alaina Urquhart and Ash Kelley dive into a "smorgasbord" of listener-contributed tales, expressing a keen interest in ghost stories and supernatural phenomena.
Listeners share supernatural encounters and strange occurrences
The eerie variety of stories ranges from hauntings and presences in homes to chilling encounters in remote forests that hint at the supernatural.
Story of a haunted house with unexplained activities like voices, TV volume changes, and a alive presence
One listener is terrorized by haunting phenomena, leading them to flee their home at 3 a.m. due to a ghost seeking justice. Alania and Ash share an experience of a TV volume turning down by itself and the mysterious appearance of a dark shadow figure in front of their house. Inside, a demonic-sounding laugh and an ice-cold breeze whoosh past them, escalating fear to the point of waiting for their family outside. Unnerving activities continue as a dark figure darts around a Jeep, and a sinister voicemail demanding violence is received.
Listener's recurring dreams about a murdered pregnant woman and her investigation into an old property's history
A recurring nightmare leads a listener to discover her family's property might be haunted by a murdered pregnant woman. This spectral figure is suspected of being buried on the property, manifested through terrifying dreams as a young girl. The listener uncovers past property records and family tales that suggest a dark history, with an unresolved curiosity about the location of the woman's remains.
Decades-old tale of a gruesome murder on a haunted farm with lingering paranormal activity
The grim story of the pig farm murder of 1887 in rural Minnesota recounts the tragic death of Lily Field and the subsequ ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Paranormal/unexplained listener stories
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- A ghost seeking justice typically implies a spirit that is believed to be lingering on Earth due to unresolved issues from their past life, often seeking retribution or resolution for a perceived injustice or wrongdoing. This concept is common in paranormal folklore and ghost stories, where spirits are thought to remain in the physical realm until their grievances are addressed or justice is served in some form. The idea of a ghost seeking justice adds a layer of motivation and purpose to the supernatural entity, driving their actions or manifestations towards achieving closure or balance in the afterlife.
- A dark shadow figure typically refers to a perceived silhouette or shape that appears dark or black in color, often associated with paranormal encounters. These figures are commonly reported in ghost stories and supernatural experiences, where they are described as moving or manifesting in a way that suggests a presence but lacks clear features or details. The appearance of a dark shadow figure can evoke feelings of fear, unease, or mystery in individuals who witness them. These manifestations are often linked to haunted locations or areas with reported paranormal activity.
- A demonic-sounding laugh is a laugh that sounds sinister, evil, or malevolent, often associated with supernatural or malevolent entities. An ice-cold breeze typically signifies a sudden drop in temperature, which can be linked to paranormal activity or the presence of spirits. These experiences are commonly reported in haunted locations or during encounters with entities believed to be of a supernatural nature.
- Recurring dreams about a murdered pregnant woman suggest that the dreamer experiences the same unsettling dream multiple times. The dream typically involves the presence of a woman who was murdered while pregnant, indicating a tragic and unresolved event. This recurring dream may prompt the dreamer to investigate the history or circumstances surrounding the woman's death, leading to a deeper exploration of the paranormal or mysterious occurrences.
- When someone experiences the manifestation of a murdered pregnant woman through dreams, it means they are having recurring dreams or nightmares about this woman who was killed. These dreams can feel vivid and unsettling, often leading the dreamer to investigate the history or circumstances surrounding the murder. The woman's presence in the dreams may suggest unresolved issues or a connection to the location where the crime occurred. This phenomenon can evoke strong emotions and a sense of unease in the dreamer. ...
Counterarguments
- Skepticism about the existence of the paranormal: There is no scientific evidence to support the existence of ghosts or supernatural phenomena, and many supposed encounters can be explained by psychological factors, such as the power of suggestion, or natural phenomena that are misunderstood.
- Confirmation bias: People who believe in the paranormal may interpret ambiguous events as supernatural due to their pre-existing beliefs, rather than considering more mundane explanations.
- Misinterpretation of events: Unusual occurrences in old houses, such as sounds or movements, can often be attributed to structural issues, wildlife, or other non-paranormal causes.
- The power of suggestion: Shared stories of hauntings can influence individuals to perceive normal events as paranormal, especially in a group setting where such ideas are reinforced.
- Recurring dreams and their interpretations: Dreams can be influenced by a variety of factors, including stress, anxiety, and personal experiences, and do not necessarily indicate a connection to real past events or presences.
- Unreliable witness accounts: Human memory is fallible, and eyewitness accounts can be influenced by numerous factors, making them unreliable sources for verifying paranormal activity.
- Alternative explanations for technological malfunctions: Electronic devices can malfunction due to technical issues, low batteries, or interference, rather than paranormal activity.
- Historical rec ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
The hosts' reactions and personal connections to the stories
Alaina Urquhart and Ash Kelley demonstrate a vivid mix of empathy, shock, and humor as they engage with listeners' astonishing tales, ranging from encounters with Bigfoot to unsettling supernatural incidents and tragic events.
Hosts express empathy, shock, and intrigue in response to the listeners' experiences
The hosts connect deeply with the stories shared by their audience, resonating with the emotional and intriguing elements.
Hosts relate to elements of the stories, like the paranormal sensitivity and strange family histories
Urquhart shares her agreement with a listener's belief in encountering Bigfoot, a sentiment that, like many people, the creature probably prefers to avoid human interaction. Kelley humorously identifies with Bigfoot’s desire for peace and solitude.
The duo reacts with shock and disgust at the harrowing story of Lily, a 16-year-old who defended herself against a 28-year-old man. They show empathy, lamenting the tragedy of her murder due to simply rejecting a man's advances. Their reactions delve into the excitement for exploring paranormal stories, with Urquhart voicing a need for light-hearted ghost tales, further solidifying their personal connection to such narratives.
The hosts visibly engage with the stories that resonate personally, such as the tale of a listener who sees themselves as a combination of both hosts' personalities, indicating a deep appreciation for the shared experience.
With reactions ranging from shock and hilarity at Zach’s eagerness to converse with spirits, to curiosity over the mention of an EVP and a malfunctioning recorder, the hosts showcase their awe and deep investment in the supernatural.
Kelley reacts emotionally to a listener's story, expressing desire to see it adapted into a television episode, while Urquhart echoes this enthusiasm, eager for more narratives from the audience.
Urquhart reveals her own fascination with ghosts when reacting to a tale involving spiritual encounters and a protective dog. In discussing another listener's family legacy, both hosts commend the individual for their perspective on life's unexpected turns and the meaningful relationships that ensued.
Upon hearing about a hair-raising supernatural experience, the hosts empathize, saying they would be terrified, with Kelley humorously imagining an escape scenario. They jokingly attempt to recreate a demonic voice from a voicemail, balancing their s ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
The hosts' reactions and personal connections to the stories
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- EVP stands for Electronic Voice Phenomenon, which is the purported phenomenon of voices or sounds from the spirit world captured on audio recordings. Researchers and paranormal enthusiasts believe that these voices are not heard at the time of recording but become apparent during playback. EVP is often associated with paranormal investigations and ghost hunting.
- A séance is a gathering where individuals attempt to communicate with spirits of the deceased. Participants often sit in a circle, holding hands, and may use tools like a Ouija board or a medium to facilitate contact with the spirit world. Séances are commonly associated with spiritualism and paranormal investigations.
- Lily's desire for privacy in this context may imply that if she were a ghost, she would prefer not to be disturbed or have her story sensationalized. It suggests a wish for peace or solitude even in the afterlife. The hosts' mention of Lily's desire for privacy could be a way to humanize her and show respe ...
Counterarguments
- While the hosts express empathy and shock, it could be argued that their reactions are exaggerated for entertainment purposes and may not always reflect genuine emotion.
- Relating to paranormal encounters and strange family histories might alienate some listeners who are skeptical of such phenomena and prefer more grounded, factual storytelling.
- Personal engagement with stories can sometimes lead to bias, potentially affecting the objectivity of the hosts when discussing various narratives.
- The hosts' investment in supernatural stories might inadvertently promote belief in unverified phenomena, which could be seen as irresponsible if not balanced with a critical perspective.
- Encouraging further investigation into supernatural cases could be seen as encouraging belief in the paranormal without sufficient evidence.
- While the hosts' concern for unsettling tales is commendable, it's important to consider the privacy and emotional well-being of those involved in such stories, especially in cases of true crime.
- Expressing horror and disgust towards gruesome details and disdain towards perpetr ...
Related Shortform Content
Morbid: A True Crime Podcast | Episode 9: The Axeman of New Orleans AKA A Real Crumb
Ash Kelley, Alaina Urquhart
Morbid: A True Crime Podcast | Episode 3: The Dyatlov Pass Incident
Ashleigh Kelley, Alaina Urquhart
Morbid: A True Crime Podcast | Episode 10: The Sodder Children….where the hell are they?
Ash Kelley, Alaina Urquhart, Annie, Advertiser
Get access to the context and additional materials
Nostalgia and reminiscing about the past
Ash Kelley and Alaina Urquhart delve into a heartfelt discussion on the cultural touchstones of their pasts that evoke a strong sense of nostalgia and a yearning for the simplicity and intimacy of the old days.
Hosts fondly recall cultural touchstones of the past, like video rental stores and old-fashioned communication
Hosts discuss the personal significance and comforting sense of bygone eras
The hosts, Ash Kelley and Alaina Urquhart, share their warm memories from the past, painting scenes filled with clean, crisp air, and the warmth of the sun barely peeking through. They mention riding in the back of pickup trucks, a common practice that now seems like a relic from a bygone era. Kelley and Urquhart evoke the '90s vibe by referencing the cover of Geneva Rose's book, which resembles a nostalgic VHS tape. The hosts also humorously touch upon the difference between store-bought and homemade bread, with a proclivity for the latter, which they suggest is the 'real' bread.
Ash Kelley brings up the familiar routine of mailing DVDs and the quintessential Friday night trips to video rental stores, tapping into a shared communal experience many listeners would recognize from the '80s and '90s. Continuing with the theme of "what used to be," Kelley reminisces about relying on printed MapQuest directions before the advent of GPS technology, hinting at a time where planning and preparation held more importance.
The hosts reflect on family cookouts and the casual practice of kids riding unsafely in the back of pickup trucks. Despite the safety concerns of today, these memories are recounted with laughter and a hint of fondness for the closeness such practices fostered among families and friends.
Hosts lament the loss of certain social practices and the intimacy they fostered
Alaina Urquhart recalls the simpler times when her father wou ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Nostalgia and reminiscing about the past
Additional Materials
Clarifications
...
Counterarguments
- Nostalgia can sometimes idealize the past, overlooking its challenges and the benefits of modern advancements.
- The simplicity of the past often came with inconveniences and limitations that current technology has significantly improved.
- The sense of community felt in the past may still exist today, but it manifests differently due to changes in society and technology.
- While the hosts lament the loss of intimacy in social practices, digital communication has enabled connections across greater distances and with more immediacy.
- The safety concerns of practices like riding in the back of pickup trucks are valid, and regulations have evolved to prevent injuries and fatalities.
- The reliance on printed MapQuest directions before GPS technology may be seen as cumbersome and less efficient by today's standards.
- The longing for the closeness of past eras may overlook the diversity of experiences a ...
Related Shortform Content
Morbid: A True Crime Podcast | Episode 7: Charles Manson Part 1 Ya dig?
Ash Kelley, Alaina Urquhart, Advertiser
Morbid: A True Crime Podcast | Episode 9: The Axeman of New Orleans AKA A Real Crumb
Ash Kelley, Alaina Urquhart
Relaxed Fit: True Crime Roundup - The Melbourne Mushroom Murders
Henry Zebrowski, Theme Song, Ben Kissel, Marcus Parks
Get access to the context and additional materials
Listener engagement and feedback
Alaina Urquhart and Ash Kelley, the hosts of the podcast, experience an outpouring of admiration and personal connection from their audience.
Listeners express deep appreciation for the hosts and their podcast
The hosts receive heartfelt compliments and acknowledgment from listeners who deeply appreciate the effort and content provided by the podcast.
Listeners perceive the hosts as relatable, "spirit animal" figures
Listener Jackie compliments the hosts, stating "I fucking love all of the hard work you put into the podcast," and further appreciates Urquhart's work on her book, "The Butcher and the Wren." Jackie resonates with the hosts, sharing personal details that align with the hosts' experiences, while another listener, Becca, goes as far as to say she relates to them more than any other podcasters.
Listeners, including the one who reached out for their mother, love the hosts, and one has even labeled the hosts as her "whole ass spirit animals." This strong emotional connection indicates that listeners see the hosts as kindred spirits.
Listeners eagerly anticipate the hosts potentially featuring their stories on the podcast
Becca thanks the hosts for keeping her entertained and expresses excitement over a previous episode, showing that the content resonates pers ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Listener engagement and feedback
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- A "spirit animal" is a concept from various cultures, often Native American, representing a spiritual guide or protector in animal form. In modern usage, it's a metaphorical term to describe a person's deep connection or affinity with a particular animal's qualities or characteristics. When someone calls another their "spirit animal," they are expressing a strong identification with that person's traits or values. In this context, it signifies a profound emotional bond and relatability between the podcast hosts and their listeners.
- Featuring listener stories on a podcast can deepen the audience's connection by making them feel heard and valued. It adds a personal touch, ...
Counterarguments
- While the hosts receive positive feedback, it's possible that not all listeners are as engaged or satisfied, and their voices may be underrepresented in the provided context.
- The term "spirit animal" can be culturally insensitive to Indigenous peoples for whom spirit animals are a part of their spiritual beliefs and practices.
- The anticipation of listeners' stories being featured could create unrealistic expectations, as not all submissions can be included in the podcast.
- The personal impact of the podcast on listeners might not be as profound for all audience members, ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
