Dive into a chilling narrative with "Morbid," as hosts Ash Kelley and Alaina Urquhart unravel the harrowing 1963 case known as The Career Girl Murders. Through meticulous recounting, they explore the gruesome details of the fatal attack on Janice Wiley and Emily Hoffert by Ricky Robles. The podcast paints a vivid scene of a burglary turned deadly, its aftermath, and the cascade of events that led to the conviction of the true perpetrator after an initial miscarriage of justice.
The somber tale continues with a critical examination of George Whitmore Jr.'s wrongful conviction, shedding light on the prejudicial conduct of law enforcement, specifically Detective Eddie Bulger. "Morbid" doesn't just recount the details of a historic crime; it delves into the far-reaching impact of this case on the American judicial landscape. By dissecting how this injustice prompted significant changes like the introduction of Miranda rights, the episode underscores the profound transformations in legal protocols and the abolition of the death penalty in New York that arose from this infamous case.
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
In 1963, Ricky Robles commits a heinous crime, murdering Janice Wiley and Emily Hoffert during a burglary for drug money. Selecting an Upper East Side building for its lack of a doorman, Robles breaks into the apartment through an open window. Inside, he sexually assaults Wiley and, when Hoffert intervenes, ties them together. Under the pressure of being identified, Robles panics and stabs both women to death, using a bottle and knives. He then steals money to purchase heroin. Initially the wrong man, George Whitmore, is charged with the murders until Robles’s eventual confession leads to his arrest. Tried in 1965, Robles is found guilty and sentenced to life imprisonment, only admitting the murders to a parole board in 1986.
Detective Eddie Bulger, notorious for his racism, wrongfully targets George Whitmore Jr. for the murder of Wiley and Hoffert. Whitmore is coerced into a false confession after 26 hours of interrogation, during which his rights are not communicated, nor is he offered legal representation. Despite incoherences in the confession and an alibi confirmed by his coworkers, Bulger manipulates evidence and authorities pursue prosecution doggedly. Photos wrongfully purported as being of Wiley are a pivotal point in the case. Whitmore faces years in prison for crimes he did not commit until Robles admits to the murders, highlighting a profound miscarriage of justice attributable to Bulger and others, who faced no accountability for their actions.
George Whitmore's wrongful conviction is instrumental in catalyzing legal reforms within the United States. His case becomes a significant factor in the suspension of the death penalty in New York and influences the historic Supreme Court ruling on Miranda rights in 1966. This ruling transforms legal procedures by mandating that criminal suspects are informed of their right to an attorney, ensuring that such miscarriages of justice do not reoccur. Whitmore's experience, while tragic, marks a turning point in the history of the American legal system, leading to more stringent guidelines for police interrogations and suspects' rights.
1-Page Summary
Alaina Urquhart and Ash Kelley discuss the appalling murders of Janice Wiley and Emily Hoffert, which shook the city in 1963.
Ricky Robles admitted to killing Janis Wiley and Emily Hoffert while looking for drug money. His taped confession was submitted to the prosecutor, contributing to a warrant for his arrest. During the commission of a burglary, Robles entered an apartment on East 88th Street. He chose the building because it had no doorman. After finding the doors locked, he spotted an open window, climbed onto the ledge, and entered apartment 3C.
Inside, he encountered Janis Wiley in her bedroom and decided to sexually assault her. When Emily Hoffert walked in and resisted, Robles tied the two women together after Janice tried to calm Emily down, suggesting compliance to avoid harm. Hoffert wanted a good look at Robles, presumably for identification, which panicked Robles. He deliberated for about five minutes before stabbing both women to death with a glass bottle and two knives, grabbing different implements from the kitchen as he did so.
After the murders, Robles stole money from Emily's purse to buy heroin. He was tried for the murders in October 1965, f ...
The brutal murders of Janice Wiley and Emily Hoffert in 1963 by Ricky Robles
...
Detective Eddie Bulger, described as being incredibly racist, fixated on 19-year-old George Whitmore Jr., pursuing his wrongful conviction for crimes he didn't commit.
George Whitmore endured 26 hours of interrogation without being informed of his rights or given the option to have a lawyer present. In an exhausted and vulnerable state, Whitmore signed a 61-page confession which included intimate details about the Wiley-Hoffert murders — details supposedly known only to the police and the perpetrator. However, the confession was riddled with inaccuracies, such as the claim that the door to the victims' apartment was unlocked, whereas it was actually found locked.
Even though Whitmore had an alibi, which was confirmed by his co-workers, who stated that he was working at a New Jersey restaurant during the March on Washington and watching Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.'s televised speech, authorities still pushed forward with prosecution. Detective Bulger claimed that photographs found in Whitmore's possession were of one of the murder victims, Janice Wiley, which Whitmore denied, and Janice's father confirmed they were not of his daughter. Despite the confession's doubtful credibility, authorities pursued the case against Whitmore relentlessly. Deputy Police Commissioner Walter Arm noted that Whitmore provided details that should only be known by the killer or detectives, casting a shadow on the legitimacy of the confession.
Whitmore's case continued to push ...
Racist detective Eddie Bulger targeted 19-year-old George Whitmore and pushed for wrongful conviction of assault and murders
...
Whitmore's case, which was one of the catalysts for significant reforms in legal procedures and the justice system, serves as an important chapter in legal history.
The case of Whitmore played a pivotal role in sparking changes that have had far-reaching consequences. It not only aided in the movement towards suspending the death penalty in New York but also influenced the landmark Supreme Court Miranda rul ...
Whitmore's wrongful conviction helped lead to reforms such as Miranda rights and death penalty abolition in New York
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser