Dive into the enigmatic case of George Saxton's murder in Canton, Ohio, with "Morbid" hosts Ash Kelley and Alaina Urquhart. The episode delves into the troubled relationship between Saxton and Annie George, a romance that ended tumultuously with public disputes and litigation. Annie's intense focus on her former lover, which resulted in her engaging in lawsuits and public confrontations, paints a picture of a woman driven more by heartbreak than hatred, earning her the community's empathy amidst her alarming behavior.
In a twist of fate, when Saxton is found murdered, suspicion turns toward Annie, due primarily to her prior threats and some incriminating, yet circumstantial, pieces of evidence. The subsequent trial becomes a polarizing affair, with the defense and prosecution painting vastly different portraits of both the victim's morals and Annie's potential for murder. "Morbid" gives listeners a detailed account of a trial that shook a community, where Annie's acquittal leaves more questions than answers, especially after conflicting testimonies emerge post-trial. Join the journey through this tangled web of emotion, law, and enduring mystery in this episode of "Morbid."
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
George Saxton's murder in Canton, Ohio, was marked by his fraught relationship with Annie George—their breakup had led to a series of confrontations and legal issues. Despite their split, Annie became fixated on Saxton, resorting to public confrontations and multiple lawsuits against him and her ex-husband Sample George for alienation of affection and breach of promise. Although her behavior was seen as obsessive, the public sympathized with her, viewing her actions as driven by emotion rather than malicious intent.
Saxton was fatally shot and circumstances pointed towards Annie because of her known threats against his life. Witnesses spotted a figure presumed to be a woman acting suspiciously at the scene. Despite these observations, police had no solid evidence, and Annie's arrest was based on circumstantial evidence, such as a discoloration on her hand and burrs on her dress matching the crime scene. The defense argued that Saxton could have been killed by a man disguised as a woman, adding to the public doubt regarding Annie's guilt.
The trial of Annie George was influenced by the community's mixed opinions of George Saxton's character, viewed by some as justification for his murder. The prosecution argued Annie's guilt based on her history, threats, and circumstantial evidence. The defense focused on Saxton's mistreatment of Annie, suggesting her threats were due to emotional distress. Despite Annie's acquittal, additional witnesses later claimed they saw her commit the murder. However, due to double jeopardy, she could not be retried, leaving her legally absolved of the crime.
1-Page Summary
The tale of George Saxton's murder unfolds against a backdrop of his turbulent relationship with Annie George, whose obsession after their breakup led to a series of confrontations, legal battles, and public outcries that rattled the community of Canton, Ohio.
Despite their split, Annie George remained resolutely committed to winning George Saxton back, going as far as standing outside his residence, screaming for him to return to her, and hurling obscenities about his new partner, Eva Outhouse. The community became aware of the toxic nature of the relationship after the breakup, and Annie was known to make threats against George's life. Her obsession took the form of stalking, with Annie accosting Saxton publicly, beseeching him to return to her, and waiting for him outside his block and even his room.
Annie's refusal to let go led her to show up outside George's residence and his new partner's home, stalking them, and causing public scenes. Her behavior escalated to alarming levels, demonstrated by waiting for George near Eva's house, pleading with him not to enter or standing outside for hours, flipping between pleading cries and hurling abuse at Eva. In the legal arena, multiple lawsuits ensued, including one where Sample George, Annie's estranged husband, filed a $30,000 lawsuit against George Saxton for alienation of affection. Annie herself filed her own breach of promise suit against George, demanding $50,000, though it was thrown out of court, only for her to immediately refile it.
Annie’s legal pressure on George suggested an obsession rather than legitimate legal complaints. George was concurrently fighting a lawsuit Sample George had taken to the Supreme Court. The legal battles were not just about the relationship but also included allegations of stolen belongings, forcing George to defend himself on multip ...
The murder of George Saxton
...
The murder of George Saxton and the doubts over Annie's guilt involve tangled relations and an array of evidence that drew sustained public intrigue.
George Saxton, fatally shot on his way to his girlfriend's house, was believed to be targeted due to his fraught relationship with Annie. Witnesses described a figure in dark clothing, presumed to be a woman, who leaned down to Saxton after the shooting, grabbed his arm, and fired additional shots before fleeing. At the scene, there were no obvious signs of violence aside from the gunshot wounds, and Saxton’s satchel was found nearby with its contents scattered.
Annie's reputation for making threats against Saxton's life became a focus of the investigation. She had publicly assaulted him and had been heard shouting at him about not entering a house with his girlfriend. In the aftermath of Saxton’s murder, the public instantly suspected Annie, and she was arrested at Cora Oberlin’s rooming house after being found at Florence Klinger’s home roughly half an hour after the shooting.
Annie was seen calm and unagitated while walking through town, in contrast with her usual demeanor. After her arrest, police noticed a discoloration on Annie's hand resembling gunpowder residue, and the right side of her dress had burrs matching those at the crime scene. Her previous visit to Chicago where she purchased a .38 caliber revolver, which she allegedly planned to use on Saxton after a legal case with a person named Sample George, was also disclosed by the prosecution.
Despite these allegations, the prosecution had little physical evidence and no eyewitnesses to directly place Annie at the scene with a gun. They relied heavily on circumstantial elements such as Annie’s threats, her physical assault on Saxton, and ...
Murder of George Saxton
Annie George’s trial was a complex weave of public sentiment, character judgments, and circumstantial evidence, culminating in an acquittal that was later called into question by a surprise eyewitness account.
Public opinions played a significant role in the trial of Annie George, affecting the sentiment around the case. The local press, mindful of their reputation, exercised restraint in reporting Annie’s accusations against George Saxton. The report implied that George Saxton’s less than honorable departure from Annie influenced the public to empathize less with his murder. Saxton was widely regarded as someone most people only pretended to respect, and an individual who was not genuinely liked within the community. A journalist wrote that Canton residents were glad of Saxton's demise, labeling him a home wrecker. This social bias affected the jury's perceptions, as George's history with women was considered by some as a justification for the shooting.
The prosecution presented a scenario in which Annie, overcome with indignation and jealousy, shot George Saxton multiple times outside the home of another woman. They based their argument on circumstantial evidence, which included powder on Annie’s hands and her previous threats towards Saxton.
The defense, spearheaded by attorney John Welty, did not dissuade the circulation of rumors about George Saxton’s character, using these innuendos to build a case that justified Annie's actions. Welty detailed the turbulent legal history between Saxton and Annie, including Saxton’s failure to marry Annie after a promise, seduction, and deception. The defense claimed that the threats she had made were outbursts of passion resulting from Saxton’s abandonment, painting the picture of a woman pushed to the brink by a man who was cruel and abusive. They firmly stood by the notion that threats alone did not constitute evidence for murder, focusing instead on Saxton's reputation as a self-centered playboy ...
Trial and acquittal of Annie George
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser