In this episode of Money Rehab, analyst Ryan Detrick examines technical market indicators that suggest optimistic market outcomes. He explains how specific patterns in the S&P 500 and the Zweig Breadth Thrust indicator have historically predicted market gains, and discusses how market sentiment often works in counterintuitive ways—with extreme negative sentiment sometimes signaling upcoming rallies.
The conversation also covers practical investment strategies, including portfolio diversification across different assets and geographical regions. Nicole Lapin and Detrick explore the potential of international markets, the role of gold in traditional portfolios, and the importance of maintaining a disciplined investment approach rather than making emotional decisions during market volatility. Their discussion provides context for understanding market behavior and making informed investment choices.
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
Analyst Ryan Detrick discusses several technical indicators that suggest optimistic market outcomes despite recent volatility. He points to a particularly powerful signal: when the S&P 500 gains 1.5% or more for three consecutive days, the market has shown positive returns 90% of the time over the following six months, and 100% of the time over one year, based on data since 1950.
Detrick also highlights the Zweig Breadth Thrust indicator, which measures market momentum by tracking advancing versus declining stocks. According to Ned Davis Research, this indicator has successfully predicted market gains in all 19 instances since World War II. When combined with other positive signals and a calming VIX (dropping below 25), these indicators suggest market stabilization ahead.
Detrick emphasizes the importance of portfolio diversification across different assets and geographical regions. He particularly recommends increasing international exposure, noting strong performances in markets like Germany, China, and several African countries. For investors new to international markets, Nicole Lapin suggests using low-cost ETFs like VEA, VXUS, and VEU.
The conversation also touches on gold as a diversification tool, with Detrick suggesting it could be incorporated within the bond portion of a traditional 60/40 portfolio. He advocates for a disciplined "set it and forget it" approach, emphasizing the benefits of dollar-cost averaging through regular investments in retirement accounts.
Market sentiment often works in counterintuitive ways, according to Detrick. He explains that extreme negative sentiment and high levels of short selling can actually signal upcoming market rallies, comparing it to a beach ball being pushed underwater that eventually surges upward.
Nicole Lapin advocates for focusing on charts rather than emotions when making investment decisions, as emotional responses often lead to suboptimal choices. Detrick agrees, pointing out how fear-driven decisions, such as selling during market drops, can harm long-term investment success. He emphasizes the importance of recognizing and overcoming psychological biases in investment decision-making.
1-Page Summary
Analyst Ryan Detrick sheds light on the technical market indicators that can foreshadow future market performance, providing optimism despite recent market scares.
Detrick points out that even with a pullback in the markets, such as the 25% stock gain last year despite a three-day market scare in the first week of August, other indicators suggest the financial markets are more stable than they seem.
Detrick illustrates a specific bullish signal: when the S&P 500 gains one and a half percent for three consecutive days. This phenomenon has occurred 10 times since 1950, and in 90% of these cases, the S&P 500 was up six months later, and it was higher all 10 times one year later. Detrick further notes that the average return after such a three-day gain is over 20 percent, implying a strong positive correlation with future market performance.
Detrick also brings attention to the Zweig Breadth Thrust indicator. Developed by Martin Zweig, it measures the number of stocks advancing versus declining on the NYSE, searching for a move from oversold to overbought conditions in a typically 10-day EMA. The Zweig Breadth Thrust is triggered when there's a swift shift in market momentum, often after market lows or sell-offs. Detrick cites Ned Davis Research, noting the market has been higher one year later after each of the 19 occurrences of the Zweig Breadth Thrust trigger since World War II.
Technical Market Indicators and Their Predictive Power
Financial experts emphasize the significance of diversifying investment portfolios across different assets and geographies to mitigate risk and enhance long-term performance.
The importance of staying diversified in an investment portfolio has been underscored by the prior condition of investors to favor large cap tech names before their significant drop. Ryan Detrick underscores the importance of increasing international exposure, observing positive performances in Germany, China, and several African countries. He also notes the strong performance of gold, though it may be currently overstretched.
Nicole Lapin and Ryan Detrick discuss the intimidation investors might feel towards international markets. To combat the common "home country bias," Detrick suggests using ETFs, which provide a simple avenue for diversification into developed international markets, such as Germany. These model portfolios typically allocate around 10-15% to developed international markets. Lapin suggests low-cost ETFs such as VEA, VXUS, and VEU for those looking to diversify with international markets and gold.
Detrick touches on the benefits of holding international stocks, especially when the U.S. dollar is weak. He concurs with Lapin on the strategy of buying gold during dips and mentions adding gold to some models back in March of 2023. In terms of portfolio allocation, Detrick notes it could be beneficial to have some gold within the 40% bond allocation in a traditional 60/40 portfolio, referring to GLD as a prominent gold ETF.
Detrick comments on the portfolio strategy at Carson Group, mentioning an initial overweight in equities but diversification into othe ...
Diversification and Asset Allocation Strategies
Investing isn't just about numbers and trends; it's deeply entwined with human psychology and sentiment. Ryan Detrick and Nicole Lapin explore how emotions and perceptions significantly impact market fluctuations and investment outcomes.
Sentiment in the investing world can often be a signal for contrarian opportunities. Ryan Detrick cites instances of extreme negativity and negative calls made by people as indicative of the market's sentiment. He points out that high levels of negative sentiment, alongside a prevalence of short selling—where investors bet against stocks—can often lead to a rally. This is because when the market starts to recover, short sellers buy back shares to cover their positions, resulting in additional buying pressure. Detrick likens this to a beach ball being pushed underwater; once released, it surges upwards. He suggests that such overall negativity, while seemingly detrimental, can present positive scenarios for alert investors.
Similarly, when the investing public is excessively bullish or bearish, it could signal a time to act in opposition. For instance, Detrick references the cover of Barron's magazine featuring gold bars at the height of gold's popularity as an indication that it might be time for the run to pause. This sentiment-driven peak, he recalls, was marked by the GLD ETF surpassing the SPY ETF in assets, which turned out to be a major turning point for gold prices.
Nicole Lapin suggests favoring charts over sentiments in making investment decisions, as they remove "the drama and emotion" from investing. Emotions often lead to suboptimal decisions, as illustrated by investors who sell off their holdings in the wake of a market drop. Detrick discusses this tendency to sell when the market is down, even if an individual might have favo ...
The Role of Sentiment and Psychology in Investing
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser