This episode explores the advantages of newsletters over social media platforms, offering creators more control and direct access to their audience. Experienced newsletter writers share advice on designing engaging newsletters by setting a consistent format and tone, providing value, optimizing for open rates, utilizing storytelling techniques, and experimenting while maintaining consistency.
Strategies for growing a newsletter subscriber base are also covered, including leveraging platform features like Instagram, lead magnets, challenges, and cross-promotions. The episode highlights newsletters as a powerful tool for creators to build a connection with their audience and establish themselves as experts in their field.

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
Newsletters provide direct access to your audience by having their email addresses, says Jason Pfeiffer. This means bypassing platform algorithms, as content reaches users' inboxes directly. The risk of relying on platforms is illustrated by Pfeiffer's experience with Facebook's failed Bulletin, which left him "out in the cold" after it ended support.
Pfeiffer advocates for establishing a promise and fulfilling it consistently, with surprises. His newsletter has a structured format with sections for easy reading and skimming. He aims for a unique, relatable voice providing "success and satisfaction tips."
Morgan Lavoie plans to focus on environmental challenges, positioning her newsletter as a solution. Newsletters should offer practical advice through stories, exercises, and analysis, says Pfeiffer.
Alyssa Dulin suggests crafting curiosity-piquing subject lines and sending welcome emails to set expectations. Maintaining cadence and quality builds trust, so consider evergreen newsletters with automation.
Lavoie emphasizes storytelling to make complex topics approachable, drawing from her tutoring background.
Pfeiffer iterates to find what resonates while keeping structure consistent to avoid burnout. Lavoie simplified her format based on advice.
Dulin recommends leveraging Instagram, lead magnets, challenges, and cross-promotions to expand reach. Automated evergreen newsletters via tools like ConvertKit aid deliverability.
1-Page Summary
The debate between the value of newsletters and social media platforms for connecting with audiences reveals fundamental differences in control and dependency.
One of the key advantages of newsletters is that you "own your customer." By having direct access to their email addresses, you can reach them independently of any social media platform. This direct line of communication means that you can bypass algorithms or platform decisions that might otherwise dictate who sees your content.
Pfeiffer, an advocate for newsletters, shares his experience with Bulletin, Facebook’s failed attempt to enter the newsletter space. Pfeiffer emphasizes that while newsletters provide a way to directly reach and retain your audience, his experience with Bulletin exposed the risks of platform dependency. With newsletters, your content lands directly in an individual's inbox, whereas on platforms like Facebook, your success could be contingent on promotional spaces within the platform itself, which appeals to a different kind of audience profile.
The challenges with social media platforms become starker when you consider scenarios such as a potential ban. For instance, if TikTok were to be banned in the US, creators who built their entire business around it would pot ...
The Value of Newsletters vs. Social Media Platforms
Creating an engaging newsletter is essential for maintaining a dedicated readership. Morgan Lavoie expresses a desire to understand both creative and technical best practices for starting one.
Consistency in your newsletter's format and tone reassures your subscribers and helps establish trust.
Jason Pfeiffer talks about the importance of establishing a promise with your newsletter and delivering on that promise consistently but with surprising elements. His newsletter goes through various iterations, suggesting changes were made to refine its structure. It is usually around a thousand words and divided into three or four sections, easily read and skimmable with big headers marking each section. This helps in not losing readers, especially those who read on their phones with distractions around them.
Pfeiffer describes his newsletter as providing weekly success and satisfaction tips, showcasing a unique voice and style. A newsletter must be valuable and establish a promise to deliver what people want, fulfilling that promise, and addressing readers' problems or challenges. Pfeiffer emphasizes making a newsletter relatable and useful to an audience and should have a specific approach that differentiates it in the market.
Newsletters should offer practical advice and solve subscribers' challenges.
Morgan Lavoie plans to focus on one environmental issue per week in her newsletter and offer a related personal challenge. By sharing her experiences with the weekly challenge, she positions her newsletter as a solution for those wanting to be more environmentally friendly.
After presenting a problem and telling a related story, newsletters should give readers exercises or questions to consider as a form of practical advice. Lavoie's newsletter, which suggests practical advice for being more sustainable, provides value to her readers by detailing her experience with weekly challenges and whether she succeeded.
To ensure readers engage with your newsletter, it's crucial to optimize for open rates and deliverability.
Alyssa Dulin suggests crafting subject lines that grab the reader's attention without being clickbait. They should stand out in the inbox and ...
Best Practices For Creating an Engaging Newsletter
Experienced newsletter creators such as Morgan Lavoie, Jason Pfeiffer, and Alyssa Dulin share their insights on connecting with readers, maintaining consistency, and growing a subscriber base.
Morgan Lavoie emphasizes the power of stories to make content relatable and to establish a personal connection with her audience. By sharing experiences and challenges, like her environmental challenges or the mild winters in Maine, she makes her newsletter's content more relevant to her readers. Lavoie applies her skill of simplifying academic topics through anecdotes to make complex topics, such as business and climate change, more approachable. Reflecting on her past as a college tutor who helped students understand science courses through storytelling, she understands the effectiveness of this technique.
Jason Pfeiffer advocates for experimenting with content to see what resonates with readers while maintaining a consistent structure and tone to avoid burnout and ensure sustainability. He reflects on his own experiences of iterating through different newsletter phases, names, and concepts, finding a balance between experimenting and consistency to solidify his brand's identity to the readers. To avoid overwhelming efforts, Pfeiffer has developed a formula for his newsletter that includes the problem being solved, a compelling story, and an exercise, allowing him to write each newsletter efficiently within about an hour and a half.
Similarly, after receiving advice, Lavoie simplified her newsletter by eliminating interviews and complex segments. She acknowledges the uncertainty around the concept but is open to the newsletter evolving over time.
Alyssa Dulin provides practical advice on using social media, challenges, and platform fea ...
Specific Advice and Tips From Experienced Newsletter Creators
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
