In this episode of Modern Wisdom, Anne-Laure Le Cunff and Chris Williamson examine the drawbacks of society's fixation on finding one's purpose. Le Cunff explains how this obsession can lead to constant dissatisfaction and comparison, noting that human interests naturally evolve over time, making it impossible to predict what will bring fulfillment in the future.
The conversation explores how cognitive scripts and biases influence life choices, and how humans' natural aversion to uncertainty affects decision-making. Le Cunff introduces the concept of liminal spaces—periods of transition and uncertainty—as opportunities for growth, and discusses the benefits of maintaining diverse interests and identities. She and Williamson also address the role of mindful habit formation in personal development and daily routines.
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
Anne-Laure Le Cunff and Chris Williamson explore the drawbacks of obsessing over finding one's purpose. According to Le Cunff, this fixation often leads to dissatisfaction and endless comparison with seemingly purposeful individuals. She explains that the linear narrative of finding purpose overlooks how human interests naturally evolve and change over time, making it impossible to predict what we'll enjoy in the future.
Le Cunff identifies several cognitive scripts that influence our life choices. These include the sequel script (aligning choices with past decisions), the crowd pleaser script (making decisions to impress others), and the Hollywood script (believing our purpose must be grand). She and Williamson discuss how humans have an innate aversion to uncertainty, leading to compensatory control behaviors like rigid routines and schedules. This desire for certainty, Le Cunff explains, stems from our ancestral need to avoid threats and ensure survival.
Le Cunff introduces the concept of liminal spaces—periods of transition and uncertainty—as opportunities for growth and self-discovery. Rather than rushing through these uncomfortable periods, she advocates for embracing them and using them for reflection. She recommends treating personal growth like a scientific experiment, starting with small, low-risk trials to discover what truly brings fulfillment.
Le Cunff emphasizes the value of cultivating diverse interests and identities, which she calls self-complexity. This approach provides multiple paths to fulfillment and helps prevent burnout when one pursuit becomes challenging. She and Williamson also discuss the importance of mindful habit formation, particularly regarding morning and evening routines. Le Cunff notes that the type of [restricted term] sources we engage with early in the day can influence our cravings and decision-making throughout the day.
1-Page Summary
The "find your purpose" mindset is scrutinized by Anne-Laure Le Cunff and Chris Williamson, pointing out that it can lead to dissatisfaction and serve as a false narrative that doesn't account for the unpredictable evolution of personal interests.
According to Anne-Laure Le Cunff, the fixation on finding one's ultimate purpose leads to misery as it imposes a belief that life is meaningless without a clearly defined purpose. This mindset causes individuals to draw futile comparisons with those who seem passionate and appear to have a direction. It traps people in a relentless pursuit of purpose at the expense of exploring a variety of experiences that could potentially lead them to their genuine interests.
Le Cunff notes that time spent comparing oneself to others, who are perceived to have a more profound sense of direction, can create anxiety. This compulsive comparison hinders personal exploration and discovery of purpose, making individuals feel lost and directionless.
The societal narrative pressuring individuals to map out their life's purpose often overlooks the non-linear nature of human development.
Humans, Le Cunff explains, ...
The Problems With the "Find Your Purpose" Mindset
Anne-Laure Le Cunff and Chris Williamson unpack the complex world of decision-making, highlighting how cognitive scripts and a deep-seated dislike of uncertainty guide our choices, often without our awareness.
Le Cunff discusses cognitive scripts, which are patterns of behavior people follow in certain situations affecting significant life decisions.
One common pattern, the sequel script, guides individuals to make choices consistent with their past. For example, people may choose careers that align with their university majors or tailor CVs to present a coherent narrative of past experiences.
Le Cunff identifies another script: the crowd pleaser. This script drives decisions that aim to impress or meet others' expectations, potentially at the expense of personal fulfillment or unconventional pursuits.
Le Cunff personalizes this by explaining how she manages her own anxious procrastination regarding big presentations. To counter this bias, she schedules a meeting with a coach two weeks prior to her deadline, creating an obligation to another person that motivates her to prepare in advance.
Williamson and Le Cunff explore societal tendencies to value appearance over substance, referencing Google engineers who focused more on showcasing rather than truly contributing to their work.
The third script Le Cunff talks about is the Hollywood script, pushing the belief that life choices must be grand and significant. This script parallels the Kronos timeline—societal expectations of achieving specific milestones by certain ages.
Humans have an innate aversion to uncertainty, striving for control and predictability for survival reasons.
Le Cunff describes the human brain's historical need to reduce uncertainty for survival, such as identifying threats like noises in the bushes or unknown adversaries. Today, despite vastly different environments, human brains still seek certainty.
Modern humans equate uncertainty with potential death, reminiscent of ancestral dangers, even though existential risks have changed. Williamson adds that people often prefer to anticipate catastrophe over facing unpredictability.
Le Cunff highlights research showing people's preference for self-inflicted pain over the uncertainty of its timing and also discusses ...
Influence of Biases and Factors on Decision-Making
Anne-Laure Le Cunff discusses the benefits of liminal spaces and the value of small experiments in self-discovery and personal growth.
Le Cunff introduces the concept of liminal spaces as periods of transition filled with uncertainty—such as the time after getting engaged but before marriage, or after graduation but before starting a job. These spaces, while uncomfortable, present opportunities for growth despite their inherent uncertainty.
Liminal spaces are described as times when individuals find themselves between stages, where the past is behind them but the future is not yet within reach. These periods can be seen in places like airports where identity is unclear, and one is neither here nor there.
Le Cunff advises that although the brain naturally wants to escape uncertainty, if one can learn to embrace these transitional periods, valuable insights might be found. Recognizing and embracing liminal spaces allows for self-reflection. Taking advantage of these periods, even in short durations like walking between meetings, can aid mental preparation and self-discovery.
Le Cunff also highlights the difference between kairos, qualitative experiences, and kronos, quantitative time. Focusing on kairos helps resist the urge to rush and may yield deeper insights from every moment. She stresses the importance of engaging with the present, observing that this can lead to personal insights, even if that means lingering in discomfort.
Le Cunff points out the need to experiment and treat personal growth as a scientific endeavor. By starting with a hypothesis, trying new things, and learning from mistakes, individuals can discover their purpose.
Le Cunff suggests adopting a scientific appr ...
Self-Discovery and Growth Through Experimentation and Liminal Spaces
Anne-Laure Le Cunff and Chris Williamson explore the dynamic relationship between self-complexity and habits, and how they influence overall well-being.
Le Cunff discusses self-complexity, which entails having various interests and identities. This diversity provides a buffer in times when one pursuit falters, allowing a person to find fulfillment elsewhere and avoid burnout and boredom.
With the concept of self-complexity, Le Cunff suggests multiple paths to fulfillment reduce the reliance on just one identity or interest. Injuries or a waning interest in one pursuit can be managed more easily if an individual has other areas to thrive. She highlights that having the flexibility to pause and resume interests can prevent burnout or the abandonment of the passion, allowing for sustained, long-term engagement.
Le Cunff underscores the importance of pausing using the concept of kairos versus kronos time. Focusing on rich experiences over quantitative achievements leads to less reliance on a single pursuit. This balance can be maintained by taking regular breaks for personal activities, without the added pressure of productivity, leading to maintained engagement and long-term well-being.
Le Cunff discusses the formation of habits and the benefits of being mindful about the timing of daily routines and the sources of [restricted term].
Highlighting the importance of how one starts the day, Le Cunff explains that habit formation varies across individuals and is based on the repetition of actions. Enjoyment and a sense of progress can make habits more appealing and easier to adhere to. Conversely, Chris Williamson discusses avoiding caffeine early in the morning and mindful exp ...
The Importance of Self-Complexity and Habits for Well-Being
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser