Dive into "Media Pressure" with hosts John Smith, Fred Murray, Julie Murray, Curtis Murray, Timothy Ervin, and Terry O'Connell as they explore the haunting cases of two young women who disappeared in North Country under similar circumstances. Delve into the harrowing details of these chilling events, where initial suspicions pointed towards Israel Keys and theories of a possible serial predator were scrutinized by Vermont and New Hampshire law enforcement, ultimately finding no such link between the cases.
Hear about the tireless search effort led by Fred Murray to find his daughter, including legal battles for access to records against a resistant state, and his direct confrontations with individuals connected to the case. Additionally, the episode uncovers intricate details of Mara's car crash from technical analyses and shares the impact of social media in the continuous endeavor to solve this mystery, with accounts of resistance faced by Helena Murray while managing online campaigns. As the podcast unfolds, listeners are presented with the persistence of search efforts over the years, highlighting the complex web of hope, disappointment, and the relentless pursuit of answers that these cases continue to evoke.
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
Two young women, including Brianna Maitland, vanished under eerily similar circumstances in the North Country, raising suspicion of a serial predator. Both Maitland's and Mara's disappearances sparked fear of a connection to Israel Keys, a serial killer. Despite the anxiety in the community, law enforcement in Vermont and New Hampshire eventually determined that the cases were not linked, dispelling the theory of a serial killer's involvement.
Fred Murray's relentless pursuit to find his daughter is marked by explorations of every possible lead and rappelling into mineshafts. Alongside legal aid from attorney Timothy Ervin, Murray has fought for access to records via lawsuits, facing a significant pushback from the state, which cited a 75% chance of criminal proceedings and the "Murray Exemption." His interactions with locals include befriending John Smith, against police advice, and confronting persons of interest directly, such as Claude Moulton, who refused a polygraph test.
The analysis of Mara's car revealed it was moving when it crashed, with an acute angle collision that caused asymmetrical damage. High beams were on, and the seatbelt was not fastened. The car's Sensing Diagnostic Module indicated two crashes a fraction of a second apart and seven attempts to restart the engine after the airbags deployed, suggesting deliberate post-crash efforts to operate the vehicle.
Helena Murray spearheaded social media campaigns to raise awareness, facing challenges such as moderating discourse and confronting online trolls who spread misinformation and targeted her with vicious attacks.
Persistent search efforts have continued, including a 2019 excavation in the basement of a local home, where cadaver dogs and ground-penetrating radar indicated potential evidence, but only a piece of pottery was found. In 2021, a search at Loon Mountain ski slopes followed the recovery of human remains which did not belong to the missing person, leaving the family and investigators with unresolved questions.
1-Page Summary
The North Country has been troubled by eerie similarities in the cases of two young women who vanished, sparking fears and suspicions regarding a serial predator.
Brianna Maitland disappeared under circumstances that unnervingly mirrored those of another woman named Mara, with Maitland's case occurring about 90 miles from where Mara disappeared. Both incidents prompted fears that they could be the acts of a serial killer. Israel Keys, a known serial killer, was brought up in connection with the cases, ra ...
Key disappearances in the area
Fred Murray has been at the forefront of efforts to find his missing daughter, driven by an unwavering determination and supported by an extensive network of volunteers and legal advocates.
Fred Murray has consistently explored every possibility in his search, often placing himself in precarious situations to follow even the slightest lead. His fearless commitment to finding his daughter was evidenced by an instance where he decided to rappel into an unexplored mineshaft without any training.
Fred Murray, with the legal aid of attorney Timothy Ervin, undertook legal battles to uncover investigative records in the search for his daughter.
In New Hampshire, Julie Murray explains, her father pushed for more transparency, requesting access to records under the Right to Know Law. Despite these efforts, their requests were continually rebuffed due to the case's active status. Timothy Ervin from the firm of Gallant & Ervin stepped in to represent Fred Murray, leveraging the Right to Know Law in an attempt to gain access to the files. Their initial lawsuit was met with a denial by the Grafton Superior Court, supported by the state's argument that there was a 75% likelihood of criminal proceedings.
After the case escalated to the New Hampshire Supreme Court, the state maintained a strong stance, citing a significant chance of law enforcement action, a position which ultimately led to the withholding of records and birthed the so-called Murray Exemption.
Fred Murray’s ...
Fred Murray's search efforts
Parka's meticulous investigation into Mara's car accident provided key insights into the circumstances that occurred just before the crash.
The analysis conducted by Parka unveiled that Mara's Saturn was in motion, moving forward, when it encountered an accident on Route 112. The car's damage did not align with what typically results from striking a tree. Instead, it supported the conclusion that the vehicle was under its own propulsion when the collision with a fixed object occurred at an acute angle. Further examination revealed uneven damage; the hood was pushed back and buckled, bending the radiator's support. Key indicators of the crash dynamics included the car's initiation of a clockwise rotation before exiting the roadway and the evidence that the impact speed was notably low. Additional details from the scene, such as the high beams being activated and the driver’s seatbelt remaining unfastened, were noted.
The Sensing Diagnostic Module (SDM) of the car held critical data that revealed two distinct events happening a mere two one-hundredths of a second apart. The first was a non-deployment event, likely as the vehicle e ...
Analysis of Mara's car
Helena Murray took the initiative in creating an online presence to raise awareness for her cause.
Despite her efforts to promote a positive message, Helena faced significant challenges. She became the gatekeeper, moderating comments to keep the discussion constructive. However, her role made her a target for online trolls. These trolls not only infiltrat ...
Social media efforts spearheaded by Helena Murray
...
As new clues and rumors emerge, the search for answers in a long-standing mystery continues with efforts intensifying over recent years, including searches at a private residence and a ski slope.
In 2019, following up on a tip involving a disturbing discovery by a contractor, the family of the missing individual investigated rumors that suggested she might have been buried in the basement of a local home. The rumor prompted them to focus on a basement where what was reported to be bones were found before the floor was cemented over. The homeowner granted the family permission to search, enabling independent cadaver dogs to alert to the same area on two occasions and the use of ground-penetrating radar to reveal disturbances in the earth.
These findings were compelling enough to involve the New Hampshire State Police, who conducted an official excavation. Unfortunately for the family seeking closure, they were not allowed to witness the excavation, which resulted in the discovery of only a piece of pottery, not the hoped-for evidence of their loved one's fate.
A separate lead unofficially titled the "Loon Mountain 3" due to employees not showing up for work on the night of the disappearance le ...
Ongoing search efforts over the years
...
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser