Podcasts > Media Pressure > Episode 7: We Looked Into That

Episode 7: We Looked Into That

By Voices for Justice Media

Dive into "Media Pressure" with hosts John Smith, Fred Murray, Julie Murray, Curtis Murray, Timothy Ervin, and Terry O'Connell as they explore the haunting cases of two young women who disappeared in North Country under similar circumstances. Delve into the harrowing details of these chilling events, where initial suspicions pointed towards Israel Keys and theories of a possible serial predator were scrutinized by Vermont and New Hampshire law enforcement, ultimately finding no such link between the cases.

Hear about the tireless search effort led by Fred Murray to find his daughter, including legal battles for access to records against a resistant state, and his direct confrontations with individuals connected to the case. Additionally, the episode uncovers intricate details of Mara's car crash from technical analyses and shares the impact of social media in the continuous endeavor to solve this mystery, with accounts of resistance faced by Helena Murray while managing online campaigns. As the podcast unfolds, listeners are presented with the persistence of search efforts over the years, highlighting the complex web of hope, disappointment, and the relentless pursuit of answers that these cases continue to evoke.

Listen to the original

Episode 7: We Looked Into That

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Mar 11, 2024 episode of the Media Pressure

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Episode 7: We Looked Into That

1-Page Summary

Key disappearances in the area

Two young women, including Brianna Maitland, vanished under eerily similar circumstances in the North Country, raising suspicion of a serial predator. Both Maitland's and Mara's disappearances sparked fear of a connection to Israel Keys, a serial killer. Despite the anxiety in the community, law enforcement in Vermont and New Hampshire eventually determined that the cases were not linked, dispelling the theory of a serial killer's involvement.

Fred Murray's search efforts

Fred Murray's relentless pursuit to find his daughter is marked by explorations of every possible lead and rappelling into mineshafts. Alongside legal aid from attorney Timothy Ervin, Murray has fought for access to records via lawsuits, facing a significant pushback from the state, which cited a 75% chance of criminal proceedings and the "Murray Exemption." His interactions with locals include befriending John Smith, against police advice, and confronting persons of interest directly, such as Claude Moulton, who refused a polygraph test.

Analysis of Mara's car

The analysis of Mara's car revealed it was moving when it crashed, with an acute angle collision that caused asymmetrical damage. High beams were on, and the seatbelt was not fastened. The car's Sensing Diagnostic Module indicated two crashes a fraction of a second apart and seven attempts to restart the engine after the airbags deployed, suggesting deliberate post-crash efforts to operate the vehicle.

Social media efforts spearheaded by Helena Murray

Helena Murray spearheaded social media campaigns to raise awareness, facing challenges such as moderating discourse and confronting online trolls who spread misinformation and targeted her with vicious attacks.

Ongoing search efforts over the years

Persistent search efforts have continued, including a 2019 excavation in the basement of a local home, where cadaver dogs and ground-penetrating radar indicated potential evidence, but only a piece of pottery was found. In 2021, a search at Loon Mountain ski slopes followed the recovery of human remains which did not belong to the missing person, leaving the family and investigators with unresolved questions.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Israel Keyes was an American serial killer who committed a series of meticulously planned crimes across multiple states from 2001 to 2012. He was known for his extreme violence and methodical approach to his criminal activities, which included murder, robbery, arson, and kidnapping. Keyes' suicide in 2012 revealed the extent of his crimes, with evidence suggesting he may have been responsible for the deaths of at least 11 individuals. His case garnered significant attention due to the chilling nature of his crimes and the mystery surrounding the full scope of his actions.
  • The Sensing Diagnostic Module (SDM) is a component in vehicles that records data related to airbag deployment and crash events. It stores information like impact severity, seatbelt usage, vehicle speed, and other relevant details during a collision. This data can be crucial for understanding the circumstances leading up to and following a crash, aiding in accident reconstruction and investigation. The SDM helps provide insights into the dynamics of a crash, offering valuable information for analyzing the sequence of events and potential post-crash actions.
  • John Smith in this context is a local individual who became involved in the search efforts related to the disappearances mentioned in the text. He befriended Fred Murray and assisted in the investigation by interacting with persons of interest and pursuing leads, despite advice from law enforcement.
  • Cadaver dogs are specially trained canines that use their keen sense of smell to locate human remains. These dogs play a crucial role in search and rescue operations, forensic investigations, and locating missing persons. Their training focuses on detecting the scent of decomposing bodies, helping authorities locate potential evidence in various scenarios. Cadaver dogs are a valuable resource in cases involving missing persons, crime scenes, natural disasters, and other situations where locating human remains is essential.
  • Ground-penetrating radar (GPR) is a non-intrusive geophysical method that uses radar pulses to create images of the subsurface. It operates by emitting electromagnetic energy into the ground and detecting the reflections from underground structures or boundaries between different materials. GPR can detect objects, changes in material properties, voids, and cracks beneath the surface. The effectiveness of GPR is influenced by factors like the electrical conductivity of the ground, the frequency used, and the power of the radar signal.

Counterarguments

  • The determination by law enforcement that the disappearances were not linked does not necessarily rule out the possibility of a serial predator; it may simply indicate a lack of evidence to prove such a connection at this time.
  • Fred Murray's relentless pursuit, while commendable for its dedication, could be critiqued for potentially interfering with official investigations or for the use of resources on leads that law enforcement may consider less credible.
  • The analysis of Mara's car might not provide a complete picture of the events leading to her disappearance, and alternative explanations for the crash and the car's condition could exist that have not been considered or publicized.
  • Social media campaigns, while useful for raising awareness, can also spread unverified information or theories that may hinder the investigation or cause additional distress to the families involved.
  • Ongoing search efforts that yield inconclusive results might be criticized for their cost and emotional toll on the family and community, especially if they are not based on new or credible leads.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Episode 7: We Looked Into That

Key disappearances in the area

Brianna Maitland's disappearance in 2004

The North Country has been troubled by eerie similarities in the cases of two young women who vanished, sparking fears and suspicions regarding a serial predator.

Similarities to Mara's case raised suspicions of a serial killer

Brianna Maitland disappeared under circumstances that unnervingly mirrored those of another woman named Mara, with Maitland's case occurring about 90 miles from where Mara disappeared. Both incidents prompted fears that they could be the acts of a serial killer. Israel Keys, a known serial killer, was brought up in connection with the cases, ra ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Key disappearances in the area

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Israel Keyes was a notorious American serial killer who committed a series of crimes across the United States. He was known for his meticulous planning and lack of a specific victim type. Keyes' modus operandi included burying "kill kits" in various locations, which he would use when selecting his victims. While Keyes' crimes were widely publicized, there is no confirmed connection between him and the disappearances of Brianna Maitland and Mara. The mention of Keyes in relation to these cases sparked initial concerns about a potential serial killer, but authorities later clarified that there was no evidence linking him to these specific disappearances.
  • The police in Vermont and New Hampshire later announced that the disappearances of Mara and Brianna Maitland were not connected, dispelling the theories of a serial killer ...

Counterarguments

  • The connection to Israel Keyes may be speculative without concrete evidence linking him to these specific cases.
  • The announcement by police that the disappearances are not connected does not necessarily rule out the possibility of a serial predator; it may simply mean there is no evidence to support a direct link between these two cases.
  • The fear of a serial predator could be amplified by public anxiety and media coverage, which may not accurately reflect the statistical likelihood of such a scenario.
  • The similarities between the cases cou ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Episode 7: We Looked Into That

Fred Murray's search efforts

Fred Murray has been at the forefront of efforts to find his missing daughter, driven by an unwavering determination and supported by an extensive network of volunteers and legal advocates.

Early search efforts with volunteers

Fred Murray has consistently explored every possibility in his search, often placing himself in precarious situations to follow even the slightest lead. His fearless commitment to finding his daughter was evidenced by an instance where he decided to rappel into an unexplored mineshaft without any training.

Lawsuits to gain access to records

Fred Murray, with the legal aid of attorney Timothy Ervin, undertook legal battles to uncover investigative records in the search for his daughter.

Timothy Ervin helped file Right to Know lawsuit

In New Hampshire, Julie Murray explains, her father pushed for more transparency, requesting access to records under the Right to Know Law. Despite these efforts, their requests were continually rebuffed due to the case's active status. Timothy Ervin from the firm of Gallant & Ervin stepped in to represent Fred Murray, leveraging the Right to Know Law in an attempt to gain access to the files. Their initial lawsuit was met with a denial by the Grafton Superior Court, supported by the state's argument that there was a 75% likelihood of criminal proceedings.

State claimed 75% chance of naming suspect

After the case escalated to the New Hampshire Supreme Court, the state maintained a strong stance, citing a significant chance of law enforcement action, a position which ultimately led to the withholding of records and birthed the so-called Murray Exemption.

Interactions with locals

Fred Murray’s ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Fred Murray's search efforts

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Fred Murray, with legal support, pursued access to investigative records related to his daughter's case through the Right to Know Law. Despite facing initial denials, his attorney, Timothy Ervin, filed a lawsuit to challenge the withholding of records by the state, citing a high likelihood of criminal proceedings as the reason for the denial. The legal battle escalated to the New Hampshire Supreme Court, where the state's argument for withholding the records was based on the potential impact on ongoing law enforcement actions, leading to the creation of the Murray Exemption.
  • The Murray Exemption is a legal concept that arose from the case of Fred Murray's missing daughter. It allowed the state to withhold investigative records due to the perceived likelihood of criminal proceedings. This exemption was established by the New Hampshire Supreme Court based on the state's argument of a high probability of law enforcement action. It prevented Fred Murray and his legal team from accessing certain records related to the investigation.
  • John Smith was involved in earlier search and investigation efforts related to the disappearance of Fred Murray's daughter. Despite police objections, Fred Murray developed a relationship with Smith, indicating a level of trust and collaboration in their shared pursuit of answers. Smith's involvement suggests he played a significant role in the search efforts and may have provided ...

Counterarguments

  • While Fred Murray's determination is commendable, it's important to consider that untrained individuals taking part in search efforts, such as rappelling into mineshafts, could potentially put themselves and others at risk, and may hinder professional search operations.
  • Legal battles for transparency, though well-intentioned, can sometimes impede ongoing investigations if sensitive information is released prematurely.
  • The state's claim of a 75% chance of criminal proceedings could be justified if releasing records would compromise the integrity of the investigation or the rights of potential suspects.
  • Befriending individuals like John Sm ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Episode 7: We Looked Into That

Analysis of Mara's car

Parka's meticulous investigation into Mara's car accident provided key insights into the circumstances that occurred just before the crash.

Showed she was moving forward when she crashed

The analysis conducted by Parka unveiled that Mara's Saturn was in motion, moving forward, when it encountered an accident on Route 112. The car's damage did not align with what typically results from striking a tree. Instead, it supported the conclusion that the vehicle was under its own propulsion when the collision with a fixed object occurred at an acute angle. Further examination revealed uneven damage; the hood was pushed back and buckled, bending the radiator's support. Key indicators of the crash dynamics included the car's initiation of a clockwise rotation before exiting the roadway and the evidence that the impact speed was notably low. Additional details from the scene, such as the high beams being activated and the driver’s seatbelt remaining unfastened, were noted.

Evidence of attempts to restart her car after the crash

The Sensing Diagnostic Module (SDM) of the car held critical data that revealed two distinct events happening a mere two one-hundredths of a second apart. The first was a non-deployment event, likely as the vehicle e ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Analysis of Mara's car

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The Sensing Diagnostic Module (SDM) is a component in modern vehicles that records and stores data related to the vehicle's operation and any events that may impact its safety systems. It is commonly known as the vehicle's "black box" and can provide crucial information for understanding the circumstances leading up to accidents. The SDM can capture data such as vehicle speed, seatbelt usage, airbag deployment, and impact forces during a collision. This data is often used by investigators and manufacturers to analyze and reconstruct accidents accurately.
  • Deliberate efforts to engage the vehicle's systems indicate intentional actions taken to restart the car's engine or activate its functions after a crash. This suggests that someone tried to interact with the car's controls or components post-collision. These actions could include turning the ignition key or pressing buttons to restart the engine or assess the vehicle's condition. Such efforts imply a conscious decision to try to restore the car's operability following the initial ...

Counterarguments

  • The car moving forward does not necessarily indicate that Mara was in control or that it was intentional; it could have been set in motion by other means or forces.
  • Damage to a vehicle can be influenced by a variety of factors, and without witness accounts, it's difficult to determine the exact dynamics of the crash.
  • Uneven damage to the hood and radiator support could also result from previous unreported incidents or poor repair jobs, not just the crash in question.
  • A clockwise rotation could be consistent with a loss of control, but it could also be influenced by road conditions, obstacles, or evasive maneuvers.
  • A notably low impact speed might suggest cautious driving or a last-second deceleration, but it could also be due to mechanical failure or road conditions.
  • Activated high beams and an unfastened seatbelt could indicate a variety of scenarios, including a sudden need to stop or distraction, not necessarily negligence or intent.
  • The SDM data showing two distinct events could be interpreted differently, possibly as a result of elec ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Episode 7: We Looked Into That

Social media efforts spearheaded by Helena Murray

Created online presence to raise awareness

Helena Murray took the initiative in creating an online presence to raise awareness for her cause.

Faced vicious attacks from online trolls

Despite her efforts to promote a positive message, Helena faced significant challenges. She became the gatekeeper, moderating comments to keep the discussion constructive. However, her role made her a target for online trolls. These trolls not only infiltrat ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Social media efforts spearheaded by Helena Murray

Additional Materials

Clarifications

...

Counterarguments

  • While Helena Murray's initiative to create an online presence is commendable, it's important to consider whether the strategies used were effective in reaching and engaging the intended audience.
  • The approach to moderating the online space may need to be evaluated to ensure that it does not suppress legitimate criticism or dissenting views in the name of keeping the discussion constructive.
  • The presence of online trolls, while unfortunate, could indicate a need for stronger community guidelines or more robust digital security measures to protect the integrity of the discussion and the well-being of participants.
  • It's possible that the online attacks could have been mitigated through proactive measures such as ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Episode 7: We Looked Into That

Ongoing search efforts over the years

As new clues and rumors emerge, the search for answers in a long-standing mystery continues with efforts intensifying over recent years, including searches at a private residence and a ski slope.

Searched a local home's basement in 2019 based on rumor

In 2019, following up on a tip involving a disturbing discovery by a contractor, the family of the missing individual investigated rumors that suggested she might have been buried in the basement of a local home. The rumor prompted them to focus on a basement where what was reported to be bones were found before the floor was cemented over. The homeowner granted the family permission to search, enabling independent cadaver dogs to alert to the same area on two occasions and the use of ground-penetrating radar to reveal disturbances in the earth.

These findings were compelling enough to involve the New Hampshire State Police, who conducted an official excavation. Unfortunately for the family seeking closure, they were not allowed to witness the excavation, which resulted in the discovery of only a piece of pottery, not the hoped-for evidence of their loved one's fate.

2021 search at Loon Mountain ski slopes

A separate lead unofficially titled the "Loon Mountain 3" due to employees not showing up for work on the night of the disappearance le ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Ongoing search efforts over the years

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The text discusses search efforts related to a long-standing mystery involving a missing individual. It mentions a search in 2019 at a local home's basement based on a rumor and a separate search in 2021 at Loon Mountain ski slopes. The events are presented in a non-linear m ...

Counterarguments

...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA