Podcasts > Making Sense with Sam Harris > #417 — Philosophy for Life

#417 — Philosophy for Life

By Waking Up with Sam Harris

In this episode of Making Sense, Donald Robertson, an author and psychotherapist, discusses how ancient Stoic philosophy intersects with modern cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT). Robertson traces Stoicism's evolution from its origins as a philosophical movement focused on virtue and moral wisdom, to its influence on pioneers of CBT like Albert Ellis and Aaron T. Beck, who incorporated Stoic principles into their therapeutic approaches.

The discussion explores key Stoic concepts, including the idea that psychological distress stems from our interpretations of events rather than the events themselves. Robertson outlines practical Stoic techniques for developing emotional resilience, such as mindful self-awareness, Socratic questioning to examine beliefs, and methods for handling difficult situations through the lens of wisdom and virtue. These techniques parallel modern psychological approaches while offering their own distinct philosophical framework.

Listen to the original

#417 — Philosophy for Life

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the May 28, 2025 episode of the Making Sense with Sam Harris

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

#417 — Philosophy for Life

1-Page Summary

The Background and Evolution of Stoicism

Donald Robertson, an author and psychotherapist, shares his journey from studying existential philosophy to discovering Stoicism. After finding parallels between Stoicism and cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), Robertson shifted his focus and began writing about their convergence. He explains that Stoicism, spanning five centuries, is a major ancient philosophical movement centered on the belief that virtue and moral wisdom are life's only true goods.

The Core Principles and Techniques of Stoicism

Robertson discusses the fundamental Stoic principle, citing the Handbook of Epictetus, that people are distressed not by events themselves but by their opinions about those events. This aligns closely with modern cognitive therapy's approach. The philosophy includes practical techniques such as "prosoche" (mindful self-awareness), Socratic questioning to challenge beliefs, and contemplative practices that prepare individuals for potential future challenges.

The Connections Between Stoicism and Cognitive Behavioral Therapy

The influence of Stoicism on modern psychology runs deep. Robertson notes that CBT pioneers Albert Ellis and Aaron T. Beck both acknowledged Stoicism's impact on their work. Ellis, who developed rational emotive behavior therapy, considered the Stoics his main philosophical inspiration, while Beck repeatedly cited Stoicism's connection to cognitive therapy. Both approaches share the core understanding that psychological distress stems from our interpretations of events rather than the events themselves.

Applying Stoic Ideas To Real-World Problems and Experiences

Robertson and Sam Harris discuss practical applications of Stoic principles to everyday challenges. They recommend "modeling" - imagining how a wise person would handle difficult situations - as a way to gain perspective. Robertson explains that the Stoics valued mentors for helping identify blind spots in self-perception, similar to modern psychotherapy. The philosophy emphasizes developing emotional resilience through focusing on virtue and maintaining detachment from uncontrollable external circumstances.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While Stoicism and CBT share similarities, they are not identical; CBT is a structured, time-limited, and often symptom-focused approach, whereas Stoicism is a broad philosophy of life that can be practiced indefinitely.
  • The Stoic principle that distress comes from our opinions about events might not account for all types of psychological distress, such as those caused by biochemical imbalances or trauma.
  • Some critics argue that the Stoic emphasis on detachment and self-control could potentially lead to emotional suppression or avoidance, which is contrary to some modern therapeutic approaches that encourage emotional expression and processing.
  • The Stoic focus on virtue as the sole good might be seen as overly simplistic or unrealistic in the complex moral landscape of modern society.
  • The Stoic practice of preparing for future challenges through negative visualization might not be beneficial for everyone, particularly for individuals with anxiety disorders who may become more anxious as a result.
  • The idea of modeling behavior on a wise person is subjective and could lead to misinterpretation of what constitutes wisdom or appropriate behavior in different contexts.
  • The Stoic emphasis on self-reliance and personal virtue might overlook the importance of community support, social justice, and systemic factors in individual well-being.
  • The application of Stoic principles in modern psychotherapy might not resonate with all clients, especially those who do not share the philosophical assumptions or values underpinning Stoicism.
  • Some may argue that the Stoic practice of detachment from external circumstances could lead to passivity or a lack of engagement in efforts to change unjust or harmful societal conditions.

Actionables

  • Create a "Stoic Reflection Journal" where you write down daily events and your initial reactions, then challenge those reactions with Socratic questioning to find more rational responses. By doing this, you'll practice identifying and altering the opinions that cause distress, a key Stoic principle. For example, if you're upset about a work email, write down why it bothers you and question if your reaction is based on assumptions or facts.
  • Develop a "Virtue Focus Week" plan where each week you concentrate on a different Stoic virtue, such as wisdom, courage, or self-control, and set specific, measurable actions to practice it. This could involve setting a goal to handle a difficult conversation with composure (courage) or making a decision by thoroughly considering all options (wisdom).
  • Engage in a "Controlled Detachment Exercise" by listing things in your life that cause emotional reactions and categorize them into 'within your control' and 'outside your control.' For one month, consciously redirect your energy and focus only on the aspects within your control, practicing detachment from external circumstances. For instance, if you're worried about a friend's opinion of you, remind yourself that your own actions and intentions are within your control, not their perceptions.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
#417 — Philosophy for Life

The Background and Evolution of Stoicism

Donald Robertson, an author and psychotherapist, provides insight into his own professional journey, which led to a resurgence of interest in the stoic philosophy, particularly in relation to cognitive behavioral therapy.

Donald Robertson Discovered Stoicism After Initially Exploring Existential Philosophy and Psychoanalysis

Robertson's Academic Path Led from Existentialism to Stoicism

Robertson's academic pursuits began with a philosophy degree, followed by an interdisciplinary master's that combined philosophy and psychotherapy, targeting existential philosophy and Sartre's existential psychoanalysis. However, Robertson found that this path wasn't fulfilling for him. He instead became intrigued by stoicism and its similarities with cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), which led him to change his focus.

Donald Robertson then pursued a clinical career as a psychotherapist, writing books on the convergence of stoicism and CBT. His work emerged at a time when stoicism was experiencing a newfound surge in popularity.

Stoicism: A Major Ancient Philosophical School With Practical Components

Stoicism, as described by Robertson, is a major ancient philosophical movement that stretches over five centuries and is dynamic in nature.

Stoicism's Underlying Principles and Practices

Robertson elaborates on stoicism's foundation as an ethical doctrine. Citing Cicero, Robertson emphasizes tha ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The Background and Evolution of Stoicism

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While Stoicism has influenced modern therapeutic approaches, it is not the only ancient philosophy to do so; other philosophical traditions, such as Buddhism and Epicureanism, have also contributed to contemporary psychological practices.
  • The assertion that virtue is the only true good in Stoicism might be too rigid or simplistic for some, as it may not account for the complexity of modern ethical dilemmas and the value of other aspects of human life.
  • The idea that physical possessions and reputation are 'indifferents' in Stoicism could be criticized for potentially downplaying the role of social and economic factors in well-being.
  • The dynamic nature of Stoicism over five centuries could be seen as a series of interpretations and reinventions rather than a consistent, unchanging philosophy.
  • The effectiveness of Stoic practices in cultivating emotional resilience might vary among individuals, and some may find other approache ...

Actionables

  • You can start a "Stoic Thought Journal" where each day you write down a situation that elicited a strong emotional response and analyze it through the lens of Stoic virtues. For example, if you felt anger because someone cut you off in traffic, reflect on how this event is an 'indifferent' and explore how you can respond with equanimity.
  • Create a "CBT-Stoic Fusion Worksheet" to practice cognitive restructuring with a Stoic twist. When facing a negative thought, write it down, identify the cognitive distortion, and then counter it with a Stoic principle. If you think, "I must perform perfectly at work," challenge this by reminding yourself that perfection is not a virtue and that effort and wisdom in your actions are more important.
  • Develop a "Virtu ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
#417 — Philosophy for Life

The Core Principles and Techniques of Stoicism

Stoicism offers a substantial philosophical framework for understanding and managing our emotional lives, which aligns closely with modern cognitive therapy.

Distress Stems From Judgments, Not Events

Donald Robertson cites the Handbook of Epictetus to explain the fundamental principle of Stoicism that people are distressed not by events, but by their opinions about those events. This insight points to the Stoic goal of apatheia, which is the pursuit of freedom from irrational and unhealthy emotions and pathological desires.

Cognitive Model Aligns Stoicism With Cognitive Behavioral Therapy

Robertson further explores how Stoicism presents a cognitive model of emotion, which is very similar to the foundation of modern cognitive therapy, emphasizing that cognitions significantly shape our emotions. Thus, the approach suggests that by changing our thoughts, we can change our emotional reactions.

Stoicism Includes Specific Practices and Techniques, Including:

Stoic philosophy is not purely theoretical but comes with a set of practical exercises and techniques designed to train the mind and develop more rational responses to life's challenges.

Mindful Self-Observation: Practicing "Prosoche"

Robertson describes "prosoche" as an ongoing Stoic practice of mindful self-awareness. The Stoics practice attentive observation of their automatic thoughts and judgments, especially the value judgments that influence emotions, resembling a form of Stoic mindfulness.

Socratic Questioning and Challenging Beliefs in CBT

Similar to the methods used in cognitive therapy, Stoicism utilizes Socrati ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The Core Principles and Techniques of Stoicism

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While Stoicism teaches that distress arises from judgments, not events, some psychological theories argue that events can have an inherent emotional impact regardless of cognitive judgments.
  • The pursuit of apatheia might be criticized for potentially leading to emotional detachment or indifference, which could be at odds with the richness of human emotional experience.
  • The alignment of Stoicism with cognitive therapy might overlook the nuances and differences between ancient philosophical practices and modern psychological interventions.
  • The practical exercises of Stoicism may not be universally effective, as individual differences in personality, culture, and personal history can influence their utility.
  • The practice of "prosoche" might be challenging to maintain consistently, and its effectiveness can vary among i ...

Actionables

  • Create a "judgment journal" to track and analyze your emotional responses to daily events. Whenever you feel distressed, write down the event and your initial judgment of it. Then, challenge that judgment by asking if it's the event causing distress or your perception of it. Over time, you'll start to see patterns in your judgments that lead to distress and can work on altering those perceptions.
  • Develop a "misfortune simulation" habit by visualizing a small inconvenience each morning, such as spilling coffee or missing a bus. Spend a few minutes contemplating how you would handle the situation with calm and rationality. This daily practice can help build mental resilience and prepare you for larger challenges by fostering a proactive rather than reactive mindset.
  • Engage in "Socratic dialogues" with a friend or family m ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
#417 — Philosophy for Life

The Connections Between Stoicism and Cognitive Behavioral Therapy

Stoicism, an ancient Greek philosophy, has significantly influenced the development of modern Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT). Prominent figures in psychological therapy, such as Albert Ellis and Aaron T. Beck, have acknowledged the impact of Stoic principles on the practices and methodologies they developed.

Cognitive Behavioral Therapy Pioneers, Ellis and Beck, Cited Stoic Influence

Ellis and Beck Used Stoicism to Develop Key Psychological Therapies

Donald Robertson confirms a direct connection between Stoicism and cognitive behavioral therapy by referencing Albert Ellis and Aaron T. Beck. Ellis, who developed rational emotive behavior therapy, turned to Stoicism after becoming disillusioned with psychoanalysis. Having read Epictetus and Marcus Aurelius in his teenage years, he later described the Stoics as the main philosophical inspiration for his approach to therapy. Similarly, the next major pioneer, Beck, who made cognitive therapy more mainstream, acknowledges the philosophical origins of cognitive therapy in ancient Stoicism and cites this connection repeatedly.

Robertson notes how Stoicism provided a workable philosophy of life, with contemplative practices resembling meditation techniques. He illustrates his personal journey of intersecting interests in psychotherapy, meditation, philosophy, and reading, which crystallized when he encountered the works of Seneca. This encounter helped Robertson see the clear links between Stoic philosophy and modern CBT practices.

Stoicism and CBT: Identifying and Challenging Dysfunctional Thought Patterns and Values

The tenants of Stoicism offer strategies to identify and challenge dysfunctional thought patterns and values, which are the core practices of modern CBT.

Stoic Techniques and Corresponding Practices in Modern CBT

The influence of Stoic techniques on modern CBT is evident in the cognitive models of emotion, where both philosophies re ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The Connections Between Stoicism and Cognitive Behavioral Therapy

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While Stoicism has influenced CBT, it is not the sole philosophical foundation; other psychological and philosophical traditions have also contributed to the development of CBT.
  • The practical application of Stoicism in therapy may differ from its original philosophical context, which was not specifically designed to address clinical disorders.
  • Some critics argue that CBT's focus on changing thoughts may oversimplify the complexity of human emotions and experiences, which can also be influenced by biological and social factors.
  • The effectiveness of CBT, while well-documented, is not universal; some individuals may not respond to CBT as well as they do to other forms of therapy.
  • The interpretation of Stoic texts and how closely they align with CBT principles can be subjective; different scholars may emphasize different aspects of Stoicism.
  • There is a risk of cultur ...

Actionables

  • Create a "Thought Diary" to track and analyze your interpretations of daily events. Carry a small notebook or use a digital app to jot down situations that trigger strong emotions throughout the day. Later, review your notes and identify any patterns in your thoughts that may be irrational or unhelpful. For example, if you notice you often think "I can't handle this" when faced with stress, challenge that thought by listing past instances where you successfully managed similar situations.
  • Develop a "Stoic Reflection Routine" before bedtime. Spend 10 minutes reflecting on your day, focusing on what was within your control and what wasn't. This practice helps you distinguish between your actions and external events, reducing anxiety over things you can't change. For instance, if you were stuck in traffic and felt frustrated, remind yourself that you can't control traffic, but you can control how you react to it.
  • Engage in "Perception Shifting" exercises wh ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
#417 — Philosophy for Life

Applying Stoic Ideas To Real-World Problems and Experiences

Stoicism, an ancient philosophy, offers valuable tools for coping with everyday frustrations, particularly those arising from misunderstandings and challenges. Experts like Donald Robertson and Sam Harris discuss how Stoic concepts can be applied to improve self-awareness and foster resilience in the face of life's adversities.

Stoicism Addresses Frustration From Misrepresented Views

Donald Robertson and Sam Harris explain how Stoic practices can help individuals deal with the aggravation of being misrepresented or misunderstood.

Stoic "Modeling": Imagining how a Wise Person Would Respond Offers Helpful Perspective

Robertson recommends imagining how a wise person one admires—someone known personally, a fictional character, or the hypothetical sage—would handle a situation involving misunderstood views. This method, endorsed by Harris, allows an individual to step outside themselves, offering a perspective that might reveal behaviors that are more easily recognized as flawed when observed in others.

Stoics Valued Mentors For Overcoming Self-Perception Blind Spots

Robertson discusses the problem of recognizing one's own flaws, or self-perception blind spots. Using the analogy from Aesop's fable of the two sacks, he illustrates how people are adept at seeing others' flaws while often blind to their own. Stoics understood the value of a mentor or teacher in providing an external viewpoint to help reveal these blind spots, with Robertson likening it to modern-day counseling or psychotherapy. Even historical figures like Marcus Aurelius benefited from such guidance as noted by the wisdom from his physician, Galen.

Stoic Focus on Judgments and Regulating Reactions Guides Life's Challenges

The Stoic philosophy emphasizes the importance of regulating one’s reactions to external events, fostering both an analytical detachment and a ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Applying Stoic Ideas To Real-World Problems and Experiences

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While Stoicism promotes detachment from uncontrollable things, some critics argue that this can lead to passivity or a lack of engagement in improving societal conditions.
  • The idea of imagining how a wise person would respond might not always be practical, as individuals have unique circumstances and the wisdom of historical or fictional characters may not translate well into modern contexts.
  • The reliance on mentors to overcome self-perception blind spots could be seen as problematic if it leads to an over-dependence on external validation or advice, potentially undermining personal autonomy.
  • Some may argue that Stoicism's focus on regulating reactions to external events could be interpreted as suppressing emotions rather than healthily processing them.
  • Critics of Stoicism might contend that its emphasis on virtue and inner well-being can sometimes come at the expense of neglecting the importance of external factors that contribute to one's quality of life.
  • The Stoic principle of reframing reactions to mitigate suffering might not always be applicable in situations where suffering is due to systemic issues that require collective action rather than individual mindset changes.
  • The reduction of intrinsic value placed on uncontrollable things could be criticized for potentially dismissing the importance of striving for change or improvement in areas that are initially perceived as ...

Actionables

  • Start a "Stoic Response Journal" where you write down daily frustrations and then script how a wise person would handle them. This practice encourages you to step outside your immediate emotional response and consider more rational approaches. For example, if you're upset about a work email, write down how someone you admire for their calm demeanor would reply to it.
  • Create a "Control Influence Accept" (CIA) chart to visually sort life's events. Draw three columns on a piece of paper and label them "Control," "Influence," and "Accept." Whenever you face a challenge, write it down in the appropriate column. This helps you focus on what you can control or influence and accept what you cannot, aligning with Stoic principles of focusing on internal rather than external control.
  • Develop a "Virtue Spotligh ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA