#413 — “More From Sam”: Trump & Israel, Corruption, Free Speech Violations, the Democrats, & Ezra Klein
In this episode of Making Sense, Sam Harris examines Donald Trump's complex relationship with Israel and Jewish Americans during his presidency. Harris analyzes Trump's pro-Israel policies, such as moving the U.S. embassy to Jerusalem, while also discussing his interactions with far-right groups and his response to anti-Semitic figures like David Duke.
The discussion explores how anti-Semitism manifested during the Trump administration across different ideological spectrums. Harris addresses the contrast between Jewish Americans who felt protected by Trump's policies and those who were concerned about his connections to far-right groups. The conversation also covers how the administration's approach to right-wing anti-Semitism, combined with other factors, affected the political landscape for Jewish Americans.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the May 6, 2025 episode of the Making Sense with Sam Harris
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
Trump's Relationship With and Support For Israel
Donald Trump's presidency was marked by a complex relationship with Israel, characterized by supportive policies but also actions that raised significant concerns. While Trump enacted policies favoring Israel, such as recognizing Jerusalem as its capital and moving the U.S. embassy there, critics questioned whether these decisions were driven by genuine commitment or political strategy.
Trump's Pandering To Far-right Anti-Semitic Groups
Sam Harris points out a troubling pattern in Trump's interactions with far-right groups. A notable example was Trump's reluctance to denounce David Duke, a former KKK leader, during his campaign. Harris argues that Trump's failure to clearly condemn such figures effectively normalizes and empowers dangerous anti-Semitic elements within the United States.
Trump's Policies and Rhetoric: Impact on Jewish Americans' Security
Jaron Lowenstein notes that many Jewish Americans felt secure under Trump's presidency due to his pro-Israel policies and the creation of an anti-Semitism task force. However, Sam Harris counters that Trump's connections to far-right and anti-Semitic groups undermined this sense of security. Harris points to Trump's mercurial nature, exemplified by his reaction to perceived slights from Benjamin Netanyahu, as evidence of the risks in trusting Trump's commitment to Jewish safety.
Anti-Semitism in the US Under the Trump Administration
Sam Harris discusses how anti-Semitism has flourished under various ideological umbrellas. He identifies concerning trends on both the far left, where moral confusion about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict enables anti-Semitism, and the far right, where Holocaust revisionism has grown among Trump's allies. Harris suggests that the Trump administration's reluctance to condemn right-wing anti-Semitism, combined with general incompetence and corruption, has created an environment where dangerous ideologies can thrive unchallenged.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- Trump's recognition of Jerusalem as Israel's capital and the embassy move fulfilled a promise made by previous U.S. presidents, suggesting a commitment to longstanding U.S. policy goals.
- The establishment of an anti-Semitism task force could be seen as a concrete step to combat anti-Semitism, indicating action beyond mere rhetoric.
- Trump's administration argued that its policies, such as withdrawing from the Iran nuclear deal, were in the interest of Israeli security and by extension, the security of Jewish people globally.
- The rise in anti-Semitism cannot be solely attributed to any single administration, as it is a complex issue with roots in broader societal and global trends.
- Some Jewish Americans and Israelis praised Trump's policies as beneficial for the security and international standing of Israel, which they felt outweighed his controversial statements or associations.
- The increase in Holocaust revisionism and anti-Semitic sentiment on the far right may not be directly linked to Trump's policies or rhetoric, but rather to a broader resurgence of nationalist and extremist ideologies.
- The suggestion that Trump's policies were motivated by political strategy rather than genuine commitment could be countered by the argument that all political decisions are inherently influenced by strategic considerations, regardless of the administration in power.
- The complex relationship between the U.S. and Israel involves a multitude of factors, including strategic, political, and economic interests that transcend any single presidency.
Actionables
- You can enhance your critical thinking skills by analyzing political decisions through different lenses, such as ethical, strategic, and historical perspectives. For instance, when you hear about a policy change, take the time to research its historical context, the ethical debates surrounding it, and the strategic implications it might have. This will help you form a more nuanced opinion rather than taking the decision at face value.
- Engage in community dialogue by starting conversations with friends or family about the complexities of political relationships and the impact of political rhetoric on societal issues. Use current events as a starting point to discuss how political actions can have different interpretations and consequences for various groups within society, fostering a deeper understanding of the diverse perspectives that exist.
- Support educational initiatives that promote awareness and understanding of anti-Semitism and other forms of hate by donating to organizations that create resources and programs for schools and communities. By contributing, even in a small way, you help provide tools for educators and community leaders to address and combat hate speech and ideologies effectively.
Get access to the context and additional materials
Trump's Relationship With and Support For Israel
Donald Trump's presidency was characterized by a complicated relationship with Israel, which included both definitive support in policy but also actions that raised deep concerns for many observers.
Trump's Actions and Policies on Israel Were Mixed, With Positives but Also Concerns
Throughout his term, Trump enacted policies that were seen as beneficial by many supporters of Israel, but his motivations and the reliability of his actions elicited skepticism and criticism.
Trump's Support For Israel: Questionable Motivations and Unreliable Actions
Trump's tenure involved a series of moves that were regarded as supportive of Israel's government, such as the recognition of Jerusalem as the capital of Israel and the movement of the American embassy there from Tel Aviv. However, critics questioned the motivations behind these decisions, speculating that they may have been influenced more by Trump's political strategy than by a steadfast commitment to Israeli interests. His actions sparked not only praise from some quarters but also ignited concern among those who worried about the broader implications for peace and stability in the region, including the potential undermining of the long-term prospects for a two-state solution.
Trump's Alliance With Far-right, Anti-Semitic Groups Negated Benefits of His Israel Policies, Aligning With Anti-Semites for Political Support
Adding to the complexity of Trump's policies toward Israel was his simultaneous alignment with far-right groups in the United States that have a history of anti-Semitic rhet ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Trump's Relationship With and Support For Israel
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- Trump's actions related to Israel included recognizing Jerusalem as Israel's capital and relocating the U.S. embassy there. These moves were seen as supportive by some but raised concerns about their impact on peace efforts in the region. Additionally, Trump's alignment with far-right groups in the U.S. with anti-Semitic tendencies complicated perceptions of his support for Israel.
- Trump's relationship with Israel was marked by a mix of supportive policies, such as recognizing Jerusalem as Israel's capital, but critics questioned his motivations, suggesting they were more politically driven than genuinely pro-Israel. Additionally, Trump's alignment with far-right groups in the U.S. with anti-Semitic ties complicated his stance on Israel, leading to concerns and criticisms about the coherence of his approach. This dual narrative of supporting Israel while engaging with groups known for anti-Semitic views created a complex dynamic that sparked debates about the sincerity and implications of Trump's policies towards Israel.
- Recognizing Jerusalem as the capital of Israel was a significant move by the Trump administration, symbolizing a departure from the longstanding international consensus on the status of Jerusalem. This decision was controversial as it touched on the sensitive Israeli-Palestinian conflict, with Palestinians also claiming Jerusalem as the capital of a future state. The recognition was seen as a major policy shift that had implications for regional stability and the peace process. Moving the American embassy to Jerusalem further solidified this recognition and was met with both praise and criticism globally.
- The potential consequences for peace and stability in the region referred to concerns that Trump's actions in support of Israel, such as recognizing Jerusalem as its capital, could inflame tensions and hinder efforts towards a peaceful resolution between Israel and Palestine. This move was seen as potentially undermining the prospects for a two-state solution, a longstanding goal in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Critics feared that such actions could lead to increased conflict and instability in the already volatile Middle East region.
- Trump's alignment with far-right groups in the US involved his association with organizations and individuals known for promoting extremist ideologies, including white supremacy and anti-Semitism. This connection raised concerns about the ...
Counterarguments
- Trump's recognition of Jerusalem as Israel's capital fulfilled a promise made by previous U.S. presidents, reflecting a commitment to an ally rather than mere political strategy.
- The embassy move to Jerusalem was in accordance with the Jerusalem Embassy Act of 1995, which was passed by Congress with bipartisan support.
- Trump's actions could be seen as reinforcing Israel's sovereignty and historical claims, which some argue is a form of respect for the nation's self-determination.
- The peace agreements brokered by the Trump administration between Israel and several Arab states (the Abraham Accords) suggest a possible positive impact on regional stability and new pathways to peace.
- Trump's alignment with certain controversial groups does not necessarily reflect his personal beliefs or policies towards Israel and could be viewed as a separate issue from his administration's foreign policy.
- The support from controversial groups may be unsolicited and not directly indicative of the administration's stance or actions regarding anti-Semitism.
- The ad ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Trump's Pandering To Far-right Anti-Semitic Groups
Sam Harris highlights a concerning pattern of behavior from Trump in relation to the far-right and anti-Semitic groups.
Trump's History Of Failing to Condemn Anti-Semitic Figures On the Right
Trump has repeatedly come under scrutiny for his interactions with far-right figures who espouse anti-Semitic views.
Trump Often Refuses to Disavow Anti-Semites Like David Duke, Allowing Anti-Semitic Conspiracy Theories and Holocaust Revisionism to Spread Among Allies and Supporters
A notable instance of Trump's ambiguous stance towards anti-Semitic figures occurred during his campaign when he refused to denounce the support of David Duke, a known former grand wizard of the Ku Klux Klan. When pressed to disavow Duke's support, Trump feigned ignorance, claiming he did not know who Duke was.
Trump's Courtship of Far-right, Anti-Semitic Groups Norma ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Trump's Pandering To Far-right Anti-Semitic Groups
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- Trump has claimed that his statements have been taken out of context or misinterpreted by the media, suggesting that his failure to condemn certain figures does not necessarily indicate support or endorsement.
- Some argue that Trump's approach to controversial figures is part of a broader strategy to avoid alienating any potential voter base, rather than an explicit endorsement of their views.
- It has been pointed out that Trump has condemned anti-Semitism on several occasions, and his administration has taken actions that some members of the Jewish community have praised, such as recognizing Jerusalem as the capital of Israel.
- Critics of Sam Harris might argue that his interpretation of Trump's actions is influenced by political bias, and that a more objective analysis might lead to different conclusions.
- There is a perspective that suggests Trump's reluctance to di ...
Actionables
- You can educate yourself on the history and impact of anti-Semitism by reading books and articles from credible sources. Understanding the roots and consequences of anti-Semitic beliefs will help you recognize and challenge them in your daily life. For example, reading "Antisemitism: Here and Now" by Deborah E. Lipstadt could provide a comprehensive background on the subject.
- Start conversations with friends and family about the dangers of normalizing extremist views. By discussing the issues in a personal setting, you can help raise awareness and create a social environment that actively rejects hate speech and bigotry. For instance, if a family member shares a joke that plays into anti-Semitic tropes, use that as an opportunity to explain why such stereotypes are harmful.
- Support organizations t ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Trump's Policies and Rhetoric: Impact on Jewish Americans' Security
Discussions with Jaron Lowenstein and Sam Harris reveal complex sentiments among Jewish Americans regarding President Trump's policies and rhetoric, weighing his support of Israel against emboldened anti-Semitic forces in the United States.
Jewish Americans Felt Secure Under Trump Due to His Israel Support, Despite Him Emboldening Anti-Semitic Forces in the Us
Jaron Lowenstein indicates that many Jewish Americans he spoke with felt a sense of security with Trump in office, largely due to actions such as moving the U.S. embassy to Jerusalem, seen as a strong gesture of support for Israel. In addition to this, he notes that Trump's formation of an anti-Semitism task force gave some Jewish people the impression that he was protective of their interests.
Trump's Support For Israel Undermined by Ties to Anti-Semitic Groups, Affecting Jewish American Safety
Yet, Sam Harris argues that Trump's position on Jewish security was compromised due to his connections with far-right and anti-Semitic groups. While Trump enacted policies that bolstered Israel's position—which on the surface could make single-issue pro-Israel voters feel secure—Harris warns that Trump's loyalties are mercurial and often hinge on his personal interpretations of loyalty and s ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Trump's Policies and Rhetoric: Impact on Jewish Americans' Security
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- Trump's actions towards Israel, such as moving the U.S. embassy to Jerusalem, could be seen as fulfilling campaign promises and aligning with the wishes of a segment of Jewish Americans who prioritize the U.S.-Israel relationship.
- The formation of an anti-Semitism task force could be interpreted as a concrete step to address anti-Semitism, separate from any personal affiliations or rhetoric.
- It could be argued that Trump's connections to certain groups do not necessarily reflect his personal beliefs or policies and that his administration's actions should be evaluated independently of those associations.
- The rise in anti-Semitism could be considered a complex phenomenon with multiple contributing factors, not solely attributable to the rhetoric or actions of any single individual or administration.
- Some may argue that Trump's approach to foreign policy and his interactions with international leaders like Netanyahu are part of a broader strategy that may not always align with traditional diplomatic expectations but could serve U.S. interests.
- The sense of security felt by some Jewish Americans under Trump might be based on a broader assessment of his policies beyond his support for Israel, su ...
Actionables
- You can enhance your understanding of political dynamics by tracking policy changes and their impacts on different communities. Start by creating a simple spreadsheet where you note down significant political decisions, like embassy relocations, and follow up with research on their effects over time. This will help you form a more nuanced view of how such decisions influence various groups and may affect your own community.
- Develop critical thinking skills by analyzing political rhetoric for underlying messages. Whenever you hear a politician speak, take notes on the key points and later, cross-reference these with reports from multiple sources to identify any discrepancies or patterns that could indicate a deeper agenda. This practice will sharpen your ability to discern between genuine support and political maneuvering.
- Create a personal safety net by connecting with loca ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Anti-Semitism in the US Under the Trump Administration
Sam Harris discusses the dangerous rise of anti-Semitism in the US, attributing some of the cause to the actions and inactions of President Trump and his administration along with wider ideological shifts.
Anti-Semitism Persists in US: Trends on Far Left and Right
Moral Confusion and Double Standards on the Left Enable Anti-Semitism in the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict
Harris notes that there is ideological capture by certain groups, including Islamists and the far left, which are not directly related to the Trump administration but contribute to a broader atmosphere in which Western and Enlightenment values are repudiated, a climate that can foster anti-Semitism.
Rising Anti-Semitic Conspiracy Theories and Holocaust Revisionism Among Trump Allies on the Far Right
Harris directly points to a growth of Holocaust revisionism and denialism amongst Trump's allies, fueling anti-Semitism in the US. He indicates that by engaging with and not condemning far-right groups, President Trump's administration has normalized and empowered dangerous US anti-Semitism.
Trump Administration's Reluctance to Condemn Anti-Semitic Right-Wing Elements Has Normalized and Emboldened Dangerous US Anti-Semitism
While Sam Harris doesn't mention the Trump administration's explicit reluctance to condemn anti-Semitic right-wing elements, his broader critique implies a failure to address underlying issues that embolden dangerous ideologies in the US, including anti-Semitism. Harris voices con ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Anti-Semitism in the US Under the Trump Administration
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- The rise of anti-Semitism cannot be solely attributed to the actions of any single administration, as it is a complex issue with roots in historical, social, and cultural factors.
- Some argue that President Trump has been a strong supporter of Israel, which could be seen as counter to the notion that his administration has enabled anti-Semitism.
- The claim that moral confusion on the left enables anti-Semitism could be countered by pointing out that criticism of Israeli government policies is not inherently anti-Semitic and can be part of legitimate political discourse.
- Ideological capture by certain groups is not unique to the Trump era and can be observed across various political landscapes and administrations.
- It could be argued that the Trump administration has condemned anti-Semitism on several occasions, such as when President Trump signed an executive order targeting anti-Semitism on college campuses.
- The assertion that the Trump administration's inaction has led to a culture that could result in more anti-Semitism could be countered by noting efforts within the administration to combat anti-Semitism ...
Actionables
- You can educate yourself on the history and impact of anti-Semitism by reading books and articles from credible sources to understand the context and gravity of the issue. By becoming more knowledgeable, you'll be better equipped to recognize and challenge anti-Semitic rhetoric and behavior in your community. For example, reading "Antisemitism: Here and Now" by Deborah E. Lipstadt could provide a comprehensive overview of contemporary anti-Semitism.
- Start a dialogue with friends and family about the dangers of anti-Semitic conspiracy theories and Holocaust revisionism. Use facts and personal stories to illustrate the harm these narratives cause. For instance, if a family member shares a conspiracy theory on social media, reach out privately to discuss the origins and implications of such theories, emphasizing the importance of critical thinking and fact-checking.
- Support orga ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
