Podcasts > Last Podcast On The Left > Episode 561: Cryptid Towns

Episode 561: Cryptid Towns

By Marcus Parks, Henry Zebrowski

Dive into the bizarre world of American folklore with the latest episode of Last Podcast On The Left, as hosts Henry Zebrowski, Marcus Parks, and Ed Larson explore the eerie legends that haunt small towns across the country. From the whiskey-induced utterances of the Snallygaster to the enduring myth of a gigantic turtle known as the Beast of Busco, this episode will send shivers down your spine and leave you questioning what might lurk in the hidden corners of rural America.

Witness a captivating convergence of history and mystery, where President Teddy Roosevelt's cryptozoological fascinations meet a farmer's ruinous obsession, and the peculiar tradition of Huggin' Molly's spectral embrace. The trio's chilling narratives and comedic insights breathe life into these cryptic tales, ensuring that the legends of these Cryptid Towns remain as indelible as the creatures themselves. Step into the heart of the unknown with this episode that proves truth can be stranger—and much more terrifying—than fiction.

Listen to the original

Episode 561: Cryptid Towns

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Jan 20, 2024 episode of the Last Podcast On The Left

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Episode 561: Cryptid Towns

1-Page Summary

Snallygaster

The Snallygaster, a cryptid deeply rooted in American folklore, is often associated with the ghost of a Civil War soldier and garnered the interest of President Teddy Roosevelt. The creature is reputed to have once spoken after drinking whiskey, hinting at its spectral soldier roots. Its distinctive sulfuric stench and train-whistle-like screech contribute to its terrifying legend, as recounted by witness Marcus Parks. Even after his presidency, Roosevelt was captivated by the Snallygaster, planning to hunt it down and featuring it in his book "The Wilderness Hunter," although some cryptozoologists now suspect the creature he described could have been Bigfoot instead.

Beast of Busco

The Beast of Busco, a giant snapping turtle first reported by farmer Oscar Folk in 1898, became the obsession of Farmer Gale Harris in 1949, years after the initial sighting. Harris took extraordinary measures to capture the beast, named Oscar, including using another turtle as bait and draining his lake significantly. His costly and exhaustive quest left him indebted, leading to the auctioning of his farm and speculated environmental damage as a result of the haunting search. Although the Beast of Busco was never caught, it remains a celebrated part of local folklore in Churubusco, Indiana, where residents honor the legend with an annual Turtle Days Festival complete with cultural festivities.

Huggin' Molly

The spectral figure of Huggin' Molly, described as a 7-foot-tall woman dressed in black, is a ghostly icon in Abbeville, Alabama. She is infamous for her eerie behavior of chasing people and screaming into their ears. Embracing this local myth, a 1950s-themed restaurant called Huggin' Molly's was established, offering classic American food and friendly hugs, staying true to the spirit of its namesake and embedding the legend into the town's cultural fabric.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • A cryptid is a creature or being that is rumored or believed to exist based on anecdotal evidence, but has not been proven by scientific research or captured for study. These entities often have elusive or supernatural characteristics, leading to their classification as cryptids in folklore and cryptozoology. Examples include creatures like Bigfoot, the Loch Ness Monster, and the Chupacabra. Cryptozoologists study and investigate these cryptids in an effort to validate their existence and understand their place in popular culture and mythology.
  • Cryptozoologists are individuals who study and search for animals that are considered legendary, extinct, or disputed in terms of their existence, such as Bigfoot or the Loch Ness Monster. They investigate these creatures, known as cryptids, which are often part of folklore and have not been scientifically proven to exist. Cryptozoology is not recognized as a legitimate scientific field by mainstream science due to its departure from the scientific method and its focus on creatures that lack empirical evidence. The field was established in the 1950s by zoologists Bernard Heuvelmans and Ivan T. Sanderson, who published influential works on the subject.

Counterarguments

  • The Snallygaster being rooted in folklore does not necessarily imply it has a basis in reality; it could be entirely mythical or an amalgamation of various legends and misinterpretations.
  • The association with the ghost of a Civil War soldier may be an embellishment or a narrative device to give the story a historical context, rather than a factual account.
  • President Teddy Roosevelt's interest in the Snallygaster could be overstated or apocryphal, as historical figures often become linked to legends over time without concrete evidence.
  • The claim that the Snallygaster spoke after drinking whiskey is likely a fanciful addition to the legend, as it ascribes complex behaviors and interactions to a creature of unverified existence.
  • The distinctive sulfuric stench and train-whistle-like screech attributed to the Snallygaster could be natural phenomena or other animals misidentified as the cryptid.
  • Marcus Parks' recounting of the Snallygaster legend is a single perspective and may not be representative of the broader cultural understanding of the creature.
  • Roosevelt's plans to hunt the Snallygaster and its inclusion in "The Wilderness Hunter" could be interpreted as Roosevelt's interest in folklore rather than a serious pursuit of a cryptid.
  • Cryptozoologists' suspicion that the creature Roosevelt described could have been Bigfoot introduces doubt about the identity and existence of the Snallygaster.
  • The Beast of Busco's existence is based on anecdotal reports, and without scientific evidence, it remains a piece of folklore rather than a confirmed species.
  • Farmer Gale Harris's actions to capture the Beast of Busco could be criticized for being environmentally irresponsible and financially imprudent.
  • The annual Turtle Days Festival in Churubusco, Indiana, while celebrating local folklore, may inadvertently promote the pursuit of unverified creatures, which could lead to unnecessary environmental disturbances.
  • The legend of Huggin' Molly, while culturally significant, could be seen as a way to commercialize local folklore, potentially detracting from the authenticity of the original stories.
  • The establishment of Huggin' Molly's restaurant, while embedding the legend into the town's cultural fabric, could also be viewed as trivializing a potentially more complex folklore narrative for commercial purposes.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Episode 561: Cryptid Towns

Snallygaster

The Snallygaster, a creature entrenched in American folklore, has captured imaginations for years, with tales connecting it to the ghost of a Civil War soldier and attracting the interest of a former US president.

Believed to be ghost of a Civil War soldier

After consuming a large quantity of whiskey during one sighting, the Snallygaster is reported to have "spoken." The words people attributed to the creature led to the inference that it could be the unrestful spirit of a Civil War soldier. This interpretation adds a chilling historical twist to the cryptid's legend.

Known to emit sulfuric smell, screech like a train whistle

The Snallygaster is also known for its distinct and unpleasant sulfuric smell and the screeching noises it makes, which are said to be similar to a train whistle. Marcus Parks recounts an encounter where a man named Bauman was awakened by a potent odor, believed to be the creature's sulfuric stench. Additionally, Parks describes hearing several harsh, grating, and long moans, consistent with the lore surrounding the Snallygaster's unnerving screech.

Teddy Roosevelt wanted to hunt it after presidency

The infamous Snallygaster not only stirred fear among the folk but also caught the adventurous eye of President Teddy Roosevelt. Roosevelt was so intrigued by the tales of the Snallygaster that he announced plans to hunt the ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Snallygaster

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The Snallygaster is a mythical creature from American folklore, often described as a dragon-like beast with features like tentacles, a metallic beak, and wings. It is said to inhabit the Maryland area, particularly Frederick County, and has been linked to sightings dating back to the early 18th century. The legend of the Snallygaster includes its ability to emit a sulfuric smell and produce screeching noises resembling a train whistle. Over time, various stories have connected the Snallygaster to different historical events, such as the Civil War, adding layers to its mysterious origins.
  • The connection between the Snallygaster and the ghost of a Civil War soldier stems from an incident where the creature reportedly "spoke" after consuming whiskey, leading people to believe it was the spirit of a soldier. This interpretation adds a haunting historical layer to the cryptid's folklore.
  • Teddy Roosevelt's interest in hunting the Snallygaster stemmed from his fascination with folklore and adventure. He was captivated by the tales surrounding the cryptid and saw it as an exciting challenge post-presidency. Roosevelt's intention to hunt the Snallygaster added to his reputation as a daring and adventurous figure in American history. His involvement in the lore of the Snallygaster contributed to the creature's enduring place ...

Counterarguments

  • The belief that the Snallygaster is the ghost of a Civil War soldier is based on folklore and anecdotal evidence, not scientific proof. There is no verifiable evidence to support the claim that the Snallygaster has spoken or that it is the spirit of a deceased soldier.
  • The sulfuric smell and screeching noise attributed to the Snallygaster could have explanations other than the presence of a cryptid, such as natural phenomena or misidentified wildlife sounds.
  • Teddy Roosevelt's int ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Episode 561: Cryptid Towns

Beast of Busco

The enigmatic and enduring story of the Beast of Busco revolves around the elusive, massive snapping turtle first sighted over a century ago and the lengths to which one farmer went to try and capture it, which in turn has led to a local tradition.

Massive snapping turtle first seen in 1898

The tale of the supposedly gigantic snapping turtle known as the Beast of Busco begins all the way back in 1898 when a farmer named Oscar Folk reported sighting a turtle as large as a tabletop in a seven-acre lake on his property. However, it wasn't until Farmer Gale Harris claimed to have spotted this massive turtle again in 1949 that the story caught the public’s attention.

In his mission to capture the creature he called Oscar, Harris went to extreme lengths. He even tried using another turtle from Florida named Minnie to lure Oscar out, but after this failed to attract the elusive turtle, the bait turtle met an unfortunate end at a potluck where she was eaten.

Gale’s final attempt involved draining the lake on his property down from 65 feet to just 15 feet. Despite his efforts, which included the capture of a 10-pound snapping turtle, he insisted that he hadn't caught Oscar, stating that 10 pounds was too small.

A Town Celebrates with Turtle Days Festival

The obsessive hunt for the Beast of Busco was taxing and costly for Farmer Harris, with efforts including renting cranes, hiring divers, pumping out the lake, and transporting another turtle from Florida. His endeavors left him in debt and ultimately, he and his wife had to auction off their 120-acre farm.

The local road near Harris's drained lake collapsed, a mishap that some speculate was caused by a collapse in a ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Beast of Busco

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The Beast of Busco holds significance in the local community of Churubusco as it has become a cherished legend that is celebrated annually during the Churubusco Turtle Days Festival. This festival includes various events like a parade, carnival, and the Miss Turtle Days Pageant, showcasing how the community embraces and commemorates this unique piece of folklore. The legend of the Beast of Busco has become a part of the town's identity, bringing residents together to honor their local history and keep the story alive for future generations. The festival serves as a way for the community to come together, have fun, and bond over their shared connection to this enduring local legend.
  • The collapse of the road near Farmer Harris's drained lake was speculated to be linked to his search for ...

Counterarguments

...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Episode 561: Cryptid Towns

Huggin' Molly

Nestled in the town of Abbeville, Alabama, a local legend has inspired both a ghostly lore and a unique dining experience.

7-foot ghostly woman in black dress

The legend of Huggin' Molly is centered around the haunting image of a 7-foot ghostly woman dressed in black.

Known for chasing people and screaming in their ears

Molly is known in local folklore for her peculiar habit of chasing after people and screaming into their ears.

Local restaurant named after her

Her story has become so ingrained in the town’s culture that it has ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Huggin' Molly

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The 7-foot ghostly woman in a black dress, known as Huggin' Molly, is a local legend in Abbeville, Alabama. She is famous for her eerie habit of chasing people and screaming in their ears, creating a sense of fear and mystery in the town. The image of this towering figure in black has become a significant part of the folklore and culture of the area. The presence of Huggin' Molly has even inspired the creation of a themed restaurant, Huggin’ Molly's, which pays homage to her haunting legacy.
  • The local legend of Huggin' Molly, a ghostly woman known for chasing people, inspired a restaurant named Huggin’ Molly's in Abbeville, Alabama. The restaurant pays homage to the legend by offering friendly hugs to customers, ...

Counterarguments

...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA