In a departure from the typical campfire ghost story, "Just Creepy: Scary Stories" explores real-life accounts of unsettling encounters in the deep woods. The episode delves into the disappearance of Charles McCullar, a photographer who vanished in the wilderness of Crater Lake National Park under mysterious circumstances.
It also recounts the harrowing tale of a group of friends from New York who embark on a camping trip, only to confront an unnerving supernatural presence. Their encounter with an unnatural creature in the remote upstate woods leaves them traumatized, changing their relationship with the outdoors forever. These chilling stories vividly portray the unseen terrors that lurk in isolated natural landscapes.
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
Charles McCullar, a photographer and adventurer, embarked on a solo trip into the wilderness of Crater Lake National Park in 1975 to capture the park's winter beauty. Despite his experience and careful preparation with all necessary gear for the severe winter conditions, Charles vanished without a trace.
A group of friends from New York set off on a wilderness adventure to reconnect with nature and escape urban life. The trip leads them to an isolated cabin in upstate New York. There, they experience an unsettling sense of isolation and encounter strange sights culminating in the sighting of a nightmarish creature. This shared supernatural experience creates a traumatic bond among the friends.
The friends, seeking an escape from city life, drive toward an off-grid cabin in upstate New York. Throughout their journey, they feel a growing unease, which turns to apprehension as they arrive at the cabin enveloped by darkness and silence—a stark contrast to the city they left.
The friends face an onslaught of terrifying experiences, including encounters with a mysterious creature in the woods. These incidents leave them traumatized, with vivid memories of an unknown creature accosting them and their pets. The community's shared stories add to the eeriness and contribute to a bond of unity and understanding among the group.
Their final decision to leave the wilderness and not speak of what transpired marks a significant change in their bond and relationship with the outdoors. The once thrilling adventure is now a silent, shared memory of otherworldly horror.
1-Page Summary
In 1975, the mysterious disappearance of Charles McCullar in the wilderness of Crater Lake National Park perplexed authorities and sparked theories ranging from natural peril to supernatural forces. Despite being an experienced adventurer with meticulous preparation, Charles's venture into the harsh winter conditions left more questions than answers when he vanished without a trace.
Drawn by the allure of Crater Lake's frosted landscapes, Charles McCullar, a photographer and adventurer, embarked on a solo journey from Eugene, Oregon, to capture its beauty despite the severe snow conditions and the perils of trekking alone in winter. His last known stop was a store at Dry Creek for supplies before stepping into the wilderness, ultimately leaving no discernible trail.
Charles's meticulous preparation—which included warm clothing, a suitable sleeping bag, and enough food for a four-day trip—and his act of informing a friend to alert authorities if he failed to return, suggested he was equipped to handle the hazardous conditions. Yet, the enchanting but perilous wilderness of Crater Lake beckoned, leading him into the unknown.
When Charles failed to return, a concerned friend notified the authorities, and an extensive search began. Teams equipped with skis, snowmobiles, and airplanes scoured the northern section of Crater Lake National Park, the area Charles was believed to have explored. However, even with the aid of modern search technologies, no sign of Charles was found, and efforts to reconstruct his last days were thwarted by the immense area and jurisdictional disputes.
A year after Charles's disappearance, two hikers stumbled upon his sparse remains in an isolated canyon near Bybee Creek. His bones were bizarrely arranged—a pair of pants with his foot bones still inside was resting on a log as if his body had vanished or dissolved. The strange positioning echoed a ranger's tale of another hiker found dead, with his body arranged ritually, suggesting that no animal could have caused such an arrangement.
...
The Disappearance of Charles McCullar
A group of friends from New York City, including the narrator, Lisa, Anna, and Charlotte, embark on a journey to reconnect with nature. Planning a road trip that will circle Lake Ontario, their adventure culminates at an off-grid cabin in upstate New York, seeking a respite from urban life. However, their excitement gives way to an unsettling sense of isolation and the observance of strange sights. Eventually, their experience with a nightmarish creature solidifies a traumatic bond among them.
The group's intention to escape the constant buzz of city life is strong as they drive towards the remote cabin, hoping for solace in the stillness of nature. As they near their destination, however, the mood shifts from eager anticipation to creeping apprehension. The darkness of the surrounding forest and a distant lone campfire send shivers down their spines, contrasted sharply against their usual backdrop of New York City. As their GPS loses signal, they lean on maps and instincts to navigate, their unease magnified by the oppressive silence and the sensation of unseen eyes on them—the wilderness seems to watch and wait.
The eerie atmosphere thickens when the solitude of the area engulfs the narrator with a sense of foreboding. The trauma truly begins when the narrator's aunt, staying in a family home on the edge of dense woods, sees a figure resembling a wolf or dogman. The terror of the creature approaching her car propels her into a prayerful state until it retreats, leaving her shaken.
Adding to the aura of fear, the narrator, along with their friend Ryan and his dog Chief, experiences a different but equally terrifying encounter in Minnesota. Initially startled by glowing yellow orbs in the trees, their unease intensifies when they encounter a grotesque deer the next day. When the narrator fails to shoot it, it vanishes without a trace, leaving blood and clawed trees as the only evidence of its presence. They find their cabin ransacked and see a tall, pale figure, eliciting a scream from the creature and prompting their rushed departure.
In a separate incident, Chief retrieves a surgically dismembered deer leg, an act suggesting intelligence and intent. Large, erratic tracks and an overwhelming silence prime the narrator for the encounter with a monstrous, bear-wolf-like beast with glowing eyes. Chief bravely confronts the creature, saving the narrator and Jenna, a woman targeted by the beast.
The narrator's Native American ties underscore their familiarity with the supernatural, but nothing could prepare them for the sight of a nine-foot tall, emaciated figure, with deer le ...
A Shared Supernatural Experience in the Wilderness
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser