Our inner voice serves important cognitive functions like self-reflection and planning. However, excessive negative chatter—persistent rumination—can drain mental resources and contribute to mood disorders like depression and anxiety. In this episode, Huberman Lab host Andrew Huberman and psychologist Dr. Ethan Kross explore strategies for managing this unproductive inner chatter.
They dive into techniques like cognitive distancing, environmental modification, and using technology strategically. Kross highlights the importance of a diverse toolkit, as different methods work for different individuals. The episode also examines the effects of digital communication dynamics and constant stimuli from social media, weighing both potential pitfalls and opportunities for utilizing technology to support emotional regulation.
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
Ethan Kross and Andrew Huberman explore the inner voice, acknowledging its importance as a cognitive tool while cautioning against its unproductive form known as "chatter."
1-Page Summary
Ethan Kross and Andrew Huberman delve into the intricacies of the inner voice, or "chatter," and the cognitive functions it serves, stressing its importance but also cautioning about its potentially detrimental effects.
The inner voice is a fundamental human ability that allows us to silently use language to reflect on our lives, keep information active in our minds, and mentally simulate and plan our actions. Kross describes it as a Swiss army knife for the mind.
Ethan Kross emphasizes that we use the inner voice to reflect on various aspects of our lives, constructing entire narratives, even creating positive or negative fantasies about experiences we desire to happen. This silent use of language is a valuable tool for self-reflection and assessment.
Kross explains how the inner voice is part of our verbal working memory system, which enables us to keep information, such as phone numbers and grocery lists, active in our short-term memory. Huberman adds that during exercise, he uses his inner voice to maintain focus and motivation, demonstrating how it helps keep specific thoughts and motivations at the forefront of our minds.
By using our inner voice to rehearse what to say before an interview or presentation, we demonstrate its role in simulating and planning, according to Kross. It allows us to mentally work through future scenarios and time-travel with our thoughts.
Chatter is the repetitive, unproductive looping of thoughts and negative emotions that can dominate our attention and hinder problem-solving. Kross defines it as the dark side of the inner voice that consumes ...
The nature and functions of the inner voice/chatter
Huberman and Kross tackle the concept of "chatter" or the persistent inner monologue that can often take a negative turn, and how it impacts mental and emotional well-being.
Chatter, especially when unproductive or negative, can act like an attentional sponge, consuming cognitive resources that might be better used for problem-solving or progression in one's personal and professional life. When individuals ruminate on their problems without making any progress, this type of chatter can prevent them from engaging in more constructive activities. This unproductive looping can have detrimental consequences on one's mental and emotional health.
Kross points out that avoidance of problems or over-concentration on them leads to negative emotional and physical health outcomes. He argues that when issues are persistently avoided, it can lead to a cycle of negative experiences that consume attention and block progress—highlighting the dangers of chatter on well-being.
Excessive chatter, when associated with intense negative emotions, can also lead to significant mental health issues such as depression, anxiety, and the constant reliving of painful experiences. The conversation notes that if chatter involves hyper-focusing on negative emotions and looping through them, it can influence an individual's mental health and may contribute to mood disorders.
While it's natural for the human mind to generate intrusive thoughts and dark imaginings, these are not necessarily indicative of deeper psychological issues as long as they ...
The downsides and dangers of excessive or unproductive chatter
Ethan Kross and Andrew Huberman delve into the ways individuals can manage their internal "chatter" and regulate their emotions through various cognitive, behavioral, and environmental strategies. They emphasize the importance of a dynamic approach tailored to personal needs and underline the effectiveness of a diversified toolkit for emotional regulation.
Kross explains that employing distancing tools, such as using one's own name and the second-person pronoun "you," can aid in stepping back to view oneself from an objective perspective. By speaking to oneself as if giving advice to another person—for example, asking, "Ethan, how are you going to manage this situation?"—one can utilize this form of distance self-talk to manage chatter and regain a calmer state of mind.
Discussing mental time travel, Kross shares that he imagines how he will feel about an issue in the future to manage chatter. This method, also known as temporal distancing, allows one to consider how the problem will feel tomorrow, next week, or even years into the future, putting current difficulties into perspective. Huberman adds that altering perception of time can be a useful strategy for dealing with emotional problems, and Kross uses mental time travel to achieve all-encompassing calm before bed.
To manage emotions, Kross and Huberman discuss how structuring the stream of thoughts and physical environments, such as leaving phones out of sight, can minimize chatter's triggers. For example, Huberman notes Deisseroth’s practice of thinking in complete sentences, while Kross relates to organizing physical spaces, like insisting guests take leftover pizza home, to align with personal regulatory goals. Organizing spaces is a strategy to gain control outwardly, thus managing inward chatter. Also, choosing supportive and comforting environments helps in improving mood and managing emotions.
Kross underscores the significance of not solely venting to friends, but working together to solve issues, avoiding co-rumination. He suggests forming a "chatter advisory board" composed of individuals who provide empathy, perspecti ...
Techniques and strategies for managing chatter and regulating emotions
The ubiquity of digital technology and social environments profoundly influences our inner experiences, challenging traditional forms of emotion regulation while also offering new tools for managing our emotions.
Ethan Kross elaborates on how the immediacy of texting and social media communication has transformed our emotional lives. The ease and anonymity of online dialogue prompt people to share their inner thoughts in more unfiltered ways, possibly amplifying emotional intensity and spreading affect more widely than face-to-face interactions. This shift to immediacy with less emotional feedback can result in uninhibited expression that might not occur in person. This often leads to dynamics such as cyberbullying and the spread of moral outrage, as seen in social media environments where emotions are expressed without the tempering effect of time or face-to-face feedback.
Andrew Huberman compares social media scrolling to "cognitive chewing gum," suggesting that it occupies our minds without providing real value, potentially hindering us from engaging with our deeper thoughts. Kross discusses the phenomenon of emotional contagion in environments like football stadiums, linking this to how digital spaces might similarly affect emotional regulation and the spread of emotions.
The continuous stream of information and stimulation from smartphones and social media can prevent people from disengaging from inner chatter to find moments of presence. Huberman notes that smartphones bring countless contexts into our environments, which can make it hard to be present and let the mind wander freely. The near-constant engagement with devices might lead to a semi-dissociative state where individuals are not fully involved with their surroundings or their internal dialogue.
Despite the challenges posed by technology, it can be leveraged to our benefit if used strategically. Kross and Huberman discuss how individuals are learning to navigate digital environments in ways that cater to their emotional needs.
Huberman and Kross mention that they intentionally structure their environment to minimize distractions from technology, thus supporting their emotion regulation. For example, Kross talks about using social media to view funny videos before bed as a way to lighten his mood and unwind, highlighting the potential benefits of curating digi ...
The influence of external factors like technology and social environments on inner experience
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser