Is the modern world conditioning us to think only in the short term? In this episode of the Huberman Lab podcast, host Andrew Huberman and his guest Ari Wallach explore the uniquely human ability to envision future scenarios and how incessant digital notifications and external reward schedules have narrowed many people's temporal horizons.
Wallach proposes concrete strategies for cultivating the long-view, "transgenerational" thinking needed to steer a positive trajectory for ourselves and future generations. They discuss how practices like visualizing future selves and embracing "protopian" narratives of human flourishing could empower prudent long-term planning and decision-making.
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
Ari Wallach and Marty Seligman introduce the concept that humans possess a unique ability to mentally envision future scenarios. This skill, emerging around 150,000 years ago, enabled strategic hunting and survival planning aided by the hippocampus reconstructing memories into imagined futures.
Andrew Huberman and Wallach explore how modern environments condition short-term reactivity through instant notifications, social media, and reward schedules that narrow temporal horizons. The decline of institutions providing overarching purpose compounds this short-term focus without clear generational legacies.
Wallach describes developing empathy across one's lifetimes - past, present, and future - as foundational to long-term thinking. He recommends practices like visualizing aged selves and writing future self-letters to foster connections beyond the self. Conceptualizing the future as an active "verb" to shape can empower positive trajectories.
Wallach remarks on prevalent dystopian narratives cultivating pessimism, advocating for "protopian" stories of human flourishing. As traditional institutions erode, selectively preserving beneficial aspects while innovating new intergenerational knowledge transfer mechanisms becomes crucial.
1-Page Summary
Ari Wallach and Marty Seligman introduce the concept that the ability of humans to mentally time-travel and envision future scenarios is a distinguishing feature of our species. This skill plays a critical role in our evolutionary history and continues to inform how we consider our impact on future generations.
The ability to think ahead emerged approximately 150,000 years ago as Homo sapiens began to hunt larger game. This required them to mentally time travel to consider various future outcomes and strategies. Wallach discusses these complex hunting scenarios, which required strategic thinking and planning, as essential to providing more protein for their increasingly energy-intensive brains.
Wallach explains how the hippocampus, a brain region without a specific timestamp for memories, can take snapshots of episodic memories and reconstruct them to enable projections into the future. This reconstructiv ...
The human capacity for future-oriented thinking and its evolutionary significance
Andrew Huberman and Ari Wallach explore how the modern technological and cultural climate fosters a state of short-term thinking and reactivity, while the decline of traditional structures further compounds the issue.
Huberman voices concern over society's conditioning towards quick gratifications, where rewards are expected on short timetables. He traces the evolution from game shows to social media, where dramatic content gains attention. The hosts contemplate the idea of a "time capsule" social media platform that emphasizes lasting content over short-term virality.
Huberman expresses concern over the "shorter timescale reward thing" tied to social media and instant purchases. He describes how modern-day notifications condition humans to focus on immediate gratification, engaging in constant stimulus-response interactions, shifting cognitive focus from future-oriented thinking to being locked in the present.
This technology is said to hack the older parts of our brain, narrowing our temporal horizons and making it hard to consider long-term planning. Huberman likens social media rewards to Las Vegas casinos which maximize short-term thinking. Social media operates on similar random intermittent schedules, reinforcing short-term engagement with content that has a short half-life.
Algorithms on social platforms are designed to feed individual content preferences, maintaining a stimulus-response state. Smartphones are compared to slot machines, consistently engaging users with preferred content.
Wallach observes how religious institutions historically provided a purpose to human existence, but the rise of rationality and the Enlightenment has shifted perspectives, creating challenges in understanding our purpose without these structures.
The growth of ration ...
Psychological and societal factors that encourage short-term thinking
Ari Wallach, supported by the commentary of Andrew Huberman, describes strategies for cultivating empathy and compassion across generations, thereby fostering long-term, "transgenerational" thinking.
Wallach introduces the concept of "transgenerational empathy," starting with compassion for oneself as integral to long-term thinking. He critiques the cultural imagery and narratives promoting idealized success, which can lead to feelings of inadequacy. Wallach shares a personal story about showing self-compassion for his younger self's inability to be fully present during his father's cancer experience, emphasizing the importance of acknowledging one's continuous evolution over time. He argues that one must cultivate empathy with oneself first, as it is difficult to have empathy for the past or future without first developing it for oneself.
Worth emphasizing is Wallach's rejection of legacy as ego-driven recognition, stating his impact on future generations will manifest through the behaviors he models for his children and those around him. These behaviors become memes, according to Susan Blackmore's theory, and are cultural units that pass laterally and to future generations.
Wallach explains that he may not meet his great-grandchildren biologically, but his model of being in the world will reach them. His children learn from observing his interactions, suggesting his behaviors and values will impact how they and their descendants treat others.
Wallach's "long path" thinking promotes everyday behaviors and decisions as contributing to a large-scale vision of the future society. Andrew Huberman contributes by outlining that being present and attentive is crucial for developing empathy, and Martha Beck's practice involves reflecting on past empowering states to anchor oneself to those emotions.
Multiple exercises were discussed that can foster this empathy, such as Wallach visualizing his own aging to influence daily decisions, and Huberman's use of a life-weeks chart to gain perspective on life's timeline. Functional MRI studies reveal people consider their future selves like strangers, but visualization can improve one's connection to their future self, as shown when individuals who met their aged selves in virtual reality engaged in increased savings behavior.
Practices to build transgenerational empathy and compassion mentioned include having photos of ancestors, oneself, and blank frames for future generations, and using mantras such as "long path" to remind oneself of their role in a continuum beyond their lifetime.
Wallach suggests engaging with biographies and autobiographies to understand past struggles and imperfections, and he critiques the current nuclear family practice, contrasting it with indigenous practices. Huberman speaks about Dr. Wendy Suzuki’s work teaching NYU students emotional development and self-regulation, fostering a forward-thinking attitude.
Wallach talks about writing letters to one's future self and visualizing a better future not only as self-sacrifice but as pro-self and others initiatives. These acts can enable stronger emotional connections with future generations. Huberman mentions creating time capsules and record keeping as fostering a sense of legacy and interconne ...
Strategies and practices for cultivating long-term, "transgenerational" thinking
Storytelling, institutions, and cultural narratives play pivotal roles in how we perceive and prepare for the future. Their influence on our cultural mindsets and transmission of long-term values and purposes has significant implications for the collective orientation towards the generations to come.
Ari Wallach remarks on the prevalence of dystopian narratives in young adult literature like "The Hunger Games," "The Hundred," and "The Maze Runner," portraying a future gone wrong. These stories serve as early warnings, but also shape a negative view of the future. Wallach contends that we must shift from dystopia to "protopia," a term coined by Kevin Kelly for a future that is better, though not perfect. Creating stories with "better tomorrows" can inspire a more constructive vision of the future.
Andrew Huberman and Wallach agree on the importance of proliferating "protopian" stories in media and literature to counterbalance the negative, pessimistic view cultivated by dystopian narratives. These optimistic tales could encourage a cultural mindset supportive of human flourishing and progress over time.
Wallach discusses the disconnection from self, others, and nature—a significant error in modern civilization—suggested by the erosion of institutions such as religion, and how past traditions engendered a sense of connectedness. The essence of religion about love and connection to something larger is emphasized, despite its practice sometimes being tangled in power and control.
A significant shift in society's trust and reliance on institutions like academia and religion, which historically helped transmit long-term values, has been noted. Wallach and Huberman discuss the need for new guiding narratives or stories, as traditional institutions no longer articulate a desired direction for the future. People are less influenced by religion and traditional family structures, whi ...
The role of storytelling, institutions, and cultural narratives in shaping our orientation towards the future
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser